Member Reviews

My Kind of Perfect is a sweet, Quirky and breezy romance. Tracy Brogan creates unforgettable characters and love stories.

I have become fan of Ms. Bogan writing and highly Recommend it to all readers.

Was this review helpful?

I must firstly apologise for the amount of time it has taken me to provide a review of this book, my health was rather bad for quite some time, something that had me in hospital on numerous occasions and simply didnt leave me with the time I once had to do what I love most.

Unfortunately that does mean I have missed the archive date for many of these books, so It would feel unjust throwing any review together without being able to pay attention to each novel properly.

However, I am now back to reading as before and look forward to sharing my honest reviews as always going forward. I thank you f0r the patience and understanding throughout x

Was this review helpful?

My kind of Perfect by Tracy Brogan

Lilly returns home to the small rural community of Trillium Bay after her broken romance. Her sister employs her to be her personal assistant in the run up to her wedding then a film crew comes to the small island town to make a movie.

The characters from the temperamental movie stars ,town gossips and of course Lilly’s family make for a great read then we throw in to the mix the two men fight for Lilly's heart - the movie star and town heartthrob!

The book just keeps on givint with many twists and bumps along the way. Great thoroughly enjoyable fun read . Though part of a series that I haven’t read the previous books it makes no difference. 4.5/5

Was this review helpful?

"My Kind of Perfect" by Tracy Brogan is a delightful and heartfelt novel that explores the complexities of love and the choices we make when faced with two compelling options. Set in the picturesque Trillium Bay, this story follows Lilly Callaghan, the youngest of her sisters, as she returns home after a scandalous May-December romance ends. Struggling to find her footing both personally and professionally, Lilly is faced with difficult decisions and the attention of two intriguing men.

Lilly's surprise job offer from her sister leads her to reconnect with Matt Eastman, a handsome and free-spirited Wenniway Island transplant. As she contemplates a potential new romance with Matt, she crosses paths with Jayden Pierce, a charismatic Hollywood heartthrob filming a movie on the island. Caught between the attention of both men, Lilly must navigate her feelings and make a choice that will shape her future.

Tracy Brogan skillfully crafts a love triangle that keeps readers engaged and invested in Lilly's journey. Each character brings their own unique qualities and charms to the story. Matt represents stability and a deep connection to the island community, while Jayden offers excitement and the allure of a life outside of Lilly's comfort zone. Brogan expertly explores the dynamics between these characters, creating a palpable tension that keeps readers guessing until the end.

The setting of Trillium Bay serves as a captivating backdrop for the story, with its close-knit community and idyllic charm. Brogan's vivid descriptions bring the island to life, allowing readers to immerse themselves in its beauty and feel a sense of belonging alongside the characters.

Lilly is a relatable and likable protagonist, grappling with her own insecurities and the pressure of making the right choice. Her emotional journey and personal growth form the heart of the story, and readers will find themselves rooting for her as she navigates the complexities of love and self-discovery.

Tracy Brogan's writing style is engaging and filled with warmth and humor. The dialogue is witty, and the pacing of the narrative keeps the story flowing smoothly. While the plot may follow a familiar pattern for romance novels, the author's execution and the depth of the characters make it an enjoyable read.

While the love triangle is the central focus of the story, "My Kind of Perfect" also explores themes of family, forgiveness, and finding one's true path. The relationships between Lilly and her sisters add depth and emotional resonance to the narrative, showcasing the power of sisterhood and unconditional love.

If there is a minor criticism, it would be that some plot developments feel slightly predictable. However, the engaging characters and the author's skill in crafting heartfelt and tender moments more than compensate for any predictability.

In conclusion, "My Kind of Perfect" is a charming and heartwarming novel that will sweep readers away to the enchanting world of Trillium Bay. Tracy Brogan's compelling storytelling and lovable characters make this a delightful read for fans of contemporary romance. It is a tale of love, self-discovery, and the courage to follow one's heart to find true happiness.

Was this review helpful?

I want to thank Netgalley and the author for gifting me the ebook. I love the cover first off. A great women's fiction/romance/drama novel.

Was this review helpful?

4.0 out of 5 stars More fun with the folks from Trillium Bay

This is the third book in the fun Trillium Bay series, which takes place on a fictional island community very closely resembling Mackinac Island in Michigan. I spent a summer working on Mackinac, so it was fun reading about places I’ve been (though the names were changed). It really made the reading experience even more rich and enjoyable. You don’t need to have visited Mackinac to enjoy this book, but you should definitely go if you get the opportunity!

If you’re read the first two books, which I would recommend, the fun and familiar characters are back. I liked seeing their stories pick up where the second book left off. This book introduces a new cast of characters, who are on island to film a movie. I don’t normally enjoy famous people stories, but this one worked for me because it was still mainly about the island and its inhabitants.

Tracy Brogan knows how to make you laugh and also pull at your heart strings. I’d love to see a fourth book about Emily’s daughter Chloe all grown up.

Thanks to netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this book

Was this review helpful?

A Trillium Bay Novel Book 3.

Lilly returns home after a breakup. She is hired by her sister Emily to be her Personal Assistant and is an extra in a movie being filmed in town. She meets Matt while helping her sister and gains attention from movie star Jayden Pierce. Which man will give her the life she has always dreamed of?

This is a fun, charming romance! It was well written with great characters. I love how Lilly describes Matt as “Prince Charming in a tool belt.” I enjoyed the plot of Lilly having two men interested in her and watching her decide which man would be the best fit for her. If you enjoy a cute love story, this is a good pick!

Thank you to NetGalley and Montlake for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Lilly is caught in the best conundrum. She gets to choose between, a solid sensible figure,or one that could open doors not normally within her reach. Her choice flits between two distinct futures. And the town of course has its opinion as well as all the people in it.

Was this review helpful?

I haven’t read any of the author’s books before but this one is just perfect. A beautiful cover, great characters with interesting traits and such a heartwarming story overall. Loved it.

Very grateful to the publisher for my review copy

Was this review helpful?

This is the perfect summer read! The Town here is unique and quirky. I loved all the characters, both MC and side characters. It was fun to watch the story between the two people Lily met when she arrived and sparks definitely flew. It was a fun and quick read!

Was this review helpful?

*review posted timely on goodreads*

A perfect cover for this breezy, sweet romance. Typical of Ms. Brogan's books, this one has a cast replete with quirky, loving family members and the right balance of humor and heart. The heroine, Lilly, returns home contemplating a permanent separation from her much older boyfriend. She's immediately thrust into the center of all her family's needs as a sort of jack-of-all-trades gopher girl, and ends up as an extra on a movie set. Thus a love-triangle begins--a movie star vs. a local yoga guy. Small town gossip and well-intentioned family advice along with plenty of flirtation are the engine of the plot, which ultimately forces Lilly to decide what she needs and wants in her life. If you've got cabin-fever from being stuck inside throughout the pandemic, take a trip to Trillium Bay. It's the perfect escape.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book, and everything about it. It is a great read, I will definitely be telling my friends about this book! I give it 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

A flirtatious, threesome is at the heart of a truly warm classic romance. Lilly is caught in a most delicious conundrum. She gets to choose between, a solid sensible figure,or one that could open doors not normally within her reach. Her choice hovers between two distinct futures. And the town is ripe with tongues wagging their own preferences. A happy probed indeed!

Was this review helpful?

My Kind of Perfect is the perfect summer read. It is full of tears and laugh out loud laughter. It is about family sticking together. Mistakes made and coming home again. Making decisions that are good for you and finding your true self. I read this bok in one sitting without putting it down once. I love the cover as well it really fits the story.

Was this review helpful?

While this is the third book in the Trillium Bay series, this book can be read as a standalone, as you’ll immediately be submerged into the small town island and its inhabitants. There’s lots happening in this book, sure to keep you entertained.

After a scandalous affair with her sister’s much older soon-to-be father-in-law, Lilly has returned home to Trillium Bay, not yet sure if she plans to stay. She makes herself useful by helping her older sisters out; Brooke, the town’s mayor, can use some help with odds and ends around town and the mayoral office, while middle sister Emily is swamped with wedding planning, a baby on the way, and several housing projects, including her own bed and breakfast. Between them, Lilly is sure to stay busy, while she also intends to inquire about her former teaching job.

Add to that a big Hollywood production that is being filmed on the island, and everyone is a-buzz with excitement and gossip. Almost the entire population auditions to be an extra in the movie, and Lilly is also cast. She ends up in some pivotal scenes with the movie’s lead, Jayden, both on and off screen, and she can’t help the crush that develops for the charismatic movie star. Jayden is fun, flirty, and outgoing, and she relishes the attention he bestows on her.

Meanwhile, she also reconnects with Matt, who moved to the island about a year before and is quite the hot commodity himself. He hasn’t shown a romantic interest in anyone since his arrival, that is, until Lilly returns. Her sister Emily is happy to send them on errands together, trying to be a bit of a matchmaker. While Matt has some issues from his past – who doesn’t? – falling for him would be as easy as breathing.

Fresh out of her relationship with Tag, Lilly isn’t looking for a rebound, so she’s a bit cautious at returning either man’s attention. I think this is very smart; she wouldn’t want to dive headfirst into something new without letting her heart do some healing. Since she’s set on becoming a mother sooner rather than later, it’s also important to determine whether their lifestyles and aspirations for the future match up.

For me, there wasn’t really any contest: while Jayden is sincere in his attention, he’d offer Lilly a similar lifestyle she had with Tag, which she ultimately found lacking. Despite his trust issues and somewhat nomadic tendencies, Matt is obviously the better choice for her. But will her friendship with Jayden ruin any chance she has with Matt?

The town’s inhabitants and goings-on, as well as the shenanigans surrounding the movie production form a good background for this story. I enjoyed the smaller storylines as much as the main one.

Was this review helpful?

If you're looking for a great summer read, My Kind of Perfect by Tracy Brogan is the book for you! Lilly returns home to Trillium Bay after breaking up with her much older boyfriend. The island itself has so much charm and all the quirky, weird characters you could ask for. Not sure what to do with her life, Lilly meets not one but TWO great guys and we're along for the ride! Laughed out loud several times! Great book!

Was this review helpful?

I won this book from a book group on Facebook along with her other one My Kind of You. This book wasn't particularly my style of writing and the plot was just okay for me. Otherwise, it was well written and looking forward to reading My Kind of You and future ones.

Was this review helpful?

I love this series and I love this book. You really need to read the previous two books to understand all the side issues going on in this book. This book is about the third daughter of a family, Lilly. If you have read the first book, you will remember Lilly as the “money digging bimbo” (which she really wasn’t). Her May - December romance came to an end as soon as Lilly started thinking straight again (thank goodness) so she came back to the tiny Michigan island to return home. Her other two sisters found their HEAs (the subjects of the first two books) and now Lilly felt like she was running home only to hear the entire island scream “I told you so”.

Lilly rekindles her friendship with Matt (affectionately called Yoga Matt by Lilly’s dad) and Lilly also begins a friendship with a popular movie star, Jayden, who is on the island to film a movie. Both guys are giving her much attention, but which one will make her happy? And can she not scare off both guys by continuing to hang around the other one?

I really liked this book - I laughed out loud many times and I felt like I was on the island along with everyone else. If you haven’t read this series, give it a try - you’ll love it.

I received this book in exchange for an honest review. The opinions stated above are mine without biases.

Was this review helpful?

What attracted me at first glance was the appealing cover and the description, a small island, a love triangle, and amusing characters ... what more do you need? But as I turned the pages, I was definitely thrilled with this fun, flirty summer read, which abounds in humor, interesting family situations, and sweet love dilemmas.
This is my first book by this author, and I have to admit that it amazed me over from the very beginning with the perfect mix of humor and heart. I thought I might miss some background action or details because it part of a series, but after reading it, I can freely say that this book can be a stand-alone without any problems.
The story of Lilly, the girl who thought she had a perfect relationship and a perfect life with her older, rich boyfriend, only to realize that she has nothing. Instead of her happily ever after, a family, and a loving partner, she ends up alone and confused. Returning home to Trillium Bay after the failed romance to try to find the helm of her life, seems like the reasonable thing to do. And after several interesting family events, new adventures and possibilities, new acquaintances and new characters .... just in the blink of an eye, our heroine is torn between two perfect men .... one is a handsome movie star, the other one – a charming and irresistible yoga instructor ... but who is the right choice?
The writing style is really refreshing, easy, readable with an abundance of laugh-out moments, witty dialogue, and solid plotline. The nice balance of fun situations, quirky townspeople, chemistry, witty dialogue, and memorable characters is adding such an appeal to the book, that from the very beginning till the end you’ll be nailed to the pages. What I did not like a bit was the lack of drama and conflict, which I personally think is a key part of any interesting story. The biggest dilemma for the main character was the choice between the many suitors, as well as the few gossips, and I honestly love when the book brims with dramatic moments.
But anyway, if you are looking for the perfect book for the beach, which will cheer you up and make you laugh, then definitely My Kind of Perfect is a solid choice.

Was this review helpful?

This is the perfect, sweet read for a summer day at the beach. Lily’s story is the most interesting of the series, in my opinion, but that may stem from her attracting not just one but three men who think she’s great. I think the town and their preconceived notions make her seem flightier than she is. Sometimes the citizens in general cross the line between quirky and irritating, which was kind of my complaint in the first two books.
It was definitely well written and enjoyable. But it was a bit too sweet for me.

Was this review helpful?