I really wanted to like this book. And, at times, it wasn’t too bad. But it really needed a strong editor to remove a few sections. It also really needed to end sooner.

I find it hard to believe that a foster child would be allowed to go wherever she wanted with a group of adults without someone getting concerned. And as to the resolution of the mystery, it’s revealed too early and then in excruciating detail. It seriously doesn’t take like 30 pages to spill everything, but that’s still what the author chose to do.

I also had an issue with the fact that the book’s gay character lost his husband to AIDS. First off, it’s not nearly the death sentence it used to be as long as people take the medication. Secondly, it seemed so stereotypical. As to the other revelation about HIV, it was extremely hard to believe.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an ARC. This review contains my honest, unbiased opinion.

Point Roberts is a perfectly good mystery novel. It’s creepy and great at ratcheting up the tension, but it’s also a novel that I just didn’t click with. I think the problem, as it is most times, was that I was expecting something just a bit different from what I got.

Point Roberts is a town that shuts down every February, no one allowed in or out, because of the Point Roberts Killer, a serial murderer who terrorised the town and killed fifteen people. But when the mayor shut the town down, those murders stopped and now it has become something of a tradition, or superstition. This February, however, is the first time Lisa has experienced it, so she decides to find out who really killed all those people, with the help of four others. In doing so, she’ll attract someone’s attention that she really doesn’t want.

Firstly, I have to say this whole book was just somewhat melodramatic. It felt like Scooby-Doo on steroids. You had to seriously suspend your disbelief to read it. Which was fine, I could do that, but it meant I was not that into the book. I mean, every character was basically a caricature, right down to the evil self-serving mayor and the members of a cult, so that, when it’s revealed who did it, you’re just like… well of course it was them. And don’t get me started on the reason behind it all.

Actually you may as well get me started on it, since the reveal is my next talking point. If you don’t want even the vaguest of spoilers, skip to the next paragraph. The murderer is described as “bipolar” and “schizophrenic”, while also locking her daughter away in the basement, because she wants no one to know she has a daughter, because her daughter keeps having seizures. So she kills fourteen people who happen to find out she does have a child. What’s worse? That she murders people so no one will find out she has a disabled child? Or that she herself is described using mental illnesses that are absolutely nothing to do with what just seems to be psychopathy? Bipolar disorder and schizophrenia are almost laughably different from how they’re often characterised in literature and this book just continues to mischaracterise them. And do so in a way that links them to a psychopathic murderer.

That was probably the part I enjoyed least about this book because it’s just a weak reason for having the killer. I mean, of course with a culprit who’s killed fourteen people, there might never be a… more-reasonable-in-the-context-of-the-book reason, but this was bad even by that standard. Not to mention, there’s not really a whole lot of on-page investigation being done. A lot of it happens off-page, and what is on-page is just a simple recounting of each of the previous deaths. They basically stumble onto who did it by chance.

I think this would work better as a thriller than an out-and-out mystery, in all honesty, but if the premise does interest you, please don’t let me put you off it. Tastes differ, and all that.

I mainly requested this because of the title and description. I live in Washington state and know of Point Roberts and was really intrigued. I thought the location was awesome and unique because Point Roberts itself is a unique place. The premise that like 30 years ago, there was a serial killer killing 5 people in Point Roberts every February. The mayor started locking the town down so nobody could go in or out for the whole month of February and since then there have been no more killings. 5 strangers in the town come together and try to solve the mystery of who is the Point Robert’s Slayer.
I was really excited about this book at first. I love the setting, my town Bellingham was mentioned a handful of times and I got all excited each time a place was mentioned that I know. Of the 5 folks who became like a team hunting for answers, I liked most of them. Liza was my fave, I felt like for a teen she was pretty mature and I liked that. It was kind of a lot to keep in my head, each persons backstory because 4 of the 5 were family member’s of victims and that’s why they were trying to solve the mystery. I really liked bond between Liza, Theo, Maude and Colette. However.. after awhile, I kind of felt like it was too long. I started losing interest around 70% through and had a hard time staying focused. I felt like the last 30% of the book everyone knows who the killer is and it’s just a giant rehash of everything and letting the slayer ramble on unnecessarily. I mean, I like hearing the killer’s side generally. Finding out why they did what they did, what their motivation to kill was - I'm usually fascinated by that part. This time just felt a bit too long and repetitive to me.

So to sum up, I liked it, didn’t love it. Found it hard to stay interested near the end. But maybe that’s just me. But the setting was brilliant! Thank you so much @netgalley and @girlfridayproductions for the ARC!

Point Roberts is a mysterious town, much more so than Liza realizes when she is sent there to live with her new foster family. Every February the town goes on lockdown, and this February the decades long mystery surrounding the place will finally be solved. 15 murders that happened 30 years ago. A group of misfits of various ages, all connected to the victims.

This book is definitely atmospheric, with the cold, foggy Washington ambiance offering a great backdrop for the murders and the mystery solving. The shifting perspectives are pretty interesting, although there is a bit of info-dumping regarding everyone’s backstories. While the stories were interesting, at times they were conveyed a bit too detailed. Additionally, characters divulged their personal traumas and secrets a bit too eagerly to strangers for my liking.

There is always a bit of suspending of disbelief regarding fictional stories, so too in this novel. From a woman not leaving her house for 29 years and not having major consequences from that to a girl hidden in her basement undiscovered for years, a few things were a little unrealistic. I did appreciate the diversity of the cast a lot, from gay characters to older characters to several multi-dimensional female characters. The mystery itself was really engaging and I liked following along to find out what happened. Without divulging too many spoilers, the solution of the mystery was decently satisfying and definitely not easily guessable.

At times I found the language used a bit wooden, telling more than it was showing. However, a few lines were really transcendent or funny or memorable, like these:

“‘Some things last.’
It was just three words, and even though it could have been in reference to many things, it lodged itself deep inside Theodore, getting stuck somewhere between his bones and tissue, not far from the essential parts of what allowed him to live.”

and

“No matter what happened, people never stopped shitting.”

I loved finding out that the town actually exists, as well as the novel’s visual design with different writing for journal enties and notes, really adding to the atmosphere.

If you are a fan of mystery, unique group dynamics, diverse characters, found family, and foggy sea towns, this is definitely the book for you!

(3.5 stars)

Interesting book about a town on a northwestern peninsula that goes in lockdown every february to avoid a killer from striking again. This year with the arrival of a teenage girl in foster care and a baker from Montreal a series of events gets triggered that will hopefully lead to the end of the murder cycle.
The writing style is all knowing and while I tend to dislike that, it actually worked in this book for me. It was mainly used as small hints towards certain events than a real disclosure about what would happen next. The point of view shifts from person to person and since each chapter is named after the characters whose voice you'll be hearing things don't get confusing.
Some parts of the plot were not needed and seemed invented to make it a bit more interesting, but at it's base lies a nicely done mystery and while I figured out the killer pretty soon the story is interesting enough to keep you reading and even manages to give you some doubts about your suspect when new clues are dropped.
Solid book and worth a read.

Super super confusing in the beginning. Normally I can deal with the switch of characters pretty fast but this one messed me up because it was switching time lines and characters in the same chapter.

I loved it once I got about 30% into it and I was prepared for all the switching and I couldn’t put it down.

I do feel like the author missed an opportunity, maybe the troupe is played out or too mainstream because of “home before dark”, but switching between the book that Theo wrote and what was going on as the decoded the clues would have been SO COOL to read and it would help with the confusion between timelines and would be less switching within chapters.

I am not sure I know what to make of this novel. One definitely has to suspend one's disbelief to really engage in the story; the circumstances could not occur in real life. But the plot is really intriguing and the characters are very engaging. What I found most interesting is that the writer adopts a breezy, almost whimsical writing style for a book that is really about murder, mayhem, and very dark secrets. The juxtaposition between the writing style and the subject matter kept me reading, though. i finished the book over a week ago and I keep thinking about it. that alone makes it worth the read.

I don't even know where to start about this book. This WAS SO GOOD!!!
I devoured this book in a span of 4 hours and absolutely loved it. I couldn't stop reading. I must say that I didn't suspect who the killer might be until later, which made it a great book for me.

I enjoyed the fact that the book had different POVs. It made me like the characters and feel for them. I must say that I liked Theodore the best, along with his sarcasm and his view on life, he quickly became one of my favourites. The relationships in this book and perfectly written out. The book deals with several aspects of grief and I liked how the book pointed out that everyone deals differently with grief.

This is an absolute masterpiece and I would definitely recommend it!

*Thank you Netgalley & Girl Friday for this ARC in exchange for an honest review*

4/5 stars.

Point Roberts was an intriguing mystery novel following five different characters, all of whom were very distinct from each other and offered different perspectives about the cases and clues. I enjoyed reading the different dynamics between characters, with each chapter focusing on a certain character or relationship, along with the depth offered to the fifteen murders.

Out of all the characters I would have to say Liza was my favourite, a spunky and outspoken girl, and her POV being the first in the book drew me in quickly. Her grief over losing her Pa was palpable, and soon I saw that all the characters were also experiencing grief and dealing with it in one way or another. I liked that it showed how people do not process grief the same way, some needing to stay away from the world while others need to throw themselves into a task, and appreciated the varying experiences.

The mystery itself was fascinating, although the fact all the details were spread across the novel meant that I was slow in picking up the clues. I do think that if all the cases had been laid out in front of me from the beginning, as it had been for characters like Grant and Theo, I'm sure I would have discovered the big reveal sooner - but then again, where's the fun in that? It did get rather cheesy in the last few chapters, but that's something I consider about many mystery novels at the end.

Nonetheless, a fascinating read I flew through.