Member Reviews

The main character Neve Connolly has many roles with her family and friends. She also has many traits that make her both a memorable and flawed person. She draws everyone around her into her world which becomes dangerous for them as well as herself. Now the consequences of her choices leave her no opportunity to tell the truth. So how far will she go to protect those she loves.

Was this review helpful?

A woman, Neve, is having an affair with her boss, Saul. When she goes to meet him for a tryst one morning, she is stunned to find him dead in the flat where they would meet. She then decides to clean up the murder scene to wipe away any trace of their affair. However, when she discovers that she left something in the flat, and goes to retrieve it, she makes a terrifying discovery. Now she knows that someone knows about the affair and she doesn’t know what to do.
Neve tried to balance her family, her co-workers, and the detectives as she tries to find the truth about Saul’s murder. Unlikely relationships and secrets come out, and Neve is troubled more and more.
I liked the tension in this book, but I was not convinced of Neve’s ability to be so methodical and to find out the murderer. I found this to be unreal, which prevented me from liking this book more.
#TheLyingRoom #NicciFrench #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. Neve, a married mother of 3 finds a man she was having an affair with dead. Unsure what to do she cleans up the murder scene of her presence to avoid the scandal of having had an affair. In her mind she is protecting her oldest daughter, who has had some problems and her own marriage. The book continues with her every day life at home and at work. There are some twists in the plot.

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to get this one when it was offered as the Scene of the Crime book club Friday pick. Unfortunately, I wasn't keen on it at all. In fact, I wanted to DNF it about a quarter of the way through, but ended up speed reading to get to the end to see if there was anything of note I could salvage.

The Lying Room started out great--Married mother Neve Connolly pays a visit to her secret lover and finds him murdered. This should be the set up for a thrilling whodunit. But it just meanders for far too long. There are so many unnecessary details and descriptions that don't move the story forward and it's populated by the most unlikable cast I've ever met in literature. I couldn't connect at all to Neve, her husband is a drip that goes from a just-leave-me-in-a-hole-to-die persona to a sure-let's-invite-all-your-friends-to-dinner! one. Neve's sons are virtually background noise and Mabel is just...awful and so much so that I didn't even care to find out if there was backstory why. With all the detail given, I'd be expecting some insight to all these characters, but nothing was satisfying. Even the ending and the reveal of the 'bad guy' was a let down. It all left me with a very "who cares about any of this" feeling.

I do hate leaving reviews of this nature, but this wasn't the book for me at all. This couple has quite a number of books out that seem to be quite popular, so I seem to be in the minority, but it is what it is.

Thank you to William Morrow through the Scene of the Crime book club and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?