YAAAAAY! Horus Heresy!
Ahem.
I really loved this book - I really enjoyed everything about it, and was fairly engaged throughout. There was a lot of battle, and all of that, but there was a lot of richness and story and elements that I just felt were perfect touches.

My one complaint - Heresy is ongoing and has been for a very long time. I'm not entirely certain I'd remembered everything that I should reading it, and I did have to ask my more knowledgable friends who actively play the game now (as I don't any more) if I understood some of the stuff. Now, that could be because I knew I was missing something, or I'm just that sort of person, but if it's something everyone needed to do, and didn't have access to two active players (in my case), then there could be some confusion. If I could half star on here for that reason it'd be 4.5 stars.
But, I can't give it five, so I'm having to call it four.

I received a copy from Netgalley in exchange for reviews.

Dark, brutal, and utterly addictive.Haley, once again, crafted a tale that is riddle with intrigue, suspense, and balls to the wall action and horror. Simply incredible, and a must read for all Warhammer fans. I can't wait for the next one.

I have only recently discovered the pleasure of Warhammer books and really should have read this book after catching up on others in the series, it’s a good book. I enjoyed but found a lot of the characters and back story confusing as I was not aware of canon or lore, my fault not the authors

Great novel within the Horus Hersey timeline - like most things WH40k, some background knowledge is useful but not required. The individual Primarchs are well written, each feeling like a unique character with different goals and ambitions, and the non-Legion characters are well fleshed out as well. I definitely would recommend reading back and getting caught up on the storyline before jumping into the middle of the series, but as this is book two of the Siege of Terra arc, that shouldn't take too long, I'm definitely watching for the arc to continue and will pick up the rest as they come.

Guy Haley has written an excellent multi-perspective account of the Siege of Terra, following several characters, transhuman and otherwise showing us the different faces and experiences of war, on the ground, in the skies above Holy Terra and in the warp, both loyalist and traitor.

"If a man is treated as a beast, then he becomes a beast!" - Apostle

An epic continuation of the Siege of Terra, read this to see how the story unfolds with mighty battles against an unfathomable foe. 5/5 a great read, would highly recommend.

Game Workshop have been building up to the Siege of Terra for so long now, through the Horus Heresy series. It's finally arriving, and so far it's a huge disappointment,

The biggest problem I had with this book was the language. It goes totally overboard on metaphors and similes, which means that it reads like poetry written by a not very good poet. Descriptive passages go on and on, mixing metaphors and finding new ways of talking about how dirty and how noisy war is, until I was losing the will to read. So, so many pages talking about how noisy the siege is.

The Primarchs, some of the most interesting characters in the GW pantheon, have mostly been reduced to caricatures. Horus does precisely nothing for the entire book. Angron storms around in a sulk. Fulgrim just giggles and claps in his brief appearance. Sanguinius is apparently completely bullet-proof now. With their roles greatly reduced, there's very little talking in the book other than barked orders above the noise of the siege. There's one scene with the Mechanicum which hints at the possibility of some interesting politics but then ignores them for the rest of the book, and there's a scene where the 12 High Lords come together, for a little bit of exposition but no interesting interplay.

There are also a couple of Alpha Legion operatives who are sadly wasted. Having sneaked inside the defences they then do hardly anything at all. A huge waste for one of the most interesting legions.

This rather long book could have just as easily been an interesting two or three page narrative in White Dwarf magazine, rather than a filler novel to start the siege off.

Another wonderful production from Black Library! This book gets you in touch with all of the emotions that are present with all of the characters. You could really feel what the characters went through during this incredibly tumultuous experience! Feel battle on Holy Terra unfold before you!

Where The Solar War covered events spanning the whole of the Sol system this is much more concentrated on Terra and its immediate orbit. There’s still lots going on, from the perspective of primarchs, legionaries and mortals on both sides of the conflict, but it’s a more focused story this time around. While primarchs and legionaries plan their strategies (often pushing back against orders or expectations) and wait to be unleashed, conscript Katsuhiro – dragged away from his normal life and utterly out of his depth – provides a consistent, human viewpoint on the brutal realities of defending the outer wall; the siege in microcosm.

This was never going to have quite the thrill of The Solar War – being the first Siege of Terra novel – or the epic action of what’s still to come, while dedicated Space Marine fans might wish for a bit more Astartes action (don’t worry though, there’s plenty of that to come!). Instead, while there’s lots of variety – and some brilliant moments that could only come towards the end of the Heresy – the focus always returns to the grinding, attritional brutality of manning the walls, Katsuhiro’s misery broken up by (awesome) moments of bravery, glory and occasionally intrigue. There are teasing revelations and snippets of foreshadowing throughout, and in answering some of the questions about the siege Haley in turn poses some tantalising suggestions as to what might come next. Overall Haley has done a fantastic job of maintaining the tone and illustrating the complexity and ferocity of these first stages on Terra, while moving the narrative on, setting the scene for the siege to ramp up in intensity, and simply telling a compelling story.

The final stages of the Horus Heresy continue, in this engaging second novel in the Siege of Terra series. Haley packs a lot into this novel, as he moves the story forward, fills in some gaps, and sets the stage for the continuing siege. I really enjoyed this.

There’s a lot that I could write about this novel. Haley does a fantastic job of not only keeping the action coming, but also expanding the overall story of the Heresy and its main players. The author gives us plenty of new revelations about certain key players, and also starts laying the groundwork for the post-Heresy storyline(s). In many ways, I found these to be the most important aspects of the novel, and I’ll return to them in a bit.

The Lost and the Damned starts with a few short chapters and scenes to introduce us to the main players in the novel, on both sides of the war. On the loyalist side, we have the Primarchs Dorn, Sanguinius and the Khan; as well as Malcador the Sigillite and Valdor. These legends of the era grapple with the strain of the traitors’ siege on Terra and specifically the Palace. Haley focuses much of the action in the story on a (relatively) small section of the battlefield — as he suggests in the author’s note at the end of the novel, the scale of the Imperial Palace is such that to cover it all would have been nigh-impossible.

In addition to these already famous names, Haley introduces us to a handful of the rank-and-file, each of whom we will follow for as long as possible as the first waves of the siege unfold. Most prominently, Katsuhiro, a conscript on the frontlines. Through him, we get to experience many of the horrors of the ground war — the first waves of mutants and dispossessed, the ferocious charges of the World Eaters, the sinister chem-weapons of the changed Death Guard (we also get to see Mortarion in his new daemon aspect for the first time). We also see the effect of the Primarchs on the loyalist mortals. We also see at times the cold humanity of the Space Marines, as the Primarchs attempt to balance their responsibilities to the people with the tactical realities of warfare on this scale and with these stakes. There is some tension between the brothers (Dorn is becoming increasingly cold and ruthless), but ultimately they are able to make it work and utilize their best traits and skills for the war effort.

There is an excellent, very useful scene in which Dorn, Sanguinius, the Khan and Malcador discuss the disposition of their brothers. It’s a good reminder that we, the readers, know far more than those in the story. The Sigillite reveals certain truths that had been kept from the Primarchs, and confirms or contradicts some of their beliefs related to their brothers. Mistakes are admitted, Horus’s machinations become more clear, and the loyalists precarious position outlined. Of the 17 Primarchs still alive, there are only three on Terra, and it’s unsurprising that they are feeling the strain.

‘Six against three,’ said Sanguinius. ‘Where are the rest of those loyal to the Throne?’

‘The Lion, incommunicado as always,’ said Dorn. ‘Roboute Guilliman, on his way. Corax, lost. Headstrong, foolish Leman Russ, lost. Ferrus Manus, dead. And Vulkan, dead. We are short of allies.’

Meanwhile, Horus’s forces are arrayed in orbit above Terra. For most of the novel, his fleet is engaged in a relentless bombing campaign across the globe. While Horus attempts to weaken the Emperor’s psychic protections on the planet (which are preventing the daemon primarchs from landing), he must keep his brothers in check: since four of them have been risen to daemonhood, they have become rather difficult to manage. (This was also covered, in part, in Slaves to Darkness.)

Most of the traitors’ story is presented from Abaddon’s perspective, and it is his part in the novel that I found most interesting. Events are clearly progressing in such a way that the First Captain’s fate is already starting to form. Weakened by his most recent actions prior to the Siege, Horus’s time is running out. If he is unsuccessful, the Pantheon will need to find a new champion. Abaddon’s contempt for many of his fellow traitors (especially the Primarchs who have given themselves totally to specific powers) is palpable.

‘Look at how weak you have become,’ Abaddon said in disgust. ‘Lord Perturabo, you sit at the edge of the system pronouncing your genius and implying no one heeds you. This behaviour is not worthy of you.’

‘Do not provoke me, First Captain.’

‘Be quiet a minute, or you will find yourself further goaded,’ Abaddon snarled. ‘You, Fulgrim, and you, Angron, have whored yourselves out to the gods in the warp.’

Through Abaddon’s eyes, we are shown how weak are the links between the various Traitor Legions. Wholly consumed by their own agendas, weaknesses, obsessions, and insecurities they bicker and squabble throughout. There is little trust between them, and with Horus distracted, things don’t always go smoothly.

I could easily write a lot more about this novel. Haley also writes about the continuing struggle and devolution of the World Eaters — rapidly falling to Khorne, losing cohesion and rationality, all while trying not to fall to the sword of their ever-raging Primarch. There’s an interesting solution to Angron’s impatience, which provides a short reprieve for Khârn and those few are keeping it together(ish) before the ground war proper begins. There is also a thread related to agents of the Alpha Legion.

Haley has done a fantastic job of drawing in lots of threads from throughout the Heresy series, and also bringing back some fan-favourite characters (the Painted Count, for example). An excellent continuation of the Siege of Terra story, Haley skillfully avoids the pitfalls that often befall novels that fall within a series. The Lost and the Damned is not marking time between Big Events. It provides key details for various key players in the overall story. Haley does a fantastic job of maintaining the pace, and balancing the action with the story and character development. While at times he seemed a little too fond of metaphors and simile (especially at the beginning), his writing is top-notch. He does a great job of writing about what is happening on the various battlefronts, and the experiences of those who are there — the indomitable Astartes, the Primarchs, the terrified humans.

A must read for anyone who has been following the Horus Heresy story. Definitely recommended.

FOR FANS OF THE HORUS HERESY. This is the next step. The culmination of years of teasing and waiting and while it may not meet every expectation it does give it a good try and helps build the tension for the final battle