Member Reviews

This is exactly the book I didn’t know I needed. I’ve really enjoyed Lindy West’s previous books, so when I saw she was putting out a book of essays about movies, I was on board. But I didn’t expect to love it as much as I did. I laughed so I hard I cried more than once while reading this one. Her sense of humor won’t work for everyone, and if you’re especially defensive about movies you’ve enjoyed, maybe this won’t be for you, but for me? This felt like sitting on the couch watching movies with my best friend, which is exactly what I needed right now.

Thank you Hachette and NetGalley for the review copy.

Was this review helpful?

NOTE: I received a free advanced reader's copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Snarky take-downs of movies from the 80s, 90s and 00s. The essays that are good are really good and I definitely laughed aloud a few times. A few essays went on a bit too long and I ended up skipping through the ones for movies I hadn't seen. I wish the chapter titles included the actual names of the movies so that you could go directly to the ones you want to read. What's good is that you don't need to read them all, or in order, so this is a good book to pick up when you have a bit of time and want a few laughs at the expense of your favorite films. (Some of the movies included are: Love Actually, The Notebook, Shawshank Redpemtion, American Pie, Bad Boys II, Harry Potter, Twilight, Reality Bites and Titanic, among others.)

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this book, but unfortunately, I feel this writing style works better in a blogging format than in a published book. More importantly, I think this book would be funnier for someone who had seen the majority of the films included here, which I haven't, so there wasn't very much for me to take from reading this - sad, as I love Lindy West's writing.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Hachette books and Lindy West for providing me an ARC to this title. This is my first Lindy West book and will not be my last. I am about 5 years older than Lindy West, but it is apparent that we grew up enjoying (or not enjoying) the same movies. Most of the essays included in this book were about movies I have in fact seen and I found myself completely tickled with West's plot synopses and commentary. I had several laugh out loud moments and found myself reciting portions from this book aloud to my husband. I enjoyed this entire collection and really really appreciated the essays on the movies Love Actually (I can't believe people like this movie) and The Notebook. This was a great form of nostalgia but also a terrific way to reframe the sexism and misogyny prevalent in so much of our entertainment from the 90s.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read this advance copy.

If you're like me and you already love Lindy West, you'll enjoy this book. If you're not familiar with her, but you want to revisit some favorite older movies with a hilarious modern lens, you'll also enjoy this book! I've already rewatched one of the movies she reviewed that was a big favorite of mine in my late teens (Rush Hour) and plan to rewatch more. I thought the prediction that Maverick from Top Gun would be at all the "reopen America" protests was an especially funny yet accurate take.

Was this review helpful?

This book made me realize that I need to be Lindy West's friend! We'll drink wine and make fun of movies and TV shows (and lest we forget those omnipresent Hallmark Channel "movies" because that would be our thing), and get a kick out of our own clever selves while trying ever so hard to ignore the horrible dumpster fire the world around us has become. At least there will always be The Fugitive.
This wave of warmth (no longer talking about said dumpster fire) stemming from reading words written by a kindred spirit was around me from the opening chapter, and continued through the entire book. I laughed out loud and read various passages (mostly Harry Potter) to my partner. West is hilarious (and correct!) in her take downs, but these critiques are also done in the most loving way--we hate Twilight, but goddamn, we love Twilight!
This is the most enjoyment I've gotten out of a book this year (hell, probably years at this point) and should be required pandemic reading!
In conclusion:
Book - Awesome
Lindy West Friend Request - Pending

Was this review helpful?

I received a reviewer copy of Shit, Actually by Lindy West from Hachette Books from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

What It’s About: Lindy West writes reviews of about 30 movies, she covers movies like Honey I Shrunk the Kids, Face-Off, and Twilight and watches them through 2020 eyes.

What I Loved: Look, admittedly Lindy West could write a review of the telephone book and I'd read it because she is hilarious and always on point. This book is no different. All of the essays that covered movies I'd seen, I laughed out loud at least a couple of times. Some of my favorite ones were Honey I Shrunk the Kids, Harry Potter, and Twilight. These sarcastic essays are the perfect pairing to Covid entertainment. In fact, I might even watch the movie then read the essay, maximize your entertainment. Also, important to note because of the way West writes you can still enjoy the essays even if you never saw the movies.

What I didn’t like so much: Admittedly, my fault, some of the movies I never saw, so I didn't get as much out of this but again not West's fault.

Who Should Read It: If you love movies and mocking them then this book is for you.

General Summary: Sarcastic reviews and commentary about popular movies.

Was this review helpful?

*Thank you to Net Galley and Hachette Books for the advance copy*

In Shit, Actually, Lindy West hilariously breaks down some of the most ridiculous movies to ever exist. I've read her other books and enjoyed them for different reasons. Shrill felt introspective and was relatable for me; The Witches are Coming was a giant middle finger to the patriarchy, but Shit, Actually is ROASTING 90s and 00s comedies and action movies.

I don't want to mention any of the titles she examines because I read it without visiting the table of contents and loved being surprised. Most of the movies I have seen, but now I want to see the movies that I haven't because if they're as ridiculous as she writes about they're going to be a BLAST. Well, shit, actually.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed Shit, Actually by Lindy West. I found myself laughing and had a few near misses with drinks coming out of my nose. After I read West’s book, I have a list of movies I’ve never seen but now MUST watch. Convinced only by her colorful commentary. Shit, Actually is a series of essays giving color commentary on a series of movies. I’m not a sports person, but I do love movies and would love to watch with her giving a play by play of movies throughout, like I’m guessing a sportscaster does? Her writing is witty, insightful and full of quotable one liners.

Was this review helpful?

I had never read anything by Lindy West before, but reading "Shit, Actually" was incredibly entertaining. "Shit, Actually" is a collection of essays of West's commentary on various movies. I particularly loved the essays on Harry Potter, Twilight, and American Pie, and found the writing to be very engaging and conversational. I'm definitely looking forward to reading more by West in the future!

Thank you to Hachette and NetGalley for my free e-copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this book. Lindy West is freaking brilliant! I love her and everything she writes! This is a must read all about movies!

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun and funny book! I really enjoy reading Lindy West, and this is a very light and enjoyable read that also engages in light-hearted critiques of most famous contemporary films. In a book form, this can get a bit exhausting as West’s humor is often best in the short form, and her individual articles shine because of this.

Was this review helpful?

Please note, I received a copy of this book thanks to Netgalley, all thoughts are my own.

I didn't hate Shit, Actually, but I also didn't love it. I was very excited when I heard this book was a thing because I love movies and I also love Lindy West's writting! I may not have enjoyed her last book, The Witches are Coming, as much as I had hoped I would but I did enjoy it enough to not even think twice about requesting this one.

I enjoyed Shit, Actually significantly better that The Witches are Coming but not even near as much as Shrill. For me, Shrill is still my favorite of her books. I love that this one is all about movies but there were a few things I had issues with.

For starters, the chapters begin to get very repetitive. Each chapter/essay is the same format or going over what the movie is and the entirety of the plot with some witty banty thrown in every now and then. This format works very well in a blog viewpoint but as a cover to cover read I was starting to get bored.

Second, I didn't know all the movies. This is completely on me and not the book, but I just didn't care at all about the chapters when I had no idea what the movie even was. This didn't happen ofter, maybe three or four chapters, but it happened enough for me to sigh and skim through thouse chapters. Along with this point there were more movies in this book that I had never seen before than there were of ones I had, including The Fugitive, which is the movie she bases her scoring on. For some of these movies I was very intruiged because it gave me a little more of a glimpse into these movies I honestly have no intention of watching!

The final thing is another me thing, and that is the fact that each chapter was basically poking fun at every movie. I mostly didn't mind it but then she started in on The Santa Clause and (while yes, valid points) I didn't connect well with that chapter because that movie is one of my all time favorite Christmas movies! it never gets old for me!!

Overall I enjoyed the heck out of this but by the end I was skimming over movies I didn't care about just to get to the next chapter sooner. I am very interested in picking this up for a reread on audiobook though! I simply adore the way Lindy West narrates her books!

One last thing, I do appreciate the way she uses the word carcass!

Was this review helpful?

The escapist film essays we all need right now! Lindy writes like she’s your friend complaining about a movie over lunch, and since it’s going to be ages before we can do that, this book is the next best thing.

Was this review helpful?

This was absolutely hilarious and much needed. Lindy West has written other humor books but this has to be her best yet because she gives critiques on popular movies. And in her opinion, The Fugitive is the best and the other movies she discussed are based on Fugitive DVDs. My personal favorite observations of hers had to be, even if i didn't agree with the ranking are: Titanic, Twilight, The Notebook, Forrest Gump, Top Gun, Face Off and Shawshank Redemption. I don't agree that Jurassic Park is almost good as the Fugitive because they are castly different movies. And Harry Potter is better than the Santa Clause? Phht. She ranks Shawshank the equivalent of Fugitive. I concur.

All in all in this rather hilarious, good and quick read. I really recommend it if you need a laugh.

Thanks to Netgalley, Lindy West, and Hachetta Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Available: 10/20/20

Was this review helpful?

What happens when you combine surprise wedding bands with face-switching cops and violated apple pies? This work of pure brilliance from Lindy West. 'Shit, Actually' is a collection of essays West wrote after rewatching some of the biggest movies of the past few decades. Since this book is coming out during the COVID-19 pandemic, she suggests it can be used as a substitute for all those movie nights with friends (remember those?). From 'The Fugitive' (“The Only Good Movie”) to 'The Lion King' (“What Is A Monarchy We Are Animals”) West’s laugh-out-loud commentary will keep you entertained both during and after the time of masks and toilet paper shortages.

Lindy West has a wicked sense of humor and she lets it all out in these essays. From her classic roast of Love, Actually ("Shit, Actually") to her detailed recounting of inane movie plots (including Speed and Back to the Future Part II), West had me snickering, cackling, and outright roaring with laughter. It doesn’t matter that I haven’t seen at least half the movies she profiles: most of them have become enmeshed in popular culture and her plot summaries fill in the rest. In fact, I might just go back and watch some of these gems. At the very least, I’m hunting down 'The Fugitive,' but I’m going to pass on 'Face/Off.' (Who came up with this terrifying concept? And who thought it would make a good movie?? And who decided to hire Nicholas Cage?!?!!).

P.S. – Don’t miss the footnotes!

Rating: 11/10 DVDS OF THE FUGITIVE

Was this review helpful?

The introduction of this book made me burst into tears, because the author said that it could stand in for a movie night with friends while those aren't possible during the pandemic, and I was just deeply touched by that idea.

The book is less essays than humorous recaps and reviews of particular movies, but it's so fun and funny. It made me think of how the terrible things in life-- racism, sexism, etc. etc. can force writers to constantly write about those things, and never give them a chance to write what they would write if the evils of the world weren't so urgent. So I'm glad Lindy West could write a book that is just silly and fun. I wish for that freedom for so many writers.

What's great is that Lindy and I are very close in age, and our tastes are quite aligned, so it's like reading an extra funny version of my own opinions, with references I'm guaranteed to get, and there's something deeply satisfying about that as a reader.

I haven't seen every movie in this book, so I think the best way to approach the book is to read the essays about movies you're intimately familiar with, and (re)watch movies you've never seen or have forgotten the details of. Then it really would be like a movie night with a friend!


***Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for providing an ARC in exchange for my honest review.***

Was this review helpful?

This book is hilarious! When I say I cackled like the swamp witch I am, it really doesn't do the essays justice. The “Top Gun” essay had me sobbing with laughter, the breakdown of whatever Nicholas Sparks movie it was (who can even tell them apart?) was amazing and we can all definitely agree: “The Fugitive” is the best movie ever made.

Fans of Lindy West know she is smart, sharp witted and amazing with rhetoric, this collection of essays is a brilliant showcase of her skills. With humor and an eye to feminism and social justice, these movie reviews are blistering evaluations of all our “problematic faves.”

Was this review helpful?

Okay, I love Lindy West. I want to be her best friend, but I am a little too awe-struck to even imagine being her best friend. Yet, somehow, while I devoured "Shrill" and "Witches are Coming" upon their release, I have never read any of her early online work... and, after reading this book, I will CERTAINLY be remedying that! I loved this book so much that sometimes I had to stop so I could throw my head back and howl with laughter. I performed a dramatic read aloud of the titular "Shit, Actually" for my husband. I haven't even seen "The Fugitive," but I appreciated the ranking system. While I did skip over one or two essays for movies I haven't seen, I would recommend this book to anyone who loves Lindy, loves movies, or just needs a laugh. Thank you to Netgalley and to Hatchette Books for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Cultural commentary from one of literature’s leading funny ladies. Smart, accessible, and a pleasure to read.

Was this review helpful?