Member Reviews
I don’t know if I was influenced by the fact that I read this at the same time that I’m reading Little Women with a book club, but the similarities are crazy! Take the sisterhood created by Alcott and stir in a dash of magical realism and a modern setting, and the result is Tigers, Not Daughters.
At times the plot line was a bit hard to follow because of jumps between the narrator and the sisters and between past and present. Otherwise, I was hooked by the mystery and tragedy and processing of grief.
Wow.....this books was hauntingly beautiful. The Torres's sisters relationship with each other are messy, genuine, beautiful and incredibly human. You can feel their pain and frustration through the pages. Their sorrow at having lost their older sister Ana, who seemed like the one who kept them together, the glue of the family. After her death it's almost like each sister sort of unravels... Jessica wants nothing more than to become Ana. Iridian looses herself within the pages of the books Ana used to read, while Rosa finds herself trying to find that "magic" Ana always said she had. Each individual sister finds the strength to pull through and the strength to be their for each other. They don't need a man to save the day for them...the saved themselves and it's what makes this story so beautiful and touching. Not sure if my review makes a lot of sense but just know that this book will stay with you long after you've read the last page.
Thanks to NetGalley and Algonquin Young Readers for an egalley in exchange for an honest review.
Wisdom and goodness to the vile seem vile.
Filths savor but themselves. What have you done?
Tigers, not daughters, what have you performed?
A father, and a gracious agèd man,
Whose reverence even the head-lugged bear would lick,
Most barbarous, most degenerate, have you madded.
(William Shakespeare, King Lear Act 4 Scene 2)
A book that had a dash of scent that felt reminiscent of The Virgin Suicides with four sisters( Ana, Iridian, Jessica, and Rosa) who intrigue the neighbors that watch the strange ongoing drama at the Torres home. When the eldest sister, Ana is killed after seemingly falling from the bedroom window, her father is lost in his grief and her three living sisters in both grief and rage. The story as a paranormal element as the sisters and some of their neighbors start to believe that Ana Torress is not resting peacefully. We see the story through the eyes of each sister and although there were times that I felt a bit confused at the nonlinear way the story was being told, I was attached to finding out how it was all going to play out.
Goodreads review 06/03/20
Expected publication 24/03/20
this is the kind of story you don't really know how to process because it's so deeply good. you know sometimes with books dealing with hard topics (here death of a sister, physical and emotional abuse from a parent and a partner, living with grief) you feel like you can't read it unless you're in a specific mood. the right mood. but I did not feel like this for Tigers, Not Daughters. for this one, I felt like I needed to keep reading, I needed to read more and more about these three sisters and how much they love and miss their older sister, how they each have a different way to live with their grief. I simply needed to know. and this book delivered everything and more. it was so quiet and yet so brilliant.
TW: Grief, death of a family member and domestic/relationship abuse.
I liked this book. It was a story about grief and a family of sisters that went through it all together after the death of their sister. The Torres' sisters were all different and had their own things going on but they learn that embracing each other and sticking together would be the best way to overcome anything that came their way. The scenes that dealt with the abuse were a bit hard to read for me. I am not a fan of seeing a person going through it but it was such an important part of this story. I enjoyed the magical realism aspect of this as well and really liked the writing style. Overall I recommend this book as long as you are in the right headspace.
I keep thinking of this book as a Latinx version of The Virgin Suicides mixed with a paranormal Little Women, and I think that's pretty much on the nose. There were elements to this I enjoyed: the bonds between sisters, the exploration of a complicated family trying to make it in a complicated world, the stream of magical realism running throughout. But there were also things that didn't jive with me: the moments of creepy teen boy behavior like stalking and staring through bedroom windows (which, again, is very Virgin Suicides) is never really addressed here, which in a book by, about, and for women seemed a bit off; some of Ana's appearances don't really serve to move the story forward; and the jumping narrative viewpoints felt at times to serve up more open endings than answers.
Tigers, Not Daughters is the story of four sisters who feel trapped in their own lives. After the oldest sister falls from her bedroom window and dies, literally mid-escape, if only for a few hours, her three younger sisters are left to pick up the pieces. One turns to the church, one to an abusive boyfriend, and the third retreats into herself and her writing and refuses to leave the house. A year after Ana's death, the three sisters begin to notice strange happenings, and conclude that they are being haunted by their sister.
I am definitely a sucker for stories about sisterhood -- it's something that's so important for me since my own relationship with my sister is so messy and beautiful. Jessica, Iridian, and Rosa may have gone in somewhat different directions with their grieving processes, but it's shiningly clear how much they love each other unconditionally and will always have each other's backs, no matter what. This, I believe is the ultimate triumph of the book.
Magical realism is a genre I really really enjoy, and while this kind of teeters on the edge for me as to whether or not I'd actually call it that, there are so many elements of this book that are everything I love about the genre, regardless of if there's enough magic or not (which is honestly unnecessarily nitpicky, so let's just move on). Mabry's writing has the characteristic simplicity I associate with magical realism, the story follows common themes, the small elements of magic push the characters towards growth. Fans of the genre will not be disappointed.
I will say that my only criticism is the number of POVs. Each of the three sisters has one, and there's also the odd chapter that's told by this unified voice of a group of boys who hang out across the street from the Torres' house. They witness Ana's death, and their outsider's perspective gives the audience access to knowledge that the sisters themselves don't (yet) have. I actually kind of liked this fourth perspective, and honestly, my POV issue is with the sisters.
This is a short book, and I almost wished that I could have spent the entire time in just one or two POVs. I was significantly more invested in Jessica's part of the story than either of her other sisters, and perhaps if the book had been longer, I would have been able to connect more with them, but as it stands, I had trouble feeling equally invested in all four narrators.
All in all, though, I'm a fan of Tigers, Not Daughters. It's a story of growing up and growing together and sisterhood and grief and longing for freedom. If magical realism is something you're a fan of (and you don't mind the odd haunting), then this book is for you.
I think I just read the magical realistic, dark, horrific version of “Little Women”!
Yes, there are four sisters. Let’s meet the creepy, obsessed, isolated, unique Torres sisters one by one. But before that, let’s not forget: one of them is already gone!
Pure hearted, animal lover, wandering around the town in the middle of the night, one of the weirdest sisters Rosa reminded me of little Beth as introverted, couch potato, self-punisher, book-worm and forced writer Iridian carries pieces of Jo and Jessica tries to gather the pieces of estranged family, taking care of her own father and bread winner of the family, working at the drugstore, humming her songs at the storage secretly as she misses to sing in chorus is a character between dependable Meg and flirty Amy.
Three sisters trapped in a house with their neglecting, irresponsible father, living in debts and never keeping his promises. The walls start to close and they’re about to crush them as they suffer from suffocation, claustrophobia. And they are also trapped in the house with their dead sister Ana’s ghost. Isn’t it getting better? Sure it is!
Ana and her sisters try to run away from the Southtown as they spied by the neighborhood boys’ gang who want to help their escape but accidentally become the reason of their caught up. Their father Rafe brings them back but Ana is determined to escape which ends her life by falling down the window.
Three sisters deal with Ana’s death at different ways. Iridian carries Ana’s favorite book in everywhere like her compass and begins writing romance novels to finish what her sister started. Jessica moves to Ana’s room, using her makeup products (she does something a little far in the shower, I’m not gonna tell that but yes, it is really extreme!), then she also starts dating Ana’s scumbag, abusive boyfriend John as if she’s punishing herself. And Rosa thinks their sister’s soul is reincarnated into a wild hyena’s body, is wandering around the houses and create terror around the householders.
This is surprising, extreme, dark, spooky, creepy story with fast pacing, short chapters, keeping your attention alive from the beginning. Ending was good and entertaining even though there are still some plot holes. And in my opinion there are some missing pieces about the back stories of the sisters. We only know how they move on their lives while they’re struggling with their inner demons and tremendous grief. But we don’t know how they were before the tragedy hit their place and tear them apart.
Rosa, Jessica and sweetpie Peter was my favorite characters. I had some hard time to connect with Iridian till the last chapters and learning the reason why she isolated herself from the outer world.
Overall: It was still interesting, unique, moving, haunting, dazzling and promising read. And the cover is fascinating! I’m giving 3.5 stars and rounding them up to 4.
Special thanks to NetGalley and Algonquin Young Readers for sharing this captivating ARC with me in exchange my honest review.
Women need no man to thrive.
Tigers, Not Daughters is a cover request and I have no idea what this book is all about until I started reading this. Modern Little Women plus magical realism and paranormal elements seem to be a strange combination but everything clicked on this Samantha Mabry's upcoming release.
A riveting read that will make you read one more chapter until you realize you're on the last page of the book, Tigers, Not Daughters is a book that discusses the various kind of grief each of us are experiencing when dealing with the loss of someone we love.
The story is based on Torres sisters' (Ana, Jessica, Iridian, and Rosa) life after their mother, Rita, passed away giving birth to the youngest of them and living with their grieving father.
Life became worse for them after Ana died one night after falling out of her bedroom window which allow a brand new kind of feeling mixed with year's-old trauma of losing their mother surface. This made their father, Rafe, grieved more and lose his grip on staying alive resorting to sleeping on someone's house and alcohol abuse which left the sisters in disarray and with no one to hold.
All of these worsen when the ghost of Ana starts to visit the Torres house making weird activities such as appearing in the bathroom and writing passages on the wall. The remaining sisters, clueless and lonely, are all left to find the answer on why their late sister come back to their house? Is she forcing them to leave the house? Or does she have unfinished business with them?
The poetry lives in this Samantha Mabry book and it is evident all throughout with the lines and subplots developing the backstories and current lives of the remaining Torres sisters. Each one of them stood out with unique characteristics: Jessica as hardworking and family-oriented, Iridian as creative and passionate, and Rosa as adventurous and brave. This book never fail in delivering the capabilities of women and how the reality should now that women need no men to survive.
I love being surprised with this kind of book and since this is my first March read, I am looking forward to more great reads.
RATING: 4.5stars
This book deals with some heavy subject matter - a family grieving in various ways after the tragic loss of their sister.
For me, the bonds between the sisters are one of the highlights of the story. Sure, they have their squabbles, but will also defend each other until the end. Each has their own distinct personality and way of dealing with grief - some in not the most healthy ways - and I appreciated the different POVs of each sister.
My favorite parts of the story are when Ana's ghost tries to communicate with her sisters - I always love the addition of anything supernatural - and it's the primary reason I requested this book. Without giving away spoilers, one situation involving Ana left me hanging at the end, and I would have liked to know the outcome. Some parts, while interesting, felt a little disjointed and didn't really come together for me.
This is a well-written, quick read (I read it on a two hour flight), but a dark, heavy tale of grief and loss with a supernatural twist.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
The story of three sisters mourning for their late fourth sister pulled at all my heartstrings in the best way!
Trigger warnings: human and animal death, abuse in a romantic relationship.
I feel like the characters in the book were well fleshed out. The story was relatable. The writing was easy read and it was a story that had my emotions everywhere.
5 favorite stars
This was lightning in a bottle, a gunshot in progress. Loved it with my entire soul.
Writing: wrap me in these sentences, I'll sleep in a bed of these words
Characters: ★★★★★
The Vibe: ★★★★★
Tigers, Not Daughters comes out on March 24, 2020!
Tigers, Not Daughters hit me from the side with a punch that I wasn't expecting. Magical realism, grief, ghosts, the unshakable reality of sisters, and use of multiple narrators all collided to bring one unforgettable (and new favorite) read.
The Torres sisters were always a set of four. Ana, Jessica, Iridian, and Rosa. Their mother isn't there, and their father shouldn't be there, but life is life and that's how it goes.
Except it's not. Because Ana's dead.
Ana's death cracks the lines of this fragile family into 3 distinct shards. We have Jessica, who misses Ana so much that she consumes her, becomes her, shoving the angry versions of herself under layers of steely indifference. We have Iridian, who feels more comfortable with words than with people, as it's only ever people who hurt her over and over. We have Rosa, whose magical ways of understanding reality leave her with a different lens, but no less pain.
All three sisters have survived the impact of Ana leaving them in waves, but when a ghostly presence interrupts their fragile grief, the storm arrives again.
This was so, so good. I loved it. Mabry's realism was definitely magical, but it was also earthy and gritty in a way that was so exciting to read. These sisters were raw, they were real, and they had all kinds of aspects—the good, the bad, the ugly, and the bizarre in a way that only girls can be. The vibe of sisters was perfect.
I also loved the writing. This is a tale in the telling, and the snapshots of perspectives and the lyricism in the sentences flowed in such a way that this story was all-consuming. You lived the Torres sisters and you were them at the same time. This kind of writing is a gem to read in any situation, and I loved its deft handling of grief, darker themes, and resilience.
Thank you to Algonquin Young Readers for an ARC of this title in exchange for an honest review.
I loved this book. It reminded me of The Virgin Suicides but with out the problem that the sisters in that story are mysterious, idyllic beings. The Torres sisters are real and complex. Their story is moving and compelling.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an eARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Magical realism is one of my favorite genres and this book has this as a surprising twist. I was not expecting some of the magical elements and I felt that they flowed smoothly for the most part. I will say that one of the sisters had a power that I felt wasn’t explored enough, but overall the magic was done well.
I loved how strong the girls were together and the overall message of sisterhood and love. It was a fast-paced, suspenseful book that tugged at my heart quite a bit.
Some things I was disappointed in was the development of the dad and the ending with him...I just felt a little lost and let down. I also had a hard time believing the ending with him. The same is with the relationship between the oldest sister and the boyfriend John. I don’t want to give anything away, but his role and her haunting just felt confusing and I wish it had been elaborated a little.
Overall, I enjoyed this young adult magical realism book. Although some plot points felt rushed, it was enjoyable and I loved the theme.
Immediately this book reminded me of THE VIRGIN SUICIDES. But there is one major difference: I hated THE VIRGIN SUICIDES and loved TIGERS, NOT DAUGHTERS. Beginning with tragedy, this story is woven with so much love and I found myself rooting for the Torres sisters at every step. I’m very excited to see where the author takes the story next.
The Torres sisters are the modern-day Little Women. A tragedy rips their family apart but through everything, the sisters reunite when it matters the most. I was drawn in by the description of this book. When I started reading it the characters were what kept me reading. In the same way as Little Women, you kind of find yourself identifying with one of the characters. For me, Iridian was the one I connected with the most because of her love of literature and writing. But the other sisters had characteristics that I loved as well. Like Rosa’s love for animals and her empathy towards them. Through their narratives, you see how each one of them has their way of coping with the death of their sister, Ana. The material in the book can be quite heavy depending on the person.
This begins much like Jeffrey Eugenides's The Virgin Suicides--narrated by the boys in a neighborhood who spy on a house full of sisters, all of whom are trying to escape--until one dies. After the death of their oldest sister, the remaining girls each try to find paths for themselves--through work, relationships, religion. But none of it really works for them until everything comes to a head when the ghost of their sister appears. The reaction of the neighborhood to her appearance gives the remaining sisters the energy they need to leave their abusive father, abusive boyfriends, abusive schools, and to seek out a new path together. A good book about women making do for themselves, about empowerment, about standing up to abuse. Powerfully written and beautifully constructed.
I loved this book. Tigers, Not Daughters, tells the story of the four Torres sisters, one of whom is a ghost. They dream of running away, but are pulled back by their emotionally broken and derelict father, among other things. (Trigger warning: physical and emotional abuse.)
What starts off as a story of tragic sisters with strong Virgin Suicides vibes quickly develops into an ode to sisterhood, standing up for yourself, and being strong when no one else will.
I was giving this book in exchange of a honest review. Wow what can I say this book took me a little longer than it takes me to read a book because of the complex and emotions it took me threw... honestly if you like dysfunctional families, ghost stories, sisterly love, mysteries this book is for you. I loved the characters that we followed in the book and how each sister is written so uniquely that I couldn’t help but to grow attached to them. This is my first experience with reading a. Samantha Mabry book but I will be reading more of her work.
ARC provided by Algonquin Young Readers via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Tigers, Not Daughters by Samantha Mabry is an emotional typhoon on paper.
I was captivated from the very beginning and it just got better and better. As Courtney Summers said: “You don’t read Samantha Mabry’s books so much as experience them.” I couldn’t stop reading. I didn’t imagine how glorious this book would have been and I am utterly ecstatic.