Member Reviews

This was a very informative graphic novel. I really love war histories and thought this would be a different way of learning more. The art was great and it was a heavier read due to the amount of information. Although it takes a while to get through it is well worth the read. My favorite was the Battle of Midway story. Another bonus that is included is a written part about each battle. I really appreciated this because if you didn't quite understand everything from the graphic novel you could read more about it at the end.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Jean-Yves Delittle, and Guiseppe Baiguera, for the chance to review the book.

I've read war comics off and on since I was seven or eight years old. While the artwork in the comics in this book was beautiful, two of the three stories were pretty slow and dull, and I found it hard to keep attention on the stories. I did enjoy the historical analyses for the battles addressed in the comics, which was included at the end of the book as a separate feature. I feel like the artwork should compel a higher star rating, but the stories themselves just were not sufficiently compelling. With such significant battle about which to write, I felt that better action should have developed in the comics. The artwork alone is sufficient to warrant purchase of the book, but I would perhaps read the stories one at a time, rather than all at once, as that might reduce the feeling of the stories plodding along.

Was this review helpful?

I was disappointed with this book. I expected a book discussing the three battles and instead got a comic book. The stories were okay, but seemed to lack a lot of detail and explanations for the battles. Not what I expected.

Thank you to #NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Good artwork, great stories. I would buy a hardcopy of this graphic novel. My favorite was Midway.

Was this review helpful?