Member Reviews

Beautifully illustrated graphic novel that takes the reader inside the writer’s emotional world through the seasons.

I enjoyed the portrayal of nature, the author herself, and social media. This book will make those who experience seasonal affective disorder feel less alone.

The book explores the concept of loneliness, and how even if one knows intellectually that others are lonely, it is still a difficult experience. In addition, the book describes the demand for productivity and the struggle to manage season-based moods and these demands.

The book has an almost dreamlike quality that is perfect to let the reader slow down and look within.

Thanks to NetGalley and Randomhouse Publishing Group for the ARC of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

**I received an e-copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.**

Unfortunately I did not really connect with this book. It seemed like a spiral into seasonal depression and its symptoms. I did not feel like there was much of story beyond that. Some of the art was very pretty but that's really not enough for me.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this book, and found myself just enjoying the beautiful art for the most part. It’s short, simple, and more of a poem than a story. I think certain people will really enjoy this book, but it unfortunately wasn’t for me.

Was this review helpful?

This book is absolutely gorgeous - the art is amazing and it had a beautiful flow through the seasons. It was a very honest look at anxiety and depression over the seasons and it was a very real portrayal. The only thing I struggled with a little bit was that everything appeared fixed and anew but nothing had changed other than a season, and it mentioned that they were able to be ready for the next year, but nothing really new happened and I think sometimes mental health needs a little more work. But, I'm not the author and it could be a very real situation. It is beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

First thing's first: Thank you NetGalley and Penguin House for allowing me to read and review this AMAZING graphic novel.


I love that this book is illustrated, because word's just aren't enough to describe any mental health. The fact that Thapp created the evolution of anxiety (and what seemed like depression) through seasons really resonated with me. Not just because people tend to feel blue when the weather is cold, but because I believe we as individuals have our own seasons. I loved that before she got into each season had little "notes" about the season, like prequel to the stage of anxiety we were about to enter. There is a poetic tone to all the words. And I love how they are intentionally placed in the illustrations.

I cannot say enough how much this book resonated with me. I haven't read anything else by Thapp, but now I really want to.

I'm so getting my hands on a physical copy when it comes out in March.

For my full review, please visit my GoodReads Page (Link below):
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/3587071721

#Feelings #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful way to represent anxiety. I personally really related to this and as someone with anxiety and seasonal depression. This was just beautifully told in my opinion, so simple but so impactful.

Was this review helpful?

A Beautifully illustrated book that guides you through the 4 seasons of “feelings”. Every season has deep meaningful quotes that will flood your soul. Breathe in Breathe out “ I don’t need to break myself apart to fit anyone’s shadow”.

Was this review helpful?

i loved this! i requested it because i’ve followed manjit thapp on instagram for a while now and love her art. this was so lovely, the art is so beautiful and it all really resonated with mr and my current feelings.

Was this review helpful?

Feelings is a poignant graphic novel that explores the author's challenges with anxiety and depression throughout the seasons. The illustrations are beautifully rendered and through the color palettes and expressive character development, the reader gets the sense of how the author is feeling. I think that many people will be able to see their own experiences with anxiety disorders and seasonal affective disorder reflected in the book.

Advanced copy provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I've loved Thapp's illustrations for a while, and I was very excited to see that she was releasing a full-length graphic novel. The artwork throughout this book was absolutely beautiful. Each page felt stunning enough on its own that I could have printed them and hung them up on my walls. The text is poetic and lovely, but I found myself a little uninterested in what was written and caught up in the images instead. I honestly think this book could have had no words and I still would have loved it and taken away the same message from the illustrations. So gorgeous!!

Was this review helpful?

I think this may be my favourite graphic /visual memoir I've read this year, and I'm shocked to admit this. In receiving an eARC copy, in return I'm giving an honest review. This was probably one of the most lyrical and visually graphic biographies I read. The aesthetic backed by colour palette and the lyrical prose which was poetic helped to tie in the conceptual ideas of the story. I don't think I've ever felt this engaged in a graphic visual and the storytelling was compelling and relatable. It was so cool how innovative she took a classic metaphor of feelings to seasons and made something new out of it. I don't think I've ever connected to similar feelings as the season changed. I highly recommend this read if you're looking for something that is poignant and poetic.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully written and beautifully illustrated. It is so easy to connect with the author and how her feelings, emotions, and anxieties change throughout the seasons.

Was this review helpful?

what a simple, colorful book yet so impactful. With so much emotion, I quickly ate it up and will happily come back to it again and again.

Was this review helpful?

"Feelings" is a stunning musing on the author's self through the seasons, as both as a person and as an artist. While it is a personal story of thoughts from Summer to all the way to Spring and leading into the following summer, it is also incredibly universal to any reader. I loved the lyrical yet succinct way that these feelings were encapsulated in the piece. I related to it in so many ways and it's certainly a work that I would like to revisit as the seasons change. The illustrations are absolutely beautiful and I loved the shifting color palette as the story shifted through the different seasons. Overall, I really enjoyed this book and I look forward to seeing what else Manjit Thapp creates!

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful book, not only the illustrations, but also the journey she takes you on through the seasons of depression, which also often match up with the seasons of the year for many of us. Manjit captures that feeling of darkness where it feels like the sun won’t come out again, and as we emerged into spring I could feel the warmth in her art.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for the advanced e-copy. I'll look forward to seeing this in print!

This was so soothing and great!! In Feelings: A Story in Seasons, Manjit Thapp takes us through a woman’s emotional journey over the course of a year. We are creatively told the story of someone’s experience with anxiety as the seasons change. The beautiful art helps to create a continuous narrative, with changing color palettes to fit the season. The illustrations often connect emotions and weather: for example, on a winter night, her fears are illustrated as cycling through her head as the moon reaches higher and higher in the sky.
On some of the pages, I was briefly confused about which line to read next (since it occasionally went from reading left to right on one page to reading each column top to bottom on the next), but this was easy enough to sort out.
This colorful book is full of a lot of big feelings, and will be a nice validating comfort read for those who have experienced mental health problems or even just seasonal mood changes.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful book that follows a version of the author through a year of feelings. The different seasons are represented through the life cycle of flowers as well as the color choices in each section. There isn't a lot of prose which allows the images to tell the story as much if not more than the words. Worth a read for the art.

Was this review helpful?

This book was expertly crafted, I enjoyed the colors, the moods correlating with the seasons and the layout of each drawing.

Was this review helpful?

Feelings by Manjit Thapp is a beautiful and atmospheric exploration of human emotion as seen through the passing of seasons. Thapp brings readers into her world beginning with summer. She depicts the life of an artist also working a day job, struggling with creative block, anxiety, and juggling a social life. Thapp’s art is stunning and her use of color is mesmerizing. She portrays the change in weather, seasons, and emotions with ease. Though each season has its struggles, autumn and winter in particular seem to be times of depression and anxiety for Thapp. Her writing is poetic and lovely. A quick read that will leave readers poring over the illustrations.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful, moody graphic novel exploring the impact of the seasons on both the protagonist and, so some extent, the broader world. Elements of this work ring remarkably true.

Was this review helpful?