Member Reviews

I never repeat the blurb. Another nostalgic and enjoyable case for our retro crew. Not quite as good as the first two, but I'm definitely going to read part 4.

Was this review helpful?

Ah, the good old days when the polis could beat a confession oot ye and naebody cared. Alan Parks perfectly captures the mood of the era in "Bobby March Will Live Forever". The book is the third in the DI Harry McCoy series of gritty, Glaswegian '70s crime fiction but also works well as a standalone. Parks has superior powers of observation, breathing new life into the mundane. A brief exchange between McCoy and a taxi driver elicited an amused bark of recognition from this reader. I loved seeing Glasgow through the eyes of Parks' characters - the Barras, Govan's infamous Wine Alley and our dear departed Paddy's Market. I enjoyed the cultural references - Tufty Club, anyone? The plot also touches on the Troubles in Northern Ireland via a trip to Belfast. My favourite character was Iris, who has bigger balls than all of the men put together. A real nostalgia trip but I refuse to call it historical crime fiction because that makes me feel ancient! I would like to read the series from the beginning.

Was this review helpful?

As usual in my reviews, I will not rehash the plot - if that's what you're looking for, there are plenty of reviews like that out there already!

This is the first of the "Harry McCoy" series that I've read - but it didn't matter as this novel works just as well as a standalone, with plenty of background about the characters.

The multi-stranded plot is well conceived, and there are some well-rounded characters - you can visualise them - and their voices are authentic. The book is set in the 60s/70s, and the scene setting evoked the spirit of those times.

There is plenty of action, and - despite some violent scenes - this was a definite page turner for me.

Looking forward to reading the next in the series (and plan to read the previous two novels also).

My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for an ARC. All opinions my own.

Was this review helpful?

Harry McCoy has been sidelined from the high profile investigation into the disappearance of a young girl at the beginning of Glasgow's Fair Fortnight, after a run in with a vindictive colleague. The heat is soaring, tempers are flaring, the beer and whisky aren't helping. McCoy is asked to investigate the disappearance of a well-connected teenager as a favour to a senior colleague, as well as his work looking into the apparent overdose of fading rock star Bobby March.
Glasgow in the 1970s is drawn so carefully you can smell the sweat and the rubbish. McCoy is complex and flawed, as are the people he deals with, to maintain order rather than the rule of law.
There are some elements that didn't work so well for me, including the interweaving of cameos from known historical characters, but that's a minor thing in a book so well crafted.
I hadn't realised that this is the third in a series (the first of which is in my 'to be read' pile). I look forward to more!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for the opportunity to read this pre-publication. The story had promise and I did enjoy the overall scene but I did begin to get bogged down half way through. Sadly the end came quite abruptly with several loose ends just left which I found unfortunate. I don't think I would re-read this book at a later date but the title is true.

Was this review helpful?

I realised that I had reviewed this book before. My review is below.

Brilliant. A gritty and dark story set in the early 1970s in Glasgow. Very well written with big believable characters. This is a great series. This book had me gripped from the start. It feels true to life and raw.

Thank you to Netgalley for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

The Daily Mail described Alan Parks as the latest star of Tartan Noir! I fully agree!

I quickly immersed in the period detail, the intimate knowledge of a great sprawling city, and the music industry that played out as a meandering sub-plot. While covering several threads, the storyline wove beautifully together, with occasional connections and surprises.

Detective Harry McCoy stole the limelight, with his back story, friendships and feuds, and the gritty attention to detail. The plot provoked many emotions, and despite a torrent of violence, an act of spontaneous kindness also lent a powerful counter-influence.

The book gripped me from start to finish, and I will be revisiting Alan Parks!

Ian Rankin was always a favourite of mine, but now he has a rival!

I highly recommend Bobby March Will Live Forever.

Was this review helpful?

Felt I was reading a sequel as people would suddenly appear with no explanation, i, e Cooper! I presumed he was someone our hero McCoy had grown up with or had experienced trouble with in the past, the same applied to Angela! Also it took a while to get used to the dialect, could have done with translation notes perhaps? However, it was a good story which kept me on my toes to the end. Liked the character of McCoy and enjoyed the flashbacks to the beginning of the pop era with well known idols of the time making the occasional appearance! Would I read another one? Yes I think I would!

Was this review helpful?

Police procedural set in Glasgow in the early 1970's. The main characters are DI Harry McCoy, his partner Wattie and childhood friend, gangster Cooper. The plot is around three cases: the disappearance of 13 year old Alice Kelly, rock star Bobby March being found in a hotel after a massive overdose and a series of robberies. Feels very authentic with a realistic rather than positive ending.

This is the first book I’ve read in the DI Harry McCoy series and can be read as a stand-alone. McCoy is a likeable character who unlike some of his colleagues, cares about the truth, sometimes using unorthodox methods to uncover it and help the victims.

Was this review helpful?

Bobby March Will Live Forever (2020)
By Alan Parks
Canongate, 320 pages.
★★★★

Have you read all of Louise Penny’s Armand Gamache novels? Looking for something grittier until she writes another? Scottish author Alan Parks might be your cuppa. His is a hardboiled take on crime that’s more Raymond Chandler than Penny–especially if your Glasgow patter is up to snuff.

In many ways, Parks’ detective, Harry McCoy, is the anti-Gamache. He has a drinking problem, is morose, has shady friends, acts on impulse rather than reason, is rough-tongued, and hasn’t had a girlfriend since Angela moved out two years ago. Like Gamache, though, he cares little about self-aggrandizement, remains incorruptible amidst cops on the take, and must wend his way around politicians who care more about appearances than truth.

Bobby March Will Live Forever is the third installment of Parks’ Harry McCoy novels. It wouldn’t hurt to start with book one, though you can jump right into this one if you’d rather. It is set in 1973 (with flashes back to 1969-70), a time in which Glasgow is awash in drugs, casual violence, hippies, and hippie poseurs. If you’ve been to Glasgow in the past 30 years, you won’t recognize McCoy’s city: slums, dangerous alleyways, shebeens (unlicensed bars), hookers, and men with faces ruined by knife-wielders sending a message from crime bosses. That is, when they’re not corpses instead.

If you think you’re having a tough few weeks, try Harry’s on for size. Alice Kelly, a 13-year-old girl, has gone missing. It’s the sort of thing Harry normally investigates but a rival, Bernie Raeburn, has been promoted and takes charge. Raeburn got his advance by being, as they say in Scotland, an arse-licker, and a corrupt one at that. Raeburn’s loathing for Harry is made manifest by handing him low-level assignments. McCoy knows Raeburn is incompetent, but he holds his tongue lest he hand Raeburn an excuse to fire him.

The city is in the midst of a heart wave, that leaves Glaswegians sweating and reeling and the press and politicians are screaming for the polis (police) to find Alice. Alas, Harry has lesser fish to fry. He finds rock musician Bobby March dead with a syringe in his arm– a seemingly routine death for a once-promising guitarist whose fame bus left without him –and Harry is supposed to find a missing bag that Bobby’s father would like to have returned. He’s also given robbery files to investigate, which is not his métier and, as if he didn’t have enough to do, his former boss Hector Murray, asks him to look for his 15-year-old niece Laura. It’s off the record, as her father is the Deputy Head of the Glasgow Council and has parliamentary ambitions.

Harry is a good detective because he has tons of underworld contacts, not the least of which is Stevie Cooper, a boyhood friend from the same downscale neighborhood. Stevie can now afford the trappings of bourgeois life –courtesy of drug dealing– but he keeps a full stable of thugs close at hand, including one who doubles as his gardener! Stevie owes Harry a few favors, as Harry helped him kick heroin.

McCoy, with some help from younger colleague Douglas Watson (“Wattie’), must somehow make sense of all the madness going on around them. Before the dust settles, McCoy has brushes with a Bobby March fanboy, Angela, dope dealers, Wattie’s pushy girlfriend/reporter, a photographer who wants to document Glaswegian poverty, the “Troubles” in Northern Ireland, the unwashed and the unhinged, and Raeburn. McCoy will also get the shite kicked out of him a few times.

Alan Parks’ style has been described as “tartan noir,” a descriptor that’s both catchy and appropriate. Bobby March Will Live Forever is gritty, violent, and morally ambiguous. It may be too much so for those with mild dispositions, and it will certainly be so for those who like Agatha Christie-like resolutions where everything is tied with a neat bow at the end. Harry McCoy novels are more in the mold of deciding which battles you can win and which ones you probably can’t. Verisimilitude or surrender to nihilism? You decide.

Rob Weir

Wiktionary has a useful list of Scottish phrases and slang: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Appendix:Glossary_of_Scottish_slang_and_jargon

Was this review helpful?

Received an ARC in exchange for a review
I hadn't realised that there were two previous books. Although it was a little bit on the slow side I did enjoy this book. A retro novel set in the 70s when life was very different., The atmosphere was well created even if at first I did a double take on the temperature from before realising it was Fahrenheit and not centigrade . I like Harry McCoy as a detective- shades of Rebus about him and not just the Scottish setting.
A good solid story with well written characters and very enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

A heat wave is hanging over Glasgow in July 1973 setting the scene for a tense and claustrophobic thriller. Bobby March, Glasgow's greatest rock star, has been found dead in his hotel bed. Young Alice Kelly has disappeared yards from her home. Detective Harry McCoy is kept away from the major crimes and is tasked with a series of bank robberies and locating the young niece of a superior officer. McCoy's drug underworld connections however, put him central to Alice and Bobby's cases.
This is a brilliantly written book - short sentences and Glaswegian dialect aplenty. The plot lines and characters are intricately linked, like a spider's web.
A must read!

Was this review helpful?

Good solid crime story with lots of different strands - Bobby March, drugs, missing girls, plus personal issues for McCoy involving a superior officer and his ex-wife.. Plenty of Glasgow references and Glaswegian voices. Dark and gritty most of the time with the odd light patch. Blood and gore aplenty and some unpleasant (fortunately off-screen, so to speak) descriptions of violence.

McCoy's world is one of criminals and dealers and users - and those are just his friends!

Was this review helpful?

A great Tartan Noir whodunnit set in the grim reality of 1970s Glasgow. Harry McCoy is an honest cop in a corrupt police force. He struggles to do the right thing depite the efforts of his criminal friends.

With his sidekick Wattie, he deals with the death of a popstar, the disappearance of a young girl and some old fashioned armed robberies.

This was my first Harry McCoy book but I'm going back to read Alan Parks' earlier work.

Great police drama!

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I’ve read by this author and it certainly maintained my interest. We’re taken back to July 1973, in a very hot Glasgow where the drugs business is blooming. Detective Harry McCoy is at war with his present boss, Raeburn, who gives him some unsolved robberies to work on. Three different story lines run through the book, and McCoy is not officially working on any of them. There is the death by overdose of rock star Bobby March, the abduction of a 13-year-old girl, and the disappearance of McCoy’s previous boss’s niece.
I think I’m in love with McCoy! He’s a very clever and down to earth detective with high standards who is totally loyal to his colleagues and friends, yet who blends in very easily with the criminals of the underworld. This is a fast-paced book and I did get slightly lost a couple of times, but I think this is because I haven’t read the previous books in the series and therefore didn’t know some of the characters as well as I could have. An enjoyable read and well-written.

Was this review helpful?

A stellar cast of characters come together in mid 70's Glasgow. A dark and ominous tale of gangland life. Gritty, violent and dark from the outset. It'll have you burning the midnight oil as the plot thickens and you have to keep going.

Really excellent work and Highly recommended

Was this review helpful?

I received this from Netgalley, only to realize it was third in a series. So I set it aside and ran out to find the first two entries. And so glad I did. Alan Parks is now an author I will pre-order in the future without needing to know anything about the book.

A young girl has been kidnapped and the press is crying for results from the police. Harry McCoy, however, has been sidelined to work on a string of robberies. His DCI, Murray, has been seconded to another station, and his nemesis, Raeburn, is in the charge of the station, and the kidnapping. When the investigation goes tragically sideways, it is up to Harry to find the truth. All while heroin makes inroads into Glasgow of the early 70s.

Was this review helpful?

Sex, drugs and rock’n’roll, this story has it all including good cop / bad cop. Based in Glasgow in the 1970’s McCoy seems to have as many lives as a cat. Disillusioned with his current life in the police force he seems to meander along in his own way with the help of his dubious contacts in the underworld is able to bring a number of his cases to a satisfactory conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

Set in July 1973, this is the third story in the series and follows on a few months after the end of books 1 and 2. And it's an excellent addition to the series! Harry is a detective in the Glasgow police force, quite an achievement for a boy who grew up in various children's homes and with foster parents until enrolling at age sixteen. Part of his survival is due to the protection from his continuing friendship with Stevie Cooper who ended on up on the other side of the law running prostitutes, dealing drugs and dishing out any amount of violence and threats necessary to survive. The story starts with Glasgow sweltering in a heat wave and lots has happened since February. Harry's boss Chief Inspector Murray has been seconded out to Central for six months, leaving Bernard Raeburn as Acting Detective Inspector. This is a man who has had it in for Harry ever since Harry requested a transfer away from him and the dodgy backhanders he encouraged years ago. It was widely believed that it was probably only Raeburn's friends in high places (the masons) who had kept him out of trouble for so long. There are a few different strands running as the book begins. A thirteen year old girl has gone missing from home, with the police and media all starting to come to the conclusion that she has been taken or killed by a paedophile. A famous pop star guitarist originally from Glasgow has been found dead in his hotel room and there has also been a spate of vicious armed robberies. With Raeburn wanting the glory for finding the missing girl, Harry is allowed nowhere near the investigation and gets given all the rubbish jobs, including these other two cases. Then to cap it all, Murray reappears wanting Harry to find his missing niece - completely off the books. No wonder Harry is frequently to be found in a pub!! It was gripping, watching and waiting to see if all the different cases would start to converge as the events of that month unravel with alarming consequences for some of the characters. Again there is much in the way of violence, drug dealing and poverty, and some of the settings are certainly a very grim portrayal of life in certain parts of the city. The author makes a great job of conveying a real sense of sadness and despair at many of the lives of the people there. I would definitely recommend reading the books in order to make more sense of events. Many of the old faces, like Jumbo, Stevie and Iris are back again and this time there is less by way of introduction or explanation of the history between them. Harry is still a bit flawed, probably more jaded than before and displays questionable judgement at times but he is still basically a good man put in awful situations sometimes, and this book sees all the characters progressing and becoming more defined. The ending was both shocking and surprising, and leaves lots of doors open for more from this series which I am sincerely hoping for soon. Dark, atmospheric and totally absorbing! 5*

Was this review helpful?