Member Reviews

First off... everything Silvia Moreno-Garcia writes is pure gold, and any year that she writes a book, it will automatically be my favorite book of the year. If she writes two, it will be a tie. That's just how it is.

***

Socialite Noemi receives a letter from her newlywed cousin Catalina that is so bizarre and disturbing that she immediately travels to see her. She arrives at the damp, rotting mansion where Catalina lives with her husband and his family, whose fortune has declined but whose self-image of upper-class grandeur has yet to keep up.

Noemi blithely bats aside their strange behavior and rules (no loud noises, no hot baths, no smoking, no coffee, etc.) and their well-mannered hostility so she can see to the well-being of Catalina, who is feverishly warning of ghosts and voices in the walls. Her resolve wanes, however, when she begins having the nightmares, too.

If you are a fan of Ms. Moreno-Garcia's work, you know she occasionally dips into the supernatural, but not always. So when I was reading this, I was unsure what we would find -- vampires? ghosts? or simply evil people?

It's delightfully creepy and unsettling, with a unique ending.

It reminded me of Stephen King's The Shining. (Not to say this work is in anyway derivative -- only that it invoked the same sense of dread around every corner.)

Pure gold, I tell you.

Was this review helpful?

This is easily one of the best books I've read this year!
When her cousin Catalina sends an urgent letter asking to be saved from her new husband, Noemi is sent by her father to investigate. Convinced it's only newlywed jitters, Noemi is unprepared for the dangerous and deadly atmosphere of High Place, the gloomy and depressing mansion now home to Catalina. Dark, damp, and oppressing, Noemi is barely welcome in her cousin's home and her visits with her are restricted. Virgil, Catalina's husband, is a little too charming and his overtures leave Noemi suspicious and wary. The mansion's other inhabitants leave Noemi feeling like she is constantly under watch and her every movement and word is criticized. But Noemi is incredibly tough and is intent on finding out the nature of her cousin's mysterious illness and delusions. When Noemi comes too close to the truth for the family's liking, she is placed in a deadly situation with only an unlikely ally at her side. The violent and horrific nature of the family's secret is so unbelievable that Noemi begins to question to her own sanity.
Dark, gripping, and absolutely terrifying, Mexican Gothic is a spell-binding tale of horror, greed, and unbridled power.
This book is absolutely incredible! Silvia Moreno-Garcia weaves a tale that is so engrossing you will find yourself walking the dark and damp halls of High Place alongside Noemi. This is by far one of the most atmospheric novels I've ever read. The tension can be felt on every single page and every conversation felt like a threat. I flew through this novel, unable to wait to find out what was the secret behind this family's odd and controlling behavior. The village near High Place also felt like a depressed and mysterious character. Everyone seemed to fear the family and the mansion itself, but no one would come out and say why. The aura of mystery, confusion, and oppression followed every character throughout the story, no matter where they were.
Silvia Moreno-Garcia is an incredibly talented writer and I encourage everyone to dive into one of her magical and mysterious stories.

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publisher for the opportunity to read and review this title, all opinions and mistakes are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This story is about noemi, she receives a disturbing letter from her recently married cousin, Catalina, in which she talks about ghosts and supernatural happenings in her new home, High Place. Naomi is sent to investigate what’s going on and also to check on the general well being of Catalina. This leads Naomi to a very strange family and an even stranger situation. Weird things are happening and we don’t really know what’s real and what’s a dream. Who’s to be trusted and who’s not. It’s a pretty slow moving book, it’s eerie but nothing really happens until maybe 70% of the way through the story. Honestly, I read this because I was really excited for the Mexican representation but wow was I let down. Our main character is said to be Mexican and a few Spanish terms and cities are thrown around but that’s it. I wasn’t super interested in the reveals and it just fell flat for me.

Was this review helpful?

Creepy, weird, gothic and with one of Moreno-Garcia's characteristically strong-willed heroines, MEXICAN GOTHIC is a modern, speculative REBECCA. The characters are full-bodied and compelling or unsettling, as the case may be. The supernatural elements are ever-present, but the twist is still unexpected. This is pitch-perfect gothic horror.

Planned coverage:

TOR NIGHTFIRE: Inclusion in roundup STROLLING ON THE MOORS: MODERN GOTHIC HORROR NOVELS WITH VINTAGE CHILLS

BOOK RIOT: Reading Pathways-type post, SILVIA MORENO-GARCIA: HER WORKS & THE HEROINE'S JOURNEY.

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited for this one! But the prose simply didn't grab me. I found it a little awkward and the flow was stilted. I stopped reading pretty early so I can't comment on the story or characters. Perhaps I'll return to this at some point, but I just couldn't connect to the writing right now.

Was this review helpful?

A likeable main character and lots of suspense. The mystery dragged on a little long and I should have expected the paranormal element since this is a gothic novel, but it still somehow felt out of place. Still an enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

Being a huge fan of Garcia’s Certain Dark Things I was excited to read this new novel . A reimagining of the gothic suspense this book is fabulous . Taking place in 1950s Mexico Noemi a beautiful young socialite receives a letter from her newly married Cousin begging for help . She arrives at the strange , decrepit isolated mansion where her cousin lives and the weirdness begins and doesn’t let up. I’ve not read anything else quite like the horror in this novel . Scary, suspenseful and emotional all make for an original page turner

Was this review helpful?

NetGalley ARC | June 2020 had some seriously creepy novels, and Mexican Gothic is certainly one of them. If you love historical gothic fiction and want to armchair travel to Mexico, discover a spooky mystery in a haunted house...that literally seems to come alive at night. Man, this is one messed up family.

With all of the clues leaning towards mushrooms and poisons, this women's fiction novel will completely set you off balance. Innovative and brilliantly written with a vivid ambiance, I wouldn't skip this June 2020 book release.

My one criticism is that the pacing seemed a tad off about 60% in--I could have done without about 50+ pages of the book; that could just be me and this crazy time we are in right now, though.

Find the full review on The Uncorked Librarian: https://theuncorkedlibrarian.com/june-2020-book-releases/

Thank you so much to the publisher for providing me with a free advanced copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a 2020 Del Rey publication.

An exciting new approach to Gothic Horror fiction!

I rarely ever comment on a book cover- but this one is stunning! It’s an eye-catcher for sure- but you know what they say about judging a book by its cover. So, the question is- Does the story measure up to that magnificent cover?

Mexico City- 1950s

Noemí Taboada, a young socialite, who wishes to achieve more in her life than marrying a man her father approves of, is given the chance to secure her dreams of attending university, if she will travel to “High Place” to check on her cousin, Catalina, who has been writing strange, alarming letters, suggesting she is either quite ill or in grave danger.

Upon her arrival to the crumbling mansion, Noemi receives a very frosty greeting from Catalina’s husband, Virgil, and the limited staff. Even more disconcerting to Noemi, is her cousin’s fragility, and the fierce opposition others have to Noemi’s spending time alone with Catalina.
Capping things off is the house itself- which offers no modern accommodations, not even common basics, and appears to be rotting at the seams. If that isn’t unsettling enough for you- wait until you get a load of Virgil’s ancient Uncle Howard!!

Almost immediately, Noemi begins having extremely vivid, highly sexual, and lurid dreams or hallucinations. Virgil shrugs this off as ‘sleepwalking’ episodes. However, as time passes, the atmosphere in the house becomes even more claustrophobic, and the staff’s demeanor never thaws toward Noemi. One would think they were trying to scare Noemi away, but instead they are becoming more and more insistent that she remains in the house….

As horrifying as that prospect might be, Noemi is also intrigued- by the legends, Virgil, and with the youngest member of the family, Francis- the only friendly face on the entire estate. With Francis’ reluctant help, Noemi is determined to learn the history of the region and to free her cousin from the grasp of her oddly mesmerizing husband and the curse of 'High Place'.

This is one super creepy novel! The atmosphere is off the charts spooky and the imagery is incredibly vivid. The blurb calls this a ‘re-imagining of the classic Gothic suspense novel’. Go with that description and think about what that word ‘re-imagining’ might mean.

This book has been compared to ‘Rebecca’ by publicists, promoters, and editorial or professional reviewers. Naturally, I’m going to have to agree to disagree about that comparison. Why? Both novels are, without a doubt, Gothic literature. But… I never viewed “Rebecca” as a horror novel. The supernatural tones one senses in that novel, is not at all like what one will experience when reading this novel.

If I could rewrite the blurb, I would substitute the word ‘Suspense’ with the word “Horror”. The book is very suspenseful, but you are getting a true horror novel experience here, and not one that is merely implied.

While ‘re-imagining’ is a great way to describe this modern spin on the classic genre, in more ways than one it is pure traditional Gothic Horror!!

The author did a fabulous job marrying Gothic and Horror, creating a complex and hypnotizing tone, keeping me glued to the pages- especially during the last quarter of the book. That said, keep in mind that Gothic fiction is not known for its blistering pace. However, I felt like this one moved along at a nice clip, despite a lag here and there.

It’s dark and ghastly, replete with classic Gothic Grotesquerie, and lots of mind tripping chills and thrills, plus, a little bit of romance for balance and lightness.

Overall, this is the best Gothic horror novel I’ve read in ages!
2

Was this review helpful?

This cover is one of my favorites of the year. The blurb had me very curious and I was lucky enough to get my wish granted on NetGalley.

It's hard to figure out what to expect when it comes to a book like this. The plot was nothing I would have ever imagined and the twists were ones I didn't see coming at all. The author weaved so many different strings to create this intricate plot that had me utterly disturbed but also intrigued the further I got into the story. (The first 50% or so was slow going for me as I had a hard time really connecting with the characters or plot.)

Noemí is strong-willed and even though it's not always the best trait to have, it really worked in her favor for this. I'm not sure how she coped with any of the things that were going on because I would have been in breakdown mode like her cousin.

The gothic house is filled with many people and all of them, besides Francis, are just strange. The more you get to know certain characters, the more you start loathing them. They each have a part to play and sometimes their part isn't what it seems.

There is a tad bit of romance but it does not take up much of the plot. I did like the relationship between the two characters and thought that it molded nicely into the rest of the plot.

Overall, this was everything that a gothic novel should be. It may have taken me a bit to get into but the ending was worth the wait.

Was this review helpful?

This was one of my very most anticipated books of the year, and it delivered so perfectly! What I love is a book that GOES FOR IT, and this book 100% does. It's working in the gothic tropes that lovers of the genre will know and anticipate, but it's recontextualized via the setting.

The basic premise is that a young Mexican socialite goes to rescue her cousin from a mysterious old mansion in a mining village, and then gothic things start happening. Gothic manors in other novels, like Jane Eyre or Rebecca, are always weird monuments to extracted wealth, and this one is no different, only it has more proximity to the damage it wrought, being set in Mexico. So this book is more about how rotten capitalism is than the institution of marriage, which is often the takeaway reading gothic novels. But this book does make very plain the way capitalism, inherited wealth, marriage, and childbearing all come together in horrific fashion.

But it does all this with a totally bananas plot that is EVERYTHING I want in a novel. I LOVE how different details get meted out to the reader, so we can try to guess what's going on if the novel is working in the "supernatural explained" mode (like Jane Eyre, for example, where the ghostly presence has a non-supernatural explanation). Give me ghosts, cursed families, mysterious potions, prophetic dreams, give me all of it!!!

And I truly, truly loved how it ended. I think it honors the genre and is immensely satisfying.

***Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.***

Was this review helpful?

A gothic novel set in the fifties in Mexico.So haunting so atmospheric so well written.I was drawn right in read late into the night.A book I will be recommending.#netgalley#randomhouse

Was this review helpful?

Set in the early 1950s, in an English estate in a former silver mining village in the Mexican countryside, this story is haunting you will think about it for days after.

Noemí Taboada, a rich, beautiful, Mexico City socialite is sent to find out if her cousin has gone mad or is actually in need of rescuing after Noemí's father receives a frantic letter from Catalina asking for someone to save her. Having just barely met Catalina's new husband at the wedding, Virgil Doyle is a stranger and so is his family. Once at High Place, Noemí doesn't know what to make of the once opulent English estate which is now a dark, moldy, ruin.

Once settled Noemí realizes Catalina's fears are real as the house begins to invade her dreams and the secrets the Doyle's keep hidden begin to surface.

Was this review helpful?

In the vein of Daphne DuMaurier and Shirley Jackson with a healthy sprinkling of hallucinogenic mushrooms.

It is March of 2020 and I have been unable to read anything good for a few weeks, but this book broke me out of my slump of mediocre thrillers. It helps that it is exactly my thing, gothic and suspenseful, then full on surreal. From the title it's clear what Moreno-Garcia is aiming for and she's hit the mark incredibly well. There are echoes of your favorite gothic novels here, but just like Jackson was able to move us from the English manor to the rural US, Moreno-Garcia moves us to mid-century Mexico.

Noemí is a high society girl floating through a frivolous life until her father dispatches her to the country, to the home of her cousin's new husband. Her cousin Catalina has sent a strange letter and it is Noemí's job to check on her and make sure this new husband isn't harming or taking advantage of his new, young, wealthy wife. Once she arrives, the family is strange and unwelcoming, and so is the house. Catalina is not herself but the mysteries only get deeper the longer Noemí stays.

The gothic themes here play in beautifully with the themes of the destructive force of colonization (the husband and his family are, of course, English, brought to Mexico to make their fortune off a silver mine that exploits the local population's labor) and patriarchy. Misogyny has often been a force under the surface of gothic fiction, but Moreno-Garcia is happy to bring it right out into the open. The genre agrees with her, and she particularly understands the way the worst fears can also be intertwined with desire. I hope we get more books like this from her.

Was this review helpful?

Noemi is a college student living a privileged life in Mexico City. She likes to party and have fun with her friends, but also has the ambition to be more than somebody’s wife. Her father informs her that he has received a disturbing letter from her cousin Catalina, who recently married the son of a former silver miner and moved to live in the mountains. Noemi travels to see her cousins to investigate why Catalina claims that there is something terrible happening at her new home and something is making her sick. Noemí discovers the family’s peculiarities and almost loses her life doing so. The books is well written, however, the plot moves very slowly the first half of the book, with much repetition. The real action doesn’t begin until the last third of the book. The scientific facts throughout the books were a nice addition. Recommended!

Was this review helpful?

This book was an absolute ride. It's not often that I'm in the mood for a haunted house, psychological thriller, but this fit the bill so well. I feel like these kinds of narratives are so difficult to pull off in a book, it really makes you realize how much thriller films will rely on music, pacing of takes, and visual cues to build a sense of dread, and novels don't have any of that. Moreno-Garcia is able to bake in moments that are tense, spooky, and strange until it all culminates into an explosive finale. Also the aesthetic and atmosphere of the setting and time period added an extra layer to sink your teeth into. Definitely would recommend this to anyone who likes spooky and creepy books. I like how this was able to make commentary on gender relations, gender power, generational trauma without relying on age old tropes that are usually weaponized against women in horror.

Was this review helpful?

Remote house, creepy family, mushrooms. This book reminds me of the haunting of hill house and rebecca. It also has a good dash of fairy tales. Sometimes the atmosphere of the house and family being visited by the main character were very heavy, but that's correct for a gothic.

Was this review helpful?

After reading (and loving) Silvia Moreno-Garcia's "Gods of Jade and Shadow," I was all in for her next book. What a treat that it comes in such a beautiful cover! I don't often read suspense / mystery books but I couldn't help but be interested in this one. It did not disappoint. I could not put this book down and it kept me guessing until the very end. I loved the time and place that this book was set in—1950s Mexico. Plus the house on the hill was the right amount of atmospheric and creepy. I've already told friends about this book and got them all interested in reading it come June.

Was this review helpful?

This is my third read by the author (yes, by now you can say I’m a fan) and it’s by far the darkest most disturbing one. So many kudos to her for just…going there. Gothic fiction has certain parameters, you go in knowing what to expect…the creepy mansion past its best by date, the creepy denizens of it, the shadowy corners, the mysteries, the darkness, all the things that go boo and creep and scream in the night. Mexican Gothic doesn’t disappoint there, in fact it delivers on all accounts, the only difference is, as the title advertises, it is set in Mexico. Though to be fair, the novel takes place mostly in English, in an English estate. Possibly as a nod to the genre classics. Possibly just because the traditional British aesthetic is so creepy by nature. But the protagonist Is Mexican, Noemi Taboado, a young woman from a good family, as boundary pushing and daring as a young woman from a good family can be in the late 1950s in Mexico City. She set off for a remote estate and yes it has a name, of course it has a name, High Place, owned by Doyles, a family of some renown in silver business that has seen a decline in recent years, a family into which the Noemi’s cousin married all too quickly, drawn in by the charms of their handsome scion Virgil. So Noemi arrives to High Place and it’s…well, it’s just as creepy as you’d imagine. It and everyone in it with the exception of Francis, the family’s youngest son. The cousin is in distress, under duress and hears voices in the walls. The wallpaper ambles around in a way wallpaper ought not to. The family’s presided over by a grotesque of a man, so much so that his obsession with eugenics might actually be the least disturbing thing about him. And so it goes on, Noemi desperately trying to help her cousin, the Doyle family preventing her at every turn and the High Place messing with her mind one nightmare at a time. Which is to say that the first 2/3 of the novel read pretty much like Crimson Peak meets Yellow Wallpaper. And yes, I usually frown upon descriptions like that, ones that use popular preexisting media to define the context (it’s an easy way out, reductive and so on), but here it was just so apt. So much so it had me thinking at the author…come on, you can do more with this. And then the last third (pretty much exact science at 66%) the novel pivot into a terrifying nightmare of epic proportions. It goes so dark so fast and stays there ratcheting up the terror and macabre and gore in a mesmerizingly disturbing way. I don’t want to give a single thing away, you just have to read it for yourself…and also incest and mushrooms doesn’t sound as scary by themselves. But just wait until you read what the author did with all of that. What a gloriously disturbed imagination. This turned radically original on a dime. And way to go. Way to infuse some fresh blood (through various bloodlettings, of course) into a classic and classically fairy staid genre. What a ride this one turned out to be. I read the first two thirds of the novel during the day, wishing it was darker, but finished the book late into the night, which was absolutely the perfect time to read it. Gothic is typically associated with darkness and this one especially needs the cover of night, the quiet stillness of midnight to make it come to life all the more in all its horrifying splendor. So yeah, read it at night, if you dare. Genre fans, anyone craving some high caliber literary frights, this one’s for you. Excellent read. Loved it. Recommended. Thanks Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

This book was both exactly what I hoped for and wholly unexpected. The 1950s setting and classic gothic setting was perfection. I loved the main character and her fire. The creepy setting of the house was wonderful and the journey of her in the house was exactly what I wanted from this book. However, the reveals were totally unexpected...with some reveals I was taken aback at first like "wait what?" but after taking a moment to process and be like, okay this is where the story is going...I was totally onboard and really enjoyed the story.

Was this review helpful?