Member Reviews
I won't be blogging about this book because it bored me to tears and I only post positive books on my site. I couldn't finish it and I adore craft books. When I saw it was 350 pages, my eyes rolled back in my head. It reads like someone who couldn't get into the MFA of his choice and decided HE WAS GOING TO SHOW THEM.
I've got nothing here. I'm sorry. I wanted to love it.
As an aspiring writer, I am always looking for ways to procrastinate actual writing. And this often includes reading books about writing. 27 Essential Principles of Story was an entertaining and useful resource. Each chapter/element was clearly laid out, including examples from modern media. Chapters also included exercises for the reader to try their hand at each element.
Outstanding. Practical. Clear. Logical. No showy use of terminology. No snobbery. Rubin has given us a book that values storytelling and spares us the cheap psychologizing that marks too many titles in this genre. He comes off as a guy who's genuinely trying to help us all tell stories that will engage, enlighten, and maybe even sell. There are very few "essential" books in this genre, but 27 Essential Principles has joined that list.
I'm one of those people the author pokes at as "someone you know who has a fancy degree in writing." Yet my focus has always been creative nonfiction, so I'm always looking for resources to help me understand and practice the how-to's of story-telling. I enjoy the author's variety of relatable references, from Hamlet to Harry Potter to South Park, from Beloved to Breaking Bad to Eminem. And I appreciate how his methodology emphasizes fundamentals. This is a book I will continue to work through. Then I'll keep it on my reference shelf and revisit it from time to time.
The craft of writing as demonstrated by example
I enjoyed this book. Daniel Joshua Rubin uses examples from literature, movies, and television to illustrate in detail the 27 principles in the book. Rubin also gives enough of the background to the examples he cites that it is not necessary to have read/seen them in order to appreciate his commentary. I liked the Mini Final exam at the end of each principle with an explanation of the answer. I also appreciated the continuing education where Rubin refers to specific works and asks questions. Overall this is a great book on the craft of writing.
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book via Netgalley for review purposes.
The advice in this book is sound and worth reading for any writer, including both beginners and published authors. However, the author of this book uses a huge number of pages giving synopses of works of fiction, TV shows, and movies. While I appreciated the concepts presented, I found myself skipping many, many pages of examples that I did not find helpful. I would rather have had a presentation of the concepts with very brief examples.
Overall this book covers a lot of the key topics on writing a novel. I have read a few other writing books and taken some masterclasses by authors as well. This book used a lot of examples to help the readers get a better sense of how to use the principals effectively when writing a story.
I found this book to be great for new writers and a good refresher and reference materiel for everyone else.
Daniel Joshua Rubin has written a solid and engrossing page turner of a read with 27 Essential Principles of Story! Well worth your time!
Refreshing! Wow! From Shakespeare to Southpark-it works!
I thought the book was well written with clear cut examples and it was readable-not textbookey. I did take notes, highlight and underline. The Author does an excellent job crossing the modalities of plays, songs, South Park, video games-its all there. I think it is definitely a contemporary take on writing original, creative fiction. The Author does 'drill down' and dissects the narrative, in a well written artsy-creative guy type way.
Thank you NetGalley & Workman Publishing for giving me the opportunity to read & review this delightful book!
janne boswell
https://seniorbooklounge.blogspot.com/
I am a reviewer, not a writer.
However, I use this a lot to structure my reviews, to better understand what I read and how to judge it. I loved the fact that it comes with examples so you can understand what the author is talking about.
I don't consider a book to read at once, but rather a manual to keep close and open as often as you need guidance.
Thank you to NetGalley and Workman Publishing Company for sending me a free ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.
I wish I enjoyed this book more. 27 Essential Principles of Story held a lot of promise: “a bold new approach to teaching the art of great storytelling” where the author “unlocks the secrets of what makes a story work”. Unfortunately, for me this book was simply a mediocre reiteration of principles I’ve already learned and I found it rather boring: it reads like a textbook when it could have read like a story and further explored the point it was trying to make.
While I did find some tidbits of information that I will add to my own craft knowledge, this book did not revolutionize my writing process in the way that other writing craft books have. I often found the author’s tone to be willfully ignorant, as if he was the first one to discover that stories have definable points (despite the quantity of literature that’s already been written on this same subject and the author’s refusal to acknowledge this work).
Perhaps the author was trying to impart a sense of wonder at these discoveries for his reader, but for me it missed the mark. This subject isn’t new: one of the first that comes to mind is Joseph Campbell’s The Hero’s Journey. While I can’t say The Hero’s Journey is one of my favorite writing craft resources, I do recommend Jeff Gerke’s Plot Versus Character and Jessica Brody’s Save the Cat! Writes a Novel (an adaptation of Blake Snyder’s screenwriting book Save the Cat!). Both of these books discuss the same topics as 27 Essential Principles of Story, but I personally found them much more informative, accessible, and useful.
Perhaps the information in this book is new to some (and if so, you have a wonderful journey of discovery ahead of you), so this book might be best for fiction writers who haven’t read many creative writing books or for those who have hit a road block in their writing quality and are not sure where they might start to improve it.
In all, 27 Essential Principles of Story is not the most effective book on writing craft I’ve ever read, but it does have some useful examples for writers who are just starting out with writing craft research. This book will still be added to my writing advice shelf on Goodreads, and ultimately I hope it finds the readers it needs.
Thank you again to NetGalley and Workman Publishing Company for the privilege of reviewing an ARC.
Well, a lot of me wants to suggest this how-to-write guide is a success. Part of me wants to hold back a few years to see if it succeeds in making an author of me, but that's not fair when a brief review is in order. It's well-written, and impactful in its very own talk of how to be impactful – asking us to think of hammer-drops to kick narratives into play, equating the exercises here with martial arts training (although the pointless cussing is just that, pointless and rather childish). It is successfully wide-ranging, too – not all such guides cover "South Park", Rockstar video games, televised cooking contests and Netflix box-sets alongside their "Hamlet". Format-wise, we see a similar structure to every chapter – the general introduction to the topic at hand, a more forensic discussion of it, an example from the world canon of narrative ideas, some basic portrayals of how things might be done, courtesy of our author, the whole thing in closer application, and some furtherance to all that courtesy a second well-known text and so on.
Something else it's not, in the end, is geared to the beginner – there's no mention of breaching writers' block, or telling us where to get ideas from, per se. It tells the person who knows they want to write what to think of while they write, with the emphasis on long-form narrative, and assumes we can form a cogent description, and string a few sentences together already. I think the book succeeds with the stated aim, too, of being clear as to what it's trying to tell us, and yet not prohibitive or proscriptive. What I didn't realise was that the bits where we turn to the classics are in summary – I thought we'd see them reproduced as was. But I don't think that's at all a game-changer. This book might be one, however – but give it time to prove itself before deciding if it is or not.
Before reading this amazingly informative book on writing stories, I thought successful authors are poked by some kind of divine power, get inspired and start typing. What I did not know was that behind every successful story there is a set of systematic rules and equations which lead to victory.
I loved the way the book is constructed. It is cleverly divided into chapters. In each chapter, a popular and powerful example is given in accordance with the title. These popular examples are taken from famous novels, films, series and even video games. After every story, there are mini final exams to test your new skills. Therefore by the end of the book, you will learn how to build a well-structured and engaging story, how to build dynamic, lovable characters with tips, tricks and golden rules that pave the way to success.
As a bookworm, I dream of one day writing my own story and this book has given me great tips and basic ideas. A surprisingly interesting read recommended for those curious about writing.
This is such a brilliant resource! Outside of reading, I'm also a writer and studied creative writing at the Master level. I can confidently say the content in this book rivals higher-education material and fast-tracks lessons graduate professors spend entire terms teaching. I especially appreciate how this book is thoughtfully organized for quick reference -- as I'm sure many storytellers will be returning to it again and again.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this title in exchange for an honest review.
I was always fascinated by stories. Movies, shows, books, manga or comics.
It didn't matter. I loved interesting stories, stories that made me cry, that made me laugh, that made me be afraid.
I always had my own ideas, own stories that wanted to be freed out of my head.
And when I set myself a goal to put my own idea on paper there was this book.
I got accepted for an arc and it felt like a push for myself.
And what can I say?
This book was amazing. It was filled with many great tips for storywriters, fascinating examples from movies, books, articles, songs etc. It was written in an easy way and still filled with a lot of information.
All in all I'm absolutely in love with this book.
It helped me improve my story a lot!
I got a digital review copy of this book via NetGalley and am super glad about the time that i spent reading this book. There have been many books about the importance of storytelling and most of them cover this skill at a very superficial level, whereas Daniel has done a fabulous job of explaining the nuts and bolts of building a story arc.
What I liked about this book:
- The entire book is divided in to the most important elements of good story-telling - Plot, character and Setting. He breaks down each one of these elements into their basic tenets and explains them. What i liked the most was for each one of his principles, he takes a master storyteller and explains the principle through their work (How a master did it).
- He doesn't stop there. He then gives you a challenge by proposing another work by a master and ask you to do the dissection of the work so that we can understand the nitty gritty of how the principle works.
- He then shares some clear pointers about how you could go about building on these principles.
- He also tests your understanding of the principles by giving you a test that you can take.
What could have been done differently:
- There is only one thing that in my opinion would have made this into an even better book. If he could have helped the reader build a single story consistently through out the book, using the principles, it would have made everything else in the book much more powerful. I know that this is easier said than done. However, given what i have read, I am pretty sure this was something that Daniel could have achieved had he put his mind on it.
All said, if you want to learn how to tell compelling stories, this is as good a book as you can get your hands on. As good as "A Hero with a Thousand faces" and maybe even better than "Who saved the cat!"..
When I took hold of this one, I wondered why it was so thick.
It is about writing story and that cannot be so long and so complex.
I started with fearful thoughts of wasting too much time on it.
But surprisingly it was very easy to read.
It tells basic principles that masters use. To describe that there is example of famous and successful Stories.
Stories from books, movies and series.
It was wonderful experience to read assortment of such great stories.
I enjoyed thoroughly.
There was Harry Potter, godfather, brokeback mountain, rocky Balboa and many other great tales.
Cannot say it is ultimate guide to be an expert story writer. But it will give few useful hints.
Story is so vast and ever growing it is hard to decipher all its principles and secrets. But this book is a basic guide to outer layers of story writing.
Thanks netgalley and publisher for review copy.
I received this arc to read in exchange for an honest review, thank you Netgalley and the publishers for granting me with the opportunity.
As a creative writing student, this book was very efficient. The layout was perfect and it explained everything well. The use of movie and tv show examples to further explain the principles were handy and the little 'exam' at the end of each chapter definitely helped in retaining what was taught.
This book is packed full of information that I, and I believe many others will use and appreciate. I'll definitely be buying my own physical copy of the book when it releases on July 7th!
The layout of the book was great. It was very well presented. However, I didn’t feel that there was anything new or exclusive about the content. It’s all information that I have found before in other books. I found the end of section exams patronising too, and didn’t enjoy that element. Borrow this book from a friend or from the library, sure, but I wouldn’t recommend buying it.
I’ve read a number of books on writing fiction but “27 Essential Principles of Story,” by Daniel Rubin is the first book that I’ve read that takes you into the heart of how to tell a good story. Each section -- plot, character, and setting – takes you into the actual process for developing each. Using examples from a variety of media, Rubin draws on his impressive experience to illustrate the teaching points and the mini-exams solidify what you’ve learned. I will keep this book handy to revisit and reinforce the skills I’ve learned.