Member Reviews

Yellow Jessamine is set in a dying city in a shadow filled world. It is an incredibly engaging read. This book definitely veered closer to horror than I typically like, but, I really enjoyed reading this book. The primary protagonist, Evelyn, is portrayed exceedingly well. Her mounting fear through the book is visceral. The world building is very interesting and made me want to know more about what’s around Delphinium.

Potential ***spoiler*** ahead, in which I discuss my overall feelings on the ending. I think it’s great to have any and all LGBTQ+ representation in books. That being said, I wish there were more happy endings. I would not say this ending is an outright sad ending, in fact it felt a tiny bit hopeful.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Yellow Jessamine was a very creative and fast read that follows a disease with mysterious origins.

If I were to try to explain the ending of this book, I don't think I could do it. It gets very crazy and very confusing, but if I had to explain hopefully I could still outline the main points.

There were two things that made this book such a standout. First is the characters, and I was very pleased to see how developed and interesting they were even in just a span of one hundred pages. I loved Evelyn's character of being a really cutthroat and demanding person but then has to make big sacrifices which completely conflicts what she stands for. Second is the atmosphere, there is a lot of eeriness and the Pirates of the Caribbean vibe, and an old and deadly plague really does so much for this book. I don't see any way how the disease scenario would function well in any different setting.

With that being said, I found the ending a little bit hard to follow. I would've also liked to see the atmosphere being used to its fullest abilities and sometimes I found myself disinterested in reading it even when it was so short of a book.

An author with a lot of creative potential with the settings and characters that were introduced, but the story itself didn't do a lot for me.

Was this review helpful?

An intense short gothic read. I loved sooo many aspects of this book - the ambience, the writing, the botanical terms. This book moved smoothly and although I was a tad confused in the beginning, by the end all the loose threads tied nicely. I was floored by each little twist and turn and I felt the deep despair and desolation of Evelyn. Her obsession with plants, poisons, and her garden were harrowing. Absolutely loved this novella!


*thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for sending an arc copy in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Neon Hemlock for the ARC of this book.

3.5 stars. This novella was a step outside my comfort zone, since I don't usually read horror, but I'm glad I read it, as it was an interesting read. It started out a bit slow, with some of the descriptions hard to understand. It's hard to keep track of the relationships between the characters at first, and I kept having to reread passages to solidify my understanding. The second half of the novella, in my opinion, is where the story comes to life and seizes you like a vine from a bewitched garden. It gets weird and macabre and fast paced -- good luck putting it down after you've reached the 50 percent mark!

Our protagonist, Evelyn, is strong, ruthless, grieving, conflicted, and morally grey. I love that Caitlin Starling was able to solidify Evelyn's complexity in such a short story. Though I found this book under the "LGBT" category, I don't think that the LGBT themes are obvious enough for it to be marketed as such. I would have loved a few pages exploring the twisted f/f love story more in depth, as I think there was a lot of potential for that.

Overall, this was a good read and I'd recommend it to anyone who wants a unique, creepy story to read during a thunderstorm!

Was this review helpful?

it was all that it promised: creepy, pungent and beautifully described. definitely a good one for thriller/horror fans, but not as much for people expecting an actual lgbt couple

Was this review helpful?

I don't read a lot of horror, but I was really intrigued by the entire premise of this book. If I was more a horror reader, this book may have delivered in a way that it didn't for me. Even within the first few pages I could tell that I was going to have a hard time getting into this short book. I didn't feel invested in the plot, which by itself isn't a deal breaker for me, but I also wasn't interested in the characters. I am a very character first reader. If I love your characters the plot can be a truly crazy ride and I will continue to read. However, if I'm not in love with the characters and I can't be bothered with the plot it leaves very little for me to truly enjoy.

That being said, the world building and the atmosphere was great. I really enjoyed the overall feel of a depressing and rotting overcast that comes with a collapsing empire. The world also felt much larger despite literally only a sliver being used to tell this story. I would read another book set in this world, but this one just didn't work for me. However, at the moment, my opinion is an unpopular one. Basically, that means you should check it out if it sounds interesting because plenty of others enjoyed it.

Thank you to NetGalley and Neon Hemlock Press for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for a review. However, all thoughts and opinions on this piece are my own. Full review to be released closer to publication date.

Was this review helpful?

A creepy and unsettling meditation on guilt. The gruesome and otherworldly happenings are portrayed in evocative but trim prose. I would recommend it for readers who enjoyed "We Have Always Lived in the Castle" and are looking for something a little more supernatural.

I have seen this book tagged "LGBT" on Goodreads and beg to disagree. A few sentences late in the book don't really justify that tag, and it would have been a much different read if the author had written the story with that decision in mind.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in an exchange for a fair and honest review.

4 out of 5 stars! Content warnings for minor body horror, drug use, and arguable death

I had devoured the Luminous Dead in one night, driven to turn the next page, and the one after that. Unfortunately, Yellow Jessamine does not quite live up to her predecessor, though that might be because LD had more space and pages to expand on the slow creeping horror in the way YJ does not.
The horror is certainly slightly paranoia-inducing (who else? what happens? what is it?), though due to the short length, it's forced to move quickly.

Still, a good afternoon read! Highly recommended to do so surrounded by greenery.

Was this review helpful?

A macabre and poisonous tale of a woman at heart of a mysterious plague which has taken over a decaying city. I loved how focused and well crafted this story which ultimately focused on guilt and how it can eat away at you. I can't not mention the stunning cover and the darkly beautiful chapter heading art. Thank you very much to publisher Neon Hemlock for giving me this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a good surprise! Honestly, I wasn’t sure I was going to like it, and I did almost DNF it early into it. But about 5 chapters in, the story started to pick up and it was really entrancing. I ended up finishing it in one night, and really really enjoying it. My only issue was that it was marked as LGBTQ+, and I genuinely forgot it was until the very end, because of how irrelevant it was. I wanted a wlw horror story damn it! But this was still a genuinely good book. The characters are sympathetic and flawed, and very real feeling. If you like subtle horror like Edgar Allen Poe or We Have Always Lived In The Castle, you’ll definitely enjoy this!

Was this review helpful?

<i>Nobody mistook her for a delicate, damaged flower, but few doubted that such horrid grief could leave a woman untouched. Her veil was armor. Her veil was indispensable.</i>

This is <i>wonderful</i>; creeping, unsettling, very lush horror, very brilliantly done. The story of a rich, grief-ridden shipping magnate, and how her world starts to crumble when a strange plague comes to her already dying city.

Really beautiful, atmospheric prose can make or break a novel like this one, one that relies so heavily on words to build up the specific kind of setting that the story needs. And Starling's writing <i>made</i> this novel; it really was lovely to read, even while being creepy in a lot of ways. It's horror, but it straddles a nice line in that it doesn't seek to be outright scary (which some books try and fail at) but it is quite unsettling and extremely <i>human</i> somehow. I adore reading about complicated women, selfish and somewhat amoral women, women who are perhaps unwisely loyal to one another, and I got varying doses of all of that, and it was so satisfying. I loved Evelyn's character, and all those slow reveals that let us know about her past. Also all of the imagery that this book evokes is so so good, so so vivid.

Some nitpicks:
- I always feel weird saying 'I wish this were longer' about a novella because, I mean, the author chose to write a novella because they thought that's what would work best for the story! But I really do feel like with some more detail and depth would have only benefited the story and plot here. There are some side characters especially that I think we could have spent more time with, and some of the reveals were dropped so very quickly, in an abrupt way that didn't 100% work for me. And also just... the writing was really good! I wanted more of it!
- Relatedly, I do wish we'd gotten some more moments between Evelyn and Violetta, some more backstory to their time working together, maybe a couple flashbacks. It would have made the events in the latter half of the story even more impactful and striking and emotionally dense.
- I'm very glad that there was no huge info-dumping to give us the information on this city and its history and politics but also... I remain pretty confused about what exactly was going on lol. This could just be me; I just don't have a head for politics in books, especially fantasy politics. But I would have appreciated a little more explanation/clarity.

Very minor complaints though. This was thoroughly enjoyable. A departure from my normal reads, but I'm very very glad I made the detour. Wonderful writing and a great, unique story. 4.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Succinct, fluid, and masterfully articulated - this was everything I wanted in a novella. This was like investing in a Broadway play - it takes two hours of your time and you are transported to a beautiful, vibrant world with perfectly precisioned stage setup and none of the superfluous filler of larger novels. There is no room for fluff, every scene had a carefully crafted purpose and Starling does a beautiful job attaining this alongside the characterization of the mysterious Evelyn Perdanu, who might be one of my favorite female protagonists of 2020.

This is a very gothic, very Victorian, very plague-infested horror bonanza. Which checks nearly all my boxes for what I want to read on a dark, stormy night. Character driven readers, I implore you to try this out simply for the atmospheric tone, the mystifying characters, and the guaranteed chills. There are no tropes to be found here, so enjoy a wholly unique, terrifying tale.

Please dear author, expand on this universe in another book. The horror genre needs you.

Thank you to netgalley for providing a digital copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Luminous Dead and frequently recommend it to anyone looking for a claustrophobic nightmare. So when I saw Yellow Jessamine available, I was thrilled to be approved (bonus points that it came highly recommended by Laurel Hightower).

Evelyn Perdanu is the sole female shipping magnate left in Delphinium. When her ship returns and a mysterious ailment starts plaguing some of her crew, Evelyn is terrified this could be the end of her. As one strange coincidence overlaps with another, it becomes impossible to ignore the implications, and Evelyn must confront her personal demons before it's too late.

What a fun, quiet, yet powerful period horror piece. Without the pomp and circumstance, I found myself comparing this to Shakespeare multiple times: the ambition of Lady Macbeth, the tragedy of Juliet awaking to find Romeo beside her. Starling once again proves she's an expert at character development. Evelyn is grim, troubled, and delightfully cutthroat. In spite of a plague and a nameless, inexplicable horror, this is a character-driven novel, and Evelyn steals the show. From her complex emotions about her childhood and Violetta to her rationale in handling dire straits, she's a force to be reckoned with. I could've read an entire book of her internalized dialogue about potions and poisons and their various uses. Perhaps it's that I've killed every plant I've tried to grow myself, but Evelyn's command of her garden is remarkable, and there's something inherently terrifying about a woman sowing her own poisonous seeds on the cusp of a dying town.

Overall, Yellow Jessamine is a quick, gripping tale with plenty of scares and heartbreak. Big thanks to Neon Hemlock Press and NetGalley for providing an eARC in exchange for honest review consideration.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Neon Hemlock Press & Netgalley for providing me with an arc for review.

I wanted to love this more than I do. [book:The Luminous Dead|36117102] was a 3 star read as well but it left me with such an unsettling feeling for weeks after. I love what Caitlin Starling has brought to the table with her books. She has the ability to create some truly horrific women that I can't help but want to succeed.

We are dealing with a novella here so I won't give too many details but I hoped for something else with the ending. It almost felt a little lackluster to me. I really liked seeing Starling's take on a gothic premise and am still looking forward to her upcoming releases.

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank NetGalley, the publisher, and author Caitlin Starling for providing me with an ARC of Yellow Jessamine!

This was just an okay read for me. I felt like a lot of world building was lost due to it being a novella. It was creepy and mysterious, but there could have been so much more. Also, falling under the LGBT category doesn’t seem like the correct classification for this. There was the slightest touch on F/F love, but I don’t think enough for it to be classified as such. It was a good read, but I just wanted more.

Thank you again to those named above for the chance to read and review this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I'm really loving Caitlin Starling's visions of horror so when this got announced it was immediately on my most anticipated list.

I went into this book expecting the typical plague styled horror. People dying, the threat of infection. As well as uncertainty of what kind of story it'd fully be as it's around only 130 pages total.

30 pages in and I got so excited to see it was something much more. With particular scenes catching so much of my interest. Even with my longing for it to be much longer. Evelyn's grief and panics stirred memories of my own, which made this small novel a bit of a undertaking for me.

This said, I do with we could have seen a bit more with the soldier's end. He seemed like an after thought till the last 20 pages or so. He was my only gripe.

Yet, in my opinion, Starling managed to create a garden that catches attention and showed how the blame we place upon ourselves sometimes never leaves, but grows like weed among the flowers.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Yellow Jessamine is the story of a woman named Evelyn who must navigate the depths of her lifelong guilt and grief while attempting to unravel the mysterious affliction that comes over members of her city, Delphinium. Evelyn must not only hide from the Judiciary that the "illness" somehow originated from the crew of her own trade ship, but her mounting pile of secrets and treacheries that only grows as the novel progresses.

I started out really liking this book, but there were a number of things that really bothered me about it in the end.

First, it was listed in the LGBTQ+ category, which I would not file it under. If I had not been told this was an LGBTQ+ novel, I would never have known that was the way it should have been read (and I still don’t really see it, even after being told).

Secondly, I felt there was both so much filler, and so much left unexplained. We, as readers, are dropped into a mysterious world where a rival government seeks to take hold of the city of Delphinium, but we are given very few details other than that about the conflict. I still am not sure who the Judiciary serves, and was confused about a number of the characters’ relationships to each other/the governments.

I also found Evelyn’s character to be be very conflicting, as she seems torn between calling herself cowardly or brave, wicked or a product of unfortunate circumstance. Maybe this was meant to showcase her inner turmoil, but it did not come across that way in my opinion. We also find out about some of Evelyn’s actions that serve as plot twists later on, but not in a good way. It felt like these elements were tossed in to tie the story together at the end rather than being woven throughout and alluded to along the way.

On the positive side, I found the general plot line interesting, though it was lacking in resolution. I was drawn in by the mysterious affliction that begins to come over the townspeople, and its connection to Evelyn. However, we don’t exactly get answers (or at least not satisfying ones) about what it is, which I found to be a bit of a letdown.

Toward the beginning, this almost reminded me of The Haunting of Hill House, but with more strangeness in place of horror. The book begins with the line “To those harboring the weight of self-blame: may you bury it.” I am assuming readers were supposed to focus on the message of how grief and guilt take hold and can be let go, rather than the literal plot, but if that was the case, the end message was a little startling.

Overall I would give this 2.5 stars (rounded up to to 3) for the promising idea and intrigue, but the execution left me disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

I will freely admit that this book ensnared me with that beautiful, creepy cover and the promise of a plot centred around a mysterious plague!

Due to this story being a novella, certain aspects of the plot and world were left open or without a huge deal of explanation, and for that reason, I did struggle to get as invested as I'd have liked. Likewise, beyond some shocking, satisfying revelations regarding Evelyn's backstory, I didn't get too great a grip on the characters. Overall, however, I enjoyed the close relationship between Evelyn and Violetta and the unique way it resolved, and found Yellow Jessamine to be a spooky, clever read with the odd twist I didn't see coming and one or two 'oh, dang!' moments.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, NetGalley for providing an ARC of this book, in exchange for my honest review!

"Something had come back on her ship, looking for her. And it was spreading."

It was such a good read! The writing was great, immersive, attached to a gothic, atmospheric setting. I don't wanna talk much about what happens because of spoilers, but it took some turns that I was not expecting. For that, I loved it!

The characters are morally gray, specially our main character and her maid Violetta. As for the representation, it features a F/F romance, what's perfect since we are, currently, in Pride Month! I'm not and own-voices reviewer, so keep that in mind. It's not the main focus at all, but it's there. I really enjoyed it.

Definitelly recommend this quick and intriguing novella!

Was this review helpful?

This was a very good read. Very creepy. Another great novella in the series. Historical, thriller, horror. It had everything in a quick read.

Was this review helpful?