Member Reviews
This is both a heartbreaking and beautiful book all in one go.
Bean is a 15-year-old bright and intelligent girl whose life is completely turned upside down when her brother Sam suddenly commits suicide.
Her life and that of her family are completely broken apart, but for Bean it’s more than just coping with the loss of her brother, who died too young, too soon and in a way that she cannot comprehend.
She refuses to accept that Sam, who was so in love with life, with nature and such a spiritual teenager, with strong Innuit beliefs, would just suddenly take his own life.
So, she begins a quest for answers.
Because there has to be a justifiable reason for what happened, right? Did he really kill himself? Was someone else responsible?
And being a boy with strong Innuit beliefs, is he now coming back to show signs to Bean through spirit animals, such as a wolf that she keeps seeing in broad daylight? Is he really gone or just re-incarnated in his spirit animal?
Bean needs answers, and she will not rest until she gets them… no matter the cost and no matter how much finding out the truth may hurt.
I won’t go into spoiler details of what actually happened and the path that this search for answers led Bean on, but I will say that this was a sad but also heartwarming story, because it’s also about finding peace with things that we have no control over and learning to move on without ever forgetting those that we lose.
This book became even more heartbreaking due to the fact that this was based on the real story of the author’s best friend losing her son in the exact same way as Sam dies in this book.
It’s not a happy book, but it was beautifully written and I do recommend both young readers and adults read it, and to pay very close attention to the ending and explanation of what happened, because so many more deaths can be prevented if people just pay a little bit more attention to these situations.
I think this book will stay with me for a very long time and I will likely re-read it from time to time, as I do believe you can learn something from it with each re-read and paying attention to certain details you may miss on a first read.
** TRIGGER WARNINGS: Suicide, Grief/Loss of a Loved One
#WinteroftheWolf #NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley, Greenleaf Audiobooks and, of course, the author Martha Hunt Handler for allowing me to listen to this story and experience.
TRIGGER WARNINGS: suicide, death of a loved one, death of an animal.
One of my goals for 2020 was to make my TBR more diverse. I began to realise how important it is to give the minorities more media representation and to normalise their existence. This book was a great pick, and I will tell you why.
As I wanted to start a new sewing project, I was looking for a short, yet compelling audiobook that can keep my mind occupied while my hands were working. Winter of the Wolf did just that. The audiobook had only six and a half hours, and it made me realise how important it is to try to seek the truth, even if it might seem as if it has to stay buried.
One of the best things about this book was the main character, Bean. Right from the very first page, you meet her, and you connect with her. She is devastated because of her brother's death, and she wants to find the answers that can lead her to the cause of his death. Everybody thinks Sam committed suicide, but Bean is sure he didn't. She knows him too well to believe that he did such a thing. The story is all about her and how she is searching for answers while learning about the Inuit culture.
FULL REVIEW ON MY BLOG: https://dailydooseofbooks.wordpress.com
In a day where people are more wary of the Planet and the danger the Human Race is to it, it’s always interesting to discover new cultures. The mystery is kept really well and the many twists keep you wanting to know what happened to the brother. Sad but realistic, this is a good story where they all find their way back to each other.
Despite swimming in grief, Bean is trying to solve the mystery behind her brother's suicide. It was completely out of character for him, and Bean is convinced he could not have taken his own life because of his Inuit beliefs. She also sees a lone wolf for months. Could this be her beloved brother?
I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Winter of the Wolf was an okay book. It will take you on an emotional ride and you will definitely learn some interesting things alone the way. In it, you will meet Bean and you will also find out that her brother Sam has died. No one knows what exactly happened but all signs lead to suicide at the moment. Of course, Bean doesn't think that's the truth and she is very determined to find out what really happened to her brother.
I will admit, learning about Sam along the way was pretty interesting. He was into a lot of things and hearing about how his family and friends could potentially feel or see his presence in an animal. It also made me pretty happy that they were talking about making him a totem pole just to honor him.
Then I got to the ending, and honestly - wow. I didn't know that whatever he was doing was a real thing. I'm also shocked with how many people have died doing this as well. I wasn't expecting this kind of ending at all but I am happy that they found out the truth.
Winter of the Wolf by Martha Hunt Handler and narrated by Kelly Pruner is a unique book.
Bean’s brother, Sam dies. Everyone believes it is suicide except Bean who tries to find out what actually happened. Sam was very interesting in Inuit culture, and I enjoyed learning a little about Inuit culture.
Winter of the Wolf is a very emotional and tragic story. I enjoyed hearing about Bean interacting with her family and friends and how that changes throughout the book. Bean makes a lot of assumptions about others relationship with Sam and discovers she her opinions are not always correct. I really liked Bean.
I listened to the audiobook and enjoyed Martha Hunt Handler’s narration.
Thank you NetGalley and Greenleaf Audiobooks for Winter of the Wolf.
I enjoyed listening to the audiobook version of Winter If the Wolf. The story mainly focuses on the teenage sister, Bean, who lives with her parents and her three brothers. Sadly, her favorite brother is discovered hanging from a belt pulled tightly around his neck. I think the author does a fine job of dealing with death and grief. While the story mostly focused on Bean, I appreciated how the author also depicted the ways tragedy can affect all members in the family in ways not expected. I’ve heard it said, that everyone deals with grief in their own way. I think this story was written appropriately for the teens age group.
Fifteen-year-old Bean’s brother dies in an apparent suicide and their family is left shattered. Bean is convinced that because of Sam’s Inuit beliefs he would never have killed himself. In the aftermath, Bean tries to hold the family together while also trying to find out why her brother died.
What this book did well was to explore Bean’s bereavement and spiritual journey, which eventually leads her to peace. It is a very personal book for the author as it was written following the death of her best friend’s son and obviously deals with a sensitive issue. However, I think this is a book that will be enjoyed best by those who have lost someone and may take comfort from the spiritualism and positive messages.
I’m confused as to why this book is labelled as adult fiction and thriller – it is very firmly YA (and not really the kind of YA that appeals to older audiences) and there is a mystery but thriller is pushing it a bit. In a way, I saw this book as a kind of fictionalised self-help book; the kind of book for young people to be able to see themselves in and hopefully overcome a similar problem.
What I liked less about this book was that I never really felt like I knew the characters and the dialogue often felt stilted and forced. Perhaps this is what made me feel that the book was more of a self-help journey through bereavement than a novel.
Given the title and cover, I was waiting a long time for the wolf to make more of an appearance than it does. This particular mystery was solved when I discovered at the end that Martha Hunt Handler is president of the Wolf Conservation Center. This is not a criticism, but the wolf felt shoe-horned in; I wish the wolf had had a bigger part! Not only to do the title and cover (which is great) justice but for the Wolf Conservation Center.
Narration: I found the narrator to be average. Not the worst I’ve heard, but not the best. I had some trouble sometimes distinguishing between characters, especially in the dialogue between Bean and Julie.
In conclusion: I think this book could be a valuable tool for young people or families who have experienced loss and are open to spirituality. However, if you’re simply looking for a mystery or YA novel, this might not be the right fit for you.
Thank you #NetGalley for this Audio ARC of #WinterofTheWolf
*received audiobook from netgalley for honest review* .....well. if there was ever a book i could give 0 stars to, it would be this one. truly horrible just all the way round.
First off, the amount of gross appropriation that's just, so constant in this book is horrid. Why even out that it talks about Inuit Culture in the blurb when it really doesn't? this "Weird" white kid finds some books on their culture, appropriates it, like ALOT, like thats all he seems to do? Dies, and the whole rest of the book is about his sister, who is ngl using some weird words to describe her relationship with him, then doing the SAME thing to try to contact his spirit, shes helped by her best friend (who refers to herself as a witch tho jokingly i suppose) and her mother, who gives her a book of "Shaman rituals" for her daughter and friend to basically have a slumber party and "try it out" and try to talk to her dead brother. It very clear this book is wildly full of this, like its literally the main theme of the book, even with word choices thru the book, and its really annoying that what? no one who read this before it was published and said anything?! (but lets face it they probs didnt ask/ignored the ppl who said thing soo)
I also found the authors note very odd, ive read books with similar authors notes and it was always clear that like thats what the book was about? it was very unclear in this book and even when you found out how he really died its like a footnote? they family is like "oh. huh. no way. im at peace with it now tho bc like i seen his spirit animal" like wtf.
The author also repeated full sentences what seems like way too often. specifically the ones that end with "becasuse i dont want my mother to backtrack" or whatever, it took me 2hrs to finish this book (thank satan if it was longer i couldnt have done it tbh) and it was still annoying me.
Overall this book is nonstop culture appropriation, 0 stars, would not recommend.
I really enjoyed the book, right until the last two chapters. The writing was beautiful, even though the pace seemed slow at times, it didn't seem like much. But when I did reach the end I just couldn't get it off my mind, how Sam died and how everyone easily forgave Skip. I do get it why they did it but I couldn't feel like them and it bugged me a lot.
I get that the point of the good was to forgive and move on like Sam wanted but, it just seemed to easy I guess. Also, I loved how magic realism is part of the book but never quite hits the mark exclusively so it doesn't git in the genre.
The audiobook experience was really good, not only could I picture these characters better but also understood them easily.
(NON-SPOILER)
I am very disappointed in this book. It had started off pretty strong and I was interesting right away and wanted to know what was going on. Unfortunately that interest went away pretty quickly because it took so long for the actual plot to begin. I was 40 percent through the audio book before the plot truly began. Plus when the plot began there were random side-plots thrown in like a random mini romance that didn't go anywhere and was not needed.. Oh yeah did I forget to mention the mystery was never solved by the MC! Instead of the MC solving it, it was conveniently wrapped up in the end in a very unsatisfying way. The MC is a whole other story. I thought she was sweet and just traumatized in the beginning but then she became annoying and kept forgetting that other people have feelings too. I actually hated her a little by the end cause it felt like I was being forced to think she was a good person but then shown she was just a narcissist. My favorite character was the best friend but we only saw her when the plot was going no-where and she had to come and physically push it forward.
As for the native peoples rep/ Inuit rep I cant say if it was accurate or not as I fit into neither of those categories so I would check for other people's reviews for commentary on that.
Overall, I left this book very frustrated and wishing it has been done differently.
The audio book narrator did a good job though and I do not think my experience was hampered by the way I consumed the story.
In this book we follow Bean as she has to navigate grief at the loss of her brother and come to understand where her spirituality rests. She never fully agrees with the pronouncement of the cause of death of her brother, Sam. As she does some research on her brother's fascination with the Inuit culture, she tries to meld his beliefs with the reality of his death.
Overall an okay book for me. It's always interesting to learn more about a culture I don't know. It can definitely be hard for anyone with a trigger for suicide. While I understand the need to get awareness out on this specific topic (won't say exactly what it is to avoid spoilers), the journey to that understanding didn't flow well for me. It felt like two different books even at times.
Also, I did not like the narrator in this book. I might have liked this story better if I hadn't had the narrator's voice in my head.
Thank you NetGalley for an Advanced listening copy in exchange for an honest review.
Winter of the Wolf, by Martha Hunt Handler, narrated by Kelly Pruner.
This was a debut book by the author with all sales proceeds to go to the wolf conservation center (www.nywolf.org)! I was drawn to this book due to Midwestern location, the cover is awesome, the inclusion of the Inuit beliefs and that my nickname when I was a kid was Bean.
I was a little hesitant to read a book; Bean doesn't believe that her brothers death was suicide due to his adoption of Inuit beliefs. Most people (self included) want to put blinders on in regards to the topic of suicide. Regardless of how/why there is a suicide (including drug overdose/other, intentional or not) suicide rips a family apart and is devastating to everyone involved. It touches even those who only remotely knew the person.
In the slightest way, this book reminded me of A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson in that a female high schooler is investigating a closed police investigation.
The narrators "dialog voice" for Bean did not match the character and that disappointed me; otherwise the narration was very good.
In my opinion the book ended a bit too abruptly. This book was read courtesy of NetGalley Advance Read Copy; thank you to the author/Martha Hunt Handler. Its possible that the copy reviewed will be edited before final publication.
The Winter of the Wolf is a story about the tragic and untimely death of a teenage boy and how his family and friends work towards grieving and eventually accepting his loss.
17 year old Sam Kane's body is found in his room by his mother in an apparent suicide. Sam loved and had a strong belief in the Inuit culture and customs and lived his life according to those beliefs. He was a strong, fearless, intelligent, kind, spiritual person with a deep understanding, love and appreciation for Nature and everything that inhabited it. He loved life and wanted to experience everything that life and the world had to offer. He was in no way a depressed soul, hence, his apparent suicide comes as a shock to his family but they eventually learn to accept it. All except his 14 year old sister and soul mate Bean, whose intuition and heart refuses to believe that Sam could have killed himself. She is also upset that her father and two older brothers, seem to have easily moved on from this tragedy, while her mother has become a shell of her personality. So on her 15th birthday, Bean and her best friend Julie make a pact and decide to dig deeper. Using Sam's Inuit beliefs as a main guidance, they question family and friends, go through his belongings and even perform a Shamanic ritual to find out what exactly happened. Along with the closure she eventually gets, Bean also comes to accept as a certainty (something that she has constantly and intuitively felt) that even though Sam's physical journey in this world has come to an end, his spirit is still very much alive and thriving. She also realises that she has been unfair in her assessment of her family's reaction to this tragedy--every person has his/her own personal way of coping with tragedies. Through dialogue, they learn to appreciate and celebrate Sam's life and his achievements in its entirety, and appreciate each other, with the result that by the end of the book, the Kane family are much closer and happier as a family than they have ever been.
For me, the character that stood out was Sam. Even though he is alive for only a few pages, his strong, intense personality shines through which only gets stronger as each character reminisces about him later on. The writing and language is simple but very emotional and my favourite parts are definitely the chapters describing the Inuit's culture, Shamanism and the Shamanic ritual that Bean and Julie perform at the end to get in touch with Sam's spirit. Even though it's not my belief system, it was still very interesting to read about and the author manages to explain complex ideas about this native Indian culture in a manner that is easy to understand.
My thanks to NetGalley, the publishers Greenleaf Book Group and Greenleaf Audio and the author Martha Hunt Handler for both an e-ARC and audio-ARC of this book. I both read and listened to the book. The audio is narrated by Kelly Pruner and she has done a fine job. There is both crispness and clarity in her voice and pronunciation and I didn't have any problems with the new audio format that NetGalley has introduced.
P. S.: I am not sure if my review does any justice to the book, but it is worth a read.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review. It has been published in July 2020.
"Winter of the Wolf" by Martha Hunt Handler is a heart-wrenching story about grief, loss and bereavement, but also about family ties, the strength of friendship and the importance of our relationship with nature and with the world around us.
Bean, the protagonist, is coming of age in the shadow of her brother's supposed suicide. The novel follows her search for the truth and for a way to make sense of this tragedy in the months after Sam's death.
I really enjoyed the characters - so well-rounded that they just come alive in front of your eyes - and the plot, which is surprisingly full of twists and big reveals.
The language and style are perfect for the narration, very true to the character of a mourning 15-year-old girl.
The themes are darker than what you would generally expect from a YA novel (suicide, mental illness, sex, drugs, occultism), but they're handled in a very sensitive way, so kudos to the author for managing that near-impossible feat.
Overall, "Winter of the Wolf" comes across as a story about resilience and the rebuilding of severed relationships, rather than as a story about grief.
1.5/5 Stars
Reasons why I picked up this book:
-Inuit Representation
-Thriller
-Spiritual Actualization
-Dead Twin
Reasons why this book didn't live up to my expectations
-The representation wasn't bad, but it was a white boy who really loved this culture that wasn't his own. I think it's important to have characters like this but having a character who was actually Inuit as well would have been nice
-Not at all thriller, much closer to murder mystery/general fiction. Nothing was spooking or suspenseful, I didn't find any reason to want to keep listening
-All of the characters are way to open to questions. The main girl asks then stuff surrounding this murder and people just tell her, no pushing or lying to themselves about the truth
-Everyone is into character that has nothing going for them. We also fall into the age old characters aren't like normal people their age
-The character's weren't actually twins...
-The plot was too slow, and underdeveloped. I think the story could have picked up much sooner to make the mystery more real, and then had more suspenseful narrative development
I think if they had marked this as a story of grief and loss, most of my complaints would be gone, and my rating would be a lot higher - because that is what this story really is, a family getting over the loss of one of the children
Thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
Thank you to NetGalley, Martha Hunt Handler, Greenleaf Book Group Press, and Greenleaf Audiobooks for the opportunity to listen to Winter of the Wolf in exchange for an honest review.
Initially, I requested this audiobook for two reasons:
1) I love Inuit culture. I did a report on it in 5th grade after visiting Alaska and I currently incorporate Inuit mythology and language into my own writing.
2) I wanted to try out NetGalley’s new app, NetGalley Shelf. Reading on there seems okay, but I wanted to see how this whole audiobook thing worked (not well).
I enjoy listening to audiobooks in the car, while playing games, or while grading papers. I listened to the majority of this one while playing Minecraft. I had a lot of trouble with the app in terms of getting the book to download properly, having it lose my place, having to re-download because the download failed so many times …it was a bit of a mess. But hey, it’s a new thing, and it will improve! (The publisher sent me the e-book version as well so I could cross-reference and go back and see if I missed anything or just to reread a certain part).
Regardless, I found the talents of narrator Kelly Pruner to be absolutely fantastic. She has a great reading voice and really added to Bean’s character. Bean is a fifteen-year-old girl living in the states. After her brother’s supposed suicide, Bean and her friend dig a bit deeper, as that was just not the way Sam was at all. Her older brother, Sam, loved Inuit culture and wanted to have a burial in the way of that tribe. One of my draws to this book was the Inuit culture. While there were some interesting elements laced in, it felt like the cultural aspect fell a little flat and wasn’t quite fulfilled for Sam’s character the way it could have been.
Bean and her family deal with this loss, among the daily high school life of drama and friendship. I felt like the book ended in the wrong place, that it needed just a few more chapters. It is rather short, less than three hundred pages and about a six-hour listen. I enjoy the voice and writing style. When I look at the cover, I lean more towards children’s rather than young adult, but the tone and feel are definitely in the young adult category, addressing serious issues that many young adults face, such as dealing with the loss of a loved one, suicide, and family.
I enjoyed this book, but would caution who I recommend it to, as the wrong reader might struggle with some of the presented topics. I would certainly buy this book for myself or a friend, though I am not so sure about using NetGalley’s audiobook app again…^_^’
This book was bad. I finished it because I needed to know how bad. Cultural appropriation that goes unaddressed, poor writing ("I couldn't prolong this any longer"), teen characters that act like middle schoolers and talk like adults, and much more.
The story is about Bean and her family dealing with her brother Sam's apparent death by suicide. She and her mother were very close to Sam and are wrecked by his death. Bean refuses to believe it is a suicide and decides to do some amateur sleuthing with her best friend Julie.
All throughout, Bean talks about how Sam was really into "Inuit stuff" and Inuit beliefs-- most notably the mixing of ones blood with that of an animal one has killed. This feels like the only thing the author actually researched about Inuit belief systems and the rest of the book just seems to use it as a cool characteristic for Sam, and a plot point for overcoming grief. I was incredibly disappointed that there was no author's note or other information to shed some respect on the culture that is so blatantly used by white people in this book. There was an authors note, but SPOILER ALERT, it was about the dangers of Auto-erotic asphyxia which is was killed Sam (and sadly, the author's friend's son).
Bean's voice was both melodramatic to the point of feeling more like middle grade fiction, while at the same time her dialogue was what you would expect coming out of an adult's mouth. They also use the word shit profusely.
The narration was okay. It was really hard to tell Julie and Bean apart during dialog because they sounded almost exactly the same. It also sounded like sentence attributions were just copied and pasted to the end of pre recorded dialog.
Thank you Net Galley for a copy of this audio book. This book gripped me from the very start and I listened to it in one sitting. The concepts of what happens after death enlightened me, made me hopeful. Beautiful book.
Winter of the Wolf is written in the perspective of Bean Hanes. It starts off with a completely normal day, except for the fact that Bean felt like something was gonna go wrong that day. As the day progresses, Sam, her beloved older brother, meets an untimely death that looks to be a suicide. Bean, knowing her brother, believed that he would never do this and so she tries her best to find out what happened.
I appreciate how the author handled the deeper themes of loss, grief, and healing. Throughout the novel, we see how this tragic event can break a family, but also how they can learn to move on and heal rather than remain stuck in that dark mental state. And while I did believe the portrayals of grief and the actions it causes one to take, I thought it was interesting how everyone allowed Bean to do what she did. The consequences of her actions were really 50/50 like it could have led her down a dark path where she was just 100% convinced Sam would never commit suicide and wouldn't be able to move on from it or she would have been able to move on. However, I did appreciate how realistic this portrayal is of Bean's different stages of grief.