Member Reviews

Wasn't sure if I would like this offering from Ms. McGarry, but it turned out pretty good. I was wary of the supernatural elements but I liked the way she made them real. I did think the book seemed a little long at times.

Was this review helpful?

The Quick Cut: A girl who sees her mom's ghost and a boy who struggles to be his true self end up together on a school project. Together, they heal one another's wounds to get past what's haunting them.

A Real Review:
Thank you to Tor Teen for providing the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Not all wounds are physical. Most (if not all of us) walk around carrying the emotional baggage of things that have scarred or torn us apart. However, sometimes people find ways to get past the trauma holding them back in the most unlikely of places. This is the story that brings Veronica and Sawyer together.

Veronica believes in the supernatural and wants to prove it in her senior thesis. She sees her mom's ghost all the time, but can't escape the migraines that tend to come along with it. It can't be an ominous sign for what's happening with her brain tumor right? Meanwhile, Sawyer is known as a golden boy at school - but the truth is that he feels an intense pressure to be a person he's not. Between his mom's constant injections on his choices and the friends who miss the glimmers of his true self, he feels trapped. Can he ever escape or will the pressure continue to drive him to make bad choices?

This story is everything! Veronica and Sawyer may be totally different people, but the unfolding of their connection shows just how much we are all the same inside. If that's not enough, they also find this incredible way to support and see the true versions of each other everyone else misses. It's an incredible book that I know is going to stick with me a long time.

One of my favorite parts about this book is how naturally the true details of their home lives comes out. So many times, these details end up coming out on the page at one time or like little buckets of water drenched at sporadic times. Here, that more organic and lifelike process of little details trickling in takes place, adding a level of genuine feeling that's missed often.

There are also many medical disorders discussed, in a way that feels realistic. Between Veronica's brain tumor, Sawyer's dyslexia, and the overarching conversation of addiction, it could have been too much shoved into one story. The blending of these medical conditions into the drama goes over as less explanatory and more discovering.

With so much to unpack, this book unfolds in a glamorous fashion centered around two teens falling in love.

My rating: 5 out of 5

Was this review helpful?

Another winner, where real life haunts as hard as the spirit world and love triumphs. Katie McGarry hits another home run with this one.

Was this review helpful?

When I read the description of this book, I just knew I needed to read it and I'm so glad that I did! I love both the YA and Paranormal genres and Echoes Between Us merges the two wonderfully.

Told under dual voices from the two main characters, Veronica and Sawyer, this book explores the complexities of teenage life, sickness and addiction. There are so many layers to this book and it rarely went where I thought it was going to go. It was definitely a page turner!

The characters, while quirky and a little broken, are all very believable and likable. The plot line is both creepy and intriguing.

This was the first book that I have read by Katie McGarry, but it will certainly not be the last!

Thank you to NetGalley for my digital copy of the book and to Bookish First for my print copy. Both were in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very compelling read. Every time I thought the story would go in one direction it would go in another. The two main characters were very well developed and their personal stories made them very emotionally and physically drained. During parts I became nervous to turn the page. I wanted - and didn’t want to know what was going to happen next. It was an engaging read, well worth your time.

Was this review helpful?

This book was just so good! First, I didn’t realize that this book was set in the same town and time as Katie McGarry’s last book, Only a Breath Apart! We get to explore Jamie’s friend group with Veronica in this story.

Veronica is a tough cookie, in the best way, living life to the fullest and not caring what anyone thinks about her. She has a tumour that gives her migraines and the ability to see her mother’s ghost. She keeps her secrets, but all the while trying to prove ghosts and their existence with her English assignment. She is such an honourable, bold and strong character and I loved getting to read her story.

Sawyer seeks an escape and finds it diving off cliff sides, but his last jump was a close call. He sees his problem, and with caring for his younger sister when his mother is unable too, all the while caring for her after one too many drinks, he can’t seem to risk it any longer. I loved his character growth, he was so complex, it was hard not to love him.

These two aren’t from the same circles, but when they are paired together they compliment each other so well.
Both have their struggles and get support from one another, and it’s this that keeps me coming back to Katie McGarry’s books. This book made me laugh, cry and question some things about spirits and their whereabouts. Also, the real diary entries of Evelyn Bellak was an awesome addition to the story!

Thank you to the author and publisher for the ARC via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Our main character, Veronica has a brain tumor, which causes her migraines, she also sees her mothers ghost. She is an amazing character who lives her life day by day not caring what others think of her. She has awesome relationship with her father but she also worries about him and also about the changes with her tumor as this is how her mother died,

Sawyer is a thrill seeker, its his obsession; something that he is addicted to; he has an adorable sister who he adores and will do anything to protect. His mother is an alcoholic in denial and he is often left to be the responsible one in the family, often putting his own life on hold. His mother was truly horrible! my heart broke for Sawyer and his sister. I was relieved when his father and step mum played a role in their lives.

Veronica and Sawyer couldn't be more different, they have separate friendship groups but their growing friendship and eventual relationship was wonderful to read about; the way that they supported each other had me swooning. I enjoyed the character development and growth.

I loved the ghost hunting aspects of it, I never quite knew what was going on but it was done very well.

Echoes Between Us was a thrilling read that dealt with many issues - death, addiction, friendship, love and bullying, It was written beautifully, I adore Katie McGarry's writing style and her characters that are each written to perfection.

Thank you to the author and publisher for the opportunity to read and review this title via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

**Review will be posted on my blog http://pastmidnight.home.blog on January 7, 2020, nearer to publication date.**

*4.5 stars*

Thank you to Tor Teen and NetGalley for giving me the chance to read this eARC.

After I sped through this book last night, I wondered why they didn’t release for October because it was the perfect fall read for me! Why? Because of the ghosts! The creepiness factor of this book was SO unexpected, I literally had some chills reading this late past midnight. I almost stopped but pushed on and I’m glad I did.

This is more than a story of Sawayer, the popular hot guy, who pairs up with Veronica, the quirky weird girl at school to do a project. I mean that’s the gist of it but no, ohhhh nooooo…their Senior project Veronica or V as her friends call her, want to do is to prove ghosts exists. Okay! I love a good paranormal activity story.

But this was more than just a story about hunting down ghosts as well. V has a brain tumor and she a reason for this project. Sawyer doesn’t believe in ghosts because he feels like his real life is scary and messed up already. He has secrets and these two teenager find a way past their first impressions to understand one another and help each other out in ways unexpected.

What I Liked:

*I love the ghost hunting! I love when they had to research for their project, it even scared me. Yes, I used to binge ghost hunting shows like Paranormal Activity haha and in high school, it was all about going to haunted spots with friends, just to get that thrill of maybe seeing something. But um this book did too good a job at scaring me….🙈👻

*We get dual POV in this story. Sawyer is a complex character with his role as caretaker, and swim star. The pressure and depression he feels from every aspect in his life and his dangerous coping mechanism was taking a toll on him. I seriously felt for him, so glad he gets help. I liked seeing him attend the AA meetings and basically just trying his best to be better for himself, and his sister.

*Veronica is special and the ones who realize it protect her. I love that she had a protective circle of friends since others in their community just thought she was super weird. She has these horrible migraines because of her tumor and just seeing her go through it, it’s tough. Her grief over her mother though, broke my heart.

*Sawyer and Veronica’s love story is beautiful ❤️. At one point I said aloud, “I love you, Sawyer”. 🤣😱 I was like, whoa where did that come from? HAHA…even though Veronica is this shining light and the person who shows him life can be thrilling in a different way…he is the thing that grounds her. They struggle with their relationship and feelings as well…but he was mature enough to make some hard but right decisions and I was like, go Sawyer. I didn’t mind their relationship drama in this, I thought it fit in well and was believable. Their love wasn’t all consuming, it was deep but I liked that family came first too. And V stepped up to the plate too…I love how they decided to be all in. All in.

*There are heavy topics in this story like addiction. Sawyer’s mom is clearly an addict, and Sawyer is addicting to adrenaline. Veronica is dealing with grief. Heavy topics all around but it works even as it’s interwoven with this ghost hunting project. It’s written so well.

*There is a historical angle as well to this story with the TB Hospital in Kentucky. I googled it and just looking at the photo of the sanatorium scares me! Haha, I would have not been brave like Veronica and her friends to be hanging out that place. But there is a diary that Sawyer reads, a diary of a girl named Evelyn Bellak who was a patient at the hospital back in 1918. According to the author, the diary is real. Sawyer reads the diary and relates to Evelyn in many ways.

Things That Made Me Go Hmmm:

~Sawyer’s mom… 😔 I know it’s part of Sawyer’s story but wow. It shows his mom spiraling into her addiction and Sawyer cleaning up after her but there is one thing that she does that affects his younger sister and it made me livid. But his mom was hitting rock bottom…and rock bottom is not pretty to see. I was hurting for Sawyer…I mean what’s a kid to do, he was trying so hard.

~Sylvia his best friend – she was only trying to help him but at times she frustrated me. But she had her own insecurities too so…🤷🏻‍♀️

~Just a few triggers: grief, cancer, chemo, depression, addiction.

Final Thoughts:

This story blended ghost hunting, grief, brain tumor, and addiction so seamlessly. I was getting chills from the ghost hunting scenes and Sawyer’s penchant for jumping. I was scared from both things. I was afraid for both Sawyer and Veronica and hoping both would confront their ghosts and make it out okay. But I also fell in love with with Sawyer and V falling in love. ❤️ Overall, it was an emotional rollercoaster and I enjoyed Echoes Between Us very much. Don’t read it in the dark though (I was on my fire tablet lol), because you won’t only be tingling from the love story but getting chills from the ghost stories too! Or maybe it’s because I scare easily…haha.

Was this review helpful?

I started reading this one after a much needed break from fantasy. Don't get me wrong, I love fantasy but sometimes I just need to find myself immersed in another genre. This book was definitely different than what I thought it would be. It wasn't in a bad way and I did find myself liking it for the most part but like most other books, I did have a few issues while reading through it.

Veronica is an interesting character. She dresses differently and also sees ghosts. She also is dealing with a brain tumor that is the same that took her mother. I liked that Veronica didn't let the tumor consume her life. She didn't tell people about it or want people to know to garner sympathy. She wanted people to see her for her. I also enjoyed how her dad's nickname for her was peanut because that is what my dad has called me. It definitely did make me feel connected to her in a way.

The one character that she lets in besides her friends and dad is Sawyer. He is the complete opposite of her when it comes to social status at their school. Before partnering up with her on an English project, he knows who she is and his friends talk a lot about her. His mother even mentions how weird she is. That is one thing that annoyed me. I am just not a fan of the weird/strange girl falling for the jock trope. It's just been done a lot. I will say that Sawyer may hang out with a lot of people and fit into that trope but since he is hiding an addiction it makes him seem more realistic. It proves that even though on the outside his life may be perfect, it doesn't mean that it is.

Let's also talk about his mother. She is a real terrible mother. She is the worst and it has a lot to do with her drinking problem. Sawyer is the one that has to pick up after her and is raising his sister. It's a sad thing to read about but it is an important topic to discuss and I think it was handled nicely.

When it came to the other more minor characters, some felt a bit one dimensional. This is definitely one of those books where the main characters are the star of the plot and that was okay. I didn't mind.

As for the plot, it was interesting and not really what I was expecting. There are paranormal aspects but not in the way the synopsis talks about. I think more or less it was really about how the past haunts us and to always be aware who we let in.

The romance/relationship in this book just wasn't for me. They hadn't known each other for long and they were already falling in love. It did remind me of A Walk to Remember in some ways. Even the fight they had was very reminiscent.

My favorite part about this book was the inclusion of quotes from a girl who had tuberculosis. They were real quotes from her life in one of those hospitals back in the early 1900's. The outbreak and treatments of those patients have always fascinated me and being where I live near Louisville, KY helped make this book extra special since I live 10 minutes away.

Although I ran into a few issues, I still thought it was a good read all in all.

Was this review helpful?

This book takes place in the world that Only a Breath Apart takes place. This book follows Veronica (Jesse's friend) as she struggles with making a new life after her friends have moved on to the next stage of her life. I really liked this theme because it's something that not just young adults deal with, but all people deal with. We all have to learn how to let go and let people live their lives even if it's with out us.

Sawyer has his own demons that he has to fight. He was forced to grow up before he was ready and all he wants is to be a teenager kid. I liked how he transformed through the book and he grew up to be a better version of himself.

I really enjoyed the relationship between Sawyer and Veronica. They bring out a side to each other that they may have lost. When they are with each other they get to be teenagers and forget about the rest of the world.

Mcgarry is a master at writing emotions that you can (or maybe it's just me) relate to on a deeper level. The struggle, the longing, the fear. It's hard to capture that emotion in words but somehow Mcgarry is a genius.

Was this review helpful?

Take the weird girl who likes to celebrate holidays early, the uber popular guy who has a secret addiction, add in a little ghost action and you have Echoes Between Us. I really enjoyed this book. The story kept me turning pages late into the night. The characters were very likable. The ending was a perfect wrap to this book. Pick it up! In fact pick up any Katie McGarry book! You won't be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Another heart-wrenching tale from Katie McGarry. Veronica is dying. There's a tumour in her brain and all she wants is to hide it - keep it a secret - be her own version of weird - and not die a slow agonising death like her mother. Sawyer is courting death - jumping off cliffs - looking for an adrenaline rush - trying to keep a facade going for his friends and his little sister. When Sawyer and Veronica team up for a class project to investigate the existence of ghosts, neither understood exactly what they were in for. Sawyer's a non-believer, but Veronica can see - but is what she sees real or is it just the tumour? Join two teens as they struggle to find truth about life, death and things in between.

This book is both beautiful and sad - yet full of hope. Enjoy!

Was this review helpful?

I love how everything in this book takes on a different meaning after you have read it. Like the rest of McGarry's books this one is wonderful , but it is deeper. You can read it several times and it is still not clear if anything was ever truly verified or validated. You can piece together things that prove and disprove but the beauty of the story is indisputable.
I would say this book is one of McGarry's best and I have a library of her work that I re read several times a year.

Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan-Tom Doherty Associates for the privilege of received an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review. The ideas and comments are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge fan of Katie McGarry's work and this story did not disappoint! A truly beautifully written story - I laughed, I cried, I was disappointed, I was angry - I swear I experienced almost every emotion throughout this entire novel. One HUGE emotional roller coaster ride from start to finish. She truly captured the emotion when it comes to fighting addiction and fighting to stay sane amidst devastating news.

This story combined two of my favorite things - ghosts and history. The way McGarry was able to blend the two amidst the main characters hardships was truly amazing.

When we first meet Veronica, we're introduced to this quirky, ghost loving teenager, who seems to have the world on shoulders yet doesn't want to let anyone in to alleviate her worries. She doesn't want to feel "stuck" with everyone worrying about her and worrying about her brain tumor. Especially her dad. Then we meet Sawyer, who is viewed as this typical high school jock who has the world bowing down at his feet. Yet, in reality he's someone who just doesn't know where he stands in the world. He doesn't know how to "deal" with the pressure of his family, school, struggling with dyslexia... and uses these struggles to fuel his addiction - one that he knows will kill him, but continues on to feed the need for a good rush. Especially when it comes to his family - between the issues with his parents divorce, his mom, and having to be in a way a father figure to his little sister, These pressures fuel his desire. Throughout the novel as we watch these two characters interact we see a whole different side to both, Sawyer understands that he can't be the world to everyone, that he needs to put himself first. .

Beyond understanding the characters, we're given a story within a story. McGarry uses the diary of Evelyn Bellak to bring about a way to understand what it's like for a teenager stuck in a hospital trying to hopefully overcome TB, but takes each day at a time. Continuously upbeat, despite the circumstances. We're introduced to Evelyn through Sawyer when he finds the book mysteriously placed in a room in the downstairs house that his family is renting from Veronica's dad. Sawyer becomes entranced with Evelyn's story, reading little bits at a time wherever he goes. These little bits of her diary also fuel the ideas of whats going on as Veronica and Sawyer work together to understand the idea of ghosts. Despite their views of each other, both characters are pushed together to complete a senior thesis. Using Veronicas idea of wanting to prove that ghosts are real and there. We have Veronica who wholly believes in ghosts and wants to prove to her dad before she dies that they are real - so that he'll never be alone, he'll know that she's always there - along with her mom. Then we have Sawyer who doesn't believe, even after reading Evelyn's diary, his sisters visions of ghosts, and visiting places that are haunted. He continues to be skeptical even to the end - which is contributed to the fact of him still battling the fight with addiction and his fight to continue to save Veronica as she battles her brain tumor.

However, despite his scepticism - he learns that everyone has a residual haunting. And that is one thing he'll stand by.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book in exchange for my review. Thank you NetGalley!

Katie McGarry is so talented.. Seriously.. her books NEVER disappoint.

Echoes Between Us was no different. The characters are amazing and beautiful. The storyline is unique and easy to follow.
I could NOT p ut this book down.

Was this review helpful?

I'm never disappointed in Katie McGarry's books and this one just proves that statement is even more true. Another fantastic book in her collection. And silly me, didn't realize before that Veronica is our V from Only a Breath Apart. As soon as I saw Jesse's and Scarlett's names it clicked. I was like duh, no wonder she is familiar! And it made me wish I re-read Only a Breath Apart so that I remembered everything about V. But it was okay, because as I read things started clicking. So Veronica and Sawyer's story, just wow! So many emotions with this one. Lot of difficult topics were tackled in this book and McGarry did it beautifully. Really, really fantastic. With Veronica's brain tumor and feeling like Death wherever she went and Sawyer's adrenaline addiction, you would think that throwing them together would immediately equal disaster. It didn't. And I was glad. I was glad to see that instead of their flaws and issues hurting one another and making a relationship between them impossible, it really had them acknowledging their issues and supporting one another. There wasn't hostility toward one another or throwing their issues in the other's face to harm them. It was, this is what is should be when two people love one another and only want to help the other, even when your own life is collapsing. And those two specific issues were just pieces of many others that are tackled in their stories. I was hooked from the moment I started it. I couldn't put this book down. I wanted to know how they would make it through their story, what their outcome would be, and how would they get there. If you love her other books, this one needs to be on your TBR list. It doesn't disappoint. I loved Veronica and Sawyer's story and like all good books, I'm sad to see it over.

Was this review helpful?

Well written and easy to read, the characters were very likeable! It was so easy to be pulled into their world. The main character Veronica has a brain tumour which she watched her mom die from a few years before. Sawyer comes from a broken family and ends up having to parent his youngest sister a lot. They are an unusual match but that makes their story so intriguing to read!

Was this review helpful?

Such a well written book. The characters were super lovable, the plot was intriguing and over all was a lovely story.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This book has all the emotions and I felt every one as I read it. I don't want to give away the story but this book is so different from what I thought it was going to be about and at the end. This book deals with some difficult and sad issues and a few times I had to put it down, but I was always drawn back to it. Katie does an amazing job of drawing you into her characters and care about them. I loved how these characters were total opposites, but ended up sharing many of the same problems. This was a different story from Katie, but it was well worth the read.

Was this review helpful?

I have long been a fan of this author. I love the small town setting and the references to the state and areas I know. This latest story is a worthy addition to this series. Veronica is living with a life altering condition. Sawyer is the popular jock dealing with demons of his own. These two agree to work on a senior project together and their different worlds collide. As they investigate local hauntings and ghost, to determine if they are real, they end up redefining their pasts and their future. I love how well researched this story appears to be. Ms. McGarry includes enough factual details that a big chicken like me began to feel uneasy, especially since I recognized some of the places she included. This story also reflects the valuable message that you need to look beyond outward behaviors and rumors before you pass judgement on someone else. I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves real world problems surrounded in mystery with hidden kernels of truth throughout! Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?