Member Reviews

Good heavens, do these people eat a lot of pizza.

This is a very sweet, charming ode to the joy and power of reading. It’s a good premise for a tame but enjoyable tale of magic too, although the book ends right when it seems the fun is getting started.

I’m a little baffled by all the Chronicles Of Narnia comparisons. They do mention Narnia frequently in the book, but the basics of this are actually a lot closer to Thursday Next than Narnia. I kept waiting for the kids to travel to an alternate world, and when they finally do it’s for about 30 seconds and 90% of the way through the book. There’s nothing particularly problematic about how they got there or what happens when they do, but it felt like a lot of buildup for minimal payoff.

Still, it’s a fun story with charming characters and a sweet and refreshingly subtle message. The explanation of where Iffen came from is a clever one, even though I wish there had been more to the story once the kids figured it out.

Oh, and shoutout to McKay for the clever reference to ApsleyCherry Garrard’s The Worst Journey in the World.

Was this review helpful?

With thanks to NetGalley for an early copy in return for an honest review.

I love books set in London and any book where the magic is tied to books is usually a big win for me but I didn't connect well with this one. The story had some great elements but felt a bit disjointed and I never really connected with how the magic was happening. I was also left with questions about the characters, like what was going on with Polly.

Was this review helpful?

This was adorable. It had a beautiful balance of magic and family dynamic as the focus. Each character facing his or her own struggles as well as a few that bring them all together. The writing was lovely, it was well paced and kept my interest through the whole book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a lovely book, if not actually a favorite. I enjoyed the magical realism aspect and the complex family relationships that were written with care and respect. There was just a touch of creepiness than was enthralling, and the idea of the magical house and magical books was a fantastic one. For me, though, it ended up being a bit slow, and the ending felt almost rushed in comparison to the rest of the book, so it wasn't quite satisfying. I think for my ten-year-old who read MG this book would feel quite slow and confusing. Several plot points are odd or a bit disjointed. And I think for her, since she's just begun confidently reading MG rather than chapter books, all the British jargon would be a hindrance to enjoying it. Worth reading if you enjoy slower=paced, magical realism books. The writing style really was lovely. But maybe not the best book for younger MG readers.

Was this review helpful?

It was like they were in a book, Abi thought. The Time of Green Magic is very much the sort of thing one might expect to happen if books could come to life in one's home. Unlike many children's fantasy, the events, though distinctly magical, are believable and just remarkable enough to be a bit frightening. In this novel, magic is not a tame thing that exists to establish a 7-year-old's childish fantasies, but a force of its own that simply is. Aside from the Green Magic of the title, there is also the magic of first love, the magic of learning to share, the magic of an apology, the magic of learning to trust, and the magic of letting go. Each of the three children finds a way to be just a bit more courageous, trustworthy, confident and grown up throughout the story.
As and adult, I found it a real page-turner that immersed me in a world almost as magical as the house itself, if a little less tangible. I would love to see my students read and enjoy it, and will encourage those between 10-13 to pick it up.

Was this review helpful?

The Time of Green Magic celebrates all that’s good — and challenging — about growing up. Through my adult eyes, the magic Abi, Louis and Max experience is that of imagination, stimulated by the fantastical house they live in. Through the eyes of a child, I think the magic will be just that — magic.

I think that’s why author Hilary McKay’s writing appeals to so many children and adults. It asks us to open our minds and consider the possibilities. And, as in this case, readers are given room to come to their own conclusions.

Consider the varying ages of McKay’s protagonists. When their parents marry, Max is 13, Louis 6, and Abi 11. Their ages have a direct impact on their experiences. These age variances, as well as personality differences, create a layered experience that is engrossing and enjoyable.

The Time of Green Magic is not a particularly dynamic or fast read. Instead, it’s one you settle into; take your time reading. It’s a calm book that will probably appeal to more attentive readers.

Was this review helpful?

I stan Hilary McKay, y’all, and I was so glad to get my greedy little hands on the advance copy of her new book. What I love about Hilary McKay (I think) is the way her big, messy, complicated families are big, messy, and complicated — there's no attempt to simple them up. Some people change and some people don’t, some people get better, some get worse, but everyone is ultimately accepted for who they actually are. I love that.

So in The Time of Green Magic, a new family is forming: When Theo and Polly fall in love, they move their two families together into a rambling old house covered with ivy (and at the very top of their budget). Theo’s daughter Abi is used to being an only child and having her Granny around — but now Granny’s gone back to live with her sister in Jamaica, and Abi’s stuck with two annoying brothers instead: Polly’s sons, grumpy teen Max, who is in the middle of a stupid fight with his best friend (that he knows is stupid but that he can’t bring himself to end), and little Louis, who wants to spend every minute with Abi and Max and can’t understand why they don’t want him around. Voracious reader Abi is the first to discover that there’s something strange happening in their new house — when she drifts deep into a book set on the ocean, she returns to reality with a salt-water-wet book in her hands — but lonely Louis is the one who nurtures the magic, when a mysterious and dangerous creature creeps through his window at night.

In some ways, this reminds me of Edgar Eager and Eva Ibbotsen — there’s magic here, but it’s matter-of-fact, everyday magic that believably flies under the radar of busy parents. Underneath the everyday, though, there’s this wonderful sense of eerie mystery, a reminder that the world is more magical than we assume. But it’s also pure McKay in the way that Abi, Max, and Louis become a family — a big, messy, complicated family, which is a kind of magic all its own.

Oh, I loved it. If you are in the mood for something warm and whimsical, give this one a go.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley.com.

First line: There were no curtains at the window, and the room was bare, except for the sofa and Abi's rocking horse and Abi herself, hunched over her book like a diving bird on the edge of a pool, poised between worlds.

Summary: Abi's father remarries after the loss of her mother. Her new stepmother comes with two stepbrothers. They move into a somewhat creepy, maybe haunted older house. Abi likes to get lost in books, but there's something about the house that makes the books more realistic.

My Thoughts: This book reminded me so much of the short story, The Veldt. The story has its scary, eerie moments, but it was also a feel good book about a blended family coming together.

FYI: It has a British flair, which confused me at first. Some of the jargon was foreign to me.

Was this review helpful?

A stunning book weaving the threads of the magic of story and the warmth of home. Captured from the beginning this book drew me in with descriptions of an ivy covered home, images formed before my eyes and I longed to curl up in its rooms. To breathe in the smell of the ivy. To immerse myself in the green magic. To be a part of the family renting space and learning to live together and love each other. The emotions of the main characters were portrayed beautifully as they navigated their blended family and the growing pains of adolescence. Ultimately, the magic of story, of books brought them together. A stunning cover with a story to match, a must read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing for providing me the opportunity to review.

For me, the actual book did not live up to the promise of the cover. Sadly, I think this was one of those books that attempted to do a lot without properly achieving any of it.

I went into The Time of Green Magic expect something lyrical, magical, and nostalgic, but sadly something about it just didn't click for me, and I ended up feeling disappointed. The book felt far less focused on magic and far more on the issues of living with a blended family.

I would have preferred a stronger focus on the plot rather than dipping into and out of all three children's feelings and general issues.

The story felt disjointed, all over the the place, and just downright odd. Not a favorite by a long shot.

Was this review helpful?

A blended family saga with magic for MG. It did move along a little slow for many middle graders, but I think there was enough mystery to keep kids turning pages. The mysterious house was a great bonus as well as adding other family members to find the magic.
Writing a blended family story is always difficult as every family has it's own set of problems, but this was well written and while not a neat tidy up but a more realistic approach.
Keeping you guessing on what is really going on should keep most fans of magical realism intrigued with this book.

Was this review helpful?

The premise of the book is more interesting than the content itself. The magic house is such a great concept but the plot falls flat. It doesn't deliver on the potential of the house. There are some major plot holes. There's not enough character background, especially on the adults of the novel. The author's writing styling is captivating

Was this review helpful?

For me, the actual book did not live up to the promise of the cover. The house itself is fascinating and the way the kids who live in it are able to see books come to life is a dream come true. Yet, there are plot holes big enough for a prehistoric cat to jump through. Why does the boy who can't even read have the prolonged "book" experience? Where did mom get off to and why does her work take her so far away for so long? I did appreciate the family dynamics and the ways the blended family learned to bear with and support one another. The depiction of two teenage boys and their feud was hilarious and heartwarming. It would be such fun to have a big old cat take up residence in my room to keep me warm at night. This book was a bit of a miss for me rather than a hit, unfortunately.

Thank you to Simon & Schuster and NetGalley for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book tackles some hard subjects for a younger audience - death of a parent, parental abandonment, a marriage that includes other children, and having to move to an entirely new house. The interactions between the three children are comical in their truth to reality at times. Hilary McKay has done a superb job at realistic situations and responses from the characters in The Time of Green Magic.

Abi reminds me of well... me at that age to a certain extent. I was ALWAYS so absorbed in my books that mother had to practically come and shake me out of whichever world I was currently in. Louis reminds me of Arliss Coates from Old Yeller, if you have no idea what I'm talking about - you should watch it. I understood Max and what he was going through but he wasn't my favorite character - maybe because of teenage outbursts. The way he is written in the book made him seem younger in my mind than he actually is. He does however have lessons to impart on younger readers. It was heartwarming to see the siblings that were thrust together through marriage grow closer together because of the green magic that had touched them all.

The magic elements of The Time of Green Magic is a wild thing and reminded me of the green decks I've built in Magic The Gathering. In fact, the cover is reminiscent of card illustrations I've seen as well.

The cover is absolutely beautiful, I definitely would have picked it up as a middle-grade reader and this is a title that I will more than likely pick up for my daughter to have when she's old enough to read it. I would highly recommend reading The Time of Green Magic to readers who enjoy fantasy, the middle-grade genre, and wholesome books about family. Many thanks to the publisher, Margaret K. McElderry Books (Simon & Schuster Children's Publishing), and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this entrancing book - all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a sweet, exciting book! As The Time of Green Magic opens, Abi is so caught up in reading the classic Kon Tiki that she can feel the movement and of the ocean, smell the salty air, and see the green parrot hovering over the sails. When Louis calls her, she drops her book and returns to reality. Gathering her things, she realizes the book was drenched in what smells and tastes suspiciously like sea water. And that is just the beginning. Abi and her lovely dad, Theo and Grandma Grace had been getting along just fine after the death of Abi's mom about 10 years ago. Then Theo meets Polly and her two sons Louis and Max. Everything changes quickly, Grandma Grace, happy with the way things have turned out, moves back to Jamaica to open a cafe with her sister. She sends wonderful letters full of pressed flowers and love. Theo and Abi move in with Polly and the boys. Things are just settling down, when they find the landlord is selling the apartment house and they have a month to find a new place to live. Abi finds an intriguing ivy-covered house with plenty of room on a quiet street. Everyone chips in to help with the deposit,,especially Polly who returns to work and ends up on an extended trip helping with disaster relief. Max and Abby, who are close in age, fight like siblings do and young Louis just misses his Mom, until the magic of the house, or the books inside it, starts to act up.
What follows is an enchanting story about children learning to live and love as a family as the green magic runs wild and life becomes exciting, then dangerous. Hilary McKay has crafted an exciting, engaging book with realistic characters honestly written. What starts off as 5 people living in a mysterious house, ends up with a family living in a home. Fans of magic will love this, but fans of any kid of reading will as well. This book reminded me of those by Edward Eager, humorous and exciting with a great story! The Time of Green Magic is perfect for middle schoolers as well as younger, advanced readers. I think this would make an excellent read-a-loud for classes or families of any age. I loved it - and am grateful for the chance to read the ARC. I planning on purchasing several copies for our school library as well as some for gifts.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this book felt like being let into the front of this ivy-covered house, surrounded by this strange but lovable family, and being absorbed by the magic of the pages. That is a more flowery open to a review than I normally do, but the nature of this book somewhat demands it. The plot revolves around a newly formed family moving into the only, slightly run-down, home they can afford, and the period of magical possibility that brings them together more deeply.

How the bonds of family are weaved with the magic is well done. While the way the narrative switched between characters could be somewhat disorienting, I can’t imagine it being any other way. It gave a chance to understand each member of this family and why they might struggle to understand each other. And that made the character moments all the more satisfying. The way magic manifests in this story appeals greatly to my book-loving heart. There was one character who I wish we had gotten a bit more of a chance to know, but to say who and why would be a spoiler. But, if you’re a fan of wild animal companions there is a treat waiting for you here.

That all being said, I feel like this story would be suited to a very particular audience of kids. That may be the British sensibility of it, or the whimsical, character-driven narrative. But, for that audience, I think it would be an impactful read. I enjoyed my time with it thoroughly.

Was this review helpful?

This gorgeously written book was so sweet to read. It was a joy from first page to last. The World building with solid the fantasy was there, and the characters were lovable.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this! Sadly, I don't think of my students would be interested. It has that old time fairy tale feel which I adore but can't get students to read. I will be purchasing this for my home library though.

Was this review helpful?

So much buzz for this one and it kind of flat for me as a reader. I felt like there was too much build-up and not enough straight-up magic focus. It falls under it was an okay story category for me..

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. The cover is fantastic and I think will draw many readers that are attracted to fantasy books. I expected the story to be purely fantastical, but it has a touch of magic instead. The book almost seems divided into two distinct parts: realistic fiction about a blended family learning the give and take of finding their identity and each child finding their place in the family. For most of the story, the mother is off on assignment for work- I thought for too long a stretch according to how the character was developed. The tall skinny house covered with ivy is like a character itself. I do like how the author developed the step siblings relationships and applaud the dad's valiant effort to keep a demanding job and parenting three children all on his own while his wife is half a world away. This part was the strength of the book. The magical- fantasy elements of the book were weak. It took too long to develop and never seemed to gel. The realistic part and fantastical parts never came together in a meaningful way. Many readers described this as an eerie book- I did not pick up on this mood at all. I would say if you have a younger reader that is too scared for some of the more over-the-top spooky fantasy books- this would be a good pick. I think this story is more for elementary readers and younger middle school readers that frighten easily. This story is rather benign and did not stand up to the hype that I had been reading about the book, By the end, I was left wondering more about the source of the magic and how it was brought into the children's lives. I think the author could have spent more time on that aspect of the story. All in all a good story for younger readers with great character interaction and an awesome setting, however the magical elements fell flat.

Was this review helpful?