Member Reviews
I just loved this
Probably as a woman who’s a mom of a preteen. It’s scary but beautiful to see Val struggled ,learned and finally find herself thru the exhausting journey of young adult life. Live your passions and be happy with it.
Wonderful books for girls.. feminist but for the good reasons. Raw truth sometimes but still truth
This YA graphic novel perfectly captures the Riot Grrrl scene of the early 1990s. Another reviewer says it's unrealistic for them to get a gig despite having barely played and not knowing their instruments. I saw a lot of shows/bands around this time and this was very common especially among Riot Grrrl groups where there was so much need to express themselves so quickly. As a real-world example, look up Emily's Sassy Lime. They learned as they went. (And, of course, male-dominated punk bands have a long history of not knowing how to play their instruments!)
The body image stuff was great, as were the song titles and lyrics ("I don't want to hold your hand, follow your lead. I'm not your little princess anymore, Daddy, now I bleed!"). The jealous straight-edge boyfriend, the touring burnout, and even the fact that it was all just lightning in a jar and soon over except for the coffeeshop job in adulthood -- everything was believable and fun.
I've read through the negative reviews, and I get many of them. If I had a criticism, it's like the author illustrated the Wikipedia entry for any random Riot Grrrl band, meaning that the telling is very tight and predictable for anyone who lived through it. If it weren't a YA book, I would want it to spool out slower and delve into the other characters more.
And, of course, as a YA book, some will criticize it for language (lots of it), sex, intoxicants, and fighting. I think it would've been better off not pitched at the YA market, even if that's where the graphic novel money is, but damn, this was fun!
I'd like to say it inspired me to pull out my Bikini Kill and Heaven's to Betsy albums, but I never put them away...
Bechdel test: Pass
#NetGalley #MyRiot
A gorgeously drawn graphic novel with an interesting narrative, plot, and concepts. Definitely recommended for fans of this genre.
This was actually a pretty great graphic novel about a girl who finds her destiny as a member of a riot grrl band in the nineties. I really loved the art and the story was good too - if nothing maybe a bit short? I really liked it though.
I did not expect to read My Riot as fast as I did. I started to read it with no intention to read it all the way, I just wanted to take a peek. But it made me so curious and it really got me interested!! I love how it showed the struggles women, especially during our teenage years, go through. All the expectations and the judgement we get from other people and even from the people closest to us.
The one thing I absolutely loved about this is how I felt like I’ve been reading and following Val’s story for a long time but, in reality, it’s only been less than an hour since I knew her. It showed only a part of her life, but I felt how much that part mattered to her through the way her story was told.
Overall a great read! Especially for times whenever you want to take a break from complicated and heavy books or stories.
My favorite lines:
"I'm not a slogan. I'm not a t-shirt
I don't need a label."
"I'm not a lot of things.
But I'm happy."
Fun coming-of-age graphic novel. Riot-Grrrl music scene. Finding and doing what makes you happy.
Valerie Simmons is increasingly aware that her buttoned-up, ballet-and-school life isn't what she wants. A chance meeting with Kat opens up a whole new world of music and discovery. Val and Kat start a (pretty awful) punk rock band, that turns into a pretty awesome band and experience. Leading Kat to see the joy one can get by following their own path.
**I received this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.**
Teenage me would have wanted to be this story! This was a great coming of age story about choosing your own path and finding what matters to you. With the added bonus of punk rock and feminism whats not to love!
Thanks to Netgalley for allowing me to read an ARC of this story in return for an honest review.
Set in the 199os, at the height of the punk rock movement, 17 year old Valerie is excited to start at her first job while continuing to pursue her dream to become a ballerina. A riot resulting from a police shooting, meeting her new best friend Kat, and punk music combine to set her life off on a very different course.
Val pushes back against negative body talk from her ballet instructor, unrealistic expectations from her parents, and uncertainty about who she is. Music helps her understand herself and allows her the freedom to express all of her frustrations.
This story of friendship, family, and a love of music will speak to everyone who has connected with others through music. Overall, 4 out of 5 stars.
What a beautiful book to portray the rage of teenage years. I loved this story, the journey, the characters, and everything tying together so true to life.
* reviewed from uncorrected eARC via netgalley
teen/adult graphic novel (for mature teens-contains cigarette use, sexual situations, eating disorder)
written by Rick Spears (he, him) and illustrated by Emmett Helen (they, them)
17 y.o. awkward misfit, friendless ballerina becomes 90s punk rock star with a new Best Friend, and suddenly all the boys are interested--Valerie's story has tons of teen appeal (except for the smoking, eating disorder, etc.). This book has great artwork and a fast-paced plot--thumbs up.
Just to let you know, this book was received as an eARC from NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review. My Riot is set to be published on October 20th 2020. A little bit about the book: Set in the early '90s, My Riot is about a trio of teen girls team up to form a rock band and shake off society's expectations of what it means to be a young woman coming of age in the modern world. Blurb from Netgalley 1991—Val, a teenager from a conservative family, has grown up dreaming of becoming a ballerina, but recently something has changed. She’s begun feeling pressure to conform to a specific idea of beauty, body type, and a personality that just doesn’t fit. Val meets Kat, a smart, witty girl that doesn’t take any crap off anyone. Kat introduces Val to punk rock. Along with Rudie, another new friend, the three form an all-girl punk band they ironically name The Proper Ladies. Soon Val and her friends find themselves caught up in a movement with other girls also starting bands—also finding their voice. Collectively, these “riot grrrls” discover that their songs ring out loud and powerful, and for Val, there’s no going back. Content warnings: Eating disorders, body image issues, misogyny [SPOILERS] My Riot is an extremely well told story in graphic novel form. It follows Val, a seventeen year old ballerina who mets a new friend and decides she wants quit ballet and start a band. We follow val as she meets this new friend, Kat, and starts to discover who she really wants to be, what type of person she is looking to become, as she doesn’t feel comfortable with societies version of ‘Normal’. We follow Val through her through a long period of time in the 188 pages of the graphic novel, with the end briefly summing up everything that has happened with the band, and where Val ends up. What I liked: + The art style was very basic, but with faded words in the background e.g. posters, and the colour scheme, which was quite plain, I actually liked it a lot, it was very muted and made me focus a lot more on the story as well as the images. + The story itself was also pretty basic, about a girl who grew up doing what her parents wanted and finding her own two feet. But for some reason it was gripping and exhilarating and I wanted to read more and more of it. It really grabbed me. + I loved the lyrics that the band wrote, they were really fun and I could almost hear the music in the background of reading this. + Summing up at the end is both good and bad for me, but I liked how we know what happens next, I love when we can finish a story and not have to wonder what happens next, but this filled up my mind. + Her parents, although her mother started out as being a bit of a bitch, she slowly became more and more supportive of Val, and it was really wholesome and sweet. What I didn’t like: - a lot of the story skipped over little bits of information that could have been useful, for example, Val stays out all night, and she runs off because she obviously shouldn’t have stayed out all night without informing her parents, but we get no scene with the aftermath of this. We don’t find out what her parents thought of this, and she wasn’t grounded for it like she was in previous parts of the story. This happens a few times, with there being so little follow up to the context we are giving when we should expect there to be something. - I didn’t like the dance instructor, I know this isn’t a fault to the story, but they did say she needed to lose weight and take up smoking despite the fact she was 115 pounds and seventeen... It really made me want to punch her. - Summing up at the end, it was very quickly done and could have benefitted from a bit more explanation. I understand everything that happened, but it just seemed a little too quickly summed up for me. I wish we got to see what happened to Kat as well some other characters, like her parents. [SPOILERS END HERE] Overall, this story was a little basic, but gripping nonetheless. It was a nice short and sweet read, which gave me lots of angst-y teen vibes. I loved the art style and the illustrations, which were done by Emmett Helen. 3/5 Stars
Fun, though I was put off by the amount of bad language used in this comic. I do like it a lot though! It's a musical work of art.
Thanks to NetGalley to giving me this opportunity to read this amazing graphic-novel! I love it!
For the first pages I wasn’t completely in to it, but when I read more and more I was stuck in this story about young girl how love dance ballet but she was told that she need to cut her weight and she finding her self in her own band.
The story is so strong, but I feel like a topic of eating disorder could be more expanded. Overall it was so cool to see the grow that our main character have.
I love three girls in this band and how so much fun they had! I started being a little bit obsessed about this story. When I read Moxie I found how Riot Grrrl was founded and now I read a story that was exploring that in this time when it all happened!
Love, totally recommend and give yourself a treat and read this when it comes up 😇
I received this book as an eARC from Netgalley in exchange for a review.
My Riot is a coming of age story about ballerina Val, as she discovers her love and talents for music.
This graphic novel was beautifully illustrated and told a really fun story. I read it all in one sitting because I was hooked. I loved the way we were able to see Val's change as a character. I also was glad to see that there was discussions of the toxic nature of weight in the ballet industry. I am also glad that we got some exposure on an unhealthy relationships, because this is something we often do not see in graphic novels. I really enjoyed the narrative style of this graphic novel and I feel like it fit with the age Val is supposed to be in the story. I did have some issues with the way the story wrapped up. I would've liked more composition there.
This graphic novel was okay! There were still a lot of thing that felt unfinished to me, like Val's relationship with her parents and her relationships with friends in general. Plus, I didn't like the fact that it is never explicitly stated that Rudie was a lesbian or gender non-conforming!
Fun and sometimes bittersweet story about a fictional band that rises to prominence during the Riot Girrl movement and, in particular, the guitarist's transition from a highly controlled "good girl" living out her parents dreams to a young woman who finds a more truthful identity amid the punk scene.
This graphic novel focus on Val and her friends forming a punk rock band. It’s was a fun read about breaking from society’s expectations of what it means to be a woman. Can’t wait to learn more about the riot grrrl movement.
(Content warning: eating disorder, body issues, alcohol/drug use)
Content Warnings: eating disorders, misogyny, body image issues
I picked up My Riot on a whim from netgalley as I really liked the cover. I was particularly drawn to the style of the main character’s hair. A lil blonde stream is something I have 100% done before I was brave enough to fully bleach my hair, so I wanted to know more about her.
Val is a teenage ballerina from a conservative family in the early 90’s, and she thinks she wants to be a professional ballet dancer. But after being told she’s overweight (ugh major eye roll) and does everything in her power to get that under control. Not in a healthy way either. In a stop eating, start smoking, and other unhealthy mannerisms.
She’s also trying to keep down a job at an ice cream shop, which isn’t something she really has the energy for. Luckily, for her anyway, it gets broken into during a riot! Due to this she ends up having an ice cream fight with another girl and the two hit it off. The two have already crossed paths a few times, but it’s this incident that cemented their friendship.
Kat is unlike the other friends that Val has, especially those she knows through ballet. She’s witty and smart, loud and fat, though most importantly she’s into punk rock.
Thanks to Kat, Val gets her first taste of the punk rock scene, she fully welcomes the noise and crowds. She dives into the mosh pit and she feels something else, something freeing. She sees a new outlook on how her life can be, one that isn’t going to judge her based on appearance.
Unsurprisingly it’s around this time she starts to realise how monotonous ballet has become for her, how there is little joy in the repetitiveness whilst literally starving herself.
It’s funny how one little event can help change your perspective, help remind you that you need to exist for what you enjoy, not what you thought you enjoyed. And mostly definitely not for what society thinks you should be like.
One punk rock show leads to more shows and to a stronger friendship, though their position has changed from fans to performers. Yes that’s right, the two and Rudie join forces and become The Proper Ladies.
The first half of the story didn’t resonate with me fully, but on reflection now I realise that actually yes it does in a way. Only my experience was with cheerleading, not ballet.
I absolutely loved Val taking her life into her own hands. Feeling the inspiration and joy to form a band, to write songs, and to truly not give a fuck about what society expected from her.
Val goes on a wonderful transformation, which of course includes an at home bleach session. We love to see it! I always feel like a completely new person after I’ve dyed my hair, I feel ready to take on the world, but most importantly a fresh head of colour makes me feel like myself again.
Added to this, what the three girls achieve together and the stands they take to make sure men take them seriously was just super INSPIRING.
After finishing reading My Riot I instantly turned to Goodreads to leave a short waffling review. I never do this, but I didn’t want to forget the emotions I felt, I didn’t want to forget that I read most of the last section with tears in my eyes and my heart beating so strongly.
Truly, sometimes you just read a book and feel seel, feel welcomed, feel inspired. Ready to take on the world yourself. In short, My Riot is a graphic novel worth reading, it’s one about finding yourself and becoming who you want to be, not what the world wants to mold you to be. And I couldn’t have been happier.
Finally, if you need further proof of how much I enjoyed and resonated with this graphic novel then check out this illustration of Val at the end of My Riot. Does she look familiar? Yeah, thought so. Perhaps this is my life…
Thank you Netgalley for letting me read this book in return for an honest review.
My Riot by Rick Spears and Emmett Helen is set in 1991 about a girl named Val. Throughout this Graphic Novel we watch how she goes from a ballerina and going through the struggles of that (including body image and the pressures of being a certain weight) to becoming a guitarist and vocalist of a band called 'The Proper Girls' where we see her change, embracing her anger and frustrations. She meets new people like Kat and Rudie and explores crushes and teenage love.
The artwork in this is lovely to see as each character looks different and it is easily followed. The artwork also really matches the tone of the writing. I can't really pinpoint what it was, but something about it made me cry and I was constantly rooting for Val.
Rating- 5⭐
Would I read it again:
Yes, again and again
Would I recommend it:
Yes
This graphic novel is set in the ’90s and follows Valerie, a 17-year-old girl who wants to be a ballerina- at least she thinks she does, that is until she has a chance meeting with Kat, a wild child who doesn't care what anyone thinks and does what she likes. She takes Valerie to a local club that’s showcasing a punk rock band. Valerie meets Jake, the lead guitarist, and singer of the punk rock band Straight Edge, they quickly form a connection and the show inspires Valerie to form a band with Kat and Rudie.
Valerie is dealing with a lot, she’s always gone to ballet class, but lately, she is beginning to realize how much of an effect ballet is having on her health and her instructor pressures her to lose weight. This causes Valerie to take up smoking to suppress her apatite, excessively exercise, not eat all day, and binge then purge. She’s reprimanded for not being ladylike enough by her instructor when she isn’t losing the weight fast enough. This pushes her to her breaking point and she quits. If that isn’t enough, she’s silently being slut-shamed by her mom when her mother discovers a condom wrapper while washing her clothes.
We follow Valerie as she makes some drastic changes in her life, she begins to come into her own as a woman and becomes a strong feminist, channeling her feelings and society’s expectations of girls into her lyrics. Soon the band is performing at more gigs and getting approached by reporters, magazines, and record labels- and Jake, whom Valerie is dating, and the main act of the tour- becomes jealous of Valerie's band- The Proper Ladies, and feels like she used him.
And so, we go on the road with The Proper Ladies as they experience a lot of success and the eventual drifting apart that occurs.
This graphic novel is so great. It truly illustrates the undue pressure that young girls are under to behave and look a certain way to get society’s approval. I think this is such a great graphic novel for teen girls, it deals with sexism, feminism, eating disorders, and teen sex. Its an incredibly empowering novel for young girls everywhere.
4 stars.
**ARC provided by Oni Press via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.