Member Reviews

A strong, resonant story about the conflict faced by a do tour when her best friend's child presents at the emergency room with indications that she was injured at her mother's hands The physician's dilemma is sympathetically presented, and the mental distress of of the accused mother and her husband movingly portrayed by a skillful writer. There's little drama or mystery here, but the narrative and characters are well drawn enough so that doesn't matter.

Was this review helpful?

How well do we know our closest and dearest friends? This is the question that rattles Liz when her close friend, Jess, comes in with her baby girl who has sustained a skull fracture. There is some heavy stuff in here, no joke. The mystery relating to the child abuse was hard to read. I was conflicted; I wanted to know how it happened and who was involved, but it was an emotional read. I did like that the author focused so much on mental illness and postpartum depression. I think PD isn’t a topic written about in many books so it was refreshing to see the challenges of motherhood so well articulated. I also did like the twist at the end. Wasn’t expecting that!! Overall, I’m giving this one 3.5⭐️ Thank you @netgalley and @simonandschuster for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. Recommended!
Liz is a pediatric doctor on call when a toddler is brought in with a suspicious head injury that leads to a call to child services. The mother of the child is a good friend of Liz, and while they haven’t been close as of late, Liz cannot believe that Jess would ever hurt her own baby. There are secrets and truths hiding within both women as they discover motherhood is not always as it seems.
.
I truly enjoyed this fast paced drama by @svaughanauthor. She explores the complexities of being a mother and how isolating it can be. Speaking from personal experience, postpartum depression is very common, very scary and not discussed nearly enough. I am glad the author dove into this topic and I hope it sparks some much needed conversations!

Was this review helpful?

This is a story that follows a group of friends who met at a birthing class, and stayed friends after their babies were born. The main focus is on Jess, the mother of three, who has undiagnosed postpartum psychosis, and Liz, a pediatric doctor who treats Jess' youngest when she is brought into the hospital with an unknown head trauma. Several different view points tell the story of what happened to baby Betsey that night, and the dark and twisted details of the mothers mind will make you cringe as the story unfolds.

I wasn't a huge fan of this book, as it wasn't really a mystery like the kind I usually read. There were a few twists towards the end, but I saw them coming a mile away. It took longer to get to the end than it should have, as the characters just kept repeating their same feelings over and over. Overall, not my favorite book, and I would not recommend it to others.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Anatomy of a Scandal so went into this one with high expectations and I was not disappointed. It's both heartbreaking and bittersweet as it revolves around Liz and Jess, two friends who met in their birthing classes. Now Liz is a pediatrician and when Jess brings in her young daughter with a suspicious head injury, Liz is conflicted as she knows Jess is a great mother but the law dictates social services be brought in. Of course this triggers a chain of events that creates its own momentum. In the meantime we see Liz's own past brought into the spotlight as she's estranged from her mother and brother. If you are a mother yourself, you will find some of this painful to read as you will want to constantly cuddle and hug your kids. But ultimately it's a lovely novel that explores the lengths parents go to in protecting and loving their offspring.

Was this review helpful?

Jess is a stay at home mom. Liz is a pediatrician and was in Jess's birthing class. Jess has three children and Liz has two. The mother's used to spend time together after the babies were born but not so much now. Liz is exceptionally busy at the hospital. She doesn't see Jess as much after the birth of her third baby, a little girl.
Maybe if Jess would have been more involved she would have noticed a disturbing change in Jess's behavior.
Jess is feeling overwhelmed. She did great with her first two kids, but this third child has her exhausted. Not only that she is having malevolent and evil thoughts. The only way she can control things is being overly perfectionist in everything she does. Sometimes being a mother takes more than you have to give.
Absolutely Recommended!!!

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Vaughan's latest novel Little Disasters explores how one lie can set off a tragic chain reaction with devastating consequences. Jess is a harried mother of three young children whose life appears to be perfectly happy and gorgeously curated. She and Liz, a busy pediatric doctor and Mom of two, are in the same group of friends who met in a prenatal class. The reader has a front row seat to Jess's extreme anxiety over her children's safety; and her struggle to calm her colicky baby -- all while experiencing extreme sleep deprivation and a workaholic husband (many of us can relate!). Meanwhile, Liz battles repercussions of an abusive mother and a lifetime of family secrets.

Liz is working at the hospital one night when Jess brings her infant daughter in with a head injury. Liz quickly suspects foul play and is required to report Jess to the authorities. Little Disasters considers the very real dangers of post natal anxiety and maternal OCD (content warning!). This would be a great book club pick. Sarah Vaughan made me think about how important it is to support new moms, to have a network of support, and to lift up all Mothers and not tear them down.

Was this review helpful?

Maybe I just don’t like Sarah Vaughan’s writing. I found Anatomy of a Scandal extremely tedious, and Little Disasters was the same. I slogged through it and finally gave up about 65% of the way through. The story was annoying, the characters idiotic, and the writing boring.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and Atria Books for providing this arc in exchange for an honest review.

Liz is working and a doctor in the ER when her friends Jess and Ed bring their baby, Betsy in with a head trauma that occurred several hours before. Despite their friendship, Jess agrees with others that feel an investigation into child abuse is warranted. The book is told from several perspectives, mostly Liz, who had a rough relationship with her mother and Jess, who has been struggling since the birth of her third child.

I was sent a widget from the publisher and probably should have declined based on the subject matter, but instead went for it since there seems to be nothing to do but read during lockdown. This was a well written book with a twist I didn’t expect at the end. For most of the book, I felt like I was reading a family drama and a postpartum depression account and couldn’t figure out why it was billed a mystery thriller. That became clear at the end but the mystery took too long to get to and the subject matter really isn’t my thing. I am not a fan or babies or kids really and don’t love books that revolve around motherhood. Not a bad book, just not my thing.

Was this review helpful?

I would like to begin this review by saying that it's very rare for me to not finish a book once I get started. I see it as a commitment to the story to let it unfold in its entirety before I pass judgment. I have finished many books that I've then given 1 star. However, I had to stop reading this around 25% of the way through. Obviously that means I'm reviewing this novel without knowing the entire story, so I'm going to be as fair as I possibly can and base my rating on what I did read.

First of all, had I known the "mystery" that was at the heart of this book, I never would have requested it. The back blurb was very vague and only mentioned "dark thoughts," but I think readers need to know upfront that the main plot point of this novel surrounds a woman with potential postpartum psychosis (not to be confused with postpartum depression). This means that she has frequent thoughts about hurting her child and this could be very triggering for some readers. (This isn't a spoiler, as this is made known to the reader within the first few chapters.)

Now I'm not sure if the character in question actually committed the heinous acts of which she's suspected because I didn't get that far, but the "dark thoughts" she has are extremely unsettling, to the point at times that I felt so disturbed I had to stop reading and go hug my toddler just to fight back the tears. I've read some of the most gruesome of murder mysteries and thrillers in my day, but I guess after having a kid myself, I am just too sensitive when it comes to violence against children to read a story like this. Those with thicker skins may be able to handle it, but I was not prepared for such descriptive brutality against an infant.

My other complaint is how this mother's illness is presented. Given that I only read a quarter of the book, I'm hoping that my initial impression on how the author handles this topic is wrong and that she gets it right by the end. However, it seems to me that the reader is led to believe this is what happens when a mother deals with too much pressure. Anyone who's had a baby can attest to how difficult the first few months with a newborn are and it can be even harder for those who have little to no support. However, women who commit these kinds of acts are mentally ill and not simply stressed by the overwhelming responsibilities of being a mother. I hope that's made clear by the end of the book.

Long story short, I couldn't finish this. The subject matter put a bad taste in my mouth and I was deeply unsettled by the descriptive violence against a baby. That being said, the writing was fine, the characters were believable, and there certainly is a level of suspense overall. Based on the number of good reviews, it's probably a decent enough read if you have thicker skin than I do.

Was this review helpful?

This is not what I thought it would be. It was definitely a thought provoking book and really made you think what you will do to protect your children, even if that means the possibility of losing your children in the process.
I know this happens, the terrible negative thought you may have after having a child. This one was so intense that it made me sad.
The characters were written well, a little jumbled. Maybe it just wasn't the book for me?

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for this ARC!!

Liz sees her best friend Jess as a stay-at-home mother-of-three with boundless reserves of patience, energy, and love. But when Jess, arrives at the hospital, where Liz works as a nurse, with her young daughter she begins to wonder what's wrong with Jess.

Jess’s daughter, Betsey, has suffered a head trauma, but what is even more perplexing to Liz, is Jess’s lack of concern about the situation. Why didn’t Jess rush her daughter to the hospital when the accident first happened? How did it happen? Something about the way Jess keeps avoiding Liz's questions surprises her and she wonders what is Jess hiding?

Dark thoughts and carefully guarded secrets surface—and Liz is left questioning everything she thought she knew about her friend, and about herself. The truth can’t come soon enough.

I really enjoyed reading this and the ending was surprising since I didn't expect it !!

Was this review helpful?

Didn’t really care for this one. I wanted it to be scarier than it was. There were parts that I had hoped were goin* to turn it around but it never really got there for me. I wasn’t horrible by any means, but it wasn’t anything special. It had potential to be, but didn’t.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this book with the predetermined notion that this was a thriller and/or suspense. While there were moments of this novel that had twists and turns similar to those that are in the genre, I feel that this novel is more related to a drama.

Jess seems to have it all together. As a stay-at-home mom, she is the one that always looks well put together with an endless supply of patience and acceptance of her children. Liz, a friend and pediatrician, finds herself looking up to Jess as a mother. This is until Jess' child comes to the ER with a broken skull, prompting Liz to start asking questions. Is Jess all that she seems to be or is there something that Jess is hiding?

This novel was a quick read and a wonderful depiction of something that our country likes to ignore - post partum depression, Bravo Sarah Vaughan for tackling an issue in an unique way, and in a way that can capture a wide variety of readers as an audience.

Was this review helpful?

Jess is the mom that seems to have it all together. However when her baby ends up in the ER with a skull fracture Liz, one of her closest friends and also a pediatric doctor, is forced to get social services involved. Jess denies ever hurting her baby, but her behavior makes Liz question everything she knows about her friend. Could Jess truly have hurt her little girl or did something else happen to cause something so horrific?

I’m so happy I got this as an ARC! It was a quick read for me. While this book is advertised as a mystery / thriller I don’t think it really fits that genre. It’s definitely a drama with a few twists. I really enjoyed seeing the different POV from all the characters and the background build. As someone who works with kids in the medical field and is also a mother this book really hot close to home. I really enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book for several reasons. It brought much needed attention to mothers dealing with postpartum depression and who are too afraid to ask for help. And also addresses children with emotional challenges.

It begins with Jess's daughter Betsey being taken to the hospital and then discovering she has a concussion. Soon the police, her best friend Liz, and ER doctors suspect Jess of intentionally hurting her baby.
The story was fast paced and kept me interested. I did not see the twist at the end coming! Definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I consider myself fairly educated and I do read a lot of fiction by European authors but there were a ton of words in this book that just left me scratching my head because I had no idea what they meant
This is one of those books that it's hard to do a review without giving a minor spoiler.
All I will say is that you will come to find you hated the wrong people but for the right reasons! Pediatrician Liz has just found her friend's baby admitted to her hospital with what appears to be a head injury. When the tests prove it is a fractured skull, the questions begin. While trying to separate professional opinion from personal feelings, Liz also finds herself amidst a family tragedy with the decline of her mother's health. As the story reads on, we learn about the tragic past from Liz's family, including the mystery surrounding the death of her baby sister Clare. No one, especially Liz expected what truth was finally revealed as her mother faced a certain soon death.
Jess's story also begins to unfold. What we think we see, the fake sweetness she seems to exude sometimes around baby Betsey is not what it is. This story is kind of Iike an onion with lots of layers. One by one as the layers peel back we see who has been lying and who is telling the truth. So who hurt baby Betsey? You won't know unless you read til the end!

Was this review helpful?

Very good book! A thought provoking and enjoyable read. I was surprised by the ending and was please that it wasn't predictable. I had my mind made up about how the accident happened throughout the whole story and was pleasantly surprised to see I was wrong.

Was this review helpful?

Book Review: Little Disasters by Sarah Vaughan, to be available August 2020 from Atria Books/Simon & Schuster

First let me thank NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for the opportunity to read this novel in its prepublication stage in exchange for an honest review. Thanks to Isabel Dasilva for the personal invitation!

First – let me say an overall wow. It was definitely a page turner. The plot is compelling. What happened to Jess’s baby? Pediatrician Liz Trenchard is in the emergency room when he friend Jess shows up with her baby girl. There is something clearly wrong and the evidence points to an obvious blow to the head. The story Jess tells doesn’t feel right and it gets curiouser and curiouser as time goes on. Without introducing spoilers here about what happens, I can tell you that Sarah Vaughan expertly introduces doubt about Jess and the potential for what may have happened.

The Characters: Liz is a wonderful character with a complex life and a tragic childhood and an abusive, alcoholic mother (Janet) whose early home life and has not only pushed her into her career as a pediatrician but colored many of her thoughts and compassion for what may have occurred. Jess’ husband Ed, who is a workaholic but suddenly starts questioning what may have happened himself, even though in his heart of hearts he believes that there is no way that Jess would have harmed their child.

What I liked: The twist towards the end. I loved how the reveal came slowly. Never saw it coming – which is the best part for me. I loved to be surprised by an author and a plot twist. Great job Sarah! I didn’t really like Jess in the beginning of the book when her OCD was so overwhelming and she kept silent. I suppose that’s a reality – but it kept the suspense so tight in the beginning – which was a good thing.

What I didn’t like – I guess it is surprising that no one else picked up on Jess’ compulsions. Was Ed around so little that he didn’t figure out how OCD she was? Or had she always been like that even prior to children so he just overlooked it all. Perhaps a little more background on Jess’ childhood might explain (did I miss that?) why she was so OCD.

Overall a fantastic read and great for mothers who may be doubting their ability to cope. You’re not as alone as you think you are.

Was this review helpful?

A great read and life lesson! Relatable characters who taught me something about mental health and my friendships with other moms. Though it felt like a slow build in the beginning, I was hooked until the very last word.

Was this review helpful?