Member Reviews

On the fifth of July 1948, a baby girl called Aneira is born just after midnight at the Autman Valley Village Hospital in South Wales, and she’s the first baby to be delivered via the new National Health Service. Her mother, Edna May has had her previous six children at home, delivered by the local midwife and she and her husband Willie find it difficult to comprehend the new free system.

Hold on Edna is written by Aneira ‘Nye’ Thomas, the baby who made history, seventy years later in 2018, and she’s interviewed by the media to celebrate the NHS’s special birthday. Her biography is about the generations of her Welsh family, you follow their stories and daily struggles. From the workhouse, some own small farm holdings and her male relatives worked deep underground in the dangerous coal mines.

Over the years, women died in childbirth, from child-bed fever, and the mortality rate of infants was high. People didn’t have a decent quality of life, they put up with aliments because they were poor and they couldn’t afford to see a doctor. Welsh miners didn’t live long lives, they suffered from miners lung and its official name is Pneumoconiosis. They didn’t receive palliative care, dying at home and with no pain relief.

I received a copy of Hold on Edna from NetGalley and Mirror Books in exchange for an honest review, it was interesting reading about Nye’s family, how she was the first baby delivered by the National Health Service and it's a lasting testimony to her relatives. I live in Australia so I have very little knowledge about the NHS, I can certainly see how it changed healthcare in the United Kingdom and it provided a much needed free service to everyone and three and a half stars from me.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

What a lovely book, it makes me so very grateful for the NHS. So heartwarming with a feel-good factor. Engrossing, A definite recommended read.

Was this review helpful?

A thought-provoking insight into the effect health care (and the lack there off) has affected the life of one British family through the past 150 years, as told by the first baby born in the NHS.
At times the correlations between family history and health care felt a bit forced, like 2 books combined into 1, but for those who love history like myself it was an interesting and unique read.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting and well written story it makes you appreciate what we've got today.
It includes lots of research and it keeps you hooked till the end.
a brilliant read and i would highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Wonderful.

The book starts with a birth. Contractions. No long meandering; straight in. It is 1948, and we are in post-war South Wales. Edna is having her 7th baby. So she's done it many times before. She is in hospital, not giving birth at home this time though. Author Aneira, Edna's daughter, is named after Nye Bevan, and was the first child to be born after the start of the NHS.

This isn't just Aneira's story though-it is about all her family. She then goes back to some of her ancestors, eg. her great-great grandmother Tory, who had lived in the workhouse. This is a wonderful piece of history. Interesting facts, family history findings, and from Edna's diaries. The author has also written this from her mother, Edna, telling her tales to her, from conversations. This was fascinating, and so well-researched.

Huddersfield Union Workhouse was mentioned-I am in Huddersfield-and my mum told me where it was, and it was just up the road from where my grandparents lived: to think something like that was so close, and really not that many years ago, the terrible conditions, and hardship.

This was a fantastic book, and there was much more to it than I thought there'd be. Not just about Edna, and Aneira, but about much more-of their ancestors too. I really liked how this was put together. It was not long-winded. Quick, interesting reading, which compels you to press on. Sort of tracing family history mixed with eg. Call the Midwife, and Catherine Cookson type saga-but true in this case.

I loved immersing myself in this era. Hard times, war, what life was like then, having babies at home etc, the midwife calling. Then medical advances, and knowledge about infection control.

Heartbreaking tales, and also some heart-warming stories and lovely memories. The book was simply wonderful.

Was this review helpful?

When I saw the cover for this book it immediately put the Call the Midwife books written by Jennifer Worth and their covers. The cover depicts a woman standing in her doorway wearing her pinny with her children peeping round the doorway whilst leaning on a broom chatting to two other women. One of the women is leant on the wall near the doorway with her arms crossed wearing her pinny. One of which has a baby on her hip with her blanket round them. The cover of the book would certainly have made me pick the book up from a bookshelf, though, not necessarily for reading myself. When I worked at a large well known, bookstore years ago the cover would have initially made me think of this book being within the romance & saga section, which is a genre my mum usually loved. Having said that I have read romance & saga type book before myself. Anyhow when I took a closer look at this book, I saw it was a true story, biography, memoir so that held m interest. As the book was about the NHS it also piqued my interest as to what life could or would be like without the NHS to rely on.

The book begins with the author’s mother in quite late labour and both the Doctor and Nurse attending telling her to “Hold On Edna” which is perfect as the title for this book. The Doctor and Nurse are asking Edna to wait a minute or two so that when she gives birth it is after midnight, which she does manage to do. This means her daughter who she calls Aniera at the suggestion of the Doctor, after the man that brought about the NHS is the first baby born on the NHS as it becomes operational the 5th July 1948. The NHS a new way for women to safely give birth free of charge. In fact, it is revealed within the book that had Edna’s daughter been born before the stroke of midnight she would have had to pay. Which is why so many people avoided hospitals as much as possible! They basically did not earn enough. This book has some heart-breaking and touching tales from the mining communities of South Wales are the story of how our society changed to one no longer gripped by fear of death and disability. Nye puts it best when she says of universal healthcare: “We see it as a basic human right, but it wasn’t always the case. Sadly, we look at todays NHS and the pressure it is under during this corona virus outbreak. Even before this the politicians were slashing the money they give to the NHS and privatising different sections of it. It sometimes feels like we are going backwards and will have the old system of if you don’t have the money to pay for treatment then you will literally do without. The book goes on with Aneira looking back at her past, tracing her ancestors how they lived, what sort of financial status they had and their experiences of giving birth, losing babies as well as accidents and illnesses and how they were dealt with at that time when no NHS was in place.

One of Aneira’s ancestors we learn about is her great-great grandmother Tory whose father died when she was born, meaning her family end up in the workhouse. We join Tory Churchouse’s story when she is just 9yrs old, making her one of the older children at the workhouse. Tory is slight in build, dark haired and quite pale but is much healthier than some in the workhouse. Tory notices when she looks around that everyone in the workhouse looks ill. Whether it’s a limping leg, missing teeth, slurred speech, hunched backs, or arms inexpertly amputated at the elbow and sewed up again. The workhouse is truly gruesome, but it’s made her tough. At night, screams fill the air coming from the infirmary. Tory is used to hearing the hacking coughs and sneezes from her own ward but they are nothing compared to the shouts of pain that come from the workhouse hospital, where the invalids are kept, locked away. Tory’s sister is in the infirmary, and she longs to see her but it is not allowed. Aniera tells the history of her family from Tory right back down to her being born. It is an emotional story, with happy moments of families being together and births and good times. Though there is also the lack of work, working down dark, sometimes unsafe pits where acccidents are a regular occurrence. There are stories of one of her ancestors being a “midwife” or rather as she would have been called in her day a “handy woman”. In fact, there is a slightly amusing tale where the father of the young woman’s baby is not known, yet when Hannah (Aneira’s ancestor) safely delivers the baby it is totally clear that she has just delivered her own grandchild! The book also reveals that families were large and miscarriages and stillbirths were categorised as “one of those things” there were no tests to find out why the baby was lost. There was also no contraception so women tended to have baby after baby despite them living in poverty and not really having the money to feed them. There was no choosing how many children you wanted, it was a case of it happened when it happened. The book is quite matter of fact about the types of lives Aniera’s relatives had, and what hardships they had to live though.

The writing style of the book makes you feel like Aniera is there at the side of you telling the story. The descriptions are so good that it makes it very easy to visualise their surroundings and living conditions. From the oldest ancestor Tory, right the way to the present day Aneira you track how the family have lived and started off very poor and how they could die of by todays standard pretty minor injuries or illnesses as they didn’t have the money to pay for medication or medical help. Then you compare all that to the day the NHS began and Edna gives birth to Aniera. Edna’s first hospital birth, because it was free on the NHS.

My immediate thoughts upon finishing this book were that I had on the whole really enjoyed reading the history of the family of Aneira Thomas who was the first baby to be born on the NHS. The title fits the book so well. As you read about Aneira's ancestors you can visualise them and their surroundings along with hearing their voices too. Interesting from a historical point of view about NHS but also as a biography of Edna the woman who had the first baby born on the NHS.

To sum up, on the whole I found the book interesting, even though it wasn’t what I had initially thought it would be like. I had thought the book would be more about how the NHS was formed and Nye Bevin the person who was responsible for it, however, the book was more about Aneira and her family.

Was this review helpful?

This is the true story of the first NHS baby. We are in South Wales on the night before, when patients still had to pay to be medically treated. Edna was in labour. In fact, Edna's baby was about to be born and it was fast approaching midnight. If Edna would "hold on" formanother minute she wouldn't need to pay and the Midwifes were encouraging her to do this. The story then goes on to tell us about four generations of Nye's family who had battled to survive before the NHS was launched.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It's interesting and informative. It sickens me to think that people could o ly be treated if they had money in their pocket to pay for it. We are lucky to have the NHS.

I would like to thank NetGalley Mirror Books and the author Aneira Thomas for my ARC in exchange for an honest review .

Was this review helpful?

This is a brilliant piece of social history with real life stories woven into it, which makes for an enthralling read. Detailing life for the poorer generation in particular- think the workhouse- and the difference brought about by the introduction of the NHS. The title refers to the birth of the author and the birth of the NHS. Informative and a great read. Thank goodness for our NHS!

Was this review helpful?

A very interesting and well written story that makes you thankful for what we've got today.
It's well researched and it keeps you hooked till the end.
An engrossing read, recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

An excellent tribute to the NHS,
Hold on Edna was the call given so that the birth of a little Welsh girl was paid for by the National Health service.
The launch of the NHS was the most positive move towards a civilised and dignifying advancement in health for all.
Anerira has delved into the past to understand the difference it would have made to her ancestors. Families were in fear of having an infant with a cough or a injured wage earner that meant they could not work meaning no spare pennies or shillings for the Doctors help. . So many new born babies died from diseases and dirty conditions now in the past,.
Most new mothers are now delivered safely , many injuries incurred through everyday living and basic health issues are now dealt with by our excellent services that are free. The support showed and given by the family, many of who have worked in the health service is written with pride and respect by this first NHS baby.

Was this review helpful?

I found this highly interesting and eye opening about how much conditions have improved and how grateful we should be for the NHS. I also had an extra surprise at the beginning as I live locally to wells and godney so was of extra importance knowing details about the past of the local area. It is really well written and I enjoyed it thoroughly.

Was this review helpful?