Member Reviews

Thank you to Netgalley & the publisher for giving me an e-arc of this book!

This book is an anthology of many episodes that we've seen in the Clone Wars show. The only added bonus is that these episodes are related by different character's POVs' like Yoda, Maul, Dooku, Anakin, Obi-Wan and many more. This is an amazing middle-grade book for younger fans but I also highly recommend it to any Star Wars fan.

It's a collection of eleven stories and each one has a different writing style. I think it was refreshing to read from many perspectives. It added so much more depth to these major events that occurred during that era. I don't want to go much further than that because it might be spoilery for those of you who haven't watch the show. Clone Wars have become one of my favorite Tv Show of all time. It has so many amazing Star Wars content & lore. It's filled with all of these amazing characters we've seen in the movies but we get the opportunity to learn even more about them. I cannot stop recommending this series. It's why I love Star Wars. After it ended, I was so sad. I wanted more of my favorite characters and I'm so grateful that I got a copy of these books.

Reading this anthology made me revisit so many episodes in a unique way. However, I wish we had some "deleted scenes". What I mean by that is even if we're visiting these episodes from a distinct character's POV, I wish we had a bonus scene that would've added way more depth to the character. For example, the last POV in this book ends in a bonus scene that we never saw in the show and i really appreciated it.

I hope that Lucasfilm is coming with more content and books about The Clone Wars because it is my favorite. I will read anything from this era. I gave this amazing anthology 4 stars out of 5. I had so much fun!

This book is coming out on August 25 and you can go pre-order your copy on Amazon or Book Depository :)

Was this review helpful?

I’m not sure if this would appeal to non-Star Wars fans, but I definitely think my students who love Star Wars, especially the Clone Wars tv series, will enjoy this book. It’s a collection of short stories which makes it easy to read one story at a time and still feel satisfied without needing to read the whole thing at once. Each story gives insight into a different character, both the good guys and the bad guys.

Was this review helpful?

A nice walk down memory lane or an extended directors cut of the episodes they’re based on. The artwork is lovely. A nice indicator about who the chapter is about before you read it. . I enjoyed the extra insight into the characters and what was just subtext on the show. I’ve seen all the episodes many times even some of the slower ones so the show dialogue was less engaging at times. I loved some stories and liked others Some of the stories weren’t written in a normal he said she said formula and it was interesting. The story was told not just from the character’s POV but in their own words. I could have kept reading more stories like some from season 6 or 7. The new nightsister story advertised or the story by Filoni’s own wife Anne wasn’t in the review copy I read. Perhaps they’re one and the same. It’s understandable since it’s an unfinished version and the story/stories might not be ready. I look forward to getting my own finished copy in August. I know a diehard fan in his late 30s isn’t the main demographic the book is made for. Maybe I’ll read it to my baby daughter when she’s older. I’m gonna raise her on Star Wars cartoons.

Was this review helpful?

The Clone Wars: Stories of Light and Dark is written by Lou Anders, Tom Angleberger, Preeti Chhibber, Zoraida Córdova, Jason Fry, Yoon Ha Lee, Rebecca Roanhorse, Anne Ursu and Greg Van Eekhout. The short stories retell Clone Wars episodes from perspectives rarely seen in the expanded universe — Yoda narrates the first episode, and Dooku shares his snarky view on the events of “Dooku Captured.”
More emotional stories are related by Anakin and Padmé, who filter episodes through their mutual love and relationship anxiety, heightened by readers’ full knowledge of where the story is going. As Padmé in particular balances her friendships and her lack of confidence in herself in “Pursuit of Peace,” she echoes the deep character of the novels rather than the weak damsel of the films. In fact, her story echoes Queen’s Peril as it explores how her public persona has transformed from the stoic queen to the senator expected to move others with her carefully channeled passion. Meanwhile, fan-favorite Ahsoka’s story is told more through one of her young admirers she aids in building a lightsaber. (Her lack of a story of her own is a surprising omission but one that works thematically with her outsider status and final exile.) Asajj Ventress, meanwhile, intrigues readers with her nuanced personality, filled with rage at her mistreatment and a surprising empathy for another young victim. This story truly benefits from the extra insights of prose. Likewise, in Rex’s tale, he spends quite a long time struggling with the ethics of obeying a bad commander and thus particularly benefits from the new format.
Of course, the nastiest, most selfish characters can be the most fun. Hondo gets a chance to snark as he explains, “Now, if you ask Moralo Eval, he’ll probably tell you something different. I wouldn’t be surprised if that ugly old wheeze bag tried to blame it all on me. I’ll tell you what really happened: the true story of the biggest crime ever attempted this side of Kessel.” Still, the most delightful voice belongs to maddened Darth Maul as he describes his resurrection and overwhelming hatred for Obi-Wan in a story brimming with personality. As it begins, “Tell me, child, do you know who I am? Do they whisper my name in the classrooms of your academy, down the winding halls of your space station, in the hollows and fields of your farming planet, or across the dunes of your desert home?” Maul continues through his angry reminiscences of tangling with Obi-Wan, focus of his total obsession. This is followed by Obi-Wan’s own epic adventure trying to save his lost love, but it can’t match up to his spitting, hissing nemesis. It’s a fun return to the best, most impactful episodes for prexisting fans or an introduction for new ones now that it’s all on Disney plus. There’s little new information in this Clone Wars celebration, but plenty of fun. https://medium.com/pop-off/star-wars-novels-summer-2020-aedae4eb9d6d?source=friends_link&sk=da882f663da349a799cbed4d8c43cd83

Was this review helpful?

The Clone Wars: Stores of Light and Dark does an amazing job of retelling Clone Wars stories, with the written format allowing authors to go more in-depth with how characters feel and what they are thinking. As an avid fan of the Clone Wars show, I was apprehensive to whether the stories in the book would simply reword what had already been in the show. I'm glad to say that is not the case at all, with each individual author adding insightful thoughts and character moments all around. Some stories in Light and Dark have completely changed my opinion on the arc within the show itself, and with some arcs I'll never look at them the same. I would highly recommend fans of The Clone Wars to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is a great YA book, in a similar vein to From a Certain Point of View, but taking key episodes of The Clone Wars and re-writing then from a different first person.
There are a couple of little nods to the OT “I’m here to rescue you!” (as one example) and the episodes selected were all fairly iconic in the series.
The great thing about this is that you don’t have to have watched TCW to enjoy this. Each shirt story stands its own ground.
Without going into any spoilers, the short stories give great insight into the thoughts emotions and mindsets of the characters, adding richness to some of the episodes (if you recognise them) and depth to the prequel trilogy if you haven’t watched TCW.

Overall, a really solid read

Was this review helpful?

Informative. I think this is a fun kick it up if it interests you kind of book. Not one I would have for my personal library hit maybe to pick up at a public library.

Was this review helpful?

Both middle-grade readers and fans of The Clone Wars TV series would enjoy this anthology -- and I might even say that Star Wars fans who aren't big fans of The Clone Wars should give this anthology a shot.

This anthology surprised me! I have a mixed relationship to The Clone Wars TV series, alternatively enjoying it and being frustrated with it depending on the episode. When I found out that Stories of Light and Dark was going to be an anthology adapting episodes from the series, I was a little concerned. Straight adaptations of TV/movies generally aren't my favorite. I ended up being pleasantly surprised!

The great thing about this anthology is that it features a number of voices and a number of different approaches to telling these stories. I especially appreciate seeing new voices write Star Wars, and a short story anthology is a great way to showcase these authors in the Star Wars universe,. I love getting new voices in Star Wars writing.

I particularly want to give shout-outs to the stories written by Preeti Chhibber and Anne Ursu, because they adapted two of my least favorite episodes from The Clone Wars and turned them into two of my favorite stories in the whole anthology! Chhibber used an excellent third person perspective to turn an episode that frustrated me into an excellent character study. Ursu handled a political episode that I found confusing and frustrating (and I like space politics!) and delivered an examination of public service, the cost of war, and the importance of keeping in people in mind -- and I deeply appreciated it.

I have a lot more to say about these stories -- both the work of Star Wars veterans Angleburger, Cordova, Fry, and Roanhorse as well as newer SW voices Anders, Durst, Lee, Eekhout, and Convery (whose story was not in the e-galley I reviewed), but I am keeping this initial review spoiler-free.

I will update this review with a link to a fuller discussion about the book that will be posted when the anthology is published in August, for spoiler reasons.

Was this review helpful?

I have a new book review to share with you today. Please note: I received a digital ARC of this book (via NetGalley) from its publisher in exchange for an honest and fair review.

Star Wars The Clone Wars: Stories of Light and is an anthology of eleven stories of some of the most eruptive events from the Clone Wars animated series. The stories are written by some of today's most popular authors including Lou Anders, Tom Angleberger, Preeti Chhibber, Zoraida Cordova, Jason Fry, Rebecca Roanhorse, Anne Ursu, Sarah Beth Durst, Yoon Ha Lee, Greg van Eekhout, E. and Anne Convery! This is categorized as a middle grade reader, but it is a must read for any Star Wars fan! I truly enjoyed this collection.

I was originally interested in this anthology because I love all things Star Wars and for Zoraida Cordova and Rebecca Roanhorse' stories, so it is no surprise that those two were my favorites in the book. If I had to pick one, my favorite story is The Lost Night Sister by Zoraida Cordova. Ventress and the Night Sisters are so complex and interesting, they really deserve their own novel! But there were other gems that I really enjoyed like Hostage Crisis by Preeti Chhibber. This little tale includes Anakin, Padme, and the bounty hunter you love to hate...Bane. Honestly there isn't a bad story in the bunch. I thought each was well written and provided more in depth perspectives from a variety of characters that were prominent during the Clone Wars, like Ashoka Tano, Captain Rex, Yoda, Bane, Maul, and more! The different writing styles made each story feel fresh. Now that the Clone Wars animated series has ended this is a great way to revisit some of the major events that took place during that era.

This gem published by Disney Lucas Film Press is set to release on August 25, 2020, and is available for pre-order from all major booksellers. I give Star Wars The Clone Wars: Stories of Light and Dark 5 out of 5 gems. I enjoyed this collection and hope to read more stories like this in the future. Happy Reading!

Was this review helpful?

The ideal anthology for young (and older) readers. I loved how each author took on this fictional universe with a unique approach. Both Rebecca Roanhorse and Yoon Ha Lee are favorites, but there are many other voices here to enjoy, as well.

Was this review helpful?

This was an awesome testament to the love that all of these well established middle grade authors have for Star Wars.

I didn't really understand any of it.

There are a lot of Star Wars books out there, some by the authors included in this anthology of what is essentially very, very good fan fiction. I can't comment on how the stories fit in with the Star Wars canon, but I'm sure my students who love the franchise will be more than happy to tell me in great detail. Some of the books (especially the series by the Davids and by Jude Watson) are easy enough for people unfamiliar with the movies to understand, but this had so many details and characters that I was lost.

This means that it is perfect for readers who DO know the characters, but for me, it was sort of like reading the Silmarillion. I understood each word, but struggled with following exactly what was going on.


Will I buy a copy? Yes. Will it circulate well? Indeed. Was it my cup of soup that Baby Yoda drinks?

Clearly, I am culturally illiterate when it comes to this fandom.

Was this review helpful?