Member Reviews

I have been waiting to read this book for months! I was not disappointed, it is a brilliant novel. I am a huge fan of Jean Hanff Korelitz, and I leave this book as an even bigger fan! It a novel of a plot within a plot, the story of an author duped into writing a magnum opus whose astounding success produces unexpected results.

The main character, is Jacob Finch Bonnner, an author of no note, who I liked very much. I empathized with his neuroses and I understood his complicated feelings. I was happy for him when he finally achieved professional and emotional success.

This book is so clever and so intricately woven that I was fooled and kept in a state of thrall for all the glorious hours I spent reading this. I refuse to be a spoiler, so let it suffice that I believe this will be one of the big reads this summer

Thank you Netgalley for this opportunity to read, review and enjoy this novel.

Was this review helpful?

I figured this out pretty quickly but still found it to be a delicious, twisty thriller. Having read more about the author, I see she has written other books I’ve enjoyed (Admission) and a book, You Should Have Known, that was made into an HBO series I loved (Undoing). She’s great at building suspense and at showing the dark side of human nature. Highly recommend The Plot especially if you enjoy thrillers and books about authors. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read and review an advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

This was everything I hoped it would be. The premise of this story is a favorite storyline of mine (reminded me of The Words in basic premise) and I went into this with high expectations. The beginning was compelling and I became immediately invested in the story. I loved the exposition throughout of what it is to be a writer. I will say, some things in the story I completely predicted or saw coming...but the storyline and reveals unfolded in such a beautiful and successful way that by correct predictions didn't ruin anything for me at all.

Was this review helpful?

Sure the beginning of this novel was a little slow,,all the better to savor the snarky,,cynical look at MFA programs, writing retreats and the slippery ladder to literary success, Who but the mega bestselling author can ever feel secure?
Jake Bonner had a highly praised first novel, but finds himself laboring at the margins of the literary establishment. He latches on to a promising plot which was shared with him by his student at an MFA program. When he learns that this student has died without have any work at all having been published, well he isn’t one to deprive the public of this surefire story. What this plot actually consists of is revealed over the course of our novel. Meanwhile tasty morsels about the publishing business are interspersed, including commentary on who has a right to tell which stories.
Complications ensue when a charge of plagiarism is made and Jake feels the need to investigate. The final plot twist will be apparent to most readers several chapters before the end, but I for one enjoyed seeing it play out until the not so bitter end. After all weren’t we all a little envious of Jake?

Thank you to NetGalley and Celadon for providing this e ARC.

Was this review helpful?

With a clever premise and a dark exploration of the publishing world, this literary thriller is unputdownable. Jacob Finch Bonner was once a young writing talent on the rise, but now he’s totally blocked—he hasn’t written a word in years. After overhearing one of his MFA students share his guaranteed-to-be-a-bestseller plot for the story he wants to write, Jake steals the brilliant idea, writes the book, and zooms to the top of the bestseller list. Nine months later, he gets an ominous note that says “You are a thief.” If you need likable characters, this isn't for you—but I sure enjoyed the ride. Heads up for graphic, but present, trigger warnings for suicide and harm done to children.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. I can honestly say this book was so different than any thriller I have read. It follows Jake a has been author who resorts to teaching at a third rate college after failing to write a successful follow up to his first novel. While teaching an arrogant student presents a plot for a novel destined for greatness. Several years later, jake discovers his student has died never writing his book. Jake write the novel using his plot and is a huge success. But he soon starts receiving threats and the real story begins. Great characters, great plot, and will make a great movie.Bravo! Thank you for the advanced copy in return for an honest review. #NetGalley #theplot #Celadon @celadon

Was this review helpful?

Jake Bonner is a one-hit wonder novelist. Riding out a long slump, he takes a position as instructor in a Writer’s Workshop where he is assigned an unlikeable, arrogant student Evan Parker. Evan believes his potential manuscript is an unbeatable future best seller. When Jake hears the plot twist he must agree. Time passes and no such work is published; Jake researches and finds an obituary instead. His reaction? Write it, twist included. Later, while traveling on a book tour for his global bestseller, he receives the acclaim he has always sought. He even meets his wife. All seems good until he receives his first ominous message accusing him of being a thief. Seeking answers, his life spirals. The importance of a plot twist remains throughout reading Jean Hanff Korelitz’s work. The reader is eager to discover it in Jake’s/Evan’s novel and anticipates the same from the author. She does not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

Jacob Fitch Bonner is a writer teaching at an MFA program, years after the success of his first novel. Unfortunately for him, his follow up attempts at literary success are much less successful and he becomes bitter and resentful of the success of others. Until he meets an arrogant student who shares his plot idea for a best selling novel. Years later, Jake looks up his former student to see that he has died and he immediately takes the plot idea. The book is a bestseller and Jake finally feels like a success— until he starts receiving threatening messages. Someone out there knows he stole the plot and they’re threatening to expose him.

This is one of the most unique plots I’ve read in a while. One minor criticism is that the stakes never feel too dire: how does someone threatening to expose a writer for stealing a plot based on the crime that they committed have any power over the writer at all? At the height of his literary success, Jake meets and marries a woman fairly quickly and you can tell that his new bride is not all she seems. As Jake delves into the mystery of who’s threatening him (though it was always a bit obvious) there are a lot of people conveniently willing to talk to him, freely sharing information. Although the ending is predictable and a little silly, I enjoyed reading this. The story unfolds slowly and although it’s relatively predictable, it’s entertaining until the end.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting tale of an author who uses a students idea for a novel and becomes wildly successful.
Jacob Bonner found some success with his first novel but never really made it with his second. Now teaching writing at a small college, he has a student who shares his storyline with him. Jacob appropriates the ideas after the death of the student and has a bestseller. However, someone knows what he did.

The Plot is filled with background and information on writing and the publishing industry. I did figure it out about halfway through but it was interesting to watch Jacob put the pieces together. The ending seemed a little rushed. All in all a good read.

Was this review helpful?

#netgalley #theplot 4.5⭐️s. One of the best i have read in a while!!! Story within a story!! Only reason half star gone is it takes a little for it to gain momentum but when it did i didnt want to stop reading.
Is it theft if you write a book from anothers “idea”....... it may not be is its just an “idea” but what if.....(im not going to tell you as i dont want to ruin it!!) Releases on MAy 11, 2021!!

Was this review helpful?

The Plot promises a lot. It delivers on some of those promises. The writing is above average and the structure perfectly designed to ramp up the tension. When your novel centers on the idea of a can't miss plot, said plot has to meet expectations. I'm note sure this one does, though I buy the conceit that a book with that plot would be a hit. And there is a twist here but it is not a surprising one -- it is easily guessed even halfway through. But I don't think it makes the read any less satisfying. Overall, this is an entertaining suspense thriller, one that deserves to occupy the above-average shelf for prolific readers and a must-read for the occasional fan.

Was this review helpful?

Jean Hanff Korelitz stories are hit or miss for me. First few I read I loved them so much that I bought other remaining books by her. But new ones that I bought didn't do it for me. But this one brought me back to the days when I first met Jean Hanff Korelitz books.

Jake was a somewhat successful writer before he decided to work as a workshop teacher on this low residency MFA program. He met a cocky guy who thought that he was the best thing ever happened to writing world and his plot was fool proof to get him all the money and credentials in the world. Jake could not say anything for that plot other than agreeing with arrogant Evan Parker. Jake left it there. He continued with his miserable writing career waiting for Parker to shine, but that never happened. Jake saw an opportunity and decided to grab it...

When he was enjoying the hot shot author life with Oprah stickers and auditorium full of people dying to listen to him, he got a message he never wanted to get. After that things started to go south. He decided to get the bottom of issue as soon as possible while managing other big things happening in his life like his marriage to Anna. It took Jake a bit of time to figure out his career might not be the only thing he should fear for, but was he too late? You need to read this story for that and for your jaw to drop...

Was this review helpful?

The Plot, by Jean Hanff Korelitz, tells the story of a dark plot for a bestseller, and an even darker plot around writing it.

After a promising debut novel, an almost forgotten second novel, and no shot at publishing his third book, Jacob Finch Bonner finds himself teaching in a pay-to-play MFA program. One of his students, Evan Parker, is completely sure he's writing a winner. Evan is the worst Guy In Your MFA, convinced that he's writing the Great American Novel and that it'll be a huge commercial success, and he's not convinced that anyone could teach writing, so basically everyone around him is wasting his time. He's got a plot idea that's so good the writing won't even matter, but of course he can't tell anyone what makes it so good, and ugh, I already hate him.  Evan does tell his plot, or at least, enough of an outline with the shocking twist to Jacob, but not to the reader. We just have Jacob's reaction to go on, and Jacob is thoroughly impressed. Ugh, even worse, insufferable Evan actually has an extremely good plot.

We readers are really far into The Plot before we get to see what that twist is, and by that time I was just dying to know. I often complain that not-gonna-tell-you is probably my least favorite way to build tension, but it works here, probably because there's a whole secondary storyline and so much going on. I didn't feel like I was getting heavy hints at the Big Secret and abrupt subject changes. We discover just as much of the plot as Jacob has on his mind. And I have to tell you, I was so curious about that plot. What could possibly be so stunning and still be something that bro Evan could have made up?

As Jacob falls further and further from his literature dreams, he googles and discovers that Evan died without ever completing or publishing his book. (Evan was not stabbed to death by his MFA classmates, but I wouldn't have blamed them.) With Evan gone, there's no one else who knows about the plot idea... and it's such an amazing story... sure to be a hit... and Jacob writes it without copying a single word from the couple of pages he read years ago.

There's so much tension here, as Jacob knows he's stolen his best book, and it really is a great book. All the things Evan predicted for his own success start to come true for Jacob. I mean, I didn't exactly want Jacob to be rewarded with a bestseller for being such a half-hearted writing teacher and plot-thief, but I also didn't quite want him to get caught when someone else, somewhere, knows he didn't come up with his own plot, and begins to let Jacob know in strange, unsettling ways.

You guys, there are about a hundred twists, and basically everything I noticed in the beginning of the novel and wondered about became a plot point later. How did Evan catch lightning in a bottle with that great idea? I don't want to spoil anything, because the unfolding discovery is so tense, but basically every time I noticed a detail in the description as odd or particularly memorable, that odd thing came back later.  Such a twisty plot!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this novel from the publisher via NetGalley.

This was well-written, and (apart from a sluggish second quarter) a page-turner. The author managed to make the reader feel for Jacob as he waited for the axe to fall. It was frequently funny in a dry way and, although I worked out the twist long before the end, it was thoroughly enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

The Plot by Jean Hanff Korelitz
Rating: 5 stars

Summary: A published author that sold a book that really did not sell is teaching in a small remote college in Vermont. While starting a new class he runs across a student who wrote the next big seller. Oprah huge! Spielberg huge! Several years later the book is not published and he takes the general story idea and rewrites it. The book becomes a giant world wide success. With so much fame the original story is recognized and he begins receiving threats to come clean over the plagiarism he committed, or didn’t.

Comments. If you start the book set aside sometime because you won’t be doing much else. Totally absorbing original plot. Many aspects of novel writing and publishing are told. Really really finely written. A twisted ending you may not see coming. Oprah huge? Maybe

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars.

I swallowed this book in a gulp.

I knew the beginning was going to actually be slow as opposed to what the blurb says so I patiently made my way through it and then I was hooked and wanted to know what was going to happen. When it was time to sleep, I read in the dark on my phone so as to not wake my husband. I kept reading and reading because I wanted to know what happened next. It felt compulsive.

And then the book turned for me. Suddenly I could guess all the twists, one after the other.

At that point, I am not sure it mattered because I basically finished the whole thing in a blur. I really enjoyed the ride this book gave me and I could see the whole thing becoming a movie.

with gratitude to Celadon Books and netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Yes yes yes! LOVED this. I was totally into the main story and then also the story within the story and I totally loved how it all wrapped up.

Was this review helpful?

Book is two stories in one.

Who is thief?
Who is guilty, who is innocent?
Once you start, will read to get the answers.

Was this review helpful?

This book totally lived up to it’s hype and I enjoyed it immensely. The ending wasn’t a complete surprise and yet to read it was...wow! Highly recommend. I thank Netgalley and Celadon Books for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Plot, spellbinding and dark, is a nesting Russian doll of a mystery. There’s a plot inside a plot and twists inside twists. Jean Hanff Korelitz has delivered a carefully crafted, beautifully written thriller that is impossible to put down.

Pity Jacob Finch Bonner. His first novel earned him a mention as a “New and Noteworthy” author by the New York Times. His second and third attempts sunk like stones. Now he’s living off his dwindling success teaching a writing workshop at Ripley College when he meets Evan Parker, an overly confident young man who is convinced he’s going to be the next star author because his unfinished novel cannot fail. And when Jacob reads sample pages and hears the novel’s synopsis, he knows Evan is right.

Fast forward several years. Jacob is now coordinating a writer’s program at a hotel in an upstate New York town that is reinventing itself into a tourist attraction. After a guest reminds him of Evan Parker, he searches for him online. Parker is dead. What happened to his great idea? Another fast forward and Jacob Finch Bonner is a successful, bestselling author. How did he get here? It’s not as simple as you might think.

Jean Hanff Korelitz is already an accomplished author (the award winning HBO series The Undoing was based on her novel You Should Have Known) but The Plot is in a different league. This is a sure fire bestseller and a book club must read. 5 stars.

Thank you to NerGalley, Celadon Books and Jean Hanff Korelitz for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?