Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I have to admit that I'm a 90s baby so I didn't get to experience the glory of the mall as a teenager in the 90s, but I do have fond memories of roaming the mall with my grandma in the early 2000s and this book brought back SO many of those memories. Anyone remember B. Dalton Books (aka my favorite store for the longest time)? IT'S MENTIONED IN THE MALL! The mention alone earns The Mall same brownie points.

The Mall is a quick, easy, and mindless read that will have you feeling nostalgic and laughing nonstop. I finished the book in two sittings! The Mall is rich with 90s references and humor that will have you yearning for simpler times.

While I liked the book, it wasn't particularly anything to write home about, hence the 3.5 stars. Aside from the nostalgia and humor, the book lacked real substance, which is usually what I like most about young adult novels. Also, while The Mall reads like a young adult novel, I can't imagine any true YA-aged readers would appreciate the intense 90s nostalgia. I'm a 90s baby and I still felt like I was too young to fully appreciate the book! I definitely would recommend The Mall to anyone who lived through or loved the 90s, but would caution that it won't change your life.

Was this review helpful?

On paper, this should have been my jam. I LOVE the Jessica Darling books and I think Megan McCafferty is a great writer. I also am just about the perfect age for this book, and I love puzzles/mysteries. But somehow this just felt a bit hollow to me. I almost felt as if I was reading the outline of a book - I kept waiting for more character development, especially for Cassie and her love interest (known throughout the novel as Sam Goody, the store where he works). I just wanted more - more story development, more character development, and more focus on the mystery/puzzle aspect. I did love the setting, and I felt like McCafferty really captured those 90s mall feels.

Was this review helpful?

I am not sure if this book description would have appealed to me before these days of self-isolation. I live about two miles from a mall, and a walk last week showed me a side of it I have rarely seen. Everything closed, no cars, and the few people enjoying a stroll of a sunny, spring day, all staying well over six feet apart. Welcome to spring in New York in the new normal! I honestly never go to this mall, but the thought of going back to the nineties when my best friend and I would go there and have so much fun was an irresistible pull.
The Mall is a short book and it was a quick read. It was like entering a time machine for a little while and reliving the past. The main character Cassie is smart and has her life well planned. Unfortunately, she gets sick and by the time she is better, her boyfriend has moved on, her summer job at the mall is gone, and so are all of her well thought out plans. She gets a different job, rebuilds an old friendship, and well, has more than one mall adventure.
This wound up being an entertaining read and left me with a nostalgic feeling for those days when going to the mall was wonderful. If this were normal times, I would say this would have been a three-star, I liked the book. Considering that these times are not at all normal, it is a four-star, I enjoyed this book. If you have any fond mall memories, you might enjoy The Mall too!

Was this review helpful?

I was a big fan of Megan McCafferty back in the day. I was probably around thirteen years old when I started reading her Jessica Darling series, hiding the books under others in my room so that my mom wouldn’t find out I was reading something called Sloppy Firsts. (As if she would have cared that I was reading a YA romance novel.)

A couple years ago, I went to a YA panel moderated by Megan McCafferty. I thought about how much I’d loved her books when I was younger, but still didn’t read more from her. Then I saw The Mall show up on Netgalley and knew I had to read it. 90s nostalgia set in New Jersey, where I lived for seven years of my adult life? PLEASE.

And I will say that The Mall is a fun book. It’s a very, very easy read, and it probably took me no more than three hours to read all 320 pages. It has a little bit of everything: romance, heartbreak, a treasure hunt, rekindling of an old friendship, family drama… there’s a lot here to love.

But unfortunately, because there’s so much going on, it never really focuses on anything aside from the mall. The best way I can summarize this book is “a summer at the mall,” because that’s really the only constant in the story. Sure, there’s a romance, but it’s never at the forefront of the book. Sure, there’s some heartbreak, but it’s honestly pretty brief. Sure, there’s a treasure hunt, but it never seemed to me that Cassie took it all that seriously. And sure, there’s some family drama, but Cassie seems like she just wants to pretend it isn’t happening. (Which, of course, was completely understandable.) Of all the plot threads in this book, the rekindling of an old friendship between Cassie and her coworker Drea is probably the biggest, but even that never really feels like the point of the book.

So in the end, while I had fun reading this book, I can’t say that I particularly loved it. For me, it was a solid three-star read.

Was this review helpful?

As a 90s kid, I knew I would find a lot of nostalgia reading this book. I was transported back to Saturdays spent all day in the mall trying on funky hats and sunglasses with my besties. This is a feel-good, grrrlpower nod complete with tube dresses and Cabbage Patch dolls. I spritzed myself with Bath & Body Works splash and puckered on my best frosted Lip Smackers. If you’re looking for a summer adventure story complete with boys, drama, and 90s playlists, this one’s for you.

Was this review helpful?

Cassie Worthy has her life all planned out. The perfect boyfriend, the perfect college acceptance, the perfect summer job. Then she comes down with an extreme case of Mono which secludes her from the world for the rest of her Senior year. She comes to find out that most of the things in her life which she thought were perfect were actually far from it. I enjoyed this coming-of-age novel which centers around a mall in New Jersey in the 90's. It was very nostalgic. I also enjoyed the New Jersey references, being from New Jersey myself. Cassie reunites with a prior best friend and goes on a treasure hunt with her. This allows them to rebuild their lost friendship. I thought this book was well written and well thought out. It wasn't "wow-ing" in any way which is why I'm only giving it 4 stars. Overall, it was a good read and a way to escape the world for a little while.

Was this review helpful?

Wave goodbye to your mom, run in through the automatic doors and breathe in the smell of chlorinated fountains—it’s the early 90s and we are AT. THE. MALL.

The Mall by Megan McCafferty seeks to recreate the thrill of being at the mall the month before school starts. It allllllmost does the trick. There’s a treasure hunt and a constant soundtrack of 90s music, and those two things made me (unfairly) start comparing it to Ready Player One, and it never quite lived up to it.

But that’s my own fault! You should read this! Stop refreshing the coronavirus hashtag every three minutes (just me?) and get lost in this fictional mall!

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge Megan McCafferty fan, and this book makes me love her even more. The setting of the mall is a character in itself, and the nostalgia is so highly specific and detailed. I smiled so much while I was reading. The Cabbage Patch mystery was so much fun. So many great Easter Eggs for Jessica Darling fans. This book would make an amazing movie!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun, nostalgic read! It was like going back in time. The MC had such a beautiful transformation during her summer months. I especially enjoyed her relationship with Drea.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the premise and going back in time to the 90's. Who doesn't love the 90s!?
While I was certainly feeling nostalgic, I didn't fall in love with the characters or the story.
I found myself pushing through just to finish the book. The story read a lot like a movie plot, which I normally dig. Instead, I found myself just wanting to watch this plot in an hour episode while munching on an afternoon snack.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun little book that took me back to my own 90s mall memories. I like how the author used the Cabbage Patch mystery to take readers through all the mall stores in a way that wasn't ridiculously contrived.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this nostalgic throwback. I've long been a fan of McCafferty---I grew up with Jessica Darling. The cover is stunning and the story contains all the elements of teen life--sour relationships and difficult friendships. Takes place in the pre-cell phone days, when malls hosted fashion shows in the food court, and you were lucky if you had an old beater of a car to make out in. I can smell the cookie stand and hear the arcade as I read!

This reminded me of Mallrats and the hours I spent at the mall in my youth in the best possible way. Would be a great choice for a mother-daughter book club and I can see it appealing to adult age YA fans, in addition to current teens.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this one. A light read with several interweaving plots going on, but it never felt to crowded. My only real complaint with it was with some of the seemingly random details and touches thrown in that didnt contribute to the story. The one that really just bugged me was the 90210 scale she used for the mall. I know this detail was supposed to draw you into the feel of the era, but it was so overdone. Not to mention, this is a young adult book, A lot of the readers are not going to be familiar enough with 90210 to recall who the exact people are and what they looked like. Especially after learning some more about Troy during the book, i have a hard time believing he would joke about that with Cassie enough to be considered an inside joke. Every time this bit would come up, it would just rip me from the story.
To avoid giving spoilers this issue will be very vague, Helen's final scene versus Drea's scene at the fashion show. Why did you have to do that to Drea?
All in all a fun read about a teenage girl coming into her own while working a summer job. There's love, loss, treasure, cabbage patch kids, and all kinds of hi-jinks and drama in between.

Was this review helpful?

I was a young kid in the '90s, not a teen, but this read was still super nostalgia-filled and felt very much like an old teen movie. The characters are the sort of caricatures you would expect from a story like this -- the overachiever whose well-laid plans are upended; the pretty, well-dressed girl who seems materialistic and vapid but is more than meets the eye; the cute alternative guy who gets the overachiever to loosen up; the crappy ex-boyfriend who seemed like a catch but was actually a jerk -- and the plot is pretty much what one might expect. This books is like eating a bag of '90s candy; It's good fun in the moment but lacks any real depth.

Was this review helpful?

This book has an interesting premise, but lacks depth. The characters are one-dimensional, and the plot is lacking. I truly wanted to like it, based on the fun premise, but I just couldn't get into it.

Was this review helpful?

Set in a New Jersey mall in 1991, this YA book is as cheesy and nostalgic as you would expect. It took me down memory lane with references to KB Toys (which was the best place on earth) and record stores, it definitely put a smile on my face. Also, I really want to go to the mall now.

We follow a 17 year old name Cassandra (Cassie for short) whose dealing with a breakup just weeks before summer ends....She had a plan, THE PLAN. Going off to college with her high school sweetheart, and dreams too big for the small town she lives in. And to top it off, she just got fired from her job at the mall. Cassandra is now determined to find another job at the mall, a cool job. The job everyone wants so she can be part of the social hierarchy. Of course things don’t work exactly how she wants them, and little by little she discovers she’s not the person she was at the beginning of summer, but she’s liking who she’s become.

This book was a fun, easy read for me. It was nice to be nostalgic for a bit with my own mall memories. On the other hand our main character Cassie, was not likeable to me. She is very selfish and bratty. She comes across as condescending to people around her, she sees herself as better since she’s leaving her hometown. Through some drama she does experience some growth, buuuut not enough for me 😂 this was definitely an entertaining novel, if you want to dive headfirst into nostalgia, go for it!

Was this review helpful?

The Mall by Megan McCafferty had all my nostalgia neurons firing. I did not come of age in the 1990s nor did we have a mall in easy driving distance. The closest mall was about an hour away and I actually came of age in the early 2000s. However, being a kid during the 1990s and seeing all the Mall Madness commercials, reading this book really took me back. Personally, I really enjoyed my time with The Mall because I felt like I was reading a story from an older cousin.

The Mall follows Cassie Worthy who is about to start working her mall job at America's Best Cookie after missing out on some major milestones due to mono. She's also ready to give her boyfriend Troy her v-card, finally. Unfortunately, in one fell swoop she is attacked by a cloud of cucumber melon, broken up with by her boyfriend, and loses her job. Down on her luck, Cassie ends up working in the last place in the mall she'd ever expect - Bellarosa's. From there, she embarks on a quest for treasure with her ex best friend and spends the summer learning to be less judgmental.

I think if you go in expecting this book to mirror the Jessica Darling books, you'll be disappointed. If you go in expecting nostalgia for when malls were the place for youth to hang out, you'll enjoy this trip down memory lane. I don't necessarily know how actual youth will feel about The Mall. Personally, I enjoyed my time with this book and read it incredibly fast. It's easily a one sitting read and in these times, I am so here for that.

Was this review helpful?

I love the 90's and anything to do with it. Reminds me of the movies of that time. Thanks for bringing me back to my awesome childhood!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! As a 90’s teen it brought back so many memories for me. There is a cute summer romance, but that’s not the heart of the book. It’s really about Cassie growing up and being true to herself, and her female friendships are the real love story here. Loved the 90210 references and The Cabbage Patch treasure hunt was really fun too.

Was this review helpful?

This would make *such* a great movie or TV series. The sets, costuming, characters, scavenger hunt...I want to see it all happen on screen!

Cassie is a great protagonist: she fails spectacularly, yet she keeps getting up and trying again, and you can't help but root for her. Megan McCafferty is great at writing uptight smart girls who think they're different (read: superior?) to everyone else. She's also great at pulling the rug out from under those girls and giving them glamorous best friends with depth and brains to show that book smart isn't the only way to be smart and that it's okay to be trendy/flashy or not, whichever suits you.

The interpersonal stuff in The Mall was great; I loved how a person's summer job and social class were so closely linked. And to put a scavenger hunt on top of that and make it all work? To tie in the hopes and wants and dreams of each employee? To make Cassie manipulate them to get the clues but then start to see those around her as fully-fleshed people...that had to have taken some intense planning, but McCafferty makes it look so smooth. I'm always impressed when someone can do something I know is tough but make it look effortless, and as much as I knew Megan had to be sweating pretty hard behind the scenes, I couldn't see it.

This was a great read: fun, funny, moving, cringe-inducing...I really enjoyed the time I spent with this book.

Note: I received a review copy of this book from NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?