Member Reviews

I received this from Netgalley.com for a review.

Clear and concise tellings of disasters that were magnified by natural and man-made events.

3☆

Was this review helpful?

This book was really interesting, it's kinda scary when you read all the man-made disasters that we've caused. I thought the author had done their research well and kept the book interesting.

Was this review helpful?

The industrial era brought many advancements to the world. But with progress comes the risk for things to go horribly wrong. Here is a collection of eight man-made disasters that could have been avoided.

Of the disasters contained in this book, I was only really aware of the one: the 1865 steamship Sultana catastrophe. Even then, I only knew it had happened and not the circumstances surrounding it. With each disaster, the author outlines who the victims were, why it happened, the heroes who tried to help, and the good that came from the situation.

The author narrows down three causes for the eight disasters he outlines: malice (sabotage to a high-speed train in 1939), greed (the Sultana and 1963's Vajont Dam in Italy), and finally hubris (excessive pride or self-confidence) for the other five stories. I would say all of them come down to someone having a gross lack of respect for human life.

Since I read an advance reader copy, I did not see the pictures that will be included in the final version. These, I think, will add something more to the book, and I look forward to seeing these when the book releases.

For readers looking for a sobering look at real-life tragedies, I would recommend this.

Was this review helpful?

Borrowman succinctly writes about eight tragic events that may be lesser known than, say Titanic, but equally catastrophic. He details the events (told in chronological order), the human costs, the causes, and also how these events forged changes to prevent similar situations in the future. This is an exceptional book that I would recommend to readers interested in human nature, true-life calamities, and in history. Thank you to Netgalley for my review copy.

Was this review helpful?

As a person who reads a lot, I wanted to read this book because I love reading about real life things. I love reading about catastrophes and the heroes that help bring life back to normal. This book is just how I envisioned it would be and so much more. The stories captured real life and I can promise you that you won't have to worry about if it really happened or not. Either way I highly suggest reading this book. I do plan on buying it when it comes out so that I can allow my daughter to read it.

Was this review helpful?

Free ARC from Net Galley, the "ship of readers"!!!!!

Note to writers, here is a good example for you. Good prose and pace, 8 disasters with the what, where, and why format. Listen, if it happened it CAN happen only bigger and worse. read and heed here with this GREAT book. Very well done.

Was this review helpful?

This was an excellent delve into forgotten historical events that impacted current regulations. Although the background story was fascinating, the authors intentional focus on the heroes of each incident is what is captivating and brings the human side of tragedy to life

Was this review helpful?

I am naturally interested in disasters and this book did not disappoint. Outside of the Key West Hurricane, I had not read about or known about the catastrophes that the author outlined.
All told there was 8 catastrophes that the author outlined, gave a brief synopsis, and then commented about the heroes who came to the victims' aid.
Overall it was a great, brief read. The author kept it brief and left the reader to explore the event further.
The one drawback that I had was the author's analysis of "malice" after the tragedies.
Some of the catastrophes were without malice. The Key West Hurricane comes to mind, no malice, just ignorance of hurricanes.
Good writing and good development of the 8 tragedies.

Was this review helpful?