Member Reviews

Kieran and Mia return home with there baby Audrey to help his mother pack up there home. When a body is found on the beach an investigation begins which brings up many things from there past.

This is my first read by Jane Harper. I found it to be a very slow read. I just couldn’t really get Into it. The ending was pretty good, things were wrapped up nicely. I couldn’t connect to any of the characters unfortunately. Overall it was an alright read.

Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for a copy of the audiobook in exchange for my honest review.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Available: February 2 2021

Was this review helpful?

This is very much in the vein of Tana French's books. There is definitely a mystery to be solved amidst a tangle of relationships. Both French and Harper make their settings (Ireland and Australia respectively) more than a backdrop, and the mood of the weather, the lovely or lonely location always links with the characters' emotional worlds. The characters in this book are finely drawn and compelling. The solving of the mystery creates both upheaval and resolution in the lives of all the primary characters...and there are more than a few of them. The book is long and I think might have benefitted from some pruning, but its virtues more than make up for this.

Was this review helpful?

When Kieran visits home for the first time in years to help his parents pack up his childhood home the tragedy he's been living with comes racing back. a young woman is found murdered and as the police try to figure out what happened the secrets of the past are dredged up. What really happened during the big storm that injured Kieran and left 3 people dead. Is the this murder somehow tied to the past?

The narrator was convincing and gave Kieran his voice.

Was this review helpful?

I had a hard time getting into this audiobook. I would however recommend this book in written form. The accent was hard for me to always understand.

Was this review helpful?

This audiobook was a perfect escape listen. Thank you to Netgalley & Macmillan Audio for providing me with the ALC for this. The narration by Stephen Shanahan was very well done. His voice was easy to understand and follow along, despite not changing his tone for different characters. It was straightforward and to the point rather than distracting.

The first half of this story was a slow burn for me as far as plot twists, the point of it all, etc go. It actually took me a little bit to catch on to what I was supposed to be figuring out. The descriptions of the beach, the town, the caves, and even the weather were so vividly described I could easily put myself on the shore of this little Tasmanian town. This just wasn't as fast paced as I thought it would be, and there were quite a bit of characters that I felt didn't really add to the story. I thought I would be thinking every single one was a suspect, but that wasn't the case for me. I felt like I couldn't really even pinpoint one character as a villain because I just wasn't as invested in them due to all the red herrings that never lead anywhere. I probably connected to Kieran the most in this, but only because he was the one telling it.

I definitely enjoyed this and would recommend the audiobook for those that like a slow burn, atmospheric, small town suspense story.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve enjoyed each of Jane Harper’s previous three books. And this one wins four stars from me, too. She shows her versatility here, moving from the inland to a small Tasmanian beach town. But her ability to give us a true sense of place is the same.
Kieran has returned home with his young family to help his parents move. His father is suffering from early onset dementia. Kieran has been gone almost twelve years, since a bad decision on his part led to the death of his brother and friend during a violent storm. A young woman went missing in the same storm; her body was never found. Now, one day after his return, a young woman turns up dead on the beach.
There’s a great sense of underlying tension with this story. Everyone seems to have secrets and regrets. Harper totally gets small town life, where everyone knows everyone else’s business. And she adds a slice of modern day life, where an online forum opens up people’s suspicions, anger and vileness.
This isn’t a fast paced book, but it totally engaged me with its character studies and numerous possibilities as to who committed the crime. And I will say the ending took me totally by surprise.
A friend of mine swears by reading and listening to a book simultaneously. This is the first time I’ve done it. I found it a very enjoyable experience, allowing me to keep one story going. And this was a story I wanted to keep going.
I enjoyed the narrator, whose Australian accent was tv worthy. In other words, no problem for an American to understand. He doesn’t try to differentiate between the various voices or throw a lot of emotion into his voice. He’s a more straightforward, tell the story, kind of narrator.
My thanks to netgalley, Macmillan and Macmillan Audio for advance copies of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third audio version of Jane Harper's books that I have read. I love the combination of the intricate multi-layered stories coupled with the reading by Stephen Shanahan.

First the story: Each book by Harper takes me to a different place in Australia, this time to Tasmania. She does such a great job of immersing us in the environment that I feel like I have travelled there. I love the the geography is a character all on its own. In this story the cold and volatile ocean is a constant, dangerous presence. The intertwining of a new murder and a terrible storm from 12 years prior that had profound implications for the community was well done. There was plenty of doubt and suspicion woven through the storyline and the author did a great job of dismissing any guesses I had leading to a conclusion that was excellent.

Now the reader: Shanahan is Australian, which is perfect for the books all set there. This seems like such a simple obvious statement yet many audio books have readers that feel like they do not match the story they are reading. His voice modulation, speed, intonations make it easy to discern different characters without feeling forced. He reads with emotion that clearly matches the happenings in the book without overdoing it.

This is a smart, well written (and read) mystery. I look forward to Harper's next book highlighting other parts of Australia with interesting and real characters.

Thank you to MacMillan Audio for an early version of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Jane Harper's novels as listened to in audio format are atmospheric and unhurried. Stephen Shanahan narrates as he did the last two audio books by Ms. Harper. There is a continuity to her stories though they are unconnected. The story flows well for the listener, if perhaps the tempo could be increased a bit. The descriptions of the beach and town are easily envisioned. And when listening to the narrator read out the confrontation between mother and son, it was done well enough that I cringed as an eavesdropper to an uncomfortable conversation.
The Survivors is a play on words for both the title referring to a monument built to memorialize a shipwreck and the townspeople who have survived tragedy. The story revolves around an ex-townie, Kieran Elliott, who has returned to Evelyn Bay along with his partner, Mia, and their baby girl. Kieran is there to help with his mother's move from the family's home due to his father's dementia to help simplify his caretaking. Kieran's return to his childhood home, brings grief, guilt and more tragedy when a body is found and memories of a long-ago storm that took the life of his brother, a friend, and a young missing teen are revived. Family dynamics are explored questioning long-held memories, anger, guilt, and forgiveness.

Thank you to NetGalley and MacMillan audio for an early audio copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll probably never get to visit Australia, but every time I read a book by Jane Harper I am instantly transported down under. With The Survivors, Harper delivers another terrific mystery that carefully builds to a dramatic conclusion. The protagonist Kieran, after a long absence, returns to his hometown to assist his parents with moving Dad to a memory care facility. With his father is suffering from rapid onset Alzheimer’s, Kieran tries to reconnect with his estranged mother and face his crushing guilt over the part he played in the death of his older brother during a horrific storm that claimed several lives. The murder of a young woman on the beach, recalls the death of another young girl, who also perished on the day of the storm and once again throws the small community into mourning.
Highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Kieran Elliott's life changed forever on the day a reckless mistake led to devastating consequences.
The guilt that still haunts him resurfaces during a visit with his young family to the small coastal community he once called home.
Kieran's parents are struggling in a town where fortunes are forged by the sea. Between them all is his absent brother, Finn.
When a body is discovered on the beach, long-held secrets threaten to emerge. A sunken wreck, a missing girl, and questions that have never washed away...

A slow-burn, beautifully written with descriptions that made me feel that I was there. A story about loss, tragedy and guilt with a mix of mystery and great character development.

Thank you @netgalley and @macmillan.audio for giving me a copy of this ALC in exchange for an honest review.

http://www.instagram.com/booksandcoffeepleasemx

Was this review helpful?

Jane Harper did it again!!! Kieran’s story of death in a small town and the ripples that it causes was so well-done. Past and present were woven seamlessly.

The Survivors was as haunting as the statues in the book. The narrator was wonderful as well.

Was this review helpful?

I listened to the audiobook. The narrator did a great job keeping me interested. However, there were many times that I just wanted to walk away. I found the plot to be extremely slow. There was to much back story and I was not fully invested in any character.

Was this review helpful?

I listened to The Survivors on a 10.5-hour audiobook with much thanks to NetGalley and Macmillian Audio. I have read and enjoyed Jane Harper's three previous books. Her books are always masterfully written with absorbing characters and a wonderful sense of place. The narrator's voice enhanced the atmospheric prose and transported me to the small coastal town of Evelyn Bay in Southern Tasmania. It is autumn, and it is mostly devoid of tourists. It seems a friendly place, but underneath it is a town of speculation, friction and rumours.

A drawback of the audio version was the introduction of so many characters early in the story. I found this confusing and had difficulty keeping up with the relationships, family ties, romantic attachments, resentments, friendships, nuances, and possible clues. Unlike a book in print, it was near impossible to go back to review and clarify these introductions, but everything fell in place later in the story. The early part of the story progressed at a slow pace but picked up further into the story. It moves between two timelines, the present and a torrential, destructive storm twelve years earlier. We feel the cold ocean water, the tides, the churning waves, the dark, moist caves, and the wind.

At the foot of a seaside cliff is a carved sculpture called The Survivors, standing in tribute to a shipwreck. The height of the incoming tide is judged by how deep these statues stand in the seawater.
One storm day they disappeared entirely under the churning water. That tragic day brought destruction to the town and death to two men on a boat that crashed on the rocks. On the same day, a 14-year-old girl disappeared without a trace. What happened to her remains a mystery.

Kieran and Mia return from Sydney with their baby to Evelyn Bay where they grew up. Kieran has been feeling overpowering guilt since the day of the storm and the townspeople blame him for the deaths on the boat heading to rescue him when the rising tide stranded him in a cave. It is a place he secretly went with a girl. People have never forgotten or recovered from the loss. Now he is back and is faced with what happened that day. He and Mia are there to help move his father into a nursing home for dementia. His memory is rapidly declining and he tends to wander. His mother intends to move to a house near the nursing home. One of the deaths on the boat was that of Kiera's brother, Finn, which left his parents shattered.

During Kiera and Mia's first day home, they notice on the beach a young woman photographing the landscape. She is a talented art student from Canberra who works as a temporary waitress at the Surf and Turf. The next morning she is found dead on the beach. Drowned or murdered? There seems to be some unlikely connection between the newly dead art student and the girl who vanished long ago during the storm. They never knew each other so could this be mere speculation?

Kiera is determined to find out what dark secrets are being covered up in the town. Is a murderer hiding within the village or among the friends of his youth? What really happened on the day of the storm? Who recently killed the art student? A police investigation is ongoing. They are faced with many twists and turns and revelations. This leads up to a frightening and dramatic conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

This book was amazing! The narrator is Australian, so this intensifies the setting! I would highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to listen to this book in exchange for a fair review.
Jane HArper is back with another strong mystery/thriller. Set in Australia, we meet Kieran Elliot, who is battling his demons of a mistake in his youth that had terrible consequences. Now grown, the demons are back when a body appears on a beach. The story opens up the past like a blooming flower with a cast of characters struggling with their own demons and memories of the past.
Ms Harpers writing is very good...this to me was more of a slow burn, or a gradual whodunnit. It took me a while to latch on. Expectantly the narrator has an Australian accent which is part of the authenticity.
The story is well done, the cover beautiful, and characterization and writing is wonderful. I’m not sure this book in audio format was what I was hoping for. It took me a long time to latch onto it.
I would recommend the book, in print form, to patrons.
4* for the book.

Was this review helpful?

I made it to 62% and just wasn’t getting on with it. It was a slow start and while it did pick up I just felt bored—I usually get on with crimes stories that flash back and have connections with old cases, but this perhaps just unfurled at too slow a pace for me right now. (Please ignore star rating as I did not finish)

Was this review helpful?

For a mystery and thriller I did not find many parts of this book mysterious or thrilling. It felt to me like everything was laid out from the beginning, and then hinted at the rest of the book. I wanted to have more curiosity in what the crime was that haunted our main character, but instead I just felt like I wasn't caring.

The writing wasn't bad, but the narrator delivered the lines in such a monotone way that I caught myself zoning out and not relating to the characters. Maybe the narrator is even why I felt like the book wasn't thrilling? I cannot say for sure, but I do know that I am not a fan of who was selected.

I think if you are a reader who liked crime mysterious and the ocean, this could be a really good book for you.

Was this review helpful?

With thanks to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for this digital copy, all opinions expressed here are my own.

The Survivors is the first book I have read by Jane Harper, but certainly won’t be the last. The story was well written intermingling past events with current events until the end revealed what had actually happened to each of the people. With relatable characters and a firmly woven storyline this is a highly recommended read.

The narrator did well, though as an Australian I’m ashamed to say (after listening to so many audiobooks) when I listen to a fellow Australian they sound like they have an accent!

Overall an enjoyable read and a solid 4 stars.

Was this review helpful?

The Survivors was my first encounter with a novel by Jane Harper although I have several of her books in my TBR pile. I only regret that it took this long to spend some time with this excellent author.

The Survivors is a bit of a slow burn of a book. It is set on Tasmania in a small community that is heavily impacted by the sea around it. The location with its small town, the beach, the caves and more is brought to vivid life. (Interestingly, I read that the author often thinks of place as one of the first things when she embarks on a novel).

There are many characters and they have numerous interconnections. Some are alive and some, who are no longer living, are those who were important to the novel’s characters in the past. Past tragedies, mysteries and disappearances all have their parts to play. There is also a murder in the present.

A sculpture called The Survivors was commissioned after a disaster at sea. But…there are other survivors as well. So, think about the title as you read.

This is a complex, rich novel and one that I highly recommend. I listened to it and the narrations was very good. The male reader had the Australian accent that perfectly matched the story that he was reading.

Whether in book or audio format, I recommend this one highly.

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this title. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

First, let me say the narrator is decent and does a good job with too thick of an accent that this American was able to understand her perfectly ;)

The story is decent, the writing vivid and the narrator brings that to life, I feel and smells of the ocean etc are easy to imagine as you listen.

The downside for me is I was expecting more of a thriller and while this has mysteries to be solved, it really drug on quite a bit. With a lot of characters that are difficult to distinguish between at times, I can see where the written book would be easier for parts than the audio book. It's a decent story, a little too long (gasp! can't believe i said that)

Was this review helpful?