Member Reviews

I loved this book! I really enjoyed Griffin's book, but I didn't *love* it, per se. However, Rogan's book was amazing. It was so full of heart break, love, and realistic second chances. I was really happy that it took a little while for either of them to completely acknowledge that they still loved each other. I really feel like it was beneficial to the story line.

Harper is one of my favorite heroines that Meghan Quinn has ever written. I really liked how she knew her worth and she wasn't going to just give in to Rogan. She was very focused on getting herself back in order before she even acknowledged what she was feeling. I also liked that she didn't turn all gooey every time he walked into the room. Her hurt didn't just go away after all these years because of a steamy glance from Rogan.

I also really liked Rogan because he was very quick to admit his faults and wrongdoings. He was pretty terrible to her and instead of making excuses he tried to show her how much he had changed. It was really fantastic to see a H who recognized what an amazing person the h is and how she deserved to be treated.

I knocked a star off because I wasn't wild about the frequency of the flashbacks. I would say it was every couple of chapters and, while I acknowledge some of their value, some of them weren't needed and it could have been spaced out more. Going back and forth tends to take me out of the story I was enjoying and then it takes me a minute to get back into it when it goes back to the present. It almost felt like reading two books in one, at times. That being said, I loved the "past" chapters separately and would totally read that book, so my issue isn't with the content itself it's more about the frequency in which it happened.

Overall, I absolutely recommend this book! I'm desperately hoping Brig is next because I cannot wait to see what shenanigans that happy-go-lucky fella is going to get up to! Meghan Quinn, you've done it again.

Was this review helpful?

This didn't work for me at all. I could tell a few pages in and skimread a bit further but decided to just give up on it.

Was this review helpful?

There are some authors that when you find out they have another book out, you need to one click it. Meghan Quinn has become that for me. Every time I think this is my new book boyfriend, she writes another story and I fall in love with her characters. Her characters feel like family, her writing feels effortless and her stories will give you all the feels.

Rogan Knightly is good looking, athletic, nice build and has a good heart. Let’s face it, who wouldn’t want to be part of the Knightly family…hint…. Hint, Meghan, we need more of the brothers stories. Harper is a small town girl in love with Rogan and following in his shadow. Best friends to lovers, small town romance, sports romance, this story has it all!

That Forever Girl alternates between the present and the past. You learn about Rogan and Harper’s backstory. How they fell in love, out of love, and how they rebuild their lives in Port Snow.

There are some fun elements to the story, and romance fans will smile at the storyline and plot.

If you are a Meghan Quinn fan, a rom com fan or just like to smile, laugh and have fun reading with a little angst thrown in, this story is for you. That Forever Girl is book 2 in the Getting Lucky series.

Was this review helpful?

Where do I begin?!
That Forever Girl really touched my heart.

Rogan is always so growly and grouchy. Harper feels lost due to circumstances of the past. When the two meet back up magic happens.

I love the give and take between these two and the flashbacks from the past. Their story brought tears to my eyes. I was happy and sad and then happy again.

Such a great read! I cannot wait for the next installment. Thanks Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is a voluntary review of an advanced copy.

Harper is back in town and now has to deal with Rogan who brutally broke their engagement and her heart. Most of the beginning of the book, Rogan is just plain unlikable and hopefully that is what the author was going for but it really made it hard to want Harper back with him.

I really liked the first book with Ren and Griffin and how could you not love the Knightley family with those crazy brothers and their sister, Jen! While I did like the HEA and that Harper and Rogan finally worked things out, I was not really that invested in their story at the beginning. Not sure if it was the constant flashbacks to their high school years or that Rogan was annoyingly nasty. Or maybe that it took so long to get to the flashback of their break up.

In the end, it was good to see this family and town and can't wait for the next brother to "break" the curse when they finally grow up!

Was this review helpful?

Meghan is one of my favorite authors and everytime a new book is in the works, I get so excited. This book is freaking amazing. I loved everything about it and more. The characters were so good together and I love Meghan's writing. Another amazing book to add to my collection.

Thank you Netgalley, the author and publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 STARS

I was lucky enough to read the first book in this series featuring Griffin and his brothers, and adored it. So, I have been waiting the arrival of each of the siblings book, and the wait was worth it. I adored Rogan's story. It was not an easy going book, but there was some lightness to it, that had me laughing. My favorite thing about this series is the family aspect. I love love love how family oriented it is, it makes for great banter, and an even greater amount of meddling. But my favorite thing about That Forever Girl you ask? Mixing the old with the new. Two stories in one. This author did an amazing job between the past and present. She gave enough information to make things make sense, and not too much to where the story lagged. It genuinely flowed at the perfect pace. These characters made great strides in characters growth as one day bleed into the other. The chemistry was not just focused around the hot and steamy times, which made if a more fulfilling read. Overall, this was an outstanding read.

Rogan, ( unique and different name that I love. It fits him) is not as carefree as he used to be. Circumstances changed him, and now he is getting used to the new normal He isn't the nicest of the siblings, but given what he has been through, makes it understandable. Deep down, he has a heart with so much love to give. He is so dang romantic.

Harper is not where she thought she would be at this point in her life. She longs for the feeling of home, no matter what that might be. Her heart has been through the ringer one too many times, so she just wants to be. She comes off as quiet, but she has a backbone that can make a grown man weep.

When life brings Harper back to her hometown, can Rogan prove to her that this time is different?

Was this review helpful?

These Knightley boys are everything. Book two in the series features Rogan (second oldest of the brothers.) Broken, broody, successful and still so gorgeous. Him and his longtime best friend and high school sweetheart had a nasty breakup while away at college, and now she's back in town after seven years away. Harper is a good person who lost herself along the way, but she's back to discover who she is and what she wants in life. The town ain't big enough for the two of them. This is a second chance romance as well as an enemies to lovers romance. The supporting characters bring a lot to the book. A lot of entertainment value. There is the angst that comes with dealing with an ex, as well as remembering the good times and the love you once shared. While the characters have heavy hearts and aren't all upbeat, the book itself isn't overly emotional. There are plenty of laughs along the way. It's a well told story. Alternates between POVs. And goes back and forth in time from their youth to the present day. There is a small amount of sexual content. This is book two of the Getting Lucky series, but each can be read as a stand alone. I would suggest reading them in order though so you get more of a feel for each of the brothers and their romantic lives (or lack of) without spoilers.

*I received an ARC of this book from Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

I was eager to go back to Port Snow and visit the Knightly clan in That Forever Girl . Rogan and Harper’s second chance romance tugged at my heart. I absolutely enjoy this sweet, funny, yet at some point emotional story. It gave me all the feels and I was completely captivated. It was gratifying to take part in the couple’s journey – traveling to the past to see them transition from friends to lovers and at the same time seeing them move from enemies to lovers again in the present.

I loved that we were brought back to the past to the highlights of the couple's relationship milestones. These flashbacks were significant as they not only slowly unravel the mystery of their breakup but also proved that Rogan was not the complete jerk that he appeared to be. He remembered and communicated his love for Harper in his own unique way. Totally swoon-worthy!

Another favorite was the closeness of the Knightly clan. The siblings’ text exchanges and in person interactions ranged from hilarious to motivating which illustrated the abundant love and support between the siblings. The meddling of their parents were annoying yet timely because parents know best.

In my opinion, I feel that Meghan has grown substantially as an author throughout the years. Her writing flows effortlessly and her stories are always accompanied by well-developed characters and a well-defined plot embedded with humor and heart. I absolutely enjoyed the story and would highly recommend this funny and heartwarming small-town second chance romance.

Was this review helpful?

An incredible emotional story and one of my favorites by Meghan Quinn. The heartache of both Harper and Rogan kept me on the edge of tears for the first part of the story. Then I was cheering for them! I loved how Quinn did the flashback chapters, slowly revealing the shocker of what actually drove them apart. I am so in love with this town and the people in it!!

Was this review helpful?

Meghan quinn does it again! This is book 2 in this series and it is just as amazing as the first.
Rogan and Harper were high school sweethearts until college when Rogan breaks it off. Fast forward 7 years Harper returns to Port Snow.
The book goes back and forth between past and present but it’s easy to follow and fall in love with! This book will have you believing in second chances.

Can’t wait for book 3 !

Thank you netgalley and Meghan for my ARC of this book!

Was this review helpful?

3.75 stars

This is a bit harder for me to rate. Certain parts of this story I LOVED while other parts I struggled with. That is hard for me to admit considering that I adore this author with everything that I am. Normally, I connect with the characters that this author writes but for some reason, Rogan and Harper never really managed to get me invested in them.

I struggled with how long it took for Rogan to decide to show Harper that he still loved her, especially after being so cruel to her when she came back home. For a man that had followed through on so many of the dreams that they had shared together, it just didn't make much sense to me. Harper's reason for coming back seemed to come very late in the story too. So late in fact that I worried if it was even going to be addressed or if this was going to become two books because it was so close to the conclusion. That was another thing that frustrated me on this one. Everything seemed so rushed towards the end which made me sad because I really wanted that a little more flushed out.

That being said, The text banter between the brothers had me cracking up. I am loving the connection between all these brothers and "the curse" especially knowing that there are two brothers to go. There is also a plot twist that I didn't see coming. Even with the flashbacks, I had NO idea of a certain something in regards to Rogue. Even though this wasn't my favorite from this author it was still very good and I would recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book, although there were times where Rogan's cruelty took me out of the story- not so much the past cruelties, that I sort of understood, but the present day rudeness when Harper came back into town was a little much. He was over the top immature about her, but I guess he had to take the journey to "break the curse." Otherwise, there are a lot of very funny moments with the brothers, hot sparks between Harper and Rogan, and even a bit of mystery.

Was this review helpful?

Well, book 2 in the Getting Lucky series by Meghan Quinn features the second eldest knightly brother, Rogan, and I think I’ve found my favourite brother. He is just wonderful, all sultry and sexy, whilst been sappy and loving. Admittedly, he is a jerk in the beginning, but when everything comes to light, I understood where he was coming from, I’m not saying he did the right thing, but, we all make mistakes This is a super addictive second chance romance, some scenes are emotional, a lot of scenes are funny, proper laugh out load moments with the sibling banter, in person and by text. So so funny. A wonderful story written so so well. Great characters. I just adore all the townsfolk. The town gossip is rife, and I do love small town stories. I can’t wait to see what book 3 brings us. I received an advanced copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved, loved, loved this book! Out of all the Meghan Quinn books I have read, this one was absolutely phenomenal. I had butterflies and chills at 13%. You will definitely fall in love with Rogan from the very beginning. This book does go back and forth between the past and present, but it is vital to the unfolding of this love story. Quinn has you riding a rollercoaster of emotions as you are reading.

That Forever Girl is definitely a Top 10 read for me!




I was supplied an advanced reader copy of this novel by NetGalley and voluntarily submit this review.

Was this review helpful?

That Forever Girl is the second book in the Getting Lucky series about four brothers who after being cursed whilst in New Orleans that they will never find true love. It can be read as a standalone but Griffins story was really good.
Here we have Griffins younger brother Rogan’s story. From childhood Rogan and Harper had been a couple and had their future mapped out together. After a terrible accident whilst in college Rogan becomes embittered and twisted and breaks Harper’s heart. She moves away and Rogan realised he’s lost the love of his life, pouring everything into his work with no interest in forming any relationships.
When Harper returns to the town for good he is determined to win Harper back but she is scared stiff after the heartbreak he caused.
This is a lovely story, full of emotion, with a cast of great characters, these brothers have brilliant banter between themselves and some very funny moments. It’s a tortured journey these two travel but what a ride we have with them.
A really engrossing, thorough enjoyable, I can’t wait for the next.
My thanks to net galley and publisher for the opportunity to review this book honestly.

Was this review helpful?

Well I have a new book boyfriend and his name is Rogan! I loved how rough and standoffish Rogan comes across and then to see that his is just an amazing, heart of gold guy. Now that Rogan's first and only love is back in town he is grouchy than ever. Being a successful businessman, Rogan is on top of the real estate marker in Port Snow. Guess who Harper must deal with in her new job, a very angry Rogan.

Harper was devastated when Rogan broke her heart in college and pushed her away. She was completely lost and wandered around the East Coast for seven long years searching for herself. Which brings her right back home to the safety of Port Snow. Not that being around Rogan is safe at all, this guys has it out for her. Rogan does NOT want Harper home, in his town, stirring up feelings that were never in the past but making Rogan face head on what he has tried to hide for 7 long years.

I felt this was a super emotional read that completely captivated me with each word. These two are made for one another and their love story was EPIC!

Thanks NetGalley and Montlake Romance for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This didn't work for me.
The banter between the brothers is good even funny at times.
The curse situation, maybe it's just me but I didn't get it, they are letting it rule their lives. It was a bit ridiculous.
Dual POV.
Flashback alternative chapters.
No intimate scenes with anyone other than the Hero and heroine.
No cheating.
No other woman/man drama except an experience related from the past.
The Hero broke up with the heroine, there is a lot involved but basically although they were engaged he completely cuts her off.
The situation is extreme but he is very cruel.
When they meet back up he is continually cruel to her, rude in front of others until around 50% of the book.
He makes it clear he doesn't want her back in town, publicly, and even when she begs him to stop, crying he still carries on.
He says it's because he loves her but they can't be together but I found him very dislikeable.
The heroine says“Don’t make this harder than it already is. I know this must be fun for you, acting like we’re great friends, but this hurts for me. So let’s just be cordial and get through these next few weeks, okay?”
When I read the blurb I thought the book would be about getting her back but it's pushing away then trying to get her back after around 55% mark, it wasn't soon enough for me.
I found some of the banter between the Hero and heroine childish later on.
There are references to the couple in book 1 and other characters are developed for future books.


HEA. If you trust him. I really didn't like it.

Was this review helpful?

Enjoyed it
Back to Port Snow...

What I liked:
The writing style
The characters
The texting between the brothers
Dual POVs
Part of a series: Getting Lucky
Standalone
HEA
Epilogue

I look forward to reading the next book in this series.

Was this review helpful?

This is Harper and Rogan book, it’s book two in the getting lucky series. Harper returns to her small town of Port snow Maine , for good! She’s running from a past she wants to forget! But she has another past in her home town that she wishes her mind and heart could forget! She was engaged to her childhood sweetheart until a terrible accident tore them apart! Now she has to face her childhood best friend/ fiancé and try not to loose her heart all over again! Rogan and his brothers think they’re cursed, actually his whole home town believes it too! Now his ex fiancé is back in town , he had pushed her away after a freak accident. Rogan can’t fight the growing attraction to the woman he has loved his whole life! He’s also hoping to put this curse to rest and see if he can win back her heart! This book was very good! I think I liked the first book a little better but this one was still really really good!! I definitely recommend reading this book and the first in the series although they can be standalone but they are well worth the read! Thank you Netgalley and the publishers for sharing this book with me!

Was this review helpful?