Member Reviews

"Oh my heart, at last, I can read it!" was what I thought when I received this book, and what a lovely book it was! And I'm not talking about the gorgeous cover, but about the very sweet story that I have been waiting to read for years! I am very fond of the Jonquil brothers, and I couldn't wait to "meet" their parents in their youth.

Although Lucas was not quite the perfect gentleman one would expect from reading about him in the Jonquil series (he really is a dunderhead!), I still very much enjoyed discovering his character which encompasses his (future) sons' personalities (and understanding where some of his sons' names come from, too). The book was also full of a multitude of references to the Jonquil series, be it through references to places, people, or phrases. It was also a pleasure to discover Julia in her youth, the little spitfire who grew up to be a kind and forgiving lady. I wish, however, that the book would have been a tiny bit longer to develop our two protagonists' personalities, as Sarah M. Eden did in her Jonquil series - here, the personalities were a bit less deep and I sometimes struggled to understand what was going on in their heads. I also wonder if a couple of sentences might have been missing from their dialogues (which sometimes felt unnatural) as I read an advanced copy of the book?
I also find that the summary of the book emphasises too much the losses Lucas and Julia have been through, when the book doesn't dig much deeper into it, except for the feeling of abandonment Julia feels. The story is very much focused on Julia learning to trust that Lucas will not abandon her again, and Lucas making a mess of things, as Jonquils are bound to do!

After reading the book, I still have a few remaining questions: why does Julia not stay in touch with the other Gents in the Jonquil brothers series (makes us wonder what happens to the Gents...)? What happens to Adam (I don't remember him being especially close to Julia in the Lancaster or Jonquil series...)? Why is she called Julia when her full name is "Caroline Julia Cummings"?

Overall, a very sweet romance that I very much enjoyed. I am very much looking forward to discovering the other Gents' stories!

**I received an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion**

Was this review helpful?

A lovely, enchanting start to a new series from Sarah M. Eden! Deeply emotional and stirring, fans of Eden’s Jonquil Brothers series won’t want to miss Forget Me Not. This story showed a more fun side of the Georgian era—who knew lords and ladies played hide-and-seek?!—and the characters are all wonderfully written. I cannot wait to read the rest of the Gents’ stories! 4.5/5 stars

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I had trouble wrapping my mind around the amount of loss Julia suffered. She had very good reason to have developed abandonment issues, given that the one person left to her, apart from her father, chose to leave her and made no effort maintain any kind of relationship with her.

*SPOILERS*
To be honest, the more the story went on and more arguments were made that he had always cared and thought of her non-stop, the less believable I found it. If he really talked about her, worried about her, shared stories and memories all the time... he would have written, or tried to see her, or picked up souvenirs and sent them to her, etc. <i> anything at all </i> over the past 8 years.

*More SPOILERS*
And I found her father's character inconsistent. I got the impression that he did little-to-nothing over the years to coax her out of pain and isolation. Then he got rather heavy handed, treated her coldly, and let her go. No further efforts on his part. Then he runs to her, crying and welcoming her back and allows her to stay indefinitely. He actually tells Lucas that if she doesn't want to speak to Lucas, he will have to honor her wishes. What? The time period and the father in question would more likely have refused her sanctuary to begin with. At the very least, would have told her she belongs to her husband now and needed to find a way to make it work.

I thought the concept of the gents was very sweet. I loved how her brother Stanley had been intertwined in the group. It lent credence to the way they embraced her so thoroughly immediately. Though I wished there had really only been showing (rather than telling) of each of their characters, and though I found too much similarity between the gents (which is supposed to be a new, different series, despite this being a prequel of the former series) and the Jonquil brothers, I was intrigued enough by each of them to look forward to their stories.

I think my biggest trouble was the sadness book-ending this story. I felt so badly for Julia, for everything she had gone through. For what seemed like endless suffering. And knowing what is awaiting her in the future made it hard for me let my guard down too, to be happy for her. It was bittersweet.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first book by this author. I was looking forward to reading a book set in the 1700's and I have heard good things about this author.
This book has a light feel to it. I was really put off by the heroine for the first half of the book, then things got better. Then I was put off by the hero.......I really didn't like how the book was resolved. I felt like based on the actions of both parties I just didn't feel the love. This is a clean historical romance.
It was a sweet story if you are looking for a less then serious romance. It just left me feeling "meh" nothing bad , just okay.
I recieved a copy of this book from the publisher through Netgally all of my opinions are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

Six gentlemen...the best of friends...each so different from the other...all of which are single...at least at the beginning. This was a wonderfully creative idea for a new series by Sarah M. Eden. Readers will quickly become fond of the "gents" and will root for them the whole way through. This first installment tells the story of Julia and Lucas (the first of the "gents"). This is a slow burn romance that is both light and sweet. The cover is gorgeous! I give it 3.5 stars. I'm glad I read this book, and look forward to continuing the series. Who will the next gent be? Maybe Kes?

Was this review helpful?

Ah, Sarah Eden. Thank you for another sweet story. Julia Cummings has been neighbors with Lucas Jonquil her whole life. While nine years his junior, she managed to always insert herself with all this adventures he went on with her older brother. Once Lucas came of age, he moved away and didn't see Julia for eight years. From disease and war, they both lost loved ones and Julia had closed off her heart to any that could break it again by leaving her. Lucas, on the other hand, was determined to live his life to the fullest for all those he lost.

When Lucas returns to his parent's home the two are thrown together in a betrothal neither of them saw coming. With heavy doubts in both their minds, but a clever group of Lucas' friends in tow, they must overcome and hopefully find love.

This is a really fun book. I love how clean the love story is, but still just as sweet. The humor is great and I loved all the characters in this one. I look forward to more of her books!

Thank you NetGalley and Covenant Communications for an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"Forget Me Not" is a historical romance, which is one of my favorite genres. I was very excited to read this book by Sarah Eden. Julia and Lucas grew up together and were best friends. They went through the losses of several family members together, and Julia thought they were growing closer. Unfortunately, Lucas had just one goal in mind: to travel the world. When his parents arrange a marriage for him (with Julia) to help him grow up and start to settle down, Julia believes that maybe he will finally begin to love her. Unfortunately, I couldn't root for these two and their relationship. Lucas was thoughtless and selfish, and Julia was a pushover and would hold grudges. I thought this book was well written, but the relationship was not something I enjoyed.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I have been finding many "new author's to me" lately, and I am delighted to have found Sarah Eden, author of Forget Me Not, the first book in The Gents series.

Julia Cummings has known a great deal of loss, and so has her childhood friend Lucas Jonquil. However, they both dealt with their losses quite differently. With a nine-year age gap between them, Lucas vows to enjoy life to the fullest to honour the loss of his friend Stanley, Julia's brother. And so he leaves home to travel to all the places Stanley will never see and to enjoy all the adventures Stanley will never have.

While Lucas views his departure from home as a great adventure, Julia views it as abandonment. Everyone she loves has died and leaves her alone, but she looks forward to the promise of Lucas' letters. Unfortunately, Lucas never writes. So she deals with her grief and her loss by isolating herself in her home and stepping away from society. Her heart grows cold toward Lucas, and when he suddenly returns home, he is stumped as to why she appears to hate him.

If this book is anything, it is a lesson for men everywhere to pay attention to their words and actions. Sadly, Lucas did neither where Julia was concerned. When their parents sprang their betrothal on them at a very public event, it worsened their situation.

Thank goodness for the gents! I can't wait to hear their stories in future books to come. With their help, both Julia and Lucas learn how to be friends again, and more importantly, they learn to love.

The only thing disappointing about this book was its total lack of Christian content. Not one word. And yet it is listed as Christian fiction. The themes of trust and forgiveness, which are in the book, would have been amplified if Jesus had been brought into the mix. Sadly, he wasn't. Hence the four stars.

Knowing this, I will still be reading the rest of this series. Ms. Eden is a fine writer and crafts a fascinating tale of clean historical fiction. I look forward to her next book!

This book was provided courtesy of Covenant Communications through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Eden’s writing has a way of making the world just kind of melt away while the reader is transported to another time period. This first book in her new “The Gents” series was enjoyable and had much of the humor and wit that I have come to love from her writing. Admittedly, Julia was a hard character for me to like. I felt as though she held on to her bitterness for an extremely long portion of the story. It became a bit taxing and repetitive at points that the same conflict was being presented over and over again, and I felt it became a bit childish of her. However, the moment “The Gents” arrive on the scene this book really took a turn for the better and it was flowing with humor and wit. I enjoyed Lucas’s character and the interaction between him and his friends was my favorite part of this book. Even though Julia was a difficult character, I did enjoy this book immensely and cannot wait to see where this series goes as it features this group of friends!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fabulous book. Having read so many of her previous works, this was equally as wonderful. I will admit that I cried through most of it knowing what her future would bring. The storyline was tragic while still being so positive.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this story, the characters, the arranged marriage, but my only complaint was the immaturity of both of the main characters. If Julia is 20, smart enough to teach herself difficult mathematic equations, and Lucas is 29, well-traveled and well-educated, they should not have had so much trouble. But of course, we must have trouble for the story.

I was provided with an ARC of this book by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

While I can see Eden's appeal, I'm afraid this book just wasn't for me. I think it's a personal taste thing, but I always have an issue when an older man knows a girl as a child and then falls in love with her when she's suddenly!pretty. The writing is undeniably strong here, but I just couldn't get into the characters. Lucas was deliberately obtuse and Julia spent most of the book being whiny. I'd be interested to read something else by Eden with different characters and a different core trope.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! I was so excited to discover the back story behind the parents of the Jonquil brothers. Eden introduces a cast of characters that you can't help falling in love with. The Gents are the brothers that everyone wishes they had. Their camaraderie, loyalty, and love for each other is endearing.
It was so sweet to see how Lucas and Julia's relationship develops! Her feelings of loneliness and fear and his feelings of confusion and frustration were very relatable. This book really brought home the truth that relationships and trusting others can be scary and it's hard work, but in the end it's worth every effort. This is definitely one of my new favorites!

Was this review helpful?

What an enchanting novel! I have not read Sarah Eden before, but I cannot wait to have more in this series! What a breath of fresh air that this couple works together and is honest with one another instead of playing word games or mind games. I liked the comradery between the gents and with Julia. I cannot impress upon you enough to give this book a try, but I will warn you, it may rob you of sleep!

Thank you to Convenant Communications and NetGalley for an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Eden with her superb storytelling skills has penned a delightfully romantic narrative to launch her The Gents series. Her attention to detail evidences her extensive research. An arranged marriage between two estranged childhood friends, Lucas who craves travel and adventure in order to live life to its fullest and Julia who prefers home and “quieter pursuits”, forces them to pursue forgiveness and trust on their way to finding lasting love and happiness if such can be found with their differences. The well-structured plot moves at a steady pace, the characters are well-crafted and realistic, and the witty banter adds to the enjoyment of the read. The Gents--Digby, Kes, Henri, Aldric, and Niles--who come to help Lucas “fix” his marriage are delightfully entertaining. The author describes them this way: “All the Gents were intriguing and congenial in their own ways. What a fascinating group they made.” This emotionally rich read will make you laugh and perhaps make you cry! I thoroughly enjoyed this book and look forward to seeing and hearing more about the Gents!

I received a copy of this book in e-book form from the publisher via netgalley but am under no obligation to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Forget Me Not? HOW COULD I EVER FORGET A BOOK LIKE THIS?!

I've read the Jonquil Brothers series right before reading this book so everything is fresh in my mind. I'm in love.

Young Mater isn't how I expected her to be, she's even better. And Lucas is definitely an idiot at times (how could he be so oblivious to Julia's loneliness?) but he's lovely as well (when he comes to his senses).

The merry band of gentlemen who come to the rescue when all seems lost is the best part. I'm looking forward to reading more about them.

I really love the little things, from the names to the character traits that seem to be passed down from generation to generation.

The writing was devilishly good and took me on a roller coaster ride that I never want to get off of. What a way to start a new series! But how will I survive till the next book?

5 out of 5 stars for this hearwarming (and heartbreaking) masterpiece. Sarah M. Eden, you can steal my heart with your books anytime.

*Huge thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

Nottinghamshire, 1785
Julia Cummings has long been acquainted with loss-her mother, her brother, her sister, her friend, all gone too soon. But the loss that pushed her grief to the limit as a young girl was that of her best friend, Lucas Jonquil, who abandoned her without looking back. Now, eight years later, Lucas has returned to Lampton Park, and Julia has steeled herself-she will never forgive the man who broke her heart. After losing too many of his friends and family to early deaths, Lucas vowed to live life to the fullest. And after traversing the world for eight years, he has returned from his adventures to find his family and home as he left them-except for Julia. The little girl he left behind has blossomed into a captivating lady. With little hope of reconciliation, the former friends are blindsided when their parents make a shocking announcement. Lucas and Julia have been betrothed without their knowledge and are to marry immediately. Now Lucas must rely on the help of his closest friends to win the heart of a lady who loathes him-a lady he’s coming to love more deeply every day.
The start of a new series & a lovely start it is. Whilst it introduces the six Gents who have been close friends since attending Eton it also tells the story of Luca & Julia parents of the Jonquil siblings we didn’t learn much about Lucas in the series so I just loved that they’ve had their story & it makes me want to reread the Jonquil series. A well written book with misunderstandings & to some extent the selfishness of Lucas who wanted to live his life to the full & he didn’t realise how much he hurt Julia at times. I also loved how the other Gents were introduced & I look forward to their stories
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read

Was this review helpful?

Forget Me Not is a heart-wrenching story of forced matrimony, feelings of abandonment, and childhood friends to true romance. I cried, I laughed, and I didn't want the story to end. Julia Cummings is a fiery character with determination to be her own person while Lucas Jonquil is determined to live life as it is meant to be lived. Jonquil has some great ideas but is definitely a dunderhead. Sarah Eden was able to pull me into the story so that I wanted to knock Lucas over the head.

This story is another Sarah success. The highs and lows were entwined as the characters were reunited and found their way in a marriage they didn't want. This was such a perfect story to introduce Mater and her love story along with a new series without overshadowing the beloved Jonquil brothers saga.

Was this review helpful?

Geeezzzzz.....Sarah sure knows how to pull at the heartstrings. This is a beautiful story about the power of love and how it can heal a broken heart. This sweet girl just had it rough but don't all Eden's characters. This was not as sad or depressing as other books by Eden have been. It did have a feeling of lightness a little like the Jonquil boys gave us. This is just the beginning of a series (I hope) of the Gents. Lucas Jonquil is the idiot leading man and the Jester of the gang of 6 men who grew up together. They come to his rescue as he tries to save his marriage. Loved the whole arranged marriage story:} So fun. My only issue with this book was the negative repetition of thoughts by Julia. Way too many times we heard about her loss and sadness and how he left her behind. If I was her editor I would have only added that 2 times. Over all a very sweet, loving story. Very Edenesque:}

Was this review helpful?

Another winner from Sarah M Eden!

For those who have read her series on the Jonquil brothers, you will love learning this piece of their history. For those of you who haven't yet, this book is a great place to start!

I found it easy to relate to and understand Julia right from the start. Her struggles and loneliness seemed very real, and her spunkiness made her very likeable.

Although they were minor characters, Lucas' parents reminded me of his sons, and it was great to see that having a sense of humor has been part of the family for generations.

Lucas... for the most part he was a likeable character. One of the biggest points in his favor is that he has chosen honest friends who have no reservations about telling him when he is being idiotic. It speaks to his strength of character and humility that he is willing to listen to them, though it still seemed to take forever for the things they were telling him to truly sink in.

I would have liked to see Lucas be willing to be more vulnerable; it seemed as though Julia was always the one willing to try this, despite having been hurt so many times before.

I did find it difficult to swallow my disbelief at the actions of their parents in the beginning; would truly loving parents who had the strong relationships with their children that these parents appear to have REALLY make such a monumental decision without at least informing their children? I don't think so.

But that aside, I loved this book and cannot recommend it highly enough.

Was this review helpful?