Member Reviews
The Rule is essential to understanding the tradition of monasteries and the rules themselves cultivate an orderly world of prayer and work. St. Benedict was a visionary.
St. Benedict's "Rule" has been on my TBR list for some time, since picking up a copy of Rod Dreher's "The Benedict Option" sometime last year (true confession, also ... still, haha ... on my TBR list). His name has come up several times in that time frame--Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, anyone?--so I was entirely excited to see this new translation come up on NetGalley.
Freeman does a fantastic job at setting the stage for the Rule, providing historical context for both its writing and events leading up to it in Benedict's own life, and world history overall. Freeman also makes it relevant to both Christians and non-Christians alike, and notes how the Rule can a bridge for discussions with Buddhist monks (as just one example). Even the business and psychology realms can benefit from studying this book!
The included bibliography is also helpful for further study, and Freeman is quick to recommend additional resources in the foreword and note on translation as well. Not having read other translations of the Rule, I can't speak to whether this one is better or worse, but I found it entirely readable and approachable, convicting and practical. I loved how Scripture is front and center in every section, and also appreciated Freeman's commentary within each section, much like notes in a study Bible.
Being an introvert and very much a creature of habit/routine :) (shocker!), I reeeeally liked the vigils and services laid out; this section is like its own Book of Common Prayer. The "Reading at Meals" section (not pleasure reading, lol, but a devotion of sorts) reminded me very much of my grandparents, who faithfully practiced similarly for many years! And "Silence at Night" was perhaps my favorite, with gems like "Monks should cultivate silence at all times--but most of all in the hours of the night" (chapter 42). #introvertlife
I received an eARC of the book from the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
For anyone looking for spiritual guidance and uplifting, this is the title for you. I have read and reread and will be gifting it to my like-minded friends. A lovely read.
This type of work on monasticism will forever fascinate me. Church history is so important, as is looking at how and why different faith groups segmented and branched off when they did.
So important and relevant! I wish we'd talk more about St Benedict and his rule of life. I wish we would just reframe our understanding of "rule". BEnedict's starts with "listen", and it captured me there.
Finally, a book for the general reader outlining the instructions St. Benedict set out for his order and honored by the devout everywhere.
Footnotes and further readings abound. The scholar should acknowledge the book but the casual Christian will be welcomed into its pages.
When I was a teenager, I joked that I wanted to become a monk--a bit of a stretch for a non-Catholic female. I was delighted to learn that St. Benedict's saint day is on my birthday, so was eager to read his guide to a contemplative life.
It's important to note that this is a new translation and interpretation of his Rule. I was expecting more biographical information and had I read the description more carefully, I would have realized that. Nonetheless, it's a beautiful, easily readable translation of his Rule, which provides some guidelines applicable to everyday life in the twenty-first century. As we enter what is traditionally a very hectic time in people's lives (perhaps not so much this year as others), it's valuable to take a step back and consider how life was lived by religious communities more than a thousand years ago and consider how some of that can be translated and implemented today.
And also to speculate on the meaning of some of the advice that doesn't age as well. #TheRuleOfStBenedict #NetGalley
Thank you to St. Martin's Press for giving me a free digital galley in exchange for feedback.
I don't have any short-term plans to join a monastery. After all, I'm married, and also don't belong to a church tradition that has monasteries. Yes, I realize those aren't unsurmountable goals, but this probably isn't going to happen unless my life changes pretty dramatically.
For someone like me, this translation of the Rule of St. Benedict was ideal. I've only read this book once before, and it was too long ago for me to say anything helpful about how this translation compares to others, but I thought it was very readable, even colloquial in spots. Even for a person who isn't in a monastery, I found it rich with spiritual advice and life wisdom that I could use today, and I think even a person who isn't Christian would find benefit in reading it.
This is a good introduction to the Rile of St. Benedict. The introduction was very enlightening and though I am Catholic, I appreciated the explanations of Catholic/Christian terms aimed at those who are outside of/unfamiliar with the faith.
The translation was very easy to understand and digest!
This book was not what I was expecting it to be. I’m not Catholic, so I’m not very familiar with Catholicism and the monastic life. This book covers all the rules for those choosing to live the monastic lifestyle.
The rules cover what the monks should sing and when, punishments for those who don’t follow the rules, that they are not allowed to own personal property, what they are allowed to eat and in what measure, hierarchy, etc.
Information and details make for quite dry reading. As a handbook, I’m sure it has its place of usefulness.
This is a new translation of this timeless classic, based on a Swiss manuscript. The introductory material is well worth reading. The author of this material puts this work in context and gives a nice background and history of the Rule of St. Benedict. Recommended for students of St. Benedict and historical Christianity.
A fresh translation of the Rule of Benedict, from sixth century Italy.
The introductory materials and translation with notes are strong. The translator does well to welcome the reader into the world of sixth century Italy, the life of Benedict, and what precipitated the establishment of his Rule. The translation is very clear in modern English, and the notes are helpful for understanding for those who may not be familiar with the language of the monastery.
The substance of the Rule has become the basis of the Benedictine family of monasteries and part of the basis of all other monastic orders of the West. Benedict focused highly on a lot of the practical details about life in a monastic setting: everything from the purpose of being a monk to details about how meals ought to be governed and when various psalms should be read.
This is a helpful edition of the Rule for a modern audience. There are many principles which all can benefit from in terms of discipline and spirituality in the faith. On the whole, however, one can see the challenges that arise from such a hierarchical understanding of all relationships, and where danger might arise in considering the abbot as Jesus Himself. We can understand the impulse to withdraw into the contemplative life, and certainly can appreciate the need for seasons of contemplation and periods of contemplation - but Jesus lived in and among the people, and His people should be as well.
Outstanding and very readable modern translation of this iconic book. For those not familiar with Benedict and monasticism there is a long introduction. For those who want to learn more there is a long list of other books to read.
Very readable religious book that serves as a great meditative guide for implementing discipline in your life. Chapters are short guides on various topics including prayer, behavior in church and homelife with snippets of bible verses interspersed with instruction from St Benedict. I especially enjoyed the introduction detailing more about St Benedict's life and journey to abbot formation.