Member Reviews

Some thrillers choose to bring down the safe world you build around yourself. This is one of them. The storyline is intriguing, emotional and will keep you guessing. You might even find yourself questioning what you would do in the protangonists’ situations. A fun read that will keep you thinking about it for a while. A must-read for 2020.

Was this review helpful?

The Dilemma is more of a family drama than the usual mystery/thriller that B. A. Paris writes. This book alternated between the husband's and wife's narrations of her 40th birthday party. I found the characters in this story to seemingly be incapable of making good decisions, which made The Dilemma hard to read at times. This book kept me entertained, but I'm not sure that I would recommend it since it was rather repetitive and slow-going. Thanks to NetGalley for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

The Dilemma is a story about a husband and wife who have a wonderful marriage and couldn't really ask for more.....other then a 40th birthday bash to make up for not having a big wedding.

This book isn't one that you have to really think where it is going. You can figure out most if not all of the "who done its" but at the same time it does not take away from the emotion or shock of it all.

By the end of this book I was in tears.....because I am a mom of two and I know what it means to be a mom and love my kids unconditionally.

The relationship between husband and wife is not perfect but it feels pretty darn close.

B.A. Paris delivers another great read

Was this review helpful?

I just finished this book by B.A. Paris. I loved this book like I have loved all the others. Thank you for the opportunity to read and review this book, I highly recommend it to everybody. They are very well written with very good storylines and very easy to follow along with characters, it was a real page turner and I hated to put it down but was very glad to be able to read it, I highly recommend this to everyone.

Was this review helpful?

I must be in the minority here, bit I couldn’t get past a 40 year old planning her dream birthday party, and add to that, she’s been saving for it for years!? Because she didn’t have the wedding she wanted? Grow up lady. What!? Ridiculous premise,backdrop, whatever, couldn’t take this seriously at ALL. Gave up about a third of the way in.

Was this review helpful?

Livia has saved for years to make her 40th birthday party a huge event. She was denied a huge wedding and nothing will stop her from this party! Adam wants nothing more than Livia to be happy. He’s planned a special surprise for her, one that will alter all their lives. Lots of secrets being kept between Livia and Adam which when revealed could potentially destroy their marriage.


This is a hard review for me to write as B.A. Paris is one of my favorite authors. I didn’t like any of the characters.
They were all self absorbed and never took anyone else feelings to consideration. At the half point of the book I found myself thinking oh gosh, enough already and skipped thru quite a few pages. I felt there was no real plot or an intriguing story line. This is more of a family drama book than a Thriller.

Thank you NetGalley and St. Martins Press for allowing me to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The first part of this book was very compelling - what were the secrets that Livia and Adam were hiding? What was there dilemma? The secrets were revealed pretty early in the book, and at that point and after that it just got a little harder to get through. It was a quick read - the writing was good and the characters were developed, but the alternating viewpoints of Livia and Adam made it somewhat repetitive. Throughout the last half of the book, I just kept wondering why Livia and Adam didn't just talk to each other. Also, part of the reason for keeping a secret was to not spoil a party - I don't get the idea that someone would obsess about and save money for 20 years to throw themselves a big party on their 40th birthday, so the premise of keeping a secret was on shaky ground for me.

Would I recommend this book to others? I don't know - it would be quick and easy read for someone who enjoyed domestic drama.

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/3053292985

Was this review helpful?

I must start this review by saying that B.A. Paris is one of my favorite authors!!! However, this was my least favorite book of hers..

I had initially heard that this book would be quite different than a typical B.A. Paris book and the rumors were true.

It was still a very gripping read, however it wasn’t your typical psychological thriller. I would categorize more as general fiction to be honest which I don’t particular love.

The premise was more about a family keeping secrets from each other and how that unfolds.

I also had a hard time liking the characters and/or having sympathy for them. I just wanted to scream TELL THEM THE SECRETS AND LET’S MOVE ON. At 50% I really kind of had enough of the back and forth and just wanted to be done with the book.

There was still a small element of mystery, as we had to uncover what the numerous secrets were, and that’s why it’s a 4 star for me. Overall, if you like general fiction you will most likely love this book. If you are an avid fan of mystery and thrillers, you might not enjoy this one as much as the previous novels.

Was this review helpful?

I want to start by thanking NetGalley, the publishing house, and the author for allowing me an electronic copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

Probably closer to 4.5!
I typical B.A. Paris fashion she knows how to create some crazy tension!! I was hooked after I read "Behind Closed Doors". This novel is different in that its not so much a psychological thriller as it is domestic suspense and an almost palpable tension.
The one thing that strikes me about this novel is that I did not care for the main character! I found the wife to be very selfish and spoiled. That being said, I still cared about how "The Dilemma" was going to turn out. I enjoyed her family and friends. I like the side-drama involving the daughter and her personal life. It made the novel more believable and "real" so to speak. Since we all know in life, real people can do some real stupid things!
Can't wait for her next novel. And this one isn't even released yet!
#thestruggleisreal #thedilemma

Was this review helpful?

I loved B.A Paris’ book “Behind Closed Doors” so I was excited to read The Dilemma. Just like Behind Closed Doors, The Dilemma deals with family, secrets, & love. I was absolutely blown away! I loved the main characters, the suspenseful plot, and the surprises throughout the book that I didn’t see coming. I highly recommend this book and would be shocked if it doesn’t end up being on the best sellers list!

Was this review helpful?

Today I am existing on caffeine, because I was up all night reading this book. I couldn't stop reading the story as it alternates between a husband and wife and the day of her birthday party. Both are hiding a secret that will change the family dynamics forever. I identified with the husband more, as I found the wife's obsession with her birthday party a bit over the top. I feel like someone in her life would've told her to settle down. That said, every other aspect of this plot was so well done. I could feel the angst as the timeline of the day progressed. This is a suspenseful plot that will leave you needing to turn just one more page...and then another...Thank you to St. Martin's Press and Net Galley for an e-ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

First, let me begin by saying that I really enjoyed all of the author’s previous books. So needless to say, I was super excited when I was approved to read an ARC of her newest book, The Dilemma. I was expecting another fast paced thriller with lots of twists and turns and a surprise ending. That wasn’t the case.....

I’m struggling a little bit with how to review this one. I totally think that it was mislabeled in terms of genre. So if you are expecting a typical thriller, you will probably be pretty disappointed. Instead, I would label this as a general fiction/family drama novel. If you consider it that genre instead and pretend like you haven’t read the author’s previous books, you may like this one.

What I liked: This was a pretty clean read in terms of language. Typical thrillers tend to have a fair amount of foul language and I really can’t remember much (if any) foul language in the entire book. I also liked that the author made you think that you knew Livia’s secret, and then gradually showed you that you were wrong before revealing the actual secret. I was also wrong about why Livia was angry and distant with Max (who was her son’s best friend). So in that sense there were several plot lines that did have small surprises.

What I didn’t like: This is harder without giving away spoilers. I will say that I kept waiting and waiting for a surprise twist or for the ending to be wrong somehow. Neither thing happened. There was no surprise twist and the ending was really the ending and it was just downright devastating. At the same time, I feel like we didn’t get invested enough in each of the characters due to the fact that the entire story took place over three days. There was some backstory for sure, but not enough in my opinion. And I really don’t understand why the main character spent half of her life dreaming of an elaborate birthday party that ended up being a tent and a caterer and some music. It seemed so silly and also incredibly sad at the same time. I get that she was making up for the wedding she never had, but it seemed like EVERY decision she made from age 17-39 revolved around her 40th birthday party.

At the end, I was left questioning the author. What was the point of this book? Why did the things that happened happen? But if I reflect on the story overall and try to put a positive spin on it, I would say it’s a reminder of how short life can be, and how important communication is in any relationship. And also about how keeping secrets can lead to very negative consequences. So if this one makes you self reflect and possibly change the way you communicate with those you are closest to, than maybe it’s worth the read. It’s definitely a short read and pretty clean for a thriller. Just know that it won’t be anything like the previous novels by B.A. Paris.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for a free ARC of this book!

Was this review helpful?

Let me start by saying that I am a fan of B.A. Paris, I have loved every book by her, this book to me seems different than the others. I still loved the book and read it within 2 days. The book moved along quickly, switching back and forth between perspectives and although there was a little intrigue this wasn't as suspensefull as her past books, which still worked well due to the speed the story moved at.

Was this review helpful?

Livia has been planning her 40th birthday party for what feels like her whole life. This was her big day and time to shine. Her husband, Adam, is in on some surprises to make Livia's day extra special. However both have big secrets and are not sure how or when to reveal them.
The story alternates between Adam's voice and Livia's voice. The chapters cover a specific hour of the day. As I read, the suspense built for me and I had to finish the book before I went to bed so that I could see how the secrets were revealed and what happened next.

Was this review helpful?

I really really liked B.A. Paris's first book, 'Behind Closed Doors'. It was a great thriller with lots of twists which had me hooked me from page 1.

After that her other books haven't really done the same trick.
This one also did not really work for me. I think the pitch of the novel is incorrect as this is not a thriller at all.
This should have been a novella. It does not have enough meat to be stretched out into a full fledged novel and that shows.
The one theme which the entire novel is based on is repeated over and over again. This was a family drama and not a thriller. And for me the basic theme and the actions derived from that did not work at all.

The characters seemed shallow and not well thought out and somehow their actions , thoughts and behaviour just did not seem to hold any weightage.

My rating is 2.5 which I'm bumping to 3.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for sending me a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was an interesting one for me, and i still havent decided if I liked it. The way it opens, youre expecting a lot of twists and turns, and it ends up being a much more myopic family drama. The twists are just misunderstandings and miscommunications. The one tawdry part of the book isnt even that big of a deal. Furthermore, I had a hard time believing that someone would have put so much weight on a birthday party, which was really the foundation for the entire novel. It's ultimately missing a spark - it was was promising but came a little short for me.

Was this review helpful?

A tragedy of a book. While the writing was excellent from the start, I just could not get past the tragic plot line of this book. The author is clearly talented, as character development was excellent. Raw emotion for the characters and the reader. Thank you for an advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

I put every other book on hold to race through this new thriller by one of my favorite authors in this genre. I read it over two days and my stomach was clenched and my heart pounded all the way through. Was it the normal type of thriller?. Not at all. Was it good? It was fabulous. Tense, tearful and tragic. A story of holding out for hope, just as I did while reading it. Misleading details, miscommunication,, disappointments, letdowns, deep love and pain. I felt it all as the story unfolded in one long excruciating day and night. It really felt I was reading it in real time. It felt real, I felt it. Now I’m exhausted. Thank you for a great read!

Was this review helpful?

I was able to read this book thanks to NetGalley. I am a huge fan of this author and this book did not disappoint, however, it is extremely different from all of her other novels. It isn’t a thriller as previous novels. But it was just as good and heartbreaking.
Livia and Adam are a long married happy couple with two young adult children. They married quite young when Livia got pregnant and her parents disowned her. They had a small wedding and Livia felt something missing from this. She plans and she’s for a huge 40th birthday part for herself and invites her close circle of friends as well as many others. Her daughter is studying abroad in Hong Kong and at first they think she is not able to make it. Without any spoilers, I will say that both Livia and Adam are hiding huge secrets from each other. And waiting until the party ends to tell.
This book is written within a 24 hour time frame and from perspectives of the two main characters. I enjoyed the writing style and the format a great deal. Overall, I loved this book and will recommend it highly. Thanks again to NetGalley!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for a free digital ARC of this book. I have loved all of the B.A. Paris novels I've read, but was a little hesitant to read this one. This book is not one of her usual suspense novels. I was afraid I would not get into the book. I was totally wrong. I never understood how some people can say that they read a book in one day, but I can now say I understand! I started reading this book on a day I was sick and couldn't do anything else. I couldn't put it down. Livia and Adam's lives were so real. It has its own version of suspense, but a real tear jerker as well.

Was this review helpful?