Member Review

As someone who enjoys multi-generational novels, I was looking forward to reading this book detailing the lives of families in a small coastal town on Maine’s Northern Reach. I read the first chapter enjoying the writer’s vivid descriptions of Wellbridge, Maine, and the women grieving the unexpected deaths of two family members. Winslow’s word pictures made it easy to envision the characters in the setting, and I eagerly anticipated learning more about this family and its common acquaintances.

Unfortunately, the depictions grew less interesting as the book went on. The descriptive prose was still wonderful, but the plot and characterizations were not. There was little character development as the characters in each chapter made the same mistakes as those before. Winslow offered little insight after presenting each scenario, with major events sprouting from previous stories thrown in as a casual aside. We meet characters, we see short snippets of their lives, and then abruptly change to a different family and different generations.

Winslow’s descriptions of people and places left me eager for more but left hanging in the breeze more often than not. I hope that in future works the author will continue to create interesting characters and develop them in a way that lets the reader become fully engaged in their circumstances.

Thanks to NetGalley and Flatiron Books for providing me an advanced review copy in exchange for an honest review.