Member Reviews
Beth O'leary doesn't disappoint with this sweet tale of finding love, no matter your age. This book was easy to read, enjoyable and so sweet.
The Switch by Beth O'Leary was my first book by this author and unfortunately I was a little disappointed. The beginning started off strong but as it went on, it began to drag along and nothing really happened. A lot of detail about basically.. nothing. I do think that important topics were discussed such as grief, family, and relationships. I'm definitely going to check out O'Leary's previous book and give her another change. There are a few characters and moments that I really liked but overall, fell quite flat for me.
Thank you to Macmillan audio and Netgalley for the audiobook, it is always very much appreciated!
I absolutely loved Beth O'Leary's debut, The Flatshare, which I also listened to as an audiobook, so I was thrilled to get my hands on the audiobook for The Switch early. While The Flatshare was an emotional slow-burn romance, romantic relationships aren't the central focus of The Switch—this is a portrait of two women in moments of transition (professionally, romantically), of the relationship between grandmother and granddaughter, and of the complexities of family and grief. The audiobook is beautifully produced, and the narrators/voice actors well-chosen for their respective characters. Both added a great deal of personality and texture to the book, and kept me compelled throughout. The only thing I didn't enjoy were the phone call bits, in which dialogue spoken by the character on the other end of the line is muffled (to the point that it was actually difficult to understand at normal speed and a high volume setting)—there isn't too much of it, and I get the appeal of this kind of effect, but it didn't work for me in this case. I didn't enjoy The Switch quite as much as The Flatshare, but Beth O'Leary's character development and relationship-crafting are so strong that I know I'll be eager to pick up her future novels.
The Switch was a delight, a fun novel with excellent characters, especially the older ones. I listened to the audiobook, which is narrated by two actresses with distinct voices so I had no trouble figuring out which character was talking/narrating, and I also had no problem understanding the British accents. (Occasionally that can be an issue for me, with some British TV shows.)
The author made the people in the grandmother’s generation more “alive” in my imagination than the younger people. Having a focus on older women and men was a lovely change of pace. It seems so many novels (particularly any involving romance) revolve around people in their 20’s and/or 30s. I loved seeing Grandma Eileen flirt and have a sexual relationship during her London sojourn.
All was not “unicorns and rainbows” in this book, however. It deals straightforwardly with the repercussions of the death of a young family member from cancer, depression, infidelity, loneliness and other real-life issues. The three generations of women at the heart of this novel (Grandma Eileen, mom Marianne and granddaughter Leena) learn how to deal with these issues along the way.
It was fairly obvious who Leena would wind up with but I only partially guessed at who would wind up lighting up Eileen’s life, so kudos to Beth O’Leary for that delightful twist.
I haven’t read O’Leary’s earlier book, The Flatshare, but now I want to check that one out!
Thank you to NetGalley and MacMillan Audio for a chance to listen to this audiobook in exchange for my honest review.
Why I Requested This: I read O’Leary’s first book for a video project in January and enjoyed it enough to want to give her a second shot. Especially since this one sounded more up my alley plot wise.
Pros:
There is a good balance between the emotional tones in the story.
The two protagonists have distinct voices and listening to the audiobook made their stories more enjoyable to follow along.
Cons:
There are a lot of side plots. I know we are following two characters in two places, but there are too many side-line plots going on to be enjoyable.
I’m not sure how exactly to word this point, but there was some kind of joy missing from this for me. The story was just fine to me, but I never felt overwhelming happy to be reading it.
Overall: Despite all the things that could be going right for it, my enjoyment went left for the few things that I didn’t like.
This was a fun story of a grandmother and granddaughter switching lives. The two narrators did a great job portraying their characters.
The book was fun and fast paced. There was the perfect mix of love interests and drama. I feel like the other did a great job describing the hot mess of the granddaughter and the meddling of the grandmother. At the same time they were both successful in the life swap.
I would definitely recommend this book to people who enjoy novels like this. I will also be going back to read the authors first book Flatshare.
This is not my typical genre, but thanks to netgalley I had the audio available so I gave it a shot. It wasn’t too bad. Kinda corny in parts and maybe a tad too long for my liking, but a cute little story about an over worked woman and her not-so-elderly grandma who decide to switch houses for 2 months and adjust to being in the other person’s life and shoes. I enjoyed Eileen but Leena was a tad annoying lol. Overall, not a bad way to pass the day. Review also found on good reads.
This book is hilarious! I absolutely want to grow up to be Grandma Eileen who at 79 years old doesn't mince words and enjoys her love life to it's fullest. Make no mistake, this book deals with some rather gut wrenching issues such as the death of a loved one, grief, losing oneself, anxiety and more, but it is wrapped into witty banter, funny interactions albeit at times humiliating antics and fabulous interactions amongst the cast of characters. The characters are a variety of elderly and young, but make no mistake they are all young at heart! More than one character will find themselves truly becoming the person they have wanted to be and this book really drives home the idea that you are never to old to become the person you want to be! I have never read anything by this author before, but I certainly will be looking for more from her in the future. The narrators do an excellent job of bringing already well developed characters to life and enhancing each one's personality.
Thank you, NetGalley, Macmillan Audio and Flatiron Books, for sending me the audiobook of The Switch by Beth O'Leary in exchange for my honest review.
I have yet to read The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary, so don't ask me why I decided to pick this one up when I knew nothing about it. Maybe I was craving a fluffy romance, maybe it was all the pre-publication hype, I just know that, even after having The Flatshare on my wishlist list for months, I decided to read this and I'm GLAD.
As I said, I knew absolutely nothing about this book going in, and I must say it took me by surprise. The Switch is definitely a romance, but that's not nearly the main point of the story. We follow two POVs, Leena and Eileen Cotton, a granddaughter/grandmother duo that puts every other relationship like that to shame. The book is set a few months after Leena's sister, Carla, passed away. In the midst of all that pain and a now complicated relationship with her grieving mother, she starts having a few troubles at work, which leads to her boss giving her a paid two-month leave so she can get her feelings sorted.
That's when, after a weekend visit to her grandmother's, she has the brilliant idea that they switch lives. Eileen's husband left, and she's on the hunt to finding a new romance, while Leena desperately needs a change. They will trade lives for the entirety of Leena's eight-week leave of work. Her grandmother will move to her flat in London and try online dating, and she will move to her grandmother's house in Yorkshire and step in to care for her depressed mother and do all the work Eileen usually does for the community.
I don't even know where to begin talking about this book, I loved it that much. First, we have the characters, all fascinating and incredible people that you can't help but fall in love with. But the highlight of this story is definitely Eileen. She's charismatic, hilarious, and a joy to follow. There's also the premise of older people finding love again, and I have never read anything remotely about that, which is a shame. Even though I loved Leena's chapters, there was something about Eileen's Londoner life that won my heart. I adored that this normalised older people finding love again and following their youthful dreams. We need more of that in mainstream media. Also, seeing her inspire Leena's twenty-something-year-old friends made me want a grandmother just like her.
Seeing Leena try to win over her grandmother's elderly friends and try to fit into the village was also incredible. Seen as they're a very tightknit community, how they reacted to this big town outsider made for great banter and loving relationships. Another highlight was the connection between the two main characters. You see how much they're alike and care for each other, and just how important a granddaughter/grandmother bond can be.
Don't let this fluffy description fool you though, this book deals with some heavier topics, but it does so in a brilliant way. How grief can devastate a family, the multiple forms of coping with the loss of a loved one, and how that impacts every dynamic between the family and the community they live in. We see how each character heals differently, and the reconnection of the relationship between Leena and her mother. And as a precaution, there's a slight trigger warning for an abusive relationship. It's not a major plot point, and there's nothing graphic about it, but it does show up and I feel like it's important to mention.
All in all, I adored this book. I wasn't familiar with Beth O'Leary's writing, but The Flatshare just got bumped to the top of my TBR, although I don't think I'll love it just as much as this one. The story was predictable in the best way, and I listened to most of it in one day, because I simply couldn't stop. The narrators were also fantastic. I wasn't crazy about the wet-mouth noises but, after a while and listening to it on 2x speed (as I usually do), I got used to it.
I gave this book 4/5 ⭐️. I feel like these characters, and this story will stay with me for a while, and I highly recommend this if you're looking for a wholesome family-centred read. Also, I saw someone comparing the idea of this book to the film The Holiday, and I totally agree, which is a win, because that is one of my all-time favourite films.
Beth O’Leary will now be an auto buy author for me. I listened to, and loved, The Flatshare so I jumped at the chance to listen to The Switch and it did not disappoint!
Did you watch the 2006 movie, The Holiday? Well, The Switch gave me major The Holiday vibes and I adored both. They both had predictable endings, but that didn’t take away from my enjoyment at all.
The Switch is told from two perspectives: Granddaughter Leena and Grandmother Eileen. Leena is a 20 something Londoner who still struggles with the loss of her sister, Carla, and is forced to take two months paid holiday. Something most people would love, but it left Leena reeling since she buried herself in her work. 79-year-old Eileen lives in Yorkshire and has had a lot on her plate as well. Her husband left her, and she’s been taking care of her daughter since her granddaughter, Carla, passed away. they end up swapping lives, and it was absolutely brilliantly done.
Leena had to try to fill her grandma’s big shoes. Just because she’s almost 80, does not mean she lives a slow-paced, relaxing lifestyle lol. She’s one busy woman, and reminds me a lot of my own grandmother at that age. Hearing about Eileen transforming lives in London was just fantastic. I love stories with inter-generational friendships, we can learn so much from each other. Character development is huge for me, and I was happy with not only the main characters development, but also side characters.
While this story was full of humor and positivity, it also covered some difficult topics, especially grief and the impact it can have on a family. O’leary handled it so beautifully.
Daisy Edgar-Jones and Alison Steadman brought the characters to life with the narrations, brought out the warmth of Leena and Eileen.
I think this would be a great book for anyone who needs a lighter read, if you liked her book The Flatshare, and/or if you liked the movie The Holiday.
Many thanks to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for the ALC and opportunity to share my thoughts on this delightful book!
The Switch was a really lovely character driven story that has Leena, who has an apartment in London, swapping living situations with her recently divorced grandmother Eileen, who has a house in Leena's small hometown. Both women need a change. Leena is on a forced sabbatical after a panic attack at her high powered job and Eileen is ready to find another love and the dating prospects are dismal at home. The book alternates between the two woman's adventures.
What makes the story fun is that both of the ladies have amazing friends who support the switchees which allows both woman to hit the ground running in their new temporary lives. It is fun to see Eileen dating and also connecting people in Leena's building - she has a real knack for meddling - and it is just as fun to see Leena taking up Eileen's responsibilities - and also making things better for Eileen's friends and neighbors. And both ladies are extremely likable.
I had the opportunity to do this book in audio and both readers did a very nice job. I really liked this story.
Audio ARC courtesy of the publisher via Netgalley.
I really did try to finish the entire audiobook because the story drew me in immediately, but the narration of this book was horrible and I quit after 6 chapters. There were so many wet mouth noises that it made me ill to listen. I look forward to picking up a physical copy, but I cannot recommend the audio book. Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for access to this audiobook!
Beth O’Leary’s The Switch is a charming and heartwarming story that follows Leena, a young woman who lives and works in London. When Leena suffers a panic attack at work one day and almost costs her company a huge client, it becomes apparent that she needs a break from her life. When she confides to her grandmother Eileen about what happened, Eileen confesses that she’s not overly happy with her own life at the moment either. She’s looking for love, but unfortunately, pickings are slim in rural Yorkshire. On a whim, Eileen and Leena decide to swap places for a couple of months, the idea being that Leena can relax and revitalize in a charming, slower paced rural setting, while Eileen can kick up her heels and enjoy life in the big city, where there are of course many more opportunities to meet Mr. Right.
I enjoyed The Switch so much! Both Leena and Eileen are such likeable characters and it was fun to watch them both settle into their new environments. I thought it was so cute watching Eileen hang out with Leena’s young friends, who helped her set up social media dating profiles, and made sure her time in London was everything she hoped it would be. I also loved watching Leena interact with her grandmother’s, mostly elderly, neighbors. Everything about this aspect of the book was just so entertaining and I loved all the quirky characters both in London and in Yorkshire.
It wasn’t all fun and games though. The Switch also deals with some serious and emotional topics as well, such as grief, infidelity, and the hazards of online dating. There’s an especially moving secondary plot that focuses on the death of Leena’s sister Carla and how the loss of Carla has impacted Leena and Eileen, and especially Leena’s mother, who is really struggling with her grief.
There’s also a little romance. It’s somewhat secondary to the emotional journeys of both Eileen and Leena, but for those who love a little romance in their women’s fiction, it’s definitely there and will put a smile on your face.
I listened to the audiobook version of The Switch and thought the narration was wonderful. Leena’s chapters are narrated by Daisy Edgar-Jones, while Eileen’s are narrated by Allison Steadman. I thought both voices were perfectly suited to the characters they were narrating and that they both really brought these characters to life beautifully. I also liked that I was able to comfortably listen to the audio at my usual 1.25x speed.
The Switch is a delightful story about love, family, and community. If you enjoyed Beth O’Leary’s last novel, The Flatshare, I think you’ll love this one too.
What a SWEET book!! This is a book about a grandmother and granddaughter who are both in a rut after the loss of the granddaughter’s sister who decide to SWITCH places for two months. Leena needs to have her life slow down, while still being distracted by all of her grandmother’s special projects and volunteer endeavors in the country. Eileen wants to have a new start at romance after her husband left her and because she thinks there are no singles in the country so moves into Leena’s flat in London. They both completely embrace their new circumstances. I loved seeing Leena dive into planning the midsommer festival and loved seeing Eileen plan social events with her flatmates in London. This book gave me all the feels, including missing my late Meme (grandmother)!
For the pic, I thought I would have two sisters (my kiddos) pose with their phones and the audios since it suits the story of the sister theme in the book and because a sister switch is a fun idea too. ;-)
Fans of the movie THE HOLIDAY will swoon over this book.
Thank you SO much to @netgalley, @librofm, @macmillan.audio, and @flatiron_books for providing me with an advanced listener copy of this book. All opinions are my own! <3
Pub Day: Tuesday
Author: @betholearyauthor
Narrator: Alison Steadman & Daisy Edgar-Jones
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The Switch is the story of the two Eileen Cottons – or Leena and Eileen – granddaughter and grandmother who, after the death of Leena’s sister and the end of Eileen’s marriage, are ready for a change. So, they make the switch! Eileen goes down to stay in Leena’s London flat and look for love for two months (even taking Leena’s smartphone and laptop) and Leena goes back to the Yorkshire Dales to take over her grandmother’s projects, figure out what she wants from life, and maybe reconnect with and forgive the mother she’s been avoiding.
I’ll start by saying I listen to a lot of audiobooks so can confidently say the narration of this one was excellent! I often hear people ask for recommendations of good audiobooks but it is still as personal as recommending any book. However, you usually can’t go wrong with actors as narrators.
Daisy Edgar-Jones and Alison Steadman did a fantastic job of narrating Leena and Eileen respectively, and both brought plenty of life to the characters. It was very clear in the dialogue when another character was speaking and there were effects to signal that one half of the dialogue was on the other end of the telephone, all which helps the listening experience. My only slight quibble perhaps is that neither narrator is actually from Yorkshire – although Steadman’s voice work is stellar, and this criticism may be more relevant in other cases – I do think it is important to have an authentic voice in audiobooks.
The Switch deals well and sensitively with bereavement, loneliness, domestic abuse, as well as giving older people a voice – (it reminded me a little bit of Saving Missy). I hesitate to say the book is predictable but there is nothing unexpected here, it’s a tender yet funny story and it’s comforting because of that – it’s not going to shock or disappoint. It’s the heart-warming, Sunday afternoon family film of a book, and is saved from being too sentimental and twee by its humour and the novelty of a swap involving a grandmother and granddaughter, who already love one another and know each other well; rather than sisters who don’t get on (In Her Shoes) or extremely different strangers (The Holiday).
I really enjoyed it as an audiobook so I’ll round up from 3.5 to 4 stars. However, I definitely think the narration helped me enjoy this one more then I might have done if I had simply read the book.
Thank you #NetGalley for the audio ARC of #TheSwitch.
brilliant book.
I ditn know what to expect but i loved it from the first few pages and i was itested from the start to finsh. loved it.
Firstly this book was amazing ! I enjoyed the audiobook as it was narrated by a British person and I totally loved it . The audiobook was everything I wanted it to be and more. The switch tells the story of Eileen an almost eighty year old and her granddaughter Leena. They decide to switch lives and apartments and I can't even imagine doing that with my grandmother 😂🤭Beth O'Leary gave us a story that was not usual as it was an older woman and her granddaughter. Enjoyed the plot, the characters and everything about it. I thoroughly enjoy Eileen as she was fun, honest and a breath of fresh air. I totally recommend this audiobook. Huge thanks to the publisher for my ARC
When overachiever Leena Cotton is ordered to take a two-month sabbatical after blowing a big presentation at word, she escapes to her grandmother Eileen's house in the English countryside.
At the same time, Eileen is newly single at age 79 and goes on a "Big City" adventure in London.
That's how it happens that grandmother and granddaughter switch lives.
This was a sweet, wholesome, heartwarming story that I would recommend if you are in the mood for something to take your mind off the everyday stresses.
Thank you netgalley and Macmillan audio for the advanced listeners copy in exchange for an honest review.
I will definitely be reading more books by Beth O'Leary.
5/5 stars
** I received this ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review**
I absolutely adore this book. The narrators did a fantastic job bringing these characters to life, I'm very picky about audiobooks but I HIGHLY recommend picking up a copy and listening to this book. The book alone was fantastic, I've never read from a character around this age but I loved every second of it. I felt so connected to the characters. The writing had a way of drawing me in and keeping me there. I recommend picking this up. This book gives all the feels, happy, sad, anger, anxious. Literally all of the emotions. Again I recommend picking up this book and giving the audiobook a listen!
🚪The Switch🚪
.
.
.
Why I enjoyed it: This is a great novel about women in a family who are lost after a tragedy. Lena and her grandmother are very close, they decide to swap places. They embark on a new adventure where they find life after heart break. This novel had a very slow start for me. It took me a bit to get into it and I found it to be very predictable. That being said, I enjoyed the story as a whole. It’s very heartwarming and relatable. I think it would make a good quick read.
.
.
For my audiobook readers: The narration started out great (I love a British narrator). There are phone calls through out the story that don’t translate well via audiobook. The person on the phone doesn’t sound believable. I.E. Lena talking to her mother who sounds like she’s younger than her daughter over the phone. I otherwise enjoyed it.
.
.
.
Rating: 3/5⭐️