Member Reviews

A light, easy read which one could describe as 'very British'. It is, of course, a story and not to be taken as too realistic especially the most unlikely involvement and almost control of the Police officers who themselves were somewhat implausible. I also feel that the other main characters lacked some originality which could have been developed q little more..
However, a pleasant read with humour which will appeal to many.
My thanks to NetGalley and Penguin for this chance to give an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

This book wasn't my usual type of read! It's a lighter hearted mystery, although still has dark insinuations in parts. I chose it because I think Richard Osman is clever and funny and I was right because the book is too. The characters are well observed and the different strands and red herrings keep the pages turning. This was my holiday read for 2020 and took me away from the weirdest year ever, so thanks for the escapism.

Was this review helpful?

Firstly, a disclaimer; I’m a big fan of the author and love his weekly quiz emails which are filled with wit and wisdom.
I wasn’t at all sure for the first part of this book to the point where I wasn’t sure I’d read to the end and then suddenly, the style of story telling went off, I was pulled in and both amused and intrigued. A light hearted, entertaining read with really fabulous characters who definitely deserve their own novels for their backstories!

Was this review helpful?

Received with thanks to NetGalley...

This was an easy ready - fluffy and light with a good dose of humour interweaved amongst characters and plot alike. Though pitched as a thriller, mystery, crime novel; this debut offering from Osman really reads best when taken with a pinch of salt.
Telling the tale of a miscast set of characters who find unlikely cohesion in their love of the intrigue and mystery involved with unsolved crimes. Nothing too sinister happens, there's an embargo it seems on details of anything grisly that the pulpier titles of the genre will rest their laurels on. Osman invests in characters, setting, atmosphere. By the end, not only do you have a comfortable resolution - a true denouement which closes the narrative satisfactorily - but you have enjoyed time spent with the characters in their world. Personally, Joyce's sections were my favourite, offering that touch more insight, reality of voice and depth to the tale. Osman works hard to successfully set these people into a world readers will want to return to. And they will, with his upcoming sequel, with an ease or comfort reminiscent of worlds created by Alexander McCall Smith and his No 1 Ladies Detective Agency series.

To be honest, I was anticipating something of quite a different caliber in tone and plot. Hence only the three stars - but that's based on personal taste, not the skill of the author here.
It cannot be denied that Osman has a mastery on the lighter touch here. Think Jasper Fforde, rather than Jo Nesbo, and it's an enjoyable read in the main.

#TheThursdayMurderClub #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Living in a retirement village isn't usually the way to come to the notice of the local police department or become part of an exclusive club investigating an actual real life killing! This is what happens to Joyce however, as she becomes the newest member of the eponymous Thursday Murder Club.

She joins Elizabeth, Ibrahim and Ron, a small group of residents, whose individual strengths have come together as a force to be reckoned with, especially when it comes to unorthodox ways of gathering information. The local police, having to follow the more accepted means of investigation, have some qualms about joining them when invited but their goals are the same, aren't they?

Richard Osman, the well known presenter of House of Games and Pointless on the BBC, always comes across as a thoroughly nice guy. As an author, his intelligence and imagination have been given free rein and the resulting work is very good. People in his fictional world, it would seem, are, for the most part, decent, but all have skeletons they would far rather stayed hidden. He uses this fact to create believable, empathetic, and well rounded characters which, added to an excellent plotline and understanding of human nature, produces a novel which is both cozy and crafty in equal measure.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book, it flowed and moved along at a good pace. I had no problem working out whodunnit - only to find I was totally wrong! By the end I had one part sorted out but the rest, nope, not even close. That doesn't mean it didn't work, it did, brilliantly, especially for a first novel, and the ending was satisfyingly right, suggesting a distinct possibility of more great books in the future.

I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and the publishers in exchange for an unbiased review and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys cozy crime with a bit of a bite or is a fan of the author. In both cases you won't be disappointed and I hope this will be the first of many Thursday Murder Club books as well as the beginning of another successful part of Mr Osman's future career.

Was this review helpful?

The Thursday Murder club and Richard Osman were a great find for me and I look forward to reading more of his work in future. I have a friend who lives in a similar retirement village which made Coopers Chase, Elizabeth, Joyce, Ron, and Ibraham and the intrigues within the community very believable for me.

I really liked his style and getting to know the characters a bit at a time through them and their friends. The plot included some twists and turns and poignant moments I certainly wasn’t expecting and finally left me pondering the age old contradiction of law versus justice.

All in all I really enjoyed the tale and it would make a good film or TV mystery. I hope that this won’t be a stand alone novel and eagerly await more on Elizabeth’s hush-hush past and her fellow sleuths in future novels.

Was this review helpful?

Joyce (nurse), Ron (a Union man), Ibrahim (psychiatrist) and Elizabeth (who may have been a spy), are residents at Coopers Chase Retirement Village. They meet once a week to discuss cold case murders, but now they have a fresh murder to investigate.

Written with an original style, it was easy to conjure up images of the main characters in this book. I particularly liked Joyce and her diary entries.

The narrative includes some wonderful statements about older members of society, for example, ‘getting out of a garden chair at our age is a military operation. Once you are in one, you can be in it for the day’.

There are many jarring sudden changes of point of view within chapters, and sometimes within paragraphs. This may be a formatting issue on the ARC edition of the novel, but it did impede the reading flow on a number of occasions. The pacing of the story felt slow at first, but by the middle of the novel, I was becoming hooked.

Overall, it was an entertaining, enjoyable fictional tale. I rate it as very good, and therefore 4 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy. This is my unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

TV presenter Richard Osman's debut novel is a charming and delightful cosy mystery composed of interesting characters and infused with wit and a sense of fun.

Elizabeth, Joyce, Ron and Ibriham all live in a swanky up-market retirement village in Kent, with it's own 'contemporary upscale restaurant' and a full range of sporting and recreational activities including numerous clubs and interest groups. The four retirees all belong to the Thursday Murder Club, originally set up by Elizabeth (an ex spy/intelligence officer) and her very good friend Penny (an ex detective inspector) to take a second look at some of Penny's unsolved cases. Now that Penny is lying in the nursing home waiting for the final act in her life, ex-psychiatrist Ibrahim, ex-nurse Joyce and ex-trade union leader Ron (known as 'Red Ron' in his time) all join Elizabeth for two hours every Thursday to continue working through Penny's files. When a real life murder happens at the village the Thursday Murder club set about trying to solve the crime, feeding timely information to a young PC bored with the local petty crime, Donna de Freitas, and her boss DCI Chris Hudson.

Richard Osman has an easy writing style and his characters are all delightful, warts and all, particularly Elizabeth who seems to have had quite a past and possesses a shrewdness that has not been diminished by time. Part of the narration is in the form of a diary kept by Joyce, the newest member of the club, and gives a different perspective on life in the village and what is happening. Donna, who finds herself adopted by the murder club, is delighted to find herself somehow recruited to the investigating team with Elizabeth's assistance. The plot does become quite complex (perhaps more than needed) with a lot of red herrings and revelations, but it was nevertheless good fun and all is all neatly resolved.

Was this review helpful?

I was really looking forward to reading The Thursday Murder Club as I like Richard Osman on TV.

I am sorry to say this book was not for me. I must be honest and say that I did not read to the end as I found it rather slow and totally unrealistic from the characters in the retirement village to the Police that liaise with them regarding the murder..

I found it difficult to follow at times as there were lots of characters and it was often difficult to tell when it switched to someone else speaking.

I am sure I am in the minority and that other people will love it.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Penguin for a copy of this ARC for which I have given my voluntary and unbiased review

Was this review helpful?

I wasn’t sure what to expect but was really looking forward to reading this book.

I found it gripping even though I’m not sure I liked how it was written but I didn’t want to give up with it.

I Loved the setting. It was a classic who dunnit kind of story.
Not realistic at all but fun.

Was this review helpful?

So many twists and turns, I thought I'd solved it then something else happens and I found myself totally hooked. Good strong older characters, who are so likeable I really hope there are more books in this series.
Thank you enthralled.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! It was funny and sad and full of people that I wanted to meet and be friends with and listen to their life stories.
Set in a retirement village, these pensioners are keeping busy investigating cold cases when a murder takes place and they decided to assist the police with their investigations. Not surprisingly their help is not exactly welcomed but each side comes to appreciate the skills of the other and together they get to the bottom of the mystery.
It's a delightful story with interesting characters, a clever if convoluted plot and a satisfying conclusion. I couldn't put it down.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve not read many murder mystery books, not my preferred genre but I was intrigued by the title of this and interested to read something Richard Osman has written, being a big fan of his quiz shows. The Thursday Murder Club is a group of older people who all live in a “retirement village” and meet each week to examine and try to solve cold cases. Then a real-life murder happens ….. The Murder Club members are Elizabeth, Joyce (who could be described as the narrator), Ibrahim and Ron - they are interesting and well-drawn characters, their idiosyncrasies are beautifully observed and I found myself enjoying their company. There’s a gentle humour running through the book and a lovely conversational style. I didn’t guess the identity of the murderer and I changed my mind several times! And I'm a bit concerned about Mr Osman’s extensive criminal knowledge.

It’s a great read, pacey, very funny, moving in parts and very satisfying. I’m glad there will be a Thursday Murder Club 2!

Was this review helpful?

Thoroughly enjoyed this story about a group of pensioners solving cold case murders from records taken from one of their members who served in the police. Whilst solving these murders they stumble across a murder and become involved in solving the case
This was a feel good read which although at times was very disjointed as it suddenly slipped into another point of view (this could be down to me reading an arc) with no break between meaning at times I had to reread bits to get my head around it.
I loved all the characters and their larger than life/slightly unbelievable characteristics.
Highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

This is the Richard Osman of Pointless (and other TV quizzes and Chat shows) so you can expect an off-beat novel! You will not be disappointed - there are plenty of pithy observations, and tangential quips which are off the wall in typical Osman style. His characters, primarily located at a top-end care complex, offer the full spectrum of behaviour and customs. His quirky humour is a constant delight throughout the story,

Murder Club novels seem to be in vogue.  The Thursday Murder Club is a collection of retirees who are looking to occupy their own time but waste police time! Of course, they solve the murders before the police. Part of the fun is the way they inveigle their way into the police investigation. Totally improbable but a delight nevertheless. The murders and investigation make the bones of the story, but we also get Joyce's commentary and insight into the backstory and character of the care home residents.

As the crimes and investigation reveal past digressions and some shady pasts, you get the full range of emotions. In all, a crafty whodunnit which is great fun to read. Definitely a Pointless score of zero (you have to watch Pointless to understand the score!).

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this. It’s not a ‘thriller’ as such, it’s more of a Sunday afternoon ‘whodunnit’ which was enjoyable.

The characters are intriguing and the different perspectives keep you interested.

Read if you like watching Midsomer Murders of an afternoon.

Was this review helpful?

My partner is a big fan of Richard Osman which maybe isn't the best reason to read a book. I felt the author's sense of humour often shone through while I read The Thursday Murder Club but I didn't realise beforehand that I was taking on an ARC well out of my preferred genre; I just don't really get on with cosy, charming mysteries of this type. Errors in the digital print meant that I often struggled figuring out where one chapter and scene ended for another to begin. I did often feel like I was reading something that had been written safely, with the hope of comfortable afternoon telly and older audiences in mind. Which could certainly make a lot of sense.

Was this review helpful?

I was so impressed with this book. Clever plot, gorgeous characters and funny too.
I love a good detective story and was not disappointed by this one. The characters are great, I really felt like I knew them by the end of the book. They may be old, but they’ve still got skills and their brains are still geared up to solve puzzles.
If you like a good old ‘who done it?’ This book is a must read.

Was this review helpful?

A very interesting and well thought out novel. I am happy to say that it kept me guessing the whole way through and I didn’t figure it out.
And while it was dark and upsetting at times it was also humorous.
The only downside for me personally was that it included some slightly upsetting material (suicide) which while thoughtfully done did take me a little by surprise.
It wasn’t necessarily a bad thing but for me it was a little unsettling.
Over all though it was a a good book and I enjoyed reading about the gang and their adventures.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge Richard Osman fan so was keen to see if his clever affability transferred to the page. It does. I think I liked this more because I imagined him writing it, than I would have had I picked it up blind to the author. However, it is a witty, shrewdly observed, contemporary 'cosy' crime that would be enjoyed by anyone who likes the genre. Hooray for Joyce and Elizabeth... here's hoping we hear more from the Thursday Murder Club soon.

Was this review helpful?