Member Reviews

This was such a cute book! This story takes place in the Middle Ages as we follow Max who is supposed to be a bard just like his uncle but he doesn't want that, he wants to be a knight! Max learns a bunch of lessons throughout the book such as how to stand up for what you believe in. This was a fantastic book and one I think that a lot of kids would enjoy. If they're reading the Dork Diaries or Diaries of a Wimpy Kid then this one would be perfect to try out next!

Was this review helpful?

The first entry in the Max and the Midknights series is a Kentucky Bluegrass Award nominee, so I knew I had to get this second entry. It had been a while since I had read the first volume, so I wish there had been a little more of a recap at the beginning, but that likely won't be a problem for most readers. The plot was fun and engaging and I highly suggest this series for fans of awesome girls.

Was this review helpful?

Max continues her adventures in book two. Her friends all seem to be succeeding in their chosen paths; Millie is becoming a pretty good wizard, Kevyn is creating a library, and Simon has become an apprentice at the stables, but Max is struggling. She was doing good in Knight School until Sir Gadabout had to go on a mission for the king, and the new teacher doesn't think girls can be knights. Joining her uncle for a feast at the castle, the visiting queen tells Max that her copy of the book is a bodkin. Going to Mumblin for advice sends her on a quest to rescue the dwarves of Tresk and prevent the bodkins in the land of Knot from entering their world and taking over Byjovia. Filled with many puns, a few crude jokes, and a lot of self promotion, this is a delightful book for children who just want to be themselves and go on an adventure.

Was this review helpful?

Great follow-up to the first of this series. It will certainly be sought out by many young readers, who will no doubt, then be waiting for a number 3!

Was this review helpful?

While not as fun or as endearing as the first installment of the Max series, <u>Battle of the Bodkins</u> still delivered some chuckles while continuing the intriguing medieval storyline. (I personally just would have cut back on all the short/"dwarf" books, as dwarfism is obviously a real condition I'm not sure we should be encouraging young readers to mock and make fun of.) Barring the chunk of jokes that fell a little flat, I'm curious to see where the 3rd book takes us!

Was this review helpful?

Max is one of my favourite new characters to come on the scene. I love the style of the book, easy to read and not too hard for younger kids, while the action and adventure brings older kids to the table. This installment was inventive and silly in a great way and i can’t wait for book #3

Was this review helpful?

Max has achieved her dream of becoming a knight. But Knight school isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. The teacher, Sir Brickbat, doesn’t think she should be there and one of the students, Sedgewick seems to have allied with the teacher. To make matters worse, all the other MIdknights have found their passions. Millie is dealing with magic, Kevyn is working in the library, Simon is working with horses. Max hasn’t found hers yet. When the group duplicates a book in Kevyn’s library, they unwittingly unleash the Bodkins. Bodkins (or bodykins) are the evil duplicates that everyone has. When Sedgewick gets sucked into the Bodkins’ dimension while on a training mission with Max. Max feels obligated to save Sedgewick and set things right. Will she and the others succeed? The plot is well-crafted, humorous, and engaging. The characters are easy to relate to, flawed, and complement each other well. The world building is complete and realistic. The illustrations are mixed throughout and work well with the text. Fans of Lincoln Peirce, Big Nate, knights, historical fiction, and adventure will enjoy reading this book.

Was this review helpful?

Just as good as the first one. It has good character development, interesting plot lines, and ends on a cliff hanger. I’m looking forward to the next installation.

Was this review helpful?

This series is a favorite in our house. The art is fun (especially for fans of Peice's Big Nate series) and the story. There is a great balance of humor and heart that makes this a series I want to share with my kids because I think they will enjoy it while also gaining some lessons about determination. I especially love the format for struggling or reluctant readers. There is enough illustrated storyline on each page that it is easy to go through quickly and not realize how many lines of actual text there are.

Was this review helpful?

My ten-year-old son loved it! I'm sure my public library patrons will too, especially my middle-grade boys. A sure bet for Big Nate fans.

Was this review helpful?

I teach 4th-grade, and my students absolutely devoured the first Max and the Midknights book. After reading the newest in the Max and Midknight collection, I am sure that my students will equally love this new book.

This graphic novel is really fitting for any Big Nate or other graphic novel fans. It has a great mixture of text and illustrations. I like how it has some challenging text structure that will force readers to push their reading skills in the midst of reading a graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

In this sequel to "Max and the Midnights," Max and her friends must stop a group of evil doppelgangers (known as bodkins) from taking over the kingdom. The format is a fun hybrid of comic panels and text, making it a good fit for graphic novel fans. Lots of humor. Lots of twists. Fans of the first book should definitely read this sequel!

Was this review helpful?

As expected from "Big Nate's"Lincoln Peirce, this book packs lots of laughter and silliness (and fart jokes). It is a middle-schooler's goofy fantasy dream come true and will surely be flying off the shelves just like our "Big Nate" books.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for this read! I am so glad that there is a sequel to the first book. This sequel did not disappoint!! It was fantastical and warm hearted. The characters showed personal growth. There was the right amount of potty humor. This book made me laugh.great job, Lincoln Peirce.

Was this review helpful?

Max and the Battle of the Bodkins was a fun read with lots of entertaining twists and turns with body doubles. The Midknights have quite the adventure on their hands when they discover a hidden world with body doubles who aren't quite as kind as they are.

Was this review helpful?

Lincoln Peirce understands reluctant and motivated readers. The Big Nate series is a go-to anytime a kid is required to read a book for fun but tells me they don't really like reading. The mixture of comic panels and text help make the reads less intimidating. The plots are straightforward but also are a little deeper than your average commercial middle grade read. Max and the Midknights series is perfect for fans of the original Big Nate series, Dork Diaries, Diary of a Wimpy Kid, or Captain Underpants fans ready to read on a higher level.

The story problem is one that many kids will relate to. Max doesn't think she is ready or good enough to be a knight. This is reinforced by her interactions with the new teacher at the knight school and her failures as she solves the bodkin problem. Throughout the story, she encounters situations with no easy solution, and she can see that knights aren't perfect, and that is okay.

Definitely, a must-order for libraries. Many kids are already Big Nate fans, which is an easy story to introduce to more reluctant readers.

Was this review helpful?

I received an electronic ARC from Random House Children's Publishing through NetGalley
The Midknights are back for a second adventure. This time they face the Bodkins - clones of each person in the town who try to escape from their land to take over Byjovia. They embark on the quest and save the day with help from Max's uncle, two wizards, the head knight and the true king.
Middle grade readers will appreciate the humor throughout. Peirce captures the fun and silliness that many readers this age adore. This one will not stay on my library shelf long at all.

Was this review helpful?

It is no surprise that this book already has a wait list at my library & after previewing it I can say that kids will not be disappointed with the wait. Though they might be immensely frustrated having to wait for book 3! This book definitely lives up to the silliness of the first book. Kids are going to be thrilled to join in on this new adventure as we get to meet some Bodkins and get a little glimpse at the mystery surrounding Max's past. This book is not one I personally thrill at, but kids are going to love it A LOT!

For Libraries: Goodness, if you don't already have this one on order-buy it!

Was this review helpful?

A real gem of wit and fun! You can't ask for a better blend of modern kid humor which appeals to readers and a new vocabulary and details from a historical period. This book is entertaining, but has great supporting features. My favorite is the vocabulary and unique characters. Great choice for all!

Was this review helpful?

Max and her friends battle bodkins who are invading Byjovia, while Max is unsure if she has what it takes to be a knight. The funny dialogue, especially modern references inserted into the medieval setting, will have kids laughing out loud.

Was this review helpful?