Member Reviews

An interesting world and culture with fantastical dark legends. My favorite thing about this story was that it gave me Rogue (X-Men) vibes. I love Soraya, poor thing. I liked most of the characters, although some were lacking in development (Sorush).

The author’s note hints that this was influenced by Sleeping Beauty and “Rappaccini’s Daughter,” as well as Persian myths and legends, which I can see. I really loved it. I wish I’d read the author’s note first actually because it has a helpful section on pronunciations, which I was changing while I read. I also learned that the name of the Shahmar comes from the words “shah” meaning king and “mar” meaning snake, which also makes a lot of sense looking back. I’m not going to quote the whole author’s note, but definitely don’t skip it when you read this book. Very interesting details about folklore that really add to the story.

There’s some nice symbolism and foreshadowing throughout that I appreciated, and I’m really impressed overall with the writing style. The plot was great too. I figured out one of the little twists pretty early (around 7%) but I still found it interesting. Reminded me of dark old fairytales before they changed them to a more kid-friendly Disney version.

If you love a good villain with layers, an MC who will make you question their morality choices, a twisted love story (x2) that keeps you guessing, and a satisfying ending, check this out. (The romance was subtle by the way, and not the focus, which was perfect for this story.) I’m definitely buying the gorgeous hardback when it comes out.



NOTE: Disregard if you aren't reading a digital copy.
There are a bunch of a weird, abrupt transitions, starting I think in location 313 of my digital copy. It goes from the mother saying, “I understand,” to Soraya waking up from a dream about the Shahmar. There isn’t even an indentation for a new paragraph, and that happens throughout the book. Probably a mistake with the formatting in an unproofed ARC copy, but I still couldn’t help worrying at first that a section of the book was missing and I was missing out on something that happened in between. I do believe these were just supposed to mark page breaks though.

Was this review helpful?

Review copy provided by publisher for honest review.
I would give this book 6 out of 5 stars! I was hooked from the prologue, “There was and there was not...” wont give anything away other than it is wonderfully grabbing story of a girl, Persian mythology based, and the themes of what is good/bad, monster or not. Things are not black and white, the gray area is beautifully explored. Great for fans of fairy tales, LGBTQ+, and a story that will keep you guessing.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting story! The story focuses on the journey of a young girl to accept who she is. The main character is very flawed, but it makes her very likable. While the story can be frustrating at times with the pacing, I truly enjoyed watching Soraya's journey to fix her mistakes and accept herself. Parvaneh was one of my favorite characters, and I enjoyed reading the relationship between them blossom. I would recommend this story to anyone interested in an exciting, action pact story with flawed but beautifully written characters.

Was this review helpful?

I adored “Girls Made of Snow and Glass” and I was so excited to read Bashardoust’s latest book.

It was once again another spectacular fairytale retelling of Sleeping Beauty. I thought that the writing was stunning and the book was well-placed. I didn’t find myself invested in this fantasy world, but I loved how unpredictable and untrustworthy all the characters were. In addition, it’s queer and feminist, so I highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I am so very thankful to have received a early E-Arc from the publisher and Netgalley.
Not only is the cover beautiful but the story inside was intriguing.

This story is based around Persian mythology and folklore and it brought something new and fresh to what I normally read.

Soraya is cursed by a Div (demon) and kills anything she touches. She wants so badly to break this curse sob that her family will accept her and not leave her behind. But is breaking the curse to change who she is worth it? Can she deal with the repercussions once she gets what she wants?

There is betrayal, love, adventure and so much more to this story that I didnt want it to end. I loved Soraya so much and wanted her to find her place in the story and it did not disappoint. Plus a book with queer love?! Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a stunningly beautiful fairy tale about isolation, it's also a love story. Oh, and it's also got a great deal about self-acceptance.

As you can imagine it's a wonderful thing to read during Autism Acceptance Month and a quarantine.

Soraya has always loved hearing about the tragic story of the young princess who was cursed to be poisonous to the touch. Unfortunately, the princess is her and she must be hidden so her family's power won't be questioned.

Then Soraya discovers that what she knew was a lie.

The writing is gorgeous and the story compelling.

Was this review helpful?

Girl, Serpent, Thorn was a really fun and completely unique fantasy story about a girl who is cursed with a poisonous touch. I had a great time reading this book. I felt like the story was different from other books in the YA fantasy genre which is always nice to see. I love this theme of a girl forced into isolation because of a curse and the effects that that can have on a young girl's mental state. Yes, she may not always make the best choices but loneliness and sadness have a strong effect on people. And I also loved how she grew and learned throughout the story and while she sometimes had darker impulses, she embraced that and didn't let it change her completely.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Girls Made of Snow and Glass and was excited to read this! I wasn't disappointed! A lush, fairy tale inspired story filled with twists and turns. I had started to read this about a month ago and set it aside (due to a busy work schedule). Picked it up today and was sucked right back in...and quickly finished it! So good! Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

**I was provided an electronic ARC by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for honest review.**

Actual rating: 3.5

Melissa Bashardoust brings Girl, Serpent, Thorn, a young adult fantasy inspired by Persian mythology and folklore. Readers follow Soraya, a princess cursed to have poisonous skin. When Soraya is no longer content to be hidden away and the demonic serpent king of legend may not actually be so legendary, a lot of problems tend to crop up.

I very much liked the Persian inspiration, and enjoyed seeing the incorporation and derivations of various stories within the culture. I also liked that pretty much every character was morally grey, consistently making bad choices for good reasons. While morally grey characters are typically my favorite kind, I didn't find these characters to be particularly memorable or ones that I was attached to throughout the novel. The storytelling was fairytale-esque, and very easy to get through, with some LGBTQ rep as well. Despite all the great components, I was left pretty lukewarm on the whole experience.

I did enjoy the novel overall and found it to be a fun, easy read. I have Girls Made of Snow and Glass on my TBR, and feel encouraged to read it after this positive experience with Melissa Bashardoust.

Was this review helpful?

When I started this book, I didn’t exactly have high hopes. The excerpt hadn’t caught my eye, and the title seemed a bit simple, but the cover was gorgeous. In the end, I gave in to the hype and requested a copy of the novel to read, and let me just say, I was not disappointed.

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a completely original fairytale inspired by Persian mythology and like nothing I’ve ever read before. The novel focuses on Soraya, a princess locked up in her family’s castle because she’s been cursed with a poisonous touch. However, Bashardoust takes the typical cursed princess trope and turns it upside down. While Soraya does spend the novel grappling with her curse, it’s not in the traditional manner. Soraya must decide whether she wants to be human, monster, or both.

There are two main groups within the book: humans, and divs. Humans live in fear of the divs, killing them when necessary, but mostly hoping to be left alone. Divs are monstrous creatures, the Persian mythological equivalent to demons. Soraya begins the book doing everything she can to break the curse that makes her div-like. She often appears weak and apprehensive, content to fall for the boy who offers her an escape from the isolation her curse creates. However, just when you think you’ve figured out what will happen and that Soraya will ride off into the sunset, the book changes direction in a way I never saw coming.

Plot twists abound in this book. Every few chapters seems to offer a new action or idea that I never saw coming. I read the book in one sitting because I just had to know what happened. The foreshadowing is subtle and caused me to gasp in realization more than once throughout the book. While it is a fast-paced, the novel never seems overly complicated. The typical fairytale plotline is subverted in ways that force the read to question everything they thought they knew.

The worldbuilding throughout the story was lush and complex. As the story is rooted in Persian mythology, many of the locations, events, and terms throughout the book are Persian. The characters are also, of course, of Persian descent. (It’s always nice to read a book where the majority of characters are people of color.) We learn more about the Bashardoust’s world as Soraya sees it, as the story is told through her point of view. Because of that, the complex world become something easy to understand. Bashardoust includes this amazing glossary at the back that defines words and includes more general background information about Persian mythology. It helped to clarify any of the more complex parts of Persian mythology/Zoroastrianism that I was unsure of.

Soraya herself is an utterly unique character, which is hard to come by in a young adult novel. She’s a giant blob of contradictions, in the very best way. Despite being incredibly powerful, Soraya is often hiding in the shadows, acquiescing to other’s wishes. She is both a soft and hard character, reckless and cautious. The story isn’t about her using her poison to gain power or her finally becoming free from the curse. Instead, the story focuses on accepting what makes you unique and appreciating it, no matter what that may be. While Soraya desperately wants to be rid of her curse, her love interests constantly question how she doesn’t view the curse as a beautiful part of herself. I loved that Soraya didn’t necessarily have to become something entirely different to find love. Instead, as she learns more about who she really wants to be, Soraya realizes that she can make her own choices and that she deserves the same love she watched everyone else receive.

The love interests were also a high point for me. Soraya is a bisexual woman of color. She admits to having a crush on a female friend when she was younger and has a romance with a young male guard. However, the main romance of the book is F/F and I WAS HERE FOR IT (and that’s pretty much all I can say about that without spoiling anything). Neither of her love interests are what we would consider morally good, but then neither is Soraya. As a reader I desperately wanted Soraya to find happiness with someone who wouldn’t lock her away. The complex nature of the relationships makes it difficult to decide who to vote for at times. My only complaint with the love interests is that Soraya seems to be a much more complex character than either love interest is. I would have loved it the characters were expanded upon.

This book isn’t about falling in love. It’s about figuring out who you are and who you want to be. It’s about making mistakes and redeeming yourself and what freedom truly means. And that’s what makes it magical.

Was this review helpful?

{I received this book as an ARC on Netgalley in exchange of an honest review}

I am giving this book a 1/5. When I first saw this book on Netgalley I was extremely excited. It sounded like the perfect morally grey/ medusa styled book. That being said, I went into the book with really high expectations. My expectations were not met.

I hated Soraya and found her extremely whiny. I know that in a book the world revolves around the main character, but Soraya was a bit pathetic. The descriptions were a little bit weird, especially when it came to the div.

Maybe it was just me, but I really didn't like this book. It did have a lot of potential though and Mellisa Bashardoust does seem like she'll release some really good books.

Was this review helpful?

This book was exactly what I needed. Quick read full adventure. Soraya is a princess cursed at birth with poisonous skin. She spends her life isolated and afraid. She sees herself as weak. Her only desire is to rid herself of the monster within. This story is about coming to terms with all parts of oneself and choosing acceptance...something most people can relate to.

Was this review helpful?

**Review to be posted on my blog on 5/4/2020, closer to publication date**
***3.5 Stars***

Thank you to Flatiron Books and NetGalley for giving me a chance to read this eARC.

This story is fascinating with it having Persian mythology elements. It reads like a fairy tale and has a queer love story.

Soraya is cursed, she kills with a touch. All she wants is to get rid of the curse and live a normal life. She gets a chance to make that dream come true but there are major consequences. This story is filled with hard choices, action and love as well.

What I Liked:

*I am not familiar with many Persian mythologies so this caught my attention right away. Soraya is cursed and she wants to be free from this curse but it isn’t so easy to lift the curse. She has to make some hard decisions and at some point you wonder if she has become a villain too.

*The world building is wonderful. We are introduced to this world of divs – who are creatures with powers. A div was who cursed Soraya in the first place.

*There are some surprises in the story and mostly because I was thinking of a fairy tale when a girl meets a boy (which she does)…but it doesn’t turn out the way you expect. I like that it took different turns and dark ones at that. This is a dark fairy tale, like I said Soraya makes some hard choices when it comes to her curse or her family.
I love the cover of this book – it’s gorgeous.

Things That Made Me Go Hmm:

*One of the surprises came with the romance part of the story and I liked that it didn’t turn out as I expected but I also felt like Soraya’s romantic interest in Parvaneh was quick. Soraya is attracted to Azad as first but that got nixed when he reveals himself!

*As far as connecting with the characters, I didn’t feel a strong one to anyone in the story. I sympathized with Soraya and at times wanted to shake her – she is a complicated character and I liked that she owned up to her anger and jealousy.

Final Thoughts:
Soraya walks a fine line between good vs evil and which way is right for her. She has been someone cursed, shunned for life to live alone, knowing she can kill with a touch and wondering why…why her? Why was she cursed? There are secrets to be revealed and the lives of her family are at stake. Soraya’s journey is filled with mistakes, and consequences but she learns to gain her power back too and right her wrongs. If you like your fairy tales a little dark with some twists and turns, you will love this story.

Was this review helpful?

fantasy usually isn't my thing anymore but some titles just make me want to give it another try and unfortunately, this one wasn't for me

Was this review helpful?

I loved Bashardoust’s first novel Girls Made of Snow and Glass so I was very excited when I heard about her new book. It was inspired by the poisonous girl in a garden from Rappaccini’s Daughter and the Persian epic Shahnameh (or the Book of Kings.) Reading this solidified how I want to start reading more non-Western fairy tales and myths in the coming year.

Soraya was cursed to be poisonous to the touch and consequently hasn’t touched anyone in 18 years. She wears gloves at all times and remains in Golvahar, the oldest of the palaces. Her twin brother Sorush is the shah and about to be married to her former friend Laleh, bringing her family back to Golvahar. My heart really went out to Soraya. Can you imagine never touching anyone or being touched in return? She experienced so much loneliness and isolation with no hope of reprieve unless her curse can be broken. Because of this isolation, she knows very few people but we get to know those people fairly well as things unfold and they brought so much to story.

I don’t want to say much more than that because I loved experiencing all the twists and turns of this plot. Not everyone is who they seem and many of the characters have secrets. Add in Soraya’s determination to break the curse at almost any cost and you have a high stakes plot that doesn’t quit.

One of the most interesting parts to me was how much longing and yearning Soraya experienced and how she kept having to tamp down her hopes of ever having more. Then to not have that barrier in place anymore…whew. The story does a great job examining the line between hero and monster and what it means to belong. Soraya has to really grapple with who she is and what her power means. She can be dangerous if she wants but is that what she wants and what will it mean for her family if she acts on that?

She really comes into her own as the story progresses and it was such a great evolution of her character. She’s strong but imperfect and that’s all I ever want in my heroines. The odds were really against her as the Shahmar takes control. I loved watching her navigate all the political intrigue and betrayal, especially as she had to reconcile with her own actions. The Shahmar is a layered character in his own right but I’ll let you figure out why for yourself.

Soraya is bisexual and while there are a couple of possible love interests, the moment we met Parvaneh, I knew something more was there. Parvaneh is a pairk, the most human-looking of the divs, and a prisoner when we first encounter her. I loved how Soraya and Parvaneh danced around one another at first. I do wish we’d gotten to see more of them together at the end, once the dust had settled, but that’s a minor wish compared to how thoroughly I enjoyed this story. I can’t wait to see what Bashardoust does next.

CW: isolation, kidnapping, threat of murder/execution, murder, villain executed his own family in the past, religious shaming

Was this review helpful?

The most compelling part of this story was Soraya's journey but it was weakened by the fact that a lot of the surrounding stuff just wasn't as compelling, specifically her romantic relationships.

There is some excellent, unique worldbuilding; it feels very vivid. The opening chapter is just...wow. What a great way to twist your expectations. And Soraya's journey to figure out who she is and who she is meant to be is filled with a lot of neat twists; some of them are predictable and some of them less so. The first big twist is too predictable, though, and the relationship between Soraya and Azad was weak to begin with. Honestly found myself cringing at times with how obvious he was full of it. Their relationship eventually develops into something a bit more interesting but because of the weak beginning it doesn't feel quite earned. The same with her other relationship. I wish the author had spent more time building up the two at the beginning of the novel, so there would have been a bigger emotional payoff later, on both ends. Would have also liked to see a tiny bit more development between Soraya and her family, because I thought that dynamic was also really interesting.

Basically, this story won't be what most people expect and that is a good thing I just wish it had been a bit more developed but it is still a compelling, unique tale!

Was this review helpful?

Discussed in bimonthly Whatcha Reading post: https://smartbitchestrashybooks.com/2020/02/whatcha-reading-february-2020-edition-part-two/

I just finished an arc of Melissa Bashardoust’s Girl, Serpent, Thorn. It’s a gorgeous YA fantasy based on Persian mythology (out May 12). It features a lonely bisexual princess whose touch poisons and murders anyone unfortunate enough to make skin contact.
I would recommend it with one caveat: the romantic endgame doesn’t work as well as I wanted it to because 1) the heroine spends WAY more time with the villain (terrific, nuanced, monstrous, and semi-sympathetic villain) than with the love interest and 2) the romantic development needed to simmer more due to the comparatively smaller on-page interaction. I adored what existed of the romance; I just needed more of it so I could buy the HEA. I would’ve loved the book more with the mindset of “read for the fantasy, not the romantic endgame.”

Caveats aside, I enjoyed the book immensely and would rate it as a B+. I’m still thinking about it days after reading and I want to reread it. That it’s stuck in my brain for so long tells you something!

Was this review helpful?

Persian mythology-inspired fantasy with a bisexual heroine, what's not to love? I adore that this brings pre-Islamic Iranian culture to a new audience. Interesting characters, difficult choices, and writing that immerses you in the world.

Was this review helpful?

After reading Girls Made of Snow and Glass I was so excited to discover Melissa Bashardoust's new book and I was not disappointed.

Girl, Serpent, Thorn is a beautiful Persian-inspired fantasy book about a strong and unapologetic woman who isn't afraid of her power, and of being who she is.

Soraya is a poisonous princess who can kill people with just a touch, she's lived hidden for all her life, until she meets a new soldier who makes her feel seen for the first time. Between family secrets, monsters, love and betrayals, this book will take you along Soraya's path to discovering herself and to accepting who she really is.

This books feels like a mix of a Frozen and Beauty and the Beast retelling. The writing and the myths inside the story really make it feel like a proper fairytale. The worldbuilding was beautiful, it feels so great for once to have a fantasy world not based on a Western world. The characters were amazing, I adored Soraya from the start, I wanted to give her everything because she deserves the world. I loved all her relationships, the bad ones as much as the good ones. The relationships with her family, with Azad, with Parvaneh. All the characters were wonderful to love and hate. The twists and turns of the story kept me wanting for more, I couldn't put the book down.

If you like non-western sapphic fantasy about amazing women and monsters I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

A nice break from my regular scheduled thrillers, in which the author created an amazing new tale on the original King Midas story. Found it to be very captivating, beautifully written, and the characters developed magnificently. Loved the use of fairy tale type story setting and highly recommend to those who love original and unique, but absolutely beautiful fairy tales. Look forward to more by this author!
Will make sure I buzz it up on the different platforms!

Was this review helpful?