Member Reviews

This was a cute story about siblings finding out more about their mother's past. I liked the art and I liked the way the story went, but I would have loved to learn a bit more about the story overall. There might be another volume coming, but personally I'd just have a longer first volume with more story than short and quick volumes.

Was this review helpful?

The Gremillet Sisters is a small and beautiful tale of a family of three sisters and their mother. The three children are quite different from each other which makes it quite a task to get along, but they try to and love each other. Lush settings and sisterly quibbles abound. However, Sarah is haunted by dreams which she realizes are significant when she discovers an old photo of their mother.
The artwork is beautiful and the reader is swept along with the story. The plot builds well reaching a climax with Lucille's disappearance.
I would recommend this to slightly older children, maybe past the age of 12, who can appreciate and understand the writing and some of the topics better than their younger counterparts (The book is tinged with some pain and melancholy dealing with the mother's past)
I would like to repeat that I loved the art and the natural dialogue and am waiting to read the rest of the series!

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful little story about sisterhood, family, and secrets. It was a very pleasant read, with gorgeous illustrations.

Was this review helpful?

4 1/5 stars. The concept and art work are beautiful. I loved the story of sisterhood. There are no others words to explain the book , other than I loved it to the core.

The half star deduction is for story , it could've been longer but may be it is kept in store for next volumes. I am still in the memories of the beautiful art work.

Thank you NetGalley, Publication and Author for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is a sweet graphic novel about sisterhood, family and uncovering secrets. The art style is gorgeous and the layout of images and texts makes the story easy to read and follow. I loved the dynamic of the three sisters - their relationship felt very real and I think readers with siblings will be able to relate to the characters easily. I was disappointed by the reveal of the family secret as I felt the story and illustrations set it up to be a magical/mystical reveal, which it isn't - there is no magical element to this book. But overall, I enjoyed the art style, the characters and family dynamic portrayed in the story.

Was this review helpful?

A Family Secret

The illustrations in this book are beautiful at times, in particular the jellyfish forest that opens up the book and is seen later. As one of five sisters myself, I'm always drawn to books about sisters, and this one did not disappoint. Sister Sarah is having recurring dreams about a jellyfish forest and a magical treehouse with a room for her mother, but she always wakes up at the same point, never finding out more. When Sarah and her mother are talking the next morning, Mom escapes quickly after Sarah asks if her favorite animal as a child was a jellyfish. But it makes her, and then her sisters, curious enough to try to figure out what secret their mother might be hiding. They start exploring and find something that adds to the mystery. When the mother is asked about it, her secret comes to light. The book certainly surprised me, starting with such a whimsical, fantasy setting that turned out to be a dream but then pivoting to a family mystery and drama, which was a pleasant surprise. For a book that is essentially a “comic” book, it has surprising heart. I loved each of the very different sisters, and the author did a good job distinguishing them and making them feel like real girls and bickering sisters! I look forward to future books about these young ladies.

Was this review helpful?

This was a nice quick graphic novel. It does deal with some serious topics, but does it in a way that I feel will not overwhelm a younger audience. The art style wasn't my taste but I believe children will enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

First off the art work is stunning!!! This was such a beautiful story of love and loss! I can't wait for a second volume and see where these sisters go next!

Was this review helpful?

Entertaining and visually impressive, this still felt a little slight. I guess it's suited more for a younger audience, and it certainly features lots of youths – our leads are three girls, in fact, of the typically bickering sort. In some unconfirmed, generic European city, one of them is constantly waking up at the same place in a dream featuring the girls floating through greenery with jellyfish, and finding their mother. A discovery at home hints at a secret in the mother's past – but she's not telling. I think what lets this down a little is that, while it's billed as part one of a series, it's a self-contained story, and while I was enjoying the build-up I didn't realise we'd get a proper resolution within these covers. As a result, investing in the book (and trying to both like and distinguish the annoyingly yacky, tacky girls) as I was, the ending seemed a little rushed. The artwork isn't good enough to actually define an age for each child and stick with it, but it is still quite pretty. Three and a half stars from me, with the expectation a younger, perhaps female target audience would like it more.

Was this review helpful?

I received an e-copy of this through netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

I loved this! Although this is definitely aimed at younger audiences so the 'truth' or mystery aspect was easy for me to predict, I still adored the story and how it built to the reveal. The graphics are beautiful and the 'reveal' of their mother's mysterious past was just beautiful and heartbreaking.

Sarah, the oldest Grémillet sister, has been having a recurring dream in which she follows jellyfish to a greenhouse within a giant tree. When she looks through the window, she sees a tiny jellyfish looking at her sat on her mothers bed, but everytime she tries to explore more she wakes up. That morning over breakfast, the girls start questioning their mother about her mysterious past but their mother makes a quick escape. The girls take it upon themselves as a new mission for their 'three sisters club' to discover the truth. They explore the attic and come across old photos, one of which shows their mother pregnant, standing under the same tree from Sarah's dreams. From here, the girls investigate more before eventually coming to realise that the photo is 20 years old. They confront their mother to find out where the picture is taken, and who she was pregnant with as it cannot be any of them. The truth will bring the family even closer together than before.

I'm assuming there is more to this story in future volumes, and if that is the case I would be eager to read those. Regardless, I highly recommend this to anyone who wants a quick, fun but gorgeous story to read.

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5

This book is so cute!!!!!!!! Aw man it made me happy. What a heart-warming, short story to make anyone’s day.

The artwork is absolutely gorgeous and the plot is sweet and to the point. Character design is great and the dialogue was fresh. I wish it was longer!
If I had to give any criticism it’s that I wish there was more variety in the panels. The panels were easy to follow but kind of boring. Basically everything stayed within its rectangle for the most part.

Otherwise I really enjoyed the book! I would love to read more from the author and illustrator.

It also doesn’t hurt that I share a name with one of the characters :P

Was this review helpful?

This was absolutely beautiful. The art style is really gorgeous and the characters really felt like sisters. I read it in one sitting, because I was really interested in the mystery about their mom and the strange dreams, and it didn't disappoint. The story was really beautiful and I have to admit I shed a few tears at the end. I really recommend it to anyone, and trust me, it's worth reading.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely beautiful and fantastic visual journey! The Gremillet Sisters takes the reader into vivid and visual imagination. Lovely book!

Was this review helpful?

Graphic novels are such a great thing that not everyone thinks they are. I hear a lot of parents say "oh those comics? Why don't you pick out a real book?" But for some kids these are real books, because they are a struggling reader. The Gremillet Sisters paints such a beautiful world and is very inviting and the art work is lovely. I think a lot of children will really enjoy this story and be looking forward to more in the series.
The sisters had such great personalities and I loved the adventures they were taking us on.

Thanks NetGalley for this preview.

Was this review helpful?

It was cute. The art style was beautiful but the story didn’t go the way I was expecting.

I was hoping for more of a magical tale but the only magic in here were the jellyfishes in Sarah’s dream. There’s also the mother’s storyline, it didn’t pay off as much because her character was barely there. The sisterly bond is more of a telling story than showing, making all of the characters feel underdeveloped.

I think that if the comic had been longer it could have created a beautiful story full of character development.

Was this review helpful?

I always am going to pick up a book about three sisters, and this one did not disappoint. Despite the Grémillet sisters not being like my own and my self, I really enjoyed their distinct personalities and the adventure they go on to learn more about their mother. I did not expect the ending but loved how it all played out. The art in this book is stunning, There were scenes that would have made beautiful prints and I felt like I could just fall into them.

Was this review helpful?

• The Grémillet sisters Vol-1

This graphic novel is such a breath of fresh air. I just loved how this book took me to their land and I kind if wanted to stay there

This book is about 3 sisters, the older one saw dreams every night of the same place, but before she can figure out the thing in her sleep, she always wakes up in the same place.

The story starts with this plot and kind if revolves in it with 3 sisters their own problems and their mother who takes care of them alone.

Honestly me being a girl and one curious one at that point I loved this book.

Not gonna spoil it for you but, I recommend this graphic novel to anyone who wanna dive in some dreamland without any proper knowledge of starting or end cause that's what will hit you hard

Also last but not the least kudos to the graphic artist. You did good.

• Character development- 4☆
• Story Plot- 4☆
• Side characters- 4☆
• Flow of the story- 5☆
• Overall - 4☆

Was this review helpful?

This was a very sweet comic with an important story at it's center.
The art was very endearing. At once cute and breathtaking in spots.
The dynamic between the sisters was very believable and relatable to anyone with siblings. There is a warmth even in their trials.
The ending was well done and accessible to both kids and adults alike. It did a good job of showing the gravity of the situation and feelings involved without getting too dark for children.
Really lovely.

Was this review helpful?

2.5/5

When I saw this cover, I knew I want to read this comic. I also looked at the website to see what is the genre, and it looked interesting.
I’ll start with what I liked, namely the art style. One of the most beautiful comics I’ve read. Only Tea Dragon Society was nicer to me.
But unfortunately, there was the story. I don't like stories like that. I wouldn’t call the story fantasy at all, for me, it was rather abstract. Also, it was marked as an adventure, I don't understand why. It was about a mom and her hidden past. The dream thing was weird, and the ending became very depressing to me. This is not so much my style of story.
Unfortunately, the book was not for me. Only the beautiful art style "saved" the rating. I'm not going on with the series.

Hungarian version:
Amikor megláttam ezt a borítót, tudtam, hogy olvasni akarom ezt a képregényt. Azért rá is néztem a honlapon, milyen műfajú, hogy tetszhet-e nekem.
Kezdem azzal, hogy mi volt, ami nagyon tetszett, mégpedig a rajzok. Az egyik legszebb képregény, amit olvastam. Ennél csak a Tea Dragon Society tetszett jobban.
De sajnos ott volt a történet. Én nem szeretem az ilyen sztorikat. Egyáltalán nem nevezném fantasynak a történetet, inkább elvontnak. Igaz az álmos dolog fura volt, de ahogy vége lett, és végig nekem nagyon nyomasztó lett. Ez annyira nem az én stílusom.
Sajnos, nem nekem való volt a könyv. Az értékelést csak a gyönyörű képek "mentették meg". Nem fogom folytatni a sztorit.

Was this review helpful?

A visually interesting graphic novel that tells a fairly mundane story with elements of fantasy. It's probably strongest at showing inter-sibling rivalry and tension. The fantasy elements are not organic to the story so ultimately I felt disappointed.

Was this review helpful?