I just did not enjoy this one. Sadly. The concept was interesting but the execution was not well done and I didn't find it interesting enough to pick up and read to my kids.

I liked the concept behind this story as an adult and read it to my daughter
The images were ok and the story had a good flow to it and the ending was good too
3 stars from me for this one

Grasshopper Eye and the Lost Vial appears to be a sort of meta picture-book offering, similar to Elena Ferrante's The Beach at Night. This story apparently featured in one of Jester's adult novels. Unlike The Beach at Night, Grasshopper Eye and the Lost Vial is actually suitable for children... but I'm not sure I would recommend it to them.

The story itself, about a grasshopper who makes vials for the villagers to keep their tears in, ends up being pedantic and preachy, and ultimately a bit nonsensical. Grasshopper Eye makes a special glass vial (illustrated with a photo, which looks odd in conjunction with the hand-drawn doodles of the characters) for each villager. Whenever they cry, they store their tears in the vial. One day, a villainous ogre by the name of BugBear Opie becomes jealous and steals all the vials. Then the villagers can't cry. They resort to getting angry instead. Eventually, the vials are found, except for one: Grasshopper Eye's. The other villagers offer him their vials to use, and he's so touched that he cries. The ogre cries, too, and apologizes... and then everyone cries. Grasshopper Eye makes a vial for the ogre, even though he doesn't need one anymore (wait... what?).

I think the narrative lost me at the end. The story shows the characters crying for various reasons, and even explicitly talks about the importance of crying... but then it implies the ogre doesn't need a vial because he's happy. What about happy tears? Grateful tears? Do those not get bottled? And why do these characters need a special vial in order to cry in the first place?

There's a Bible quote at the back about weeping and loving people around you. I guess that was what inspired the story. The sentiment is nice, but the execution is pretty flawed. The writing almost made me wonder if the book were written by a child (the language is stilted and sort of reads like a kid trying to impress their teacher). The illustrations, as I mentioned before, are a strange mix of drawings and photographs. I've seen that work in other books, but it doesn't really work here.

Kids might like this, but I have my doubts as to whether readers who enjoyed the novel that this book appears in are going to be all that impressed.

Grasshopper Eye and the Lost Vial is the first book of a new series for children (Hollows on the Bayou Book 1) by Michelle Jester. Released 21st Nov 2019, it's 44 pages and available in ebook format.

This is a very short and simple book for youngsters about kindness, inclusivity, expressing emotions, community, and what it means to belong. The text is simple and accessible and would suit young readers up to 7+ (or any age as a read-to-me book). The art is simple and colorful and heartfelt, but not particularly polished. The art is a combination of photography inset into drawn illustrations. The typography has good contrast and is easy to read. It's a comic sans variant typeface.

Worth noting for Kindle Unlimited subscribers, this title is available in the KU subscription to borrow and download for free.

This might make a good tie-in for a library activity day where participants could decorate a container, talk about the themes in the book, and listen to the story.

Three stars. Heartfelt but not polished. Great themes and a good message overall.