Member Reviews

From my blog: Always With a Book:

I have long been a fan of Pam Jenoff, and have been fortunate to meet her numerous times. As soon as I saw this book, it became an anticipated read and let me just say...as heartbreaking a story it is, it is fantastic!

It is unfathomable to think that this story is inspired by true events, and yet it is. This is why I continue to read books on WWII - this is the first one I have read from this perspective or even the first one I have read that even mentions anything about this. And I still have such a hard time wrapping my head around the fact that families escaped to the sewers in Krakow and lived down there not for days but months in the hopes to escape the Germans and being sent to concentration camps.

This book kept me on the edge of my seat, not because it's a thriller, but it just is so captivating. I was so worried about these characters and their fate. I also loved the friendship that develops between the two girls - Sadie and Ella. These girls show such strength and courage despite the circumstances they find themselves in, and while one is imprisoned in a sewer, the other doesn't have it all that much better.

While this book is set during such a horrific time in our history, there are so many parallels to be drawn to our current circumstances as we continue to deal with this pandemic. That feeling of being isolated from others, finding strength that you didn't realize you had, learning to be resilient and adaptable in uncertain times - these are all things that we have had to overcome and these are things both girls had to overcome as well. While not setting out to write a book that mirrors our current conditions, it's funny how it themes are universal in that way.

I loved this book and know it's one that will stay with me for quite some time. It's definitely not an easy read at times, but it's one that needs to be read and has such a great ending - one that shocked me for sure, but was just perfect for this book. I have enjoyed every book I've read by this author, but this is certainly my new favorite and I highly recommend picking it up!

Was this review helpful?

The Review

The author does a truly fantastic and haunting job of capturing the horrors of WWII and the conditions that so many were forced to live in. Right off the bat readers are shown the pain of loss that one of the protagonists goes through in the heart-pounding moments a family attempts to find an escape from the overwhelming German forces. The imagery and sense of setting really are powerful in this story, as readers are immediately brought to the very different and distinct lives that separated those being hunted by the German occupation and those living “normally” during the occupation.

What really stands at the heart of this story however is the relationship between the two young women that become the protagonists of the story. Sadie and Ella’s stories are heartbreaking and heartwarming all at once, highlighting their individual struggles in this time of war while also showcasing how friendship, love, and relationships, in general, can give those in a time of need or struggle the hope they need to either endure or overcome those struggles. Readers will instantly be drawn into their friendship and the path their lives take during this tumultuous time.

The Verdict

A mesmerizing, haunting, and emotional historical-fiction read, author Pam Jenoff’s “The Girl with the Blue Star” is a must-read novel and the perfect historical-fiction read for the upcoming summer season. For those who love history and stories that delve into personal relationships that help overcome struggles, this is a truly engaging and intriguing read that cannot be missed. Be sure to grab your copy today!

Was this review helpful?

Pam Jenoff is one of the best historical fiction authors on the shelves. She is an auto-buy and the waiting lists for her books are extra long! The Woman with the Blue Star is well-researched and compulsively readable. Definitely another great addition!

Was this review helpful?

This emotional and heartbreaking book tells a story of strength and loyalty of two very different young women during WWII. Sadie, a Polish Jew, along with her family and strangers, hides in a literal underground sewer to try and survive the Nazis. Sadie’s mother is pregnant, it’s dark and dirty, and food is scarce. With the help of a stranger who led them to safety in the sewers and occasionally brings them food, they are hoping to survive as long as they can.

Ella, privileged and wealthy, spots Sadie one day through a sewer grate and tries to help in the little ways she can. Sadie is so strong and resilient, and Ella is so kind, loyal, and strong as well. Their unlikely friendship was a bright spot for both during the terrors of the war. Tragedy and grief abound, but this was a really inspiring and beautiful novel. If you’re a fan of historical fiction, especially wartime stories, I highly recommend this one.


Thank you to the author & Park Row books for my copy and letting me take part in this blog tour!

Was this review helpful?

Imagine living in perpetual fear everyday because of your race. Imagine hoping that your family wasn't next. Imagine getting the opportunity to go and try to escape those that wish you harm. Eighteen year old Sadie Gault and her family are Jewish and have lived in Krakow, Poland for most of their lives. Their lives were pretty peaceful until the Germans invaded. They were forced to move into the Krakow Ghetto. Everyday got progressively worse for all the Jewish families.

One day while the parents of the Jewish children were at work, the Germans raided the homes of the Jewish families, taking children with them. Sadie heard the approaching soldiers and decided to hide in a trunk in her mother's room. It was only when Sadie heard her mother trying to kill herself that Sadie came out and showed her mother...she's okay.

Sadie's parents were afraid and tired of living like this and decided to come up with a plan to finally escape the hell they were living through. With the help of a sewer worker named Pawel, they created a hole and escaped into the sewer system under the most deplorable conditions. Unfortunately, tragedy struck and things for the family became harder for them. Until one day, Sadie decided to explore the tunnels and came face to face with another girl her age through the sewer grate. After that things take an interesting turn.

I must say this book was riveting; The writing was amazing. I will definitely be checking out more of Pam Jenoff's writing. Wow...just, wow. Huge thanks to NetGalley and Park Row books for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

“Because when people look back on the history of this time, at what happened, they should see that we tried to do something.”

Oh my heart. This book broke it to pieces and then gently put it back together, a little tender from the process but for the better. There were moments I wept, moments I smiled (despite the ever-present ache for these characters), and moments I even swooned a little. And most of all I fell in love with each of the major players in this story – their courage, their humanity, their hearts – and was struck by the parallels and juxtapositions between their tale and our current world.

The Woman with the Blue Star gripped me from the very first chapter and held me in rapt attention until the bittersweet end. I’ve read a lot of WW2 fiction, much of it written around the Jewish perspective of events and the variety of conditions in which they fought to survive. But I’ve never been introduced to conditions quite like these, and I am still recovering from the new awareness of such stunning situations and such brave resilience. The scene where Sadie and her pregnant mother realize that to survive, after already so great a loss, they must hide for an indeterminate time … in the sewers …. Y’all. I can’t even describe how my mind & heart & spirit viscerally reacted to this knowledge on their behalf.

That, because you are labeled with a blue star, forced upon you by an enemy who wants to eradicate you for your heritage, you must leave your comfortable and joy-filled lifestyle to be imprisoned in a ghetto where random arrests & killings are the norm. To then live for who knows how long in nearly complete darkness, with smells we do everything to avoid in our comfortable world. Sewage water all around you, soaking your clothing and shoes, seeping into your pores. Filth you can never escape. Forced to eat food that goes against your religion. Food dependent on the continued concern of a rescuer – and on the rescuer’s continued safety. All just to ensure you and your loved ones – and a remnant of your people – survive when so many others have not. I don’t think my safe, comfortable American lifestyle can truly comprehend the horror of such a change in circumstance. Even in the middle of a pandemic when circumstances have changed all around us, we are still so far removed from conditions like those Sadie, her mother, the family who escaped with them (and the actual, non-fictional others like them) had to endure.

Lest you think this book is heavier than you can bear, let me assure you that there is a thread of hope that lets in light to illuminate the darkness. In fact, those rays of light look an awful lot like sunshine flickering through a sewer grate to the murky blackness below. It looks like a hand reaching down to the pit – and a hand reaching up – in friendship and compassion. It looks like people of great courage enduring the unimaginable to conquer what seems to be an impossible opponent. It looks like sacrificial love, and it looks like the best of humanity standing strong even when the worst of humanity seems to be winning. Your heart may be bruised a bit from the reading of this beautiful story – it should be bruised a bit – but it will also swell with joy in the end. Because true Hope never disappoints us.

Bottom Line: There were so many moments in The Woman with the Blue Star when I held my breath, not knowing what would happen next or who would survive… or who was the modern-day woman in the prologue? Pam Jenoff expertly weaves together a multi-layered tale with a distinct skill that reminded me why I loved The Orphan’s Tale so much too. The smartly-written, shifting first person narrative connected me on a personal level with these characters, putting me in someone else’s shoes for a while, and their imprint will linger on my heart for a long time to come. This is a story not easily forgotten, and one that everyone needs to read.

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)

Was this review helpful?

4.5 Stars

Sadie Gault had a dream of her future she looked forward to. However, the longer the German forces occupied her city, the quickly her dream crumbled like the buildings around her. But hope came from an unlikely ally she found in Ella Stepanek. A friendship that could save their souls, no matter how the odds stacked against them.

When I read books in a war setting, I want to feel the characters’ pain and suffering. This book is a bit mild on that aspect but it didn’t take away my enjoyment of the story.

Sadie and Ella might come from a different part of the city but desperation, survival, and humanity brought them together. I loved how they helped each other overcome their personal and shared adversity. I also enjoyed the addition of the supporting characters and the mild romance amid difficult situations.

The Woman with the Blue Star is a tale of friendship and survival. It would appeal to readers who enjoy Historical Fiction set in the World War II era.

Was this review helpful?

A powerful and moving story of a two Jewish families forced to live in the sewers of Poland and a young woman who befriends one and helps them during WWII. Based on a true story, this is both heartbreaking and uplifting. It continues to amaze me all of the untold stories of perseverance and survival that occurred.

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank Netgalley for an ARC of this title. This novel is truly powerful and moving. I could not put it down. You get transported back in time, and you can feel every emotion these two young ladies are going through. I felt the fear, the love, and the sacrifice made by each woman all the way through. Pam Jenoff did a fabulous job of bringing these two women's lives to an astonishing real-life worldview. I would recommend this book hands down to anyone and will be using it as part of my reader's advisory at my branch. A must-read!

Was this review helpful?

The Woman with the Blue Star, Pam Jenoff's latest novel was absolutely incredible! On a personal note, growing up in Israel, etched in my memory, is a woman's testimonial which was shared on Holocausts Remembrance day in our elementary school, about her survival of the war hiding in the sewers. I found this fact impossible to fathom, and, reading this novel, it all came sadly together. This book of an unimaginable journey of escape, hiding, family bonds, friendships, sacrifice and bravery was fabulous. Thank you NetGalley, the publisher and author for the e-reader for review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Mediocre at best. I read this one on the heels of "We Were The Lucky Ones" by Georgia Hunter, which is a far more researched and compelling account of the occupation of Poland. Unfortunately, I found the characters to be flat, the writing to be elementary, and the title to really make absolutely no sense in relation to the story. I also didn't love the ending, which was very cliched and contrived. I think I just like my historical fiction to be more literary and less mass market. That said, it was a page turner and would work for someone who needs to get out of a book slump. Overall though, I think there are far better entries in this genre.

Was this review helpful?

One of my favorite historical fiction books of all time!! I've been reading Pam's books for a long time and watching her evolve into writing this story has been so much fun!! I cannot say enough great things about this book. If you love WW2 historical fiction -- you need to put this on your TBR -- it's a definite must read for every historical fiction fan. Trust me the ending is worth the entire book!!

Was this review helpful?

I have been reading a lot more historical fiction after taking a break last year, and this one is fantastic. Told from the POV’s of Ella and Sadie, this is one that should not be missed. Sadie is 18, living with her parents in the Kraków Ghetto during WWII, and when the Nazis come through and clear it out, she is forced to seek refuge in the sewers with her pregnant mother beneath the city. One day she looks up through a grate and sees a girl buying flowers. Ella is an affluent Polish girl living with her stepmother, who has developed close alliances with the occupying Germans. Does she get along with her stepmother? Not at all. But she tolerates her, and one day while running an errand for her stepmother she sees something move in the grate in the street, and realizes it is a girl hiding below.

Ella and Sadie strike up an unlikely friendship and they become close, but their friendship is tested as the war rages on. This is where the book is just phenomenal, and I was holding my breath to make sure all would be ok. War is war and as such there is heartbreak and grief, but there are also moments of normalcy that Ella and Sadie clung to given they were still so young, and that just speaks to how well of a writer Jenoff is because I needed these moments as a reader as well.

This is a difficult and gut wrenching read for sure, but at the same time it is both inspiring and a true testament to the strength and resiliency of friendship and what we as humans can go through and still survive. The ending was spectacular, and overall just so well done. If you have not read Jenoff before, you really should fix that as soon as you can.

Thank you to NetGalley and Park Row Books for the advanced digital copy to review. This one is available now and it is not to be missed.

Was this review helpful?

There seems to be no shortage of WWII stories. Pam Jenoff in her new novel, THE WOMAN WITH THE BLUE STAR (ParkRowBooks) tells yet another little-known historically based, story about what Jewish people facing extermination endured in their fight to survive evil.

As the Germans plow through Poland, Sadie Gault and her mother and father are forced to leave their home in the Krakow ghetto, where the Nazis have gathered up all the Jewish people. A simple man her father respected, a sewer worker named Pawal takes it upon himself to gather the Gaults and two other Jewish families and take them into the Krakow sewer system to hide. I can't even begin to describe their existence in the sewer system which Jenoff writes about masterfully. While down in the tunnels, Sadie looks up at a grate one day and makes eyes with a young Polish girl. This starts the very unexpected relationship of two women willing to do what's right for humanity, despite the danger of certain death.

As with all of her books, Jenoff's novels revolve around atrocities during WWII and the Holocaust, but offer a glimpse of hope, determination and respect for others. I believe her ability to focus on and make sense out of such a horrifying and sickening time in our history is her strength.

Was this review helpful?

It is going to be really hard to review this book and not just force it on everyone I meet. Historical Fiction has always been a hit or miss for me, but The Woman With a Blue star was a great big hit. It is now on a list of books that are contending for my top 10 for 2021. I really love to pick out 10 for 2021.



I have to admit that I thought Krackow was the Polish name for Warsaw for the whole book. It is not. Once I did see that Krakow was a whole different city, things started to make a lot more sense. Such as the sewer open up near the river…I was like, what river?? Then I looked at a polish map and…felt kind of stupid, but there you go. It is never too late to learn stuff.

I couldn’t imagine how horrible the circumstances were in that they felt that the sewer tunnels were the best place to hide until they could get out of the city. As long as the German had control, German soldiers would shoot every Jew on sight. There was this one scene that really drove home about how bad it was under the Germans. The Germans found a Jewish woman and tried to arrest her, but when she saw she was cornered, she took her two kids and jumped in a river that most likely killed all of them. If a mother jumped, you know that it had to be equally bad if mothers thought the best course of action was to jump to their death.

This book also shows the power of friendships even when all the odds are stacked against them. I know many friends, and even I sometimes feel as everything is absolutely 100 percent a time. We think that if something or someone was evil, then there was no good in them. A Woman with the Blue Stars shows how many things exist in a morally grey area… I love to watch how Ella and Sadie’s friendship grew even though they were worlds apart. As e see things determining in Poland and how the Germans were flushing every Jew out into the camps, we also can see where love and friendship blossoms.

And yes, I said love. I am not going to say more than that, but after reading the book and knowing what I am talking about, feel free to hit me up. Needless to say, I was blown away when I read that. It is not often that I get the shock of reading things. I can usually tell what will happen because their author follows a trope, and most of them I have seen/read millions of times. Then there is The Woman With the Blue Star type books where the author comes up with a fresh way of seeing things, so when you are reading the Epilogue, it is so out there you spend all day making sure you read it correctly.

All in all, I LOVED this book. I loved it so much that I found Pam Jenoff’s backlist and will be working my way through them!

Was this review helpful?

The Woman with the Blue Star by Pam Jenoff

Set in WWII Poland, The Woman with the Blue Star introduces us to two young women from different backgrounds brought together by a chance meeting. The story unfolds in an alternating narrative between Sadie and Ella. Sadie lives with her parents in the Krakow Ghetto. They are faced with finding refuge and sanctuary with another Jewish family in the city’s sewer system. Ella lives with her stepmother who befriends and entertains German officers. After Ella meets Sadie through a sewer grate, they become friends, and Ella provides any help she can. This well-written and well-researched novel explores hardship, friendship, family, love, and resilience. I found this to be an incredible story of survival and sacrifice. If you enjoy reading WWII historical fiction, don’t miss this one!

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Pam Jenoff’s latest WWII novel is set in Poland. In the prologue there is a woman in her 70s who has traveled to Kraków to find some information to finally put together her story. She is trying to get up the courage to speak to another woman, a 90 year old lady sitting in the cafe. Although this sounds like it will be a dual timeline story, it is not. The prologue and the epilogue bookend this story with the present, but the rest transports us back to wartime and the friendship that develops between Sadie Gault and Ella Stepanek.

The story opens in 1942, with eighteen year old Sadie living in the Kraków ghetto with her parents. She looks a lot younger than 18, so her parents do not have her register to work. While the adults are away, the Nazis swoop in to find and take the children. Sadie hides and is safe, but many others were taken, never to be seen again. As this happens more often, Sadie's parents decide they need to leave the ghetto and go into hiding, just as the Germans are rounding up all the residents so they can close the ghetto. They head to the sewers, her father, her pregnant mother, herself and a devout Jewish family, the Rosenbergs. A sewer worker and friend of her fathers, Pawel, is their only link to the outside world. He brings them food and news until the day he doesn't come back. Ella Stepanek is dealing with a lot. Her father joined the Polish Army and never came back. Her stepmother is partying and collaborating with the Nazis. She tells Ella it is to keep them safe and provide them with what they need, but Ella is sick about it. She also loses all her friends because of her stepmother's actions. She is in the market one day, when Sadie just happens to look up and their eyes meet. Ella begins helping Sadie and they become friends, Sadie hanging around the market grate during the day is extremely dangerous for both of them, it only takes one person to notice something and alert the Germans.

This is a story based on true stories of Jewish people living in sewers during WWII, although the story itself is fiction. They were desperate for somewhere to hide from the Germans and not be sent to the concentration camps. I can not fathom what the Jewish people went through during this time to try and survive, some of them still being found. The characters in this story are well developed and elicited many emotions. These are characters who will be with me for a long time to come. I know when I pick up a Pam Jenoff book that it will be well-researched and extremely heartfelt. I read a lot of books involving WWII, and I am always looking for a new POV, one that shows me a new piece of what happened, and this one did just that. This is a story about survival in a horrendous place, sacrifice, the good and the evil of human behaviour, friendship, hope, and love. I recommend this book to those who read Historical Fiction, specifically WWII stories.

Was this review helpful?

There's something about heartbreaking WWII survival stories that appeal to lots of readers. This one felt a little different to me, while still familiar with the WWII backdrop. It was told in two different perspectives: Ella and Sadie, one a hiding Jewish girl and the other a polish girl. They "meet" when Sadie spots Ella hiding in the sewer drain and become friends. This book felt much more like a survival tale opposed to a life during the war tale. It was beautifully written and heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my stars...this book was BEAUTIFUL! Heartbreaking but written so spectacularly. I can’t stop gushing about it!

These stories of survival during WWII never fail to annihilate me. This one in particular was a gut punch of emotion as people live in the sewer to escape the Nazis. And yet again, I’m struck at the strength they possessed and horrified at the lengths they had to go to just to merely survive. It’s a powerful story of courage and strength, loss and love. It’s inspired by true stories and while bleak, it also highlights the “helpers” who stepped in to help these families survive.

The Woman With The Blue Star is equally heartbreaking and hopeful. It’s a stunning book and the writing is extremely powerful. The sewer setting was unique and written in an excellent, sensory laden way. The characters were portrayed fabulously. I loved every minute of it and my life is better for reading it. 5 ⭐️

My thanks to @parkrowbooks for the advance reader in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Woman with the Blue Star by Pam Jenoff, grabbed me from page one, keeping me hostage until I finished reading it, later that day. I will warn you to keep a box of tissues nearby while reading this book. This is more than a survival story during the Holocaust; it is a story of connections, courage, remembrance and an unlikely friendship. It is a tribute to the resilience of the human spirit and the power of bravery in the face of evil.

Taking place during the 1942 Nazi assaults on the Jews of Kraków, eighteen year old Sadie Gault is forced to seek refuge in the dangerous tunnels beneath the city with her pregnant mother and another family. Peering through a sewer grate, Sadie catches a glimpse of a girl her age buying flowers. Ella Stepanek, an affluent Polish girl, is living well along with her stepmother, who has built close alliances with the occupying Germans. While on an errand in the market, Ella sees something moving beneath a grate in the street. When she looks more closely, she realizes it’s a girl hiding. Ella begins to help Sadie and these two become close, but as the dangers of war worsen, their lives are set on a dangerous path that will test them, especially in the face of overwhelming odds.

Ms. Jenoff wrote a tale, inspired by amazing true stories, that is an unforgettable testament to the power of friendship and the extraordinary strength of the human will to survive. It is a journey of twists, turns, displays of bravery, and love that in unforgettable. I highly recommend The Woman with the Blue Star, a must read, to other readers.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?