Member Reviews
Sadly this book just was not for me. This sat on my kindle for quite some time - twice I have attempted to read and twice I did not finish.
Thankyou for the opportunity but I will not be providing feedback on any commercial sites for this book.
First of all a big thank you to Netgalley, the author and the publishers for sending me a copy of this book for me to read and review.
I just could not get into this one. I’m not sure if it was the genre or the writing style but something felt off for me. This was a DNF for me but I could see myself maybe giving it another go and picking it up in the future.
I went into this with an open and curious mind, not high expetations but interest nontheless.
I ended up really enjoying it, the start was somewhat slow but it was interesting and filled with action in the right place.
It was a nice reading.
I like the characters and the plot was quite nice.
Bonus point for the cover and the title.
The first book in this James Maxwell series was a little slow to get going but then it was hard to put down. There hasn't been a series I haven't loved by this author but almost feared this would be the one. I was wrong. So wrong. I now can't wait for the rest of the series to be released so I can continue on with the main characters as they complete their journey.
I really enjoyed this book. The title is a mysterious one and I loved being sent on this journey.
I loved the writing and the characters as well as the dynamics between them. The world is well-developed and I just couldn't stop reading.
*received for free from netgalley for honest review* Took me awhile to get into it but didnt hate it
I received a free digital copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This book is so different from fantasy books that I have read in a long time. It was so good and very adventurous! I hope they write more about these characters in the future.
Thank you kindly to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for this review copy.
I’m still not 100% on whether I enjoyed this or not. The concept was good and I really liked the writing style. However I found the world building a little lacking and I couldn’t really connect to the characters as much as I usually like to. Also I really don’t like books that tell you what’s happening rather than describing the action as it happens. I feel this really takes you out of the story and that’s where you lose me a bit. The ending was quite strong though and so I may continue on pure curiosity. I gave this 2.5 ⭐️ but have rounded up to 3⭐️.
ARC from NetGalley
4.5 stars
I quite enjoyed this one. It's very Mad Max. The world is a bit of a hellscape with 2 suns baking everything to a crisp and only the must hardy creatures and vegetation surviving. Humans are one of several sentient races, and with this, of course, we have interspecies misunderstandings and mistrust which breed fear and conflict.
Taimin must overcome his physical disability in addition to the years of fear and mistrust that have been drilled into his head while growing up in this desolate and unforgiving world. He and his compatriots must overcome adversity and find light in the darkest of places. In order to do that, they will need to work together and rely on each other, a frightening prospect in a world such as this.
This was a good read. It was hard to put it down. Despite the setting being mostly monochromatic and repetitive, I never grew bored of it or felt that it was too dreary. There was never a bit that I had to re-read. I was never confused. I never rolled my eyes. I never hated anyone who didn't deserve to be hated. This book was well-written and well-paced. I like it when a first book ends and I don't feel cheated out of a solid ending but at the same time am given reason to be excited for what's to come. Well done, Mr. Maxwell. I'm eager to see what you bring to the table in the next instalment.
A GIRL FROM NOWHERE is the first installment of a planned trilogy focused on a young man Taimin, who is crippled from an accident in childhood, which makes his dangerous world even more dangerous to survive in. The other main character is a somewhat mysterious girl named Selena, who has a power called "farcasting," which is a cross between astral projection, telepathy, and mind control. They and other companions live on a scorched planet with two suns and very limited resources, and there are a number of other humanoid races for the humans to battle with for those precious resources.
In this first book, we are introduced to the main and secondary characters, as well as the various life forms - both intelligent and animal - all trying to survive by attacking and killing other creatures different than themselves. And most of the planet is much too hot and devastated to support any life, so the habitable area is surrounded by a strange wall of fire to keep inhabitants inside the wall from venturing outside. Taimin and Selena and friends are trying to get to a mythical white city which is supposedly full of water and food, and provides secure protection for all who can make it inside the city's walls.
While the writing is assured, it is written in a way that suggests it is most appropriate for teens and young adults (no sex, swearing, or graphic violence). In an apparent effort to allow the main characters to grow through the series, in this first book, Taimin and Selena seem a little under-developed and bland. Also, while the world-building has promise of surprises and revelations throughout, it suffers from relying too heavily on verbal expositions from the characters, although the book is written in the third person.
This book has enough interesting ideas to warrant following up with the next book in the series, but sophisticated sci-fi/fantasy readers may find the book a little simplistic and the characters a little two-dimensional. A qualified recommendation for younger readers.
Another superb offering from this amazing author. I have been a fan of James Maxwell for some time now and I am very excited that another book series is upon us. Would absolutely recommend this book and cannot wait to read book 2.
"Self-Acceptance is the process of being where we are long enough to appreciate where we have been and where we are headed."- Dr. Christina Hibbert
James Maxwell is a fantasy author and has found inspiration for his books in multiple exotic locations. His fantasy novels have sold over a million copies. His other series include "The Evermen Saga" and "The Shifting Tides."
A Girl from Nowhere tells of a time where the land is barren, and water is rare. Different species along with humans inhabit this land, species such as wyverns, wherries, skalens, etc. The author does a great job of describing a fantasy land. The story follows Taimin and Selena on their search for the White City.
The author creates a fantasy land and has done a great job. As he introduces the reader to new species, he has taken efforts to describe them in detail. It is easy for the reader to associate with the world that the author creates, and this is the highlight of the author's writing style.
The plot is well-paced, and the author keeps the reader engaged. Taimin's life story is touching, and his pain is raw. Most of the readers will be able to relate to Selena's struggle with self -acceptance, and belonging. The crux of the book is about politics dividing people based on their physical characteristics and their way of living. We are not unaware of similar circumstances in the world we live in. The author does utilize real-world problems in the book, and I appreciate the author's style of writing.
It is the first in a trilogy, and I am excited to read the next two books. The author ended the first book on a note that has left me wanting for more. If you like fantasy, the book is for you. I give the book 4/5.
This started out with a lot of promise and fresh ideas that combined sci-fi and fantasy in some fun ways. However, the rest of the book focused on some cheesy relationships and contradictory attitudes that left the characters feeling insincere and dull. I love the world building and the promises left at the ending, but there were so many holes that kept distracting me from the main plot.
The blurb drew me in but I struggled to connect to the story and characters. I found the story itself interesting but the style of writing didn’t work for me. I felt like I was told what was happening rather than shown, and it kept me distanced from connecting with the book. Unfortunately, this book wasn’t for me. I usually enjoy these kinds of books but I couldn’t get past the constant telling situations and it distracted me.
I recieved this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I love fantasy so much and when I saw this cover and read the description I feel excited to beginning a new fantasy series! But then I was very disappointed so, here we go
The positive: It´s a very fast reading and the world is fascinating, all the idea about this books it´s amazing but...
The negative: I was a little boring while I am reading this book, like a said the idea and the world was amazing but the developing was boring, this is my personal opinion!
This book is more telling than showing BUT don´t get me wrong! This is only a warning for people who wants to read a book more showing than telling because for me it´s not a problem, my favorite books are like that (The Hobbit, Dune, IT, etc...)
About the characters I don´t feel very attached to them, maybe Selena was my favorites but I am very sure I forget her in the next months. It was more fantasy than sci-fi but maybe it’ll turn into sci-fi in the later books? And Taimin was very disappointed for me, I understand he feels bad because he is a cripple and all his life her aunt says he es weak and can´t survived alone so she take the responsibility to train him... I sincerely hoped that he could evolve during the story but clearly his condition was an impediment, and I think it is not a good example for any reader who goes through the same.
So... that´s all.
Thank you to the publishers, author and NetGalley for the free copy of this book!
I very much enjoyed reading this! Very well developed world and characters. I liked the building romance without it being the total focus, and the developing friendships and bonds with other characters. I'm hoping to see more Griff in the rest of the series!! I eagerly await what comes next.
I really liked the overall story and that one of the main characters had a physical disability.
What didn't make this a full star read though, was that the author told the story instead of showing more, and how easily some things fell into place.
As it is, it's an enjoyable story that leaves one longing for more in-depth.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for this eARC.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I loved the story building. The firewall was such a neat idea.
The characters were great as well. It really was an awesome adventure and left me wanting more.
I think the way the author “told” me the story rather than describing in more detail, was a bit hard for me. But, other than that, I really enjoyed it.
James Maxwell delivered a good book that kept me intrigued and reading for longer than I should have. The world building is solid, characters and different races are interesting to read about. For me the issue with the writing style wasn't as bad as people made it out to be, it's an easy to read book with good action, nice plot and an ending that leads to a sequel. A sequel I will want to pick up to see what happens next. For anyone that likes a story about an underdog becoming champion set in an interesting world and with a lot of action this is a book to add to your reading list.
*** An ARC was provided by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. ***