Member Reviews

I have read many historical fiction novels about WWII, this one is one of the best. Beautiful and heart wrenching. Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Longest Echo is a WW2 historical fiction novel that spans a period of 40 years, from 1944 to 1985. The story begins in Monte Sole Italy. The Allies were on the verge of breaking through to Bologna, and the Nazis were on a murder spree, ridding Southern Italy of all Partisans forces, who were putting obstacles in an attempt to halt the fascist Nazis, and permit the allies to advance.

In these very late days of WW2, the people of Monte Sole, and the Nicoletti family, were just barely getting by, surviving day to day, praying to remain unscathed by the war. Sadly, the Nazis invade their peaceful village, including the Nicoletti home, looking for members of the Stella Rosa, the underground resistance. At the same time, the Nicoletti family was hiding an escaped American POW, James Foley. The events that take place in the village of Monte Sole, unite James with Liliana Nicoletti, and alter both of their lives forever.

When the war is over, Liliana Nicoletti dreams of making the Nazi who destroyed her village, confess to his crimes. She just has to find him. And if she does, she is pretty sure, she will kill him. After years of searching, Liliana and James believe they have tracked down the Nazi responsible for the massacre at Monte Sole in Argentina …

When faced with the opportunity of revenge, Liliana thinks of her father’s words: “Don’t let the evil that the SS have inflicted imprison you. You will survive … and when you do, you must liveth most wondrous life … Don’t let their hatred live. Leave it behind and you will have won.”

I do not want to spoil the book … Pick it up and find out what happens to Liliana and James.#thelongestecho by Eoin Dempsey is an excellent read.

Thanks to #netgalley and @lakeunion for the e-arc in exchange for my honest review. #5stars.

Was this review helpful?

The Longest Echo looks at WWII from the Italian perspective, an angle that often goes unexplored. Liliana witnesses her entire family being slaughtered and vows revenge. One of my favorite scenes was her interrogating Brack and giving him the treatment he deserved and more. Some of,the events in the story are based on actual occurrences. I liked reading this historical fiction from a non traditional angle. WWII historical fiction continues to be an ever expanding genre and this story fits right in.

Was this review helpful?

This is a heartbreaking and harrowing read in places. The massacre at Monte Sole is horrific and beyond comprehension. The story is a well written account of recent history that should never be forgotten.

Thank you to NetGalley for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the character development between the two main characters and felt the plot was well formed.
The setting in Italy during the war also worked for me .
Overall she is a must read for me
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for letting me review

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading The Longest Echo by Eoin Dempsey. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc of this book. All opinions expressed are my own. I am rating this book 4 stars for its excellent character development of James and Liliana. Their long-standing and arduous story of resilience, courage, hope, and love was very beautifully written. If you enjoy historical fiction set during WWII with an emphasis on events that happened in Italy and the hunt for wanted Nazis after the war, then this is the book for you.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this ebook in exchange for an honest review
As far as WWII novels go, this was quite remarkable but im afraid the writing style was just not to my taste.

Was this review helpful?

I was hooked on this book right from the start! At times it was so heartbreaking and sad! Highly highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Let's just say.........You'll be sitting with this one a little longer after the last page.

The Longest Echo is actually inspired by true events that happened in the small town of Monte Sole in Bologna, Italy. during World War II. Whether you like the characters, or the setting, or Eoin Dempsey's writing style, it's merely a sideline to what was visited upon human to human in the clutches of war.

Sergeant James Foley of the U.S. Army escaped from a prisoner train filled with captured Allied forces in September of 1944 outside of Monte Sole. James, exhausted and fearful, comes upon a small farmhouse. The farmer and his family put themselves in danger while hiding James when the Nazis surround their home. Liliana, their twenty year old daughter, is the only one who speaks English in this family. She's made an arrangement with the head of the Stella Rossa, an Italian resistance group, to take James with them.

But savage-hearted Nazis return to Monte Sole to punish the villagers for the deeds of the Stella Rossa. It is here that a solid bond is formed between Liliana and James. The actions of the Nazis will be embedded in Liliana's mind for the rest of her days.

Eoin Dempsey presses the story forward to New York City in 1956 where Liliana and James will meet once more. Liliana is a recent widow having married an American doctor during the war. James is recently divorced from his wife after living in Mexico City. He's currently working as a journalist for a New York magazine.

Liliana has never been able to find peace after Monte Sole. She convinces James to accompany her to Argentina where she believes that Werner Brack and other Nazis like him have taken refuge during the Peron government era. And we as readers follow right behind these unusual Nazi Hunters searching for the truth.

Eoin Dempsey supplies plenty of true historical background information within The Longest Echo. But what can never be explained is how Aryan patriots followed orders in the demise of millions of innocent people. It's like an evil demon worm infiltrated their mind turning them into robotic monsters. Hell is empty and the demons are all here.

A well written historical fiction work that leaps forward from true events. We can never appreciate or value the present fully without knowing the paths that led us to today.

I received a copy of The Longest Echo through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Lake Union Publishing and to Eoin Dempsey for the opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

I read White Rose, Black Forest a few years ago and loved it. I was so excited to see this book from the same author! This book was just as fantastic and amazing as White Rose, Black Forest. This book had beautiful writing, perfect pace, great characters, and a wonderful storyline. It was suspenseful and kept me reading when I should have been sleeping. I love stories that are well told and based on true events and this one was told so well! This book has the right amount of big scenes, the right number of characters you can dive into without getting confused, and it spans decades without getting stuck or lagging too much in any of them. I have been reading WW2 fiction since junior high and this book will go on my list of favorites! I am raising a reader with similar tastes and plan to share this with her

Was this review helpful?

"My love, are you still alive?"

A story about the massacre on Monte Sol in Occupied Italy told through the eyes of the sole survivor, Liliana, and an escaped POW, James Foley. Together they must navigate through an environment crawling with Nazis who would shoot them on sight, to get to Allied lines. But years later, Liliana finds herself obsessed with one thing: finding and bringing to justice the man who ordered the massacre.

This is a part of WWII history I am not familiar with and know nothing about, I appreciated how this book opened my eyes to such an event. Some parts I read with a lump in my throat, and it pulled on my heartstrings when Liliana's desperation for justice seeped through. It was a quick, interesting, thought-provoking read. However, I felt like some things happened too quickly- I asked myself if it were to happen now, would it have been that quick and easy, like it was no trouble at all? I think not- and I didn't like how repetitive a few conversations became. I'd say the writing could have some improvements but I did like this book, I just don't think that in the long run, I'd find myself recommending this book like it was on the top of my head.

Was this review helpful?

When resistance forces ambush German officers, German military responded by murdering the entire village of Monte Sole in Italy. Nineteen year old Liliana escapes with the help of James, a former American POW. Twelve years later, a Liliana and James reconnect and track down the Nazi leader who killed her family.

I love reading historical fiction to learn about my “historical blindspots”. The Longest Echo is fictionalized account of the Marzabotto massacre, an event I knew nothing about. While I knew that many Nazis fled Germany at the end of the war, I grasp the extensive network or political climate that necessary for the large-scale exodus.

Was this review helpful?

Knowing that this book is based on real events, I can't hide the fact that I expected something more and something deeper, better.

I love historical fiction, and although authors use WWII themes too often, these stories never get boring.

But, the storytelling is key. It's that one special spice that can change the whole book.

And here, I didn't get the sparks of joy.
I didn't root for any of the characters, I wasn't feeling their pain, anything.

The historical part was great. I always love reading about different countries than the USA, France, or the UK. The WWII period didn't affect just these three, and it's nice to read something new for a change.

But unfortunately, that was all.

The whole book was just plain (and endless) conversations between the characters and detailed narration of the things that happened on the front line.


Many thanks to NetGalley for the digital ARC, in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A couple of years ago I found myself in a WWII historical fiction kick. As one of the greatest tragedies of the last century it's no surprise that many historical fiction books take place in this era and I truly enjoy the genre. As someone who is not a fan of history but loves to learn, I enjoy picking up historical facts while reading an entertaining story. All this to say, I came across White Rose, Black Forest by Eoin Dempsey and absolutely loved it. It remains one of my favorite books set during WWII.

After loving my first read I decided to read Dempsey's earlier novel, Finding Rebecca, but it did not live up to its successor. Later, I read his new book Toward the Midnight Sun and this time really disliked it. So when I saw this new book, The Longest Echo, I was skeptical. But I wanted to give it a shot hoping it could land somewhere in the realm of my love for White Rose, Black Forest.

I definitely was not disappointed as I had been with his other books. This book is also set during WWII but this time in a small town in Italy. We follow the Italian Liliana and an American soldier, James as they escape the Nazis who have invaded the town toward the end of the war. This book is split into sections that include after the war, when Liliana and James reunite in search of justice to hunt down the Nazi officer from the massacre.

I will warn you, this book gets very dark, very quick. It was quite jarring and hard to read. And the worst part is it was based on a true story. It was very heavy but it was compelling as the characters escape danger over and over.

It was very interesting to read about the German town in Argentina and try to imagine the mix of these two cultures. I really did enjoy the content and premise of this storyline.

My only complaint was how disjointed the writing felt. It often switched from point of views without warning and the sections sort of slammed into each other without smooth transitions. I feel like I would have liked this better if it started with their search for the SS Officer and we got flash backs about what happened to them during the war. The layout and flow just bothered me even though I did enjoy the story.

This was still no White Rose, Black Forest as I'm not sure anything will ever be, but I do recommend if you are a fan of this genre to pick this one up. I'm fascinated by this forgotten piece of history and am glad Dempsey decided to bring it to focus.

Thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for an ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Based on true events, this is an interesting and fast read about WWII Italy and what is known as the Massacre of Marzabotto. The first part was very engrossing but the remainder of the story, after the war, dragged a bit. I felt that there was more for us to know both about the characters as well as events so it fell short of my expectations.

I would still recommend this book based on the historical events. Thank you to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for the opportunity to review this advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

"Against the backdrop of WWII-ravaged Italy comes a powerful and emotional novel of love, survival, justice, and second chances by the bestselling author of White Rose, Black Forest."
It told the story of the attack on Monte Sole, a part of WWII history that I knew nothing about. It was a quick read, with some very interesting parts. The narrative is driven by suspense and the desire for the characters to be successful in their quest. I enjoyed reading it.

Was this review helpful?

I very much enjoyed this book! It was my 1st book by this author and I will say, it will not be the last! I love WWll books! The story is about Liliana who lives with her family in the mountain regions south of Bologna. James Foley, an escaped American POW, is aided by Liliana’s family.. The story is so intriguing that it pulls you in as if you were there! Demsey's writing is brilliant! So much so that I had a really hard time putting this book down!
I highly recommend this book~ It may be one of my favorite Historical reads yet!!!
Thank you NetGalley!
I give this book.....5 stars

Was this review helpful?

This is a very readable tale about the war in Italy and how it affected one particular small area near Bologna. The characters and locations are great and the story is engrossing. Recommended.

Thanks to Net Galley and the publishers for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

The story was ok but some of the writing was a bit boring and elementary, I also could not really see the attraction between the two main characters.

Was this review helpful?

With thanks to netgalley for an early copy in return for an honest review.
First time reading this author and iam not sure i found the book was very good but rather macabre for my liking.

Was this review helpful?