Member Reviews

The Last Fallen Star has one of the most innovative worlds and magic systems I’ve read about in a very long time. And the plot was captivating as well! It was action packed and full of unexpected twists and turns.

Hattie and Riley are such interesting main characters, and I absolutely loved their relationship. Many books take two sisters and pit them against one another or have them reluctantly help one another because they’re family. It was a breath of fresh air to see two sisters who deeply care for one another and put the other’s happiness before their own.

My main gripe with this book is the way the kids talk. The – I guess you would call it slang? – they were using was extremely jarring. Every few pages, I’d be pulled out the book by another phrase. Some examples:

“No wayyy,” a few of them exclaim. “You have all the good goss,” someone else says. Jennie smirks. “Yes way.”
“Don’t know any of the deets”
“Jenny is officially the worst”
“Uh-huh, I’m totes obsessed”
“TBH, it’s a bit rich of him to say I shouldn’t need magic when he low-key uses it all the time”

Since no one I’ve ever spoken to talks like that, those types of speech patterns shocked me into thinking about how I’d never hear people talk that way, and therefore drew me away from the story.

I felt like all the right ingredients were present in this book. It has intriguing plot twists, a wonderfully new type of magic system, as well as truly interesting main characters. I really can’t put my finger on why, but despite all these qualities, and despite how well-written I found the characters, I never fully connected with any of them. This meant that much to my dismay, when bad things were happening to the characters, I didn’t much care. Well, to rephrase, I did feel badly, but mostly I just wanted to continue reading to figure out what was going to happen plot-wise. This didn’t ruin the book for me by any means, as there were many other wonderful elements of this book that drew me in instead. I also expect that many others will care deeply about these characters, so take my opinion here with a grain of salt!

Overall, this was a very good first book, and I’ll be looking forward to reading more of Graci Kim’s work in the future.

(https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/3809096008)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
This book was one of my new favorite reads! I adored it. The characters were stunningly done, and the author did a great job making them come to life and making you feel for them and their problems. The worldbuilding was exquisite, and I fell in love with the Gifted Clans and their cool powers! Emmet is my spirit animal. "Emotions give you wrinkles" is my new catchphrase! All in all, I adored this book and the mythology in it, and I recommend it if you enjoy mythology and Percy Jackson-esqe books.

Was this review helpful?

I had high expectations going into this read and I wasn’t disappointed in the slightest. The Last Fallen Star follows Riley Oh, a young Korean-American girl who happens to be the only non-magical member of her adoptive family. When she and her sister, Hattie, attempt a spell to share Hattie’s magic, things go horribly wrong and Riley is launched into a series of adventures and revelations in order to save her sister.

The Last Fallen Star begins as a story about being the outsider and wanting nothing more than to fit in, but slowly becomes a story about discovering who you are and where you belong in the world. The characters are fun and well-rounded, their personalities shining through each interaction. Their motivations are clear and remain central to the plot. The action is nearly non-stop with fun twists and reveals that draw you in and make it difficult to put the book down.

I also appreciated how the mythology was presented throughout the story. Each figure, creature, and object was explained in an easy to understand way while also fitting in with the narrative tone. Since the story is told from Riley’s perspective, the explanations are simple and straight forward (how a kid would explain something that’s simply part of their life), which makes everything easier to understand for those who don’t know Korean mythology.

The Last Fallen Star is a fun and exciting novel from start to finish. As someone who loves mythology of any kind, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this story and hope to read more from Graci Kim in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I HAVE TO WRITE THIS REVIEW IN ALL CAPS. WHY, YOU ASK? WELL, IT'S BECAUSE I WANT TO SCREAM HOW MUCH I LOVED THIS STORY. MAGIC. WHO DOESN'T ENJOY A STORY WITH MAGIC? I FOUND THE CHARACTERIZATIONS REALISTIC AND RELATABLE. THE PLOT HELD ME THE ENTIRE TIME. I THOROUGHLY ENJOYED THE BOOK IN ITS ENTIRETY. I STRONGLY RECOMMEND IT TO LOVERS OF YA.

Was this review helpful?

Riordan does it again! I absolutely love this imprint! The Last Fallen Star is a wonderful book I would recommend to anyone. Especially kids of the same background, and teachers to bring into their classroom. I loved this heartfelt story of adventure.

Was this review helpful?

I grew up reading Rick Riordan's works, but this is the first book I've read that was part of Rick Riordan Presents. While I like the platform that it gives to multicultural mythologies, I can't help but compare it to Riordan's Percy Jackson series.

Overall, I found that this series fell a bit flat. The Korean mythology wasn't fleshed out enough, and terms that I'm not familiar with were thrown around without much explanation. Also, I found the characters were underdeveloped. So many side characters were kind of just there. Sure they serve some sort of purpose at one point, but a majority of them weren't interesting. The plot itself was also just okay and a lot of the conflict was resolved rather quickly. Despite the flaws that this had, I'm glad that this series is a good step for introducing people to Korean mythology.

Was this review helpful?

What a ride! I absolutely fell head over heels for this heartfelt, adventurous, and magical debut middle grade from Graci Kim. This is 100% an author to watch and I can't wait for the next book and the continuing adventures of Riley, Emmett, and the rest of the squad!

Was this review helpful?

Think you NetGalley for this eARC!

In this Rick Riordan Present series, we’re introduced to Riley- a Korean-American almost-13-year-old. She was adopted into a family of magically gifted healers, though she is ‘saram’ (without magic). Riley and her sister, Hattie, come up with a plan to share Hattie’s magic... but things to not go as planned.

Honestly, this was a DNF for me. I tried.
This book differs from other RRP books I’ve read in that we start with a protagonist fully versed in the mythological world. That means there is a LOT of exposition needed to get everyone up to speed. In the other books, readers get to learn alongside the characters, which allows it to not be ‘so much.’ I was able to get about a third of the way through, and just struggled with being invested at all. I’m sure that some people will really love this book. It definitely has a great plot line, I just personally couldn’t get through the extra long exposition.

Was this review helpful?

This book was really cute! I don't often read middle grade books, but I really love the rick riordan presents line. I love learning about different mythologies, and it's so refreshing to have stories that focus on non-western mythologies as well. The writing was funny and easy to get through, and I really enjoyed all of the main characters. The plot was intriguing, and the ending left me very excited to see where the story is going to go from here.

Was this review helpful?

When the publication of THE LAST FALLEN STAR was first announced, I was indescribably excited — I mean: the book promises witches, Korean mythology, heritage & magic, and themes of family and belonging. What more could an Asian-American girl ask for? After reading, I'm pleased to announce that I was not let down, not even a single bit. THE LAST FALLEN STAR exceeded each and every one of my expectations, and has reached it's way into my heart as one of the best middle grade fantasies I've ever had the honor to read. Yes, it's really *that* good.

Riley Oh has got to be one of the most relatable protagonists I've ever met. Almost 13, Riley is a lot of things: cautious, a rule-follower, has a leaky eye bladder (long story short, read the book), and loves her family and friends more than anything else in the world. Despite having virtually nothing in common with Riley — I'm not Korean, adopted, or living in a gifted society with divine elemental powers — Riley's character truly spoke to me. The idea of feeling not-fully-integrated in a society, and wanting so desperately to just *fit in* is a theme that I think many diaspora children & teens, including myself, can relate to. Other than that, I'm overly emotional and a goody-two-shoes all the way, so I was truly just cheering Riley on the entire time.

While Riley is undeniably the star (hehe) of the book, THE LAST FALLEN STAR is a story that belongs equally to all the side characters — which, frankly, is a huge feat. From characters who accompany Riley along her journey, such as her best friend Emmett, to characters who only get a little page time, such as Riley's Eomma and Appa, and her sister, Hattie, each character is fleshed out so incredibly well. I may or may not have gotten inexplicably extremely attached to each and every one of them.

My favorite part of the book, though, would be the worldbuilding. Graci Kim managed to catch my excitement, weaving a world that I desperately wish younger-me could explore. The magical world is seamlessly embedded within normal LA society, and I just know that so many younger readers are going to swept away by the portals, magical creatures, goddesses, illusions, and all the magic hidden in plain sight. Paired with a plot that is genuinely twisty, THE LAST FALLEN STAR is an exquisite debut not to be missed.

Was this review helpful?

Riley Oh is the adopted daughter of Gifted Clans Witches and she wants more than anything to be one herself. But unfortunately Riley is a saram, a mortal with no magic who therefore cannot become a witch. Riley has all but given up on her dream but her adopted sister Hattie refuses to accept that. They find a spell that will allow Hattie to share her magic with Riley but it isn't as easy as it sounds. And predictably everything goes badly. Now Hattie's life is on the line and Riley is tasked with hunting down the last fallen star in order to save her sister. Riley doesn't do it alone though. She is joined by her best friend Emmett and along the way she receives help from unlikely acquaintances and...even her enemies? Yeah it's pretty epic.

When I saw this book was about Korean witches I was immediately intrigued. First off, there are not many witch books in general but especially in the middle grade genre. So I was extremely excited when I saw that. On top of that Korean mythology is so interesting and something I know a little bit about from watching, you guessed it, k-drama's. I think it's such a fascinating mythology that is never really portrayed in Western media so I am super grateful that this book now exists so young readers have the opportunity to learn about this culture at a young age. And I am even more happy that young Korean American kids can read this book and see themselves represented.

Now onto the world. Absolutely stunning. The magic system is very cool. It's based off of the elements but each clan has a particular specialty such as the Gom who are healers and the Gumiho who are illusionists. The backdrop to this mystical world is modern day Los Angeles which made the story even more fun to read about. We got to see famous west coast landmarks while also learning about Korean culture within the city. Noraebang's, otherwise known as karaoke rooms, seem like a real fun time and I'm so sad they are not really around where I live! This brings me to another part of this book that I really loved. I was a sucker for all of the k-culture references. As I mentioned earlier I do watch k-dramas (honestly they're the best I highly recommend them) but I am also a fan of k-pop so I got a lot of the easter eggs/references that the author made. There were even some Percy Jackson references! I am always here for references to PJO. There were also some other pop culture references (especially Disney) that I was living for but I won't spoil them all for you!

Next are the characters. I really liked Riley even though I don't think I would have at another time in my life. I have recently recognized the fact that I am an emotional person and therefore also suffer from Riley's "leaky eyeball syndrome" as Emmett likes to call it. I was able to really sympathize with her because of my own recent realization and that really endeared me to her. Emmett is who I am in public aka hating emotions. Riley and Emmett were like two sides of my personality and I really connected with them. Even though I sometimes thought that Emmett was a bad friend because he liked to rub it in Riley's face when she was wrong and he was right, I realized that was probably from fear for her rather than smugness. There were also some side characters that I didn't think were going to be important but they actually played a pretty important role in the story. I really loved that Graci Kim turned pretty much all my expectations on their heads. I expected characters to be a certain way but then they ended up proving me wrong and growing throughout the book. This happened with ALL characters not just Riley. In this growth Kim also taught valuable lessons that I think is extremely important for youths to read about. I honestly wish I had this book when I was younger.

Even though this is a glowing review I do have a few critiques. First off the characters speak in slang that no one speaks in anymore. No one actually says "OMG." It really came off as someone older who was writing this and was out of touch with how the kids speak these days. Honestly it made me laugh (in a good way!!) but I am not going to fault the book for this since it is indeed targeted at a younger audience. And to be fair, I am not from California (I'm a New Yorker) so maybe that is how the youths speak over there. Another thing I wasn't super on board with was how the conflict was resolved. I'm still a little confused about everything. I'm not sure how discoveries were made or how some things are even possible but I imagine I will find out in a future book.

I absolutely cannot wait until the next book comes out. I 100% recommend checking this book out. It was fun, funny, entertaining, and an all around feel good story. Not to mention that I learned a lot from it. Life lessons and Koreans culture things. Please read this book I promise you will not be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge fan of the Percy Jackson series. My own kids just finished the first book and loved it. But they will love this one even more. My kids are half Korean and they know nothing about Korean mythology. I'm guessing most people don't! Not only is it fun to learn about another culture but the characters Graci Kim introduced us too are lovable. They are kids you wish you could be friends with. It does follow the familiar formula (kid thinks they're nothing special, chaos ensues, kid finds out they are the key to unlocking something big) but nothing else is the same. This was such a fun read. I can't wait for my kids at home and my students at school to read it. I will definitely be recommending it to teachers and librarians.

Was this review helpful?

The thing Riley Oh wants the most in the entire world is to be a real Gom, to have healing magic like her adopted family and to feel like she belongs. Riley and her adopted sister Hattie decide to use a forbidden spell during Hattie's ceremony to join the clans that will allow Riley to share Hattie's magic for a period of time. However, when they are about to complete the spell in front of the elders and their family, the head of their clan stops them and reveals life-shattering news to Riley: she is not a saram, a person with no magic, she is a Moraji, a member of the exiled clan of witches that tried to destroy the other clans. Worse than that, Riley's adopted mother, father, and aunt knew who she was. Now that the clan knows, they give Riley's adopted mother, father, and aunt a choice: they can give up all of the magic or disown Riley. Not wanting her family to lose their magic, Riley flees to her house to pack her bags, but before she can Hattie and Riley's best friend Emmett catch up to her and refuse to let her leave. Hattie decides that they should attempt another forbidden spell to summon a goddess to give Riley magic. The spell doesn't work as planned, and in order to save Hattie, Riley and Emmett must find the last fallen star. In the process of looking, they discover the exiled Moraji clan, Riley's powers, Emmett's lost mother, new friends, and Riley discovers her place in the world.

Was this review helpful?

Another strong contender in the Rick Riordan Presents stable, this one focused on Korean mythology and magic with a strong female protagonist of middle school age. The story moves quickly and the world building seems natural with enough explanation that readers unfamiliar with Korean culture can understand what is happening but no so much it begins to feel like a lecture. This volume is set in the mortal realm (specifically around Los Angeles), with strong final chapter indicators that the next volume will be set in the spirit realm. There's even a cute reference to Riordan's Percy Jackson series that implies the characters of this series occupy the same world as Percy and Co.

Was this review helpful?

Graci Kim adds another cultural layer to the Rick Riordan Presents series. Kim draws on Korean mythology to weave a story of identity that is fun, engaging, and that helps us learn more about stories passed down.

I recommend the Rick Riordan Presents books to teachers and students whenever I can — and The Last Fallen Star comes highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Before this, I had read all of the Percy Jackson books and one of the Rick Riordan Presents (Tristan Strong Punches a Hole in the Sky). I haven't met a Rick Riordan ( or Presents) book that I haven't liked. I loved this The Last Fallen Star by Graci Kim. What I will say is that there's usually a template for these books: average teenager (usually an outcast) finds out that they're actually a god (or gifted), joins other teenage gods/gifted, and together they go on a multi-step quest to solve the conflict.

The template is a little different in The Last Fallen Star; Riley Oh, the main character, is NOT gifted, and her quest starts with an effort to join the gifted clans who have adopted her. The book includes Korean myths (like Gumiho and Dokkaebi) and BTS lyrics and mentions of Korean food and Kdramas, With the awesome action-filled plot that comes with a Rick Riordan book and the K-Culture, I think this book is going to appeal to a lot of people.

Was this review helpful?

If you enjoy stories by Rick Riordanyou will love this book. This is the first book and I’m looking forward to the rest of the series.
I thoroughly enjoyed the characters, the myths, and the food of Korea. The author did a great job linking family and friends to the heroines task. I raced through the book so fast I may have to reread it.
The author mentioned wanting to see themself in a book, and I would love to see more inclusive books written. We need to know everyone’s stories and every person should be able to see themself in a book.
Excellent middle schooler read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was received as an ARC in exchange for an honest review . Opinions and thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.

Reading this book felt like a mystery joyride full of mythical creatures and so much adventure that this book will definitely leave you finished when you are done. Published with the creative mind of Rick Riordan, I was not disappointed with this book. The family sister bond between Hattie and Riley was nothing like I have ever read before . Being inspired by the magic Hattie will receive when becoming a Gi and finding out that Riley was adopted with no magic inherited, Hattie shares her new magic with Riley and while adventures await them we all know that magic does come with a price. This book will be extremely popular with our young readers and definitely a potential battle of the books nomination.

We will consider adding this title to our JFICTION collection at our library. That is why we give this book 5 stars .

Was this review helpful?

Just finished reading this book, where should I start? The storyline was great. Touching story about two sisters. One born into a family, one adopted. Do not want to give away the story. So here are some keywords. Sisters, loyalty , mythology, betrayal, family. A must read for 2021.

Was this review helpful?

My kids are big fans of Rick Riordan, but they have not really enjoyed many of the RR Presents books...this one included. As a teacher, I appreciate that he's trying to be inclusive of every culture, but some of them just don't work as well, and it's beginning to dilute the brand.

Was this review helpful?