Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this book. I loved the time travel and the historical aspects. I mostly loved all the things that tied the people from the past to Maddy's present.
I think this book touched on some difficult topics (such as an absent father and a premature birth), and I know this is a book I would have absolutely loved as a child.

Was this review helpful?

✨Book Review✨
The Girl from the Attic is a very sweet coming of age novel for middle graders. Marie Prins weaves together the past and present with startling similarities, especially for young Maddy.
.
When Maddy is forced to move into an old, octagonal, century home 100 kilometers away from her friends and grandfather, she is miserable. She feels like her stepfather hates her, and her mom doesn't have time for her anymore, now that she's pregnant with Maddy's little sister. And so, Maddy takes refuge in a loft above the old woodshed. You can imagine her surprise when an old magical door is revealed that transports her into what was once the attic of that old house, but 100 years in the past. She travels back and forth to help her new friend, and to escape her own troubles.
.
I loved this book. It's such a sweet story, and Maddy's character feels very authentic. She's a little misguided at times, but what 11-year-old girl isn't? It's set in 2001, which is around the time I was her age, so I really enjoyed the old references to dial up internet and flip phones.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fast read and interesting between books. The story was interesting and well written. Something I would recommend for children and adults alike if you want something a little different.

Was this review helpful?

This book is unusual and compelling, and will appeal to readers of all ages! I enjoyed it very much indeed. I like the time hop element of it, and Mandy is a delightful character. The ending is extremely satisfying and stitches past and present together perfectly. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick but enjoyable read reminding me of books I read in my childhood. It had a time travel element that added to the interest and I found myself caught up in the story. I would definitely purchase this for my library. Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the early look at this book.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, and think it will be a hit with MG readers. The main character, Maddy, has a coming-of-age experience that I think readers in this age group could really relate to. She has a new stepfather, whom she feels does not like her, and his decision to relocate her and her mother to the country adds to her unhappiness. The mysterious attic doorway transports her to an earlier era, and serves as a way for her to escape her own life and problems. Through her interactions with the home’s past residents, she gains a new perspective on her own life, and learns to be grateful for what she has. The book not only had a great lesson, but it also maintained suspense (When would Maddie be able to return to the past? Would Eva surprise? Why does her neighbor seem to know so much about her?) that kept me hooked until the end!

Was this review helpful?

I thought that this book was well written. It had a strong moral message. The girl in the story skipped time by use a door in the house. A tad farfetched at times and I am not sure that it was totally believable. The main character had attitude and was not always very likeable. A good ending however, definitely interested to read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

"Amy was right. Eggs and promises were meant to be broken."
First of all, I want to send my grateful thanks to @netgalley, Common Deer Press and the great author, Marie Prins.
This book is just great and it was really for me 😊. I was really interesting to read it. I took me longer time than I thought but it was as great as I wanted it to be. This book is about a young girl who moved with her family of her mother and her stepfather from the city to live in the countryside of Colebrook town. She was upset about this uprupt change in her life and honestly, she did not like her stepfather so much. One-day, she went to discover around the new house and she had found a small to the past and she would have a great journey between the past and the present during which she will learn about the past and about the present, her present, too.
I want to think the writer for the great accuracy when she was describing the life in the Canadian countryside during the late 1800s and the early 1900s. The way she described the clothes, the buildings, the customs, the family life and everything. I do recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Girl From the Attic is a really adorable children fantasy. As I like reading middle grade books, the plot and the cover made me pick this one to read. It was an interesting, twisting and cute novel. I loved reading every page of it and the drawings made it even more special.
I believe this book can give so much to children and adults as well through just opening a mysterious door. A story about a young girl, who finds new friends in a different time and learns so many things on her journey.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and the Publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book.

The cover of the book has a mystic element to it, like something waiting down the corner, and picks an interest in the reader. The book has the layout of the house which is helpful to understand and imagine the events clearly.

The flow of the book is well paced in that there is no moment of dragging or repeating things over. We are introduced to Maddy and things happening in her life, entry of Dan in her life, change in her Mother's wellness, followed by change of place, and then to the mystery around the new house. Time travel and adolescence form the theme. How the adventures end up, whether they went as she planned them, or what were the surprise elements that makes Maddy accept changes in her life and adjust to them, forms the rest of the story.

The book ended up being too honest about the issues, and though it was acceptable in a way, I really felt pity for the girl as she was trying to be as helpful as possible, but sad, was constantly blamed for the mess-ups, while her efforts went unnoticed. Poppa George, Aunt Ella were the only ones who seemed understanding, even Clare came across as too grumpy to me. It felt like she was missed only during the chores, there was hardly any lovable exchanges between the mom and the daughter.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very interesting story. I allowed my13 year old daughter to read it as well and she said “it’s a very interesting book. It has good plot twists. The story was fascinating and was a quick read”
It was a very interesting look at time travel.

Thank you for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Girl in the Attic is a charming tale, but I think it probably should have been a short story.

There's a decent narrative here, and Octagon House is a wonderful setting. I have a clear image of the house in my mind.

The illustrations at the beginning of the book were very neat additions, and I spent some time poring over these. In fact, the illustrations throughout the text were lovely, and really added to the charm.

On the other hand, this story takes a while to get going and it feels like there's a bit too much padding throughout. I wasn't hugely invested until Maddy met Clare.

However, the ending was tied up nicely and left me feeling satisfied.

I liked The Girl in the Attic - it's definitely unique - but I cannot help thinking that it would have benefitted by being written a short story.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

I really loved this book. Maddy moves to the country and is most displease until she meets a cat that guides her to a time traveling portal. This book I think will be a good one for kids because it deals with certain issues in a very honest way.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very well written middle grade story. It had a little bit of everything, family dynamics, grief and also time travel. I found that the book really dealt with issues that arise in blended families and provided a great resolution to them. Thoroughly enjoyed this

Was this review helpful?

I was given a free advance copy in exchange for my honest review.

This is a sweet, nicely written book that will appeal to middle schoolers.

Maddy's family moves to the country. Maddy, age 11, is unhappy with the move to a strange, old house far from the city.

Then with the help of a magical cat , Maddy discovers a doorway into the past. Her adventures teach her about love and family.

Although it wasn't for me, I think young readers will enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a lovely middle grade book about a girl who discovers a portal in the attic of her new home, that takes her to that same home in the past. She takes a few trips there and learns about the importance of family and work. One of the fun devices is that a black cat signals to her when she can use the portal. The book is not witchy at all, but I love the nod to a familiar bringing the magic to this otherwise realistic situation. I recommend for girls ages 8-12.

Was this review helpful?