Member Reviews

Immigration divides our globalizing world like no other issue. We are swamped by illegal immigrants and infiltrated by terrorists, our jobs stolen, our welfare system abused, our way of life destroyed--or so we are told. At a time when National Guard units are deployed alongside vigilante Minutemen on the U.S.-Mexico border, where the death toll in the past decade now exceeds 9/11's, Philippe Legrain has written the first book about immigration that looks beyond the headlines. Why are ever-rising numbers of people from poor countries arriving in the United States, Europe, and Australia? Can we keep them out? Should we even be trying?

Combining compelling firsthand reporting from around the world, incisive socioeconomic analysis, and a broad understanding of what's at stake politically and culturally, Them and Us is a passionate but lucid book. In our open world, more people will inevitably move across borders, Legrain says--and we should generally welcome them. They do the jobs we can't or won't do--and their diversity enriches us all. Left and Right, free marketeers and campaigners for global justice, enlightened patriots--all should rally behind the cause of freer migration, because They need Us and We need Them.

This is an incisive and profoundly thought-provoking read in which Legrain argues rationally about the mutual benefits for both ”Them” and ”Us” to a liberal immigration policy. Given the somewhat irrational crackdown on immigration mainly in the West with Trump and Johnson at the forefront of the move towards stricter policies, this book is more necessary now than ever before. With less than a month to go until Britain leaves the EU, I have often wondered the extent to which we will be affected given the idea of free movement will no longer be adhered to; only time will tell. An accessible, fascinating and seemingly objective book, this is a rich and detailed exploration of migration in our current time and a work I highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?