Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher!

Juliet is lesbian, Puertorican and lives in the Bronx where she gets harassment from men. It was hard to read how the men treated her just because of her body. I really didn´t like her homophobic mom who didn´t believe her when Juliet told her she was a lesbian. Fortunately, she has her little brother, her aunt and her cousin to support her.
I really liked Harlowe at the beginning, she's the white feminist author Juliet admires so much. I really liked how she thinks and how she goes around without caring what anyone says. But later we get to know the real her and I didn´t like that.

Juliet makes some queer friends and that was my favorite part of this story, she meets a lesbian couple who are friends of Harlowe and they are so loving and kind. The perfect friends Juliet needed at that time.

I also really liked her cousin Ava, she's amazing, wild, and also queer. Her mom, Juliet´s aunt, supports both of them and I wish Juliet's mom was more like her.

It's a nice graphic novel for queer teens (14+) or to anyone who wants to know how is like to be curvy, queer and black.

Was this review helpful?

I am on the fence about this graphic novel. The art is beautiful, and I loved the representation of queer women of color. Juliet is an awesome main character to root for. To me, the message and the book overall was a little overwhelming, both in content and in language. I am happy that a graphic novel like this exists, it just was not my favorite.

Was this review helpful?

I've been intending to read Juliet Takes a Breath for a while but haven't had the time, so I was excited when I saw that there was now a graphic novel version! Overall, I liked the book, and thought it brought up a lot of points which will be informative and thought-provoking for teenage and adult readers alike. I really appreciated the plot points surrounding white feminism and how white women can negatively impact women of color through this brand of feminism. As a white women, it's so important for me to read these kinds of texts and be aware, and I think BIPOC teens who read this will also be able to connect to how Juliet is feeling and put into words why this is so frustrating.

I did think there were some issues with the pacing. At times I was bored or even confused; at others I was very wrapped up in the story. It also felt a little "explainy" or too full of exposition, which I think is because it is adapted from a novel. It feels as if the graphic style weren't fully embraced. There were times when I thought the artwork could have done the talking instead of the narration.

The artwork was beautiful, and I loved the diversity in body times. I've seen more YA graphics lately willing to show fat teens, people who aren't "conventionally attractive," etc, although there still aren't enough! This book did not shy away from showing Juliet's weight and a variety in body types in general.

3.5 stars, rounded up.

Was this review helpful?

2020 has definitely been the year where I started reading more LGBTQIA+ content, as well as the year where I delved further into the world of graphic novels. Quite often, it turns out, those two domains cross over – and they do so brilliantly in Juliet Takes a Breath!

The story
Juliet Milagros Palante is leaving the Bronx and headed to Portland, Oregon.

She just came out to her family and isn’t sure if her mom will ever speak to her again. But don’t worry, Juliet has something kinda resembling a plan that’ll help her figure out what it means to be Puerto Rican, lesbian and out. See, she’s going to intern with Harlowe Brisbane – her favorite feminist author, someone’s who’s the last work on feminism, self-love and lots of of ther things that will help Juliet find her ever elusive epiphany.

There’s just one problem – Harlowe’s white, not from the Bronx and doesn’t have the answers. Okay, maybe that’s more than one problem but Juliet never said it was a perfect plan…

Critically-acclaimed writer Gabby Rivera adapts her bestselling novel alongside artist Celia Moscote in an unforgettable queer coming-of-age story exploring race, identity and what it means to be true to your amazing self. even when the rest of the world doesn’t understand.

The opinion
Now, in all honestly, I’m usually all for reading the book first – whether that be before the movie, before the adaptation, … In the case of Juliet Takes a Breath, though, I’m actually really glad I went straight into the graphic novel. Doing so, allowed me to get into this story without any preconceived notions about what the art work should look like. Sure, I’m not actually sure if it’s because of that, but either way, the art definitely drew me into the story straight away. There’s such a warmth in colour, it felt very instinctual and very much so a part of the story, rather than just being there to support the story.

That story, though, was unlike anything I’ve ever read before, and to the extent that, with this description, it can be, even unlike what I’d expected. If nothing else, it was definitely uncomfortable to read at times. It pointed out very clearly in how many aspects my feminism and anti-racism is nowhere near good enough yet. In how many ways I still have so much to learn.

That’s another thing this book did great at as well, though: it pointed out how that’s my responsibility – not something I can shove off on someone else, to have them do the work for me. Still, both the author and the illustrator made that feel (to me at least) as a positive message, rather than only a criticism.

And of course, throughout all that, getting to see the feeling of acceptance that Juliet grows into? That was really amazing (comforting, even) to read as well!

The rating: 4/5
Honestly, I don’t know if I’m the best person to rate this story. After all, it isn’t my story to rate, if you know what I mean? So I figured I’d think about this as a mathematical expression of the extent to which I both enjoyed reading Juliet Takes a Breath, and to which it stuck with me afterwards… A lot, in both cases. If that wasn’t clear yet 🙂

Was this review helpful?

It doesnt support or open after I download the pdf version of it. It's also not showing in my shelf in netgalley and I cant open it to read Please look into the issue and if you can send me the pdf in my mail ID- taniagungunsarkar@gmail.com I cant read the book from here. Please look into the issue

Was this review helpful?

I loved reading Juliet Takes a Breath when it came out, so I was excited to read an ARC of the graphic novel adaptation. The art is beautiful and expressive and matches so well to the image of each of the characters I had in my head. Some of the pacing issues that were in the novel version seemed more apparent with the story condensed into a graphic novel, but overall it was still a great read.

Was this review helpful?

actual rating: 3.5

I haven't read the prose version of this story [I am way more likely to read contemporary YA as a graphic novel than a prose book] so I'm not sure how good of an adaption it is but I thought it was overall a cute and enjoyable read. I would like to warn for some transphobia that I don't think really gets adequately addressed though. There is a nonbinary character in a few scenes at the beginning and a trans woman at the end, but since Harlowe's particular brand of awful white feminism is incredibly vagina-based I wish that had been addressed a bit more. I get that the author was more wanting to focus on the racism side of things which is incredibly valid but I feel like it might have been better tone down all the vagina stuff if they weren't going to get into it very much. Still, it was a fun read and I really enjoyed reading about Juliet's journey and her finding herself. Would definitely recommend for people like me who might have been interested in the novel but didn't want to commit to something longer.

Was this review helpful?

This book was great. The illustrations were amazing and this is just all around a good read. I think fans of the original novel and those who are just discovering this book, will love it.

Was this review helpful?

I never read the original, so there's not much I can say about the adaptation, but I have to say I really dug this. The art and color are gorgeous, and the characters are full and realistic. I struggled a little to call this a YA text, mainly because of language and sexual situations, but I also have to keep in mind that the subject matter is important, and it's possible that I am not the exact target audience who NEEDS this book. And that's the crux: there are kids out there who need this book, and it would be a disservice to keep it out of their hands. At times it reads like a woeness for beginners book, but there is a heart there that dodges some of the more cloying moments. Overall, I recommend this for kids 16 and up. 12 and up if the kid is mature and has someone to discuss the book with.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this!
The art style was gorgeous and I absolutely loved the summery color palette.
The main character was likeable and well defined and I really enjoyed this snapshot of her coming of age journey.
You really got a sense of her discovering about herself and her heritage, as well as learning about the world she inhabits.
It did a good job of talking about race and discussing white privilege while balancing it's bright/fun tone.
I think so many people could connect with this story and I'm so glad it was turned into a graphic novel. I think it translated pretty well.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher for giving me an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
*3.5 stars
I really loved the art style of this novel and the unique color pallets for each city made for a visually interesting book. Because I had previously read the novel version, this was a fun reminder of Juliet's story. However, I do think some of the finer points were glossed over in this adaptation. There are quite a few times where I would just like one more panel to make the transitions between scenes more natural. At times, it felt like the author was trying to shove as much of the story in as possible even if some aspects didn't get enough page time to make sense. I'm afraid new readers who don't know the details of the novel will be confused. For example, It isn't explicitly stated that Juliet is planning the Powell's event for Harlowe until a few pages before the event occurs.
In the end, I think this is an interesting addition to the novel, but not strong enough to stand on its own.

Was this review helpful?

I must admit, I didn't know much about the original book before I started reading the comic book adaptation.

Juliet:

- is about to start her dream internship for Harlowe Brisbane, 34, White Lady Feminist,

- is a young, gay, Latina woman trying to create her own space within feminism.

Sure, it's always a little unrealistic when 19-year-olds in YA stories get their dream internships and it's not quite explained how or why, but I'll just assume it's something normal in the US.

Ok, so right from the start you can see how different Juliet and Harlow are and due to their different experiences, they will approach feminism differently. Juliette is still figuring out how she sees feminism and how it can work for her, and her intersectional identity is much different to how Harlow is portrayed - Harlow is that hippie white feminist witch who constantly mentions reproductive organs as something that she considers common among all women. And although Harlow tries to make her feminism inclusive, she fails in many hurtful ways.

Juliet learns from every experience she goes through -- meeting other queer and POC feminists, a break up, her disappointment with Harlow, falling in love with the right person, and even dealing with her anxiety and asthma. Finally, she learns how to find people she can actually learn something from, take a breath and find a place of her own.

I have to say, I loved the color palette chosen for the graphic novel (purple-orange-ish), because it's right up my alley.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved reading this adaptation of one of my favorite book. Everything was great and the colors and drawings really gave life to Juliet and the other characters. A really good story about white feminism and the damage it can cause.

Was this review helpful?

This was amazing. I haven't read the original book, but the story worked really well as a graphic novel.
If someone doesn't know, this is about Juliet, a latina queer woman who goes on a internship with a white feminist iconic writer.
And it's about Juliet learning about herself, about love, about identity, and about what feminism should be (spoiler: it's not what the white icon thinks).
I loved Juliet and her journey, and the side character that help her, guide her and love her.
This is the representation we, latina queer women, want and need. This is the kind of stories my teenage self needed but didn't get.
Intersectional feminism is the only feminism I care about, the only one that should exist, because if your feminism excludes people I don't want it.
Also, I'm all about that anti imperialist sub plot.

Was this review helpful?

(3 stars = liked it)

This book surprised me more than I thought it would. We start with Juliet, a baby-lesbian who is just starting to dip her toes in the world. She is a latina who reads a white feminist book and, although she doesn't feel seen, she connects with it, and she wants more. So she signs up for an internship, moves from the Bronx to Portland, Oregon and suddenly she is faced with complete new realities, and starts discovering more about her own community than she even imagined existed.

Juliet's experience is relatable in the sense that many of us start(ed) out with white feminism before really figuring out that there's a lot of bs in it and there is so much more out there to learn and turn your attention towards. Unfortunately, she only figured it out when she was deep in it, but she had a great support system to get her through it and teach her what she needed to learn.

Juliet's experience is so not relatable in the sense that so many people around her were LGBT+ and accepting of her. Of course, she had that experience with her mom and that was very important to be portrayed too. But maybe I'm just being negative and not enjoying this story about gays being happy and everything working out for everyone. That kind of thing is good to see, and may serve as an escape.

Finally, I really liked the art style and the people were sooo gorgeous.

P.S.: I spent like half this book thinking they weren't going to really problematize that woman, but they did, amen. The whole vagina talk seemed like it was peak feminism to them and there were no mentions of trans women so I was totally buggin'. But we got there in the end... I think?

Was this review helpful?

This was so sweet and had so much representation. I haven’t read the novel this is based on but I think this was a nice little taste of what that book probably entails. I felt for Juliet with all of the various hardships and emotions she went through in this I just wanted to give her a big hug. She was such a sweet and beautiful character to read about. I loved following Juliet as she learned more about identity because often it seems characters are already aware of things like this and are “woke” or the complete opposite and just completely oblivious to pronouns and sexuality. It was nice to read about someone who is still learning as we all are everyday. Lastly the art in this was so gorgeous. Every single character was beautiful and I loved seeing a plus character in a graphic novel!!!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Net Galley and the publisher for letting me read this in exchange for an honest review. It was a good graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

Gorgeous!

I didn't read the book so I don't have a lot to say about the adaptation for the graphic novel. What I do know is that this is a beautiful story that took me so little to read but is going to stay with me for such a long time.

The story looks simple but it actually covers a lot of issues and it surprised me (in a good way) how the author managed to handle all of them and give them the attention they deserve.
Juliet is a beautiful character. I loved seeing her development on how she acted and communicated with other people. She grew up soooooo much in that summer, and it shows!!

The drawings were speactular and they worked perfectly with the story. I'm just so excited a book like this one is going to be in stores.

Was this review helpful?

I haven't read the original of this and I do wonder if I should have done before reading the adaptation. I love a graphic novel (especially one by BOOM!) but it's difficult to form the same attachment to the characters in such a short space of time, particularly when there are pacing issues like I thought this had and it was a bit on the short side. The characters were so complex and interesting but didn't get alot of development...I would have loved to learn more about each of them.

However, the artwork is absolutely stunning. I loved the use of just a few colours and thought the characters were all drawn beautifully.

Thank you Netgalley and  BOOM! Studios for providing me with a digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to #netgalley and Boom! Studios for an advanced copy of the graphic novel adaptation of Juliet Takes a Breath.

As a Special Ed teacher, I work with kids that feel intimidated and resistant to novels, even those that they may end up loving and finding themselves in. Graphic novels reduce the cognitive labor of reading, and help provide visuals that bring the author’s vision to life.

I loved the illustrations in this. Juliet herself was spectacular from her rambunctious hair to her expressive eyes and curved lips.

Juliet takes a Breath is about a young girl’s journey to discover what it means to be Puerto Rican, lesbian and out. She gets an internship with a white feminist author, and she learns more about her identity from the vast cast of characters that she encounters.

I think to understand this book, you must first have a foundation of understanding about feminism and queer culture. This is not a good intro to queer lit book.

While this book has young characters and may be classified as YA, it also contains recreational drug use, sex scenes and nudity. I would recommend this book for mature, young adults.

Review will be posted on IG: Bookwormplantmom

Was this review helpful?