Member Reviews

I read this book in one sitting in about an hour in a fit of coronavirus and university-induced depression and it was pretty much exactly what I needed to binge in the moment. I wouldn’t say it was spectacular or revolutionary in any way, but I did enjoy it. This was an incredibly diverse book that covered many different issues. The reason it didn’t get a high rating from me was because it felt slightly too juvenile for my liking, which is unfortunate because I really liked the premise. But, overall, it was kinda cute and it distracted me for a while which is definitely a bonus.

Was this review helpful?

A great novel written about the struggles of coming/being forced out of the closet in high school. The intersection of sexuality and cultural and identity is well explained here. I think this is a great read for any teen that may be grappling with their identity in high school or anyone wanting to live unapologetically themselves.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my god I loved this book!!! I devoured it in 2 days it was that good!
It had me all in my feelings from the very beginning and the story was just told so perfectly.
Even though it is so beautifully cute there are some very important themes that were dealt with amazingly throughout the book such as racism, homophobia and cultural appropriation.
My heart kept going from full and happy to breaking and some parts got me so emotional, I was on the verge of tears!
This is definitely one of those books I think I could read again and again and never get bored.
The romance was perfect, the friendships realistic and the sisterly bond was lovely to read about.
Have I mentioned I love this book?
If you're thinking of reading this DO IT, you won't be disappointed.

*Thanks to Netgalley for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been looking forward to The Henna Wars for so long! I mean, f/f enemies-to-lovers? This book dealt with more serious issues than I was expecting, but I very much enjoyed it. The Henna Wars was a cute read with a heartwarming narrator, a lovely sister relationship, and ownvoices Bengali culture.

Nishat has just come out to her parents and already feels left out at school because she’s one of the few people of color. She meets a girl, Flávia, whom she knew in primary school at a wedding, and they click instantly. It turns out that she goes to the same school as her now, but their budding friendship comes to a halt when they compete in a school project with rival henna businesses.

I know that the whole point of Flávia having a henna business while not being South Asian was supposed to show cultural appropriation, but it honestly made me so uncomfortable seeing her and her white cousin, Chyna, flaunt Nishat’s culture in front of her. And t!hat’s the point! I’m just always so unsettled in these situations, so reading about it was a little difficult to get through. They do eventually have a conversation about why it’s wrong although Chyna only begrudgingly agrees (and only because Flávia points out that she doesn’t treat Flávia, her brown cousin, like this).

I really adored the strong sister relationship! Nishat and Priti are probably some of my favorite fictional sisters honestly. Priti is there for Nishat through thick and thin, and even when they argue, they always aim to support each other.

It was difficult reading about their parents not really being accepting of Nishat’s sexuality because of the ideals of their culture. I liked how Nishat notes that they were willing to upend their entire lives in Bangladesh and come to Ireland for a better life, but won’t allow her to be happy and live her life to her full capacity. This very much depicts the struggle of LGBTQ+ children of immigrants to make their parents happy but being unwilling to sacrifice a part of themselves to do so. However, their parents do eventually come around a little and are in the process of learning more about Nishat being a lesbian.

The romance was very soft! Flávia brings out some of the best in Nishat towards the end when they’re no longer competing. They bond over being brown in majority-white communities and the feeling of being in-between, with Nishat being Bengali-Irish and Flávia being biracial (Afro-Brazilian and white).

The Henna Wars was an incredibly adorable read that also deals with racism and cultural appropriation. It depicts a lesbian child of immigrants who strives to show her parents that she is who she is, and hiding her sexuality would make her miserable. Overall, this was a lovely debut, and I can’t wait to see what this author has in store for the future!

Was this review helpful?

Sometimes you read books that are just cute and warm and heartbreaking. And your soul just THRIVES. 😍(Look, what is a little reading without pain.) I really fell in love with this, from the sapphic representation to the addictive and wonderful writing to the absolutely amazing sisterly bonds. And can we please admire this cover for ever it is so ridiculous CUTE I JUST !!!

Family is a really powerful theme in this book, because Nishat is lesbian and is coming out to her conservative Muslim parents. And they...do not take it well. It's a family shame, they can't talk to her, they barely look at her. The story is strongly about coming out, and you feel the ache so acutely. It's just such a gut-punch to think your parents don't love you enough. They mostly dealt with it in cold silences, but Nishat is just wracked with anxiety. But look WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT PRITI. Aka, the love of the world, the light of this solar system. I cry. She is the perfect sister. Nishat and Priti absolutely argue and they can be mean to each other, but their relationship is this warm and tight hug of unconditional love.

THIS is the sister story you want. No, you NEED. (I have a lot of sisters and the dynamic of their love and bickering and then intense defence of each other was perfect.)

Nishat gets basically an insta crush on Flavia when they meet, and like it is adorkably cute and adorable and loooooved them. Flavia is Brazilian, and Nishat from Bangladesh, and the book is set in Ireland. But their relationship barely gets moves from cute flustered glances, before they end up at odds: for a school project, the class is required to start a little business. Nishat chooses henna because it's her culture, it means things to her, her grandmother taught her, it's part of who she is. Flavia (and her heinous cousin Chyna) also start a henna business. Because it's trendy. Cue: war.

I loved the way the book dealt with cultural appropriation, really talked about it and laid out the facts cold and hard and honestly. There's a difference between enjoying and participating in a culture not your own, to profiting and otherising it and appropriating it. (Also shout out to Chyna's NAME literally being appropriation. Ugh I despised her.) I love that this was #ownvoices and I love that it featured two POC girls figuring out where they stand and what respect for other cultures means. IT was just so deftly and well written and told.

It had utterly funny moments, important moments, heartwrenching moments. It had IT ALL. I adored the sister squabbles, the jokes, the foodie appreciation. I loved Nishat figuring out who she was, and being messy and making mistakes, but also being so amazing 🥺The whole book went by FAST too. I just loved it and definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This is a love story, yes, but also about bullying. It is about business competition, but it is also about multiculturalism, and stealing culture. It is about being a lesbian, and being a disappointment to your family.

There is so much here, so many moving parts.

There is the mean white girl, so has a problem with Nishat, for just existing, as far as I can see. We have her cousin, who is half Brazilian, Flavia, who Nishat is attracted to, but yeah, there is that cousin who hates her. And we have both of them wanting to run a henna business, even though henna tattoos have nothing to do with Brazilian culture.

Set in Ireland, we have the feeling of being alien, within this world, almost as much as Nishat does.

I like how brave Nishat is, that when she is outed, she goes with it, even though it hurts her feelings, and hurts her sales.

One nit-pick is that this has been "translated" for Americans so that when they mention 40 degrees, they mean Fahrenheit, and not Celsius.

Good addition to any library.

Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Adiba Jaigirdar’s The Henna Wars promised to be everything that I love in a book upon reading the synopsis; and it did not disappoint. Jaigirdar’s novel is a gorgeously-written story of coming out, rising above others and falling in love.
Our main character Nishat was an amazing lead to this incredible story. I could really resonate with her and see the similarities between her coming to terms with her sexuality and how I went through a very similar process too. I think the pressure that she feels to come out is something that hit me the hardest, something that is so brutally honest, yet not spoken about enough; is how as soon as you figure out your sexuality, suddenly it feels like you’re lying to everyone you love by not telling them, and it was written so, so well.
From the start, Nishat’s infatuation with Flávia is adorable. The fact that they both remember each other and can recall such precise memories about their childhood is just *too* cute! Flávia is confident, bold and outgoing, everything that Nishat thinks she isn’t. Their dynamic is adorable, and from their first encounter you’re left wanting and hoping for more, and Jaigirdar does not disappoint.
The relationship in this book is so cute; both of the girls are super shy and awkward, which is beyond relatable and precious. I was so invested in their relationship and adored watching it blossom, even throughout the tough bits where Nishat was trying to ignore Flávia but she simply couldn’t. The chemistry between these two was phenomenal, like magnets drawn to each other, they just couldn’t stay away and I LOVED it!

While reading this book, I felt like I was learning something new every few chapters. Topics such as racism, homophobia and bullying are covered in such an informative way that it made me rethink so many things which seemed harmless before this book. Such as how cultural appropriation can really hurt someone, and make them feel like a part of their persona has been stripped away and used as a marketing device to be seen as “trendy”.
The friendships in this book are so supportive, inclusive and positive. Although one of Nishat’s friends doesn’t understand where she is coming from when she gets upset over Flávia culturally appropriating and copying her henna idea, she learns, is educated and then apologises for it. Both of Nishat’s friends cheer her on throughout everything, even when they have a fall out, and they’re there to support her at school when she needs it most, which is heart-warming to see.
Nishat’s sister Priti was SUCH a huge part of this book, and I absolutely loved it. Priti is the first person Nishat tells about her being a lesbian, and is constantly reassuring her that it’s okay and that she has people who love and support her. I think Priti is so incredible; while going through her own struggles, she is always making sure Nishat is okay, even as the younger sister. Their sibling dynamic is very similar to them being best friends; they are each other’s confidants and confide in each other when they have nobody else to turn to. Priti is the most supportive person in Nishat’s life, and their relationship is so precious.
In the beginning, Nishat’s parents decide to ignore her sexuality in hopes that it is a “phase” or a result of something she’s “seen on TV and in films, and read about in your books”. This reaction is truly heart-wrenching to read, even more heartbreaking when you have to acknowledge that for so, so many people it is their reality. Nishat goes through a whirlwind of emotions throughout the main part of the book, constantly scared that her parents no longer love her, or that they’re going to kick her out. When her parents near enough stop talking to her or even looking at her for too long, your heart really breaks for Nishat and all I wanted to do was pick her up and give her a hug :( Nishat’s parents slowly start to show their support through small gestures such as showing up to her school’s business event and getting angry when her stall gets trashed, researching LGBTQ+ identities in order to try and understand her better and watching the Ellen DeGeneres show after she mentions it. These gestures may seem small but the impact they have on Nishat is phenomenal; she suddenly grows in confidence when talking to them and worries less and less about them not loving her or accepting who she is. Their growth and gradual acceptance is so moving as a reader and towards the ending I started to tear up purely out of happiness for Nishat <3

This book is so important for readers, it's so inclusive and I urge every single person to pick it up if they have the chance :)

Was this review helpful?

CONTENT WARNING : this book contains instances of racism, homophobia, bullying, and a character being outed.

"When Dimple Met Rishi meets Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda in this rom com about two teen girls with rival henna businesses." Yup, this first sentence of the synopsis was enough to convince my bi ass that I needed to send a request to Netgalley for this ARC.

So. THIS BOOK. It was the perfect feel good rom-com, with a full-on emotional roller-coaster ride. The characters were so layered and relatable, and I loved the character growth, and not just on the MC's part. I loved reading and learning about the rich cultural heritage of the MC, who originates from Bengladesh and identifies as Muslim. #ownvoices

I appreciated how the author wove her story, adding important social issues throughout the book. I loved how the author demonstrated the difference between sharing your own culture and cultural appropriation. I can't help but *hope* that, if people who don't understand these nuances would read this book, they'd get it RIGHT AWAY. And stop judging issues they don't try to understand.

I also really liked how the importance of family is valued in this book. Especially when the MC's parents stopped trying to convince her to be straight, and started educating themselves on all the different types of sexualities and genders. And that they were willing to learn and right their wrongs.

Overall, this was an impressive debut. It was so well written, but still easy to read, and perfect for a rom-com. It deserves ALL of the stars. I will definitely be buying this book once it hits the shelves.

Was this review helpful?

I wholeheartedly adored this: The Henna Wars is a wonderful, sincere story with fantastic characters and relationships. The journey of Nishat and Flávia's relationship was beautifully written and charming to read about, as was the development of Nishat's relationships with her sister, friends and the rest of her family. I loved Nishat, her loved ones and the unapologetic expression of their identities.

Was this review helpful?

This story follows our main character who recently came out to her conservative, Bengali parents and is trying to use her creative skills at henna to win a school contest. I really enjoyed all of the cultural references throughout this entire book as they created a rich, vivid setting for our characters to be grounded and feel real. The love story was cute but the book was more about the family and school dynamics. Unfortunately I didn't quite understand the big plot point of the school project and felt like it was more of a framework for the characters to interact within than something that infused tension and high stakes into the storyline. Similarly, while I really like the individual love interests I didn't fully buy into their chemistry together. However, I loved the sister relationship which for me was the absolute best part of this book and one of the main reasons I'll recommend it to others. Fun, diverse f/f romance for readers looking to see themselves and others in light hearted YA lit.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love this book. The Henna Wars is a feel-good YA book. Flavia is Brazallian and and Nishat is from Bangladesh. The both attend school in Ireland. They both have amazing stories about why they are living with family in Ireland. The school they attend host a competition for their class. The competition requires students to work in groups and design a business plan and market it to the community. Winners of the competition get a sizeable cash prize. Both Flavia and Nishat are on teams who decide to create a henna art business. Nishat because for her henna is a part of her history, her culture and her family. Flavia attends a wedding with her cousin Chynna and is introduced to the henna because the bridal party is wearing it. The competition becomes one big messy and at times ugly entity. The two girls are pitted against each other because of their opposing views of what the henna means to each of them.
But, to make the story even more interesting, the girls also share a mutual attraction for each other. Nishat, who in the course of the book decides that she doesn't want to live in secrecy about her identity. She is "outed" in a mean way by Flavia's cousin Chynna. Nishat decides that even though Chynna tells her secret because of spitefulness and lack of compassion; she embraces her sexual identity and also opens up to her parents. Her parents are very traditional Bengalis and do not take the news well. Flavia, absolutely has no intentions of :coming out" to anyone at the present moment. Her fears are even more confirmed as she sees how Nishat is treated by the kids at school.
Both girls work their way through maze of family, friends, school, and community. Each one coming to understand and embrace their sexual identities as well as their identities culturally as they live in Ireland.
They story does an amazing job of helping the reader under the importance of cultural appropriation, the difficulties of living in a country not your own and the need for compassion for anyone who is coming to terms with their definition of "self".

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC.
This is a coming of age story of coming out and figuring out who you really want to be. It is a story filled with Bengali pride, a hilarious & joyful sibling relationship, and family dynamics.
This was a good read, I liked how the issues Nishat was dealing with were things that any other teenager might have to deal with when coming out. What makes it harder for her is her family traditions and in some ways the color of her skin.
I felt that parts of the story and some of the characters needed a bit more depth but overall it is a good read.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

This is SO cute in a charming and not sappy way.

Nishat is - for the most part - an extremely likable character who is originally out to her sister but then comes out to her parents early in the novel. Her parents' reactions and their comparisons to their own romance, as well as the various cultural implications they highlight, are all engaging and relatable to many readers. Early in the novel, readers also get to know Nishat's younger sister, Priti, as well as a potential love interest, Flavia. Each of these characters is round and enjoyable enough to have their own spin off, which makes for a rich read on the character front alone.

Notably, this novel contains so many critical issues but never feels didactic or over-the-top. Having read a lot of YA recently that takes on way too much at the expense of accomplishing nothing meaningful at all, this work is a truly refreshing reward. Jaigirdar includes a comprehensive content warning, which I truly appreciate. Readers will absolutely encounter in-depth instances of bullying, homophobia, and racism. Each of these is handled in a realistic manner. I also think the depictions of outing and repeatedly having to come out are expertly devised. For me, a standout component is also the depiction of cultural appropriation. This is one of the best discussions, dissections, and evaluations of this issue I've seen in any fiction, let alone YA.

I'd have like to see more ultimate processing in two relationships: the sisters and the cousins. Both felt a bit unfinished to me. Other than this relatively minor issue, as well as perhaps a bit of editing in some of the school- and home-based scenes, this is a rock solid work. I can't wait to read more from this author and will absolutely be recommending this novel and future works to students, colleagues, friends, and family.

Was this review helpful?

I am all in for the concept of the book! Nishat's story reverberates with a lot of issues we face today. The story perfectly encapsulates homophobia, racism and cultural appropriation in the most honest and heart-warming way. Nishat's family belongs to a minority community in Ireland. While her parents fought hard and tough to give Nishat and her sister Priti a comfortable life in Ireland, Nishat and Priti face a different kind of discrimination in their lives - a very subtle sort of a racism, the one that makes you uncomfortable in your own skin. Along with racism, Nishat has to face another kind of discrimination - homophobia. Not only in her school but also from her parents. For Nishat's parents homosexuality is something that simple doesn't 'happen to' Muslim girls. It is beyond their understanding that something like that is possible, something like that is what people 'are', something like that is acceptable, and something like that won't bring shame on the family. And I feel the author has beautifully dealt with these sensitive issues in the book.

I loved how the author has talked about these delicate subjects dealing from the Bengali and Bangladeshi culture to a young girl's conflicts when it comes to falling in love. The author has beautifully crafted a delightful novel that enriches the reader's view on celebrating one's culture and love, all in one book. Also, the book has lots of pop culture references that I enjoyed reading about and most importantly references from the Bengali culture. Even though I'm a Indian-Bengali, I squealed with joy everytime there was a reference because my culture and Bangladeshi-Bengali culture has the same roots.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this book. Nishat is a bad ass and I loved how fierce she is in spite of so many people in her life being awful. The sister dynamic with Priti was sweet and relatable and it was nice to see she had one person by her side even when her family was being terrible and everyone at school was being the absolute worst.

Was this review helpful?

“What I want more than anything else is to feel like being myself isn’t something that should be hidden and a secret” (end of chapter 18 in the eARC).

Nishat attends a majority White, all-girls Catholic high school in Dublin. Although the administration claims to have a zero-tolerance policy for bullying, students who routinely bully others face no consequences. Nishat has been repeatedly bullied and feels as though she doesn’t really fit in at the school. Her little sister, Priti, fares a little better, but likewise faces bullying. Neither girl is excited for the start of the new school year, especially since Priti is facing high-pressure national exams for which she is already studying.

Nishat runs into an old primary school classmate, Flávia, at a wedding, and immediately feels a connection with her. The first day of school, Nishat is surprised and pleased to see that Flávia now attends her school, but she is dismayed to learn that Flávia’s cousin is one of the girls who bullies her.. Nishat finds herself falling for Flávia, who seems to reciprocate her feelings. However, they become rivals during a business competition for a class when they each open a henna business. Soon someone outs Nishat, damaging her chances to win the competition and increasing the bullying she faces, but pulling her closer to Flávia. Caught between her parents’ wishes (and heterosupremacy) and her peace of mind (and desire for authenticity), Nishat struggles to find a place for herself.

This book broke my heart and healed it. It made me cry, hurt, laugh, and rejoice with Nishat. Nishat’s turmoil was authentically rendered, as was her courage in moving forward and being herself. The journey through the fear of coming out to loved ones, the pain and trauma of being rejected and outed, and the path to self-acceptance are ones to which many LGBTQ+ readers can relate.

This book can be difficult to read due to the heterosexism and racism of some characters and the harmful actions those characters choose. I appreciate the content warnings that the author includes at the beginning of the book, so that the reader can choose whether s/he is in the right place/frame of mind to read this book. This book is one that I wish I had as a teenager. I think I would have felt seen if I had access to books like this. To use Dr. Rudine Sims Bishop’s metaphor, this book was a much-needed mirror, window, and door for me, and I highly recommend it.

I am very impressed with this writer’s debut novel, and I have ordered a hard copy of this book. I will also be booktalking it to my students.

This review is posted on Goodreads.

Was this review helpful?

This book was one of my most anticipated books of the year, and while it didn't completely live up to all my expectations (they may have been a bit too high) it was still a really great book and an impressive debut.
This follows our main character Nishat, who lived in Bangladesh until she was 10 but then her family moved to Dublin, Ireland. At the beginning of this book, Nishat decides to come out as a lesbian to her parents and it doesn't go to plan. She decides to set up a henna business as part of her school project, and then to her dismay, her crush, Flavia, decides to go into competitive business with her by creating her own henna business despite it not being part of her culture. So we follow a confused and frustrated Nishat as she tries to navigate this difficult year of her life.
What I Liked:
-Female/Female enemies to lovers? Yes please. At first Flavia wasn't totally likeable, and I was worried that I wouldn't root for their relationship but I think it developed really well and I ended up loving their romance. It definitely had a natural progression and was a learning experience for both the girls and it was amazing.
-The writing was amazing. For a debut author, this was even more impressive. The dialogue was natural, the prose felt personal and engaging, and at no point did it feel forced or like the author was trying too hard to "relate" to teenagers.
-I loved the relationship between Nishat and her sister, Priti. It was such a supportive sibling relationship, and I always love books with sisters who have a really strong bond. They loved each other, and even though they argued, they were there for each other as much as they could be and it was so lovely to see.
-I loved how much culture was included in this book. I didn't know all that much about Bengali culture and I appreciated that it didn't seem 'watered down'. I am white so I don't feel like it's my place to talk too much about this, but it was really nice to see a f/f romance between two WOC and I really did learn a lot from this book.
What I Didn't Like:
-My main issue with this book was that this was another queer book with a public and non consensual outing. I get really fed up with so many outings that the characters didn't want, and it just feels very tiring to have the same terrible thing happen to so many queer people in books. This also was just quite generally full of homophobia, and while this did have a 'happy' ending, it was quite difficult to read. I just wanted things to go well for Nishat.
-My other problem was that I don't feel like we got to know Nishat enough. Despite this being told in first person, I just don't feel Nishat's personality came through fully. If you asked me to describe her personality, pretty much all I could say is that she's resilient and loves her family and culture. I just think she needed a bit more depth.
Overall, this was a very impressive debut that was an extremely solid read. It was great to see more lesbian representation, and I really loved the romance. I would definitely recommend picking it up in May when it's released.

Was this review helpful?