Member Reviews

What a delight this book is. Some of the language is a little dated, it's not at all p.c. and the societal niceties have definitely changed over the years but the actual crime stories were beautifully written and I enjoyed them all.

The cover drew me in and fits the book perfectly. The authors were all new to me except for Francis Durbridge whose television series was a favourite of my dad's. I guessed some of the murderers or at least a few of the clues in most of the tales but that didn't matter. Instead I was just enjoying the differences between the crime stories of the past and those I read today and I think I will read this again when the festive season is a little closer.

I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and the publishers in exchange for an unbiased review and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys a slightly different but nonetheless entertaining type of short story; all of these will take you to Christmases in the past in a very pleasing way.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for the e-Galley of this anthology.

This is the third winter themed anthology in the collection of books offered as part of the British Library Crime Classics. Once again Martin Edwards is the editor and there is an Introduction by him as well as information regarding each author at the beginning of their story. There are eleven stories from these authors: Baroness Orczy, Selwyn Jepson, Donald Stuart, Ronald Knox, Carter Dickson, Francis Durbridge, Cyril Hare, E. C. R. Lorac, John Bude, John Birmingham, and Julian Symons. Through that introductory information I discovered that one of these authors was an Earl, was recruited by MI5 and was the basis for the George Smiley character by John Le Carre. I never skip over those story introductions because you just never know what you will find out about the authors.

I was delighted to find that I had not previously read any of the stories offered here. That was surprising since I've been reading mystery anthologies for a long time. I was pleased to see contributions from authors I've liked for a long time and offerings by authors I've recently discovered through these British Library Crime Classics. Some of the authors were new to me so I now know a little about their style of writing. There isn't a "bad" story in the collection but, of course, some I enjoyed more. Recommended for readers who enjoy authors who wrote during the golden age of mystery; maybe they are now considered old fashioned, but they are very satisfying reading for me.

Was this review helpful?

This is a wonderful collection of stories from the golden age of mysteries. I love that these stories are being republished for a whole new generation to enjoy. Every story in this collection is well plotted and a fun glimpse into another era. Thank you NetGalley for the advanced readers copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

As an anthology fan, I enjoyed this nice mix of stories. The editor is excellent, and provided excellent intros. Kudos on the selections overall. Recommended.

I really appreciate the advanced copy for review!!

Was this review helpful?

While it feels incongruous reading a Christmas anthology while in the midst of a summer heatwave, not all these stories are really that Christmassy. As with all anthologies, this is a mixed bag: known crime names are here such as Cyril Hare, Ronald Knox, Carter Dickson and John Bude, with some unknowns to liven up the mix. The plots range from locked room mysteries to that old chestnut which I still love of a group of strangers stranded on a snow-bound train. This would make an ideal winter/Xmas present especially for someone who loves reading vintage mysteries on the commute.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read and review this book.

This is a delightful collection of old, short, mystery stories set at Christmas time. Each writer sets the scene and creates an excellent twist on the season and how human nature can be turned to a darker hue.

This is a fine collection of stories that will capture the reader’s interest.

Was this review helpful?

The Christmas Card Crime & Other Stories is a short story collection compiled by the British Library in an effort to bring back to print many stories that have not seen the light of day in more than half a century.

Yes, I know this review is being written in July, but I received an advanced copy for review from the publisher and if I’m being honest, I’m a Christmas lunatic and will take my festive fiction when and where I can get it. That being said, many of these stories could barely be classified as Christmas themed. I’m talking a few throwaway lines at the beginning of the story to set the novel in December and then it’s never mentioned or touched on again.

However, that doesn’t hold true for all of them. There are many stories that make great use of the season. The title story – The Christmas Card Crime by Donald Stuart – builds a locked-room mystery around killing involving a torn Christmas card, Sister Bessie or Your Old Leech (my favorite of the bunch) by Cyril Hare involves a bit of blackmail originating from a family Christmas party and John Bingham’s Crime at Lark Cottage invokes a great twist ending during a tense Christmas Eve in the country.

A few of the stories just didn’t do it for me, but that’s to be expected in a short story collection from various writers. It’s sort of a mixed bag when it comes to a reader’s taste. One story in particular, The Motive by Ronald Knox, put me to sleep; it was about as dry as fireplace kindling.

There seems to be very little in the way of Christmas-themed fiction around the holidays that isn’t primarily romance, so I welcome a bit of mischief, misdirection and mayhem under the tree. While The Christmas Card Crime & Other Stories isn’t perfect, it’s worth checking out. You’re not going to like everyone at a Christmas party, are you?

The Christmas Card Crime & Other Stories will be released on October 01, 2019

Was this review helpful?

Another fabulous dip into the stories from, and around the golden age. I do really enjoy reading books from this era, and these anthologies give a taste of authors that have not yet discovered and will seek out in the future.
Martin Edwards again give a informative overview of the author at the beginning of each stories, and how they fitting in to this type of crime writing. These ones, as the title says are written employing the Christmas theme and do not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?