Member Reviews

I gravitated to The Hinterlands because I really enjoy African historical fiction. Unfortunately I had to make myself read this book since it had been provided to me for an honest review from #NetGalley. #TheHinterlands is an outrageous, farfetched story. There is nothing historically accurate about this book. I'm sorry I couldn't offer a better review.

Was this review helpful?

"From a land you've never heard of comes a story you'll never forget." This is the first line of this book's description and my immediate thought was, "I know where Benin is, but this might be really good." I was wrong. I still know where Benin is and the story is definitely unforgettable, but for all the wrong reasons.

From the start it required suspension of disbelief A female anthropologist in 1896? Traveling with man who's not her husband, but obediently follows her around and does her bidding? And she knows the word clitorectomy...

I keep waiting to find out they were time travelers or something, anything to explain why they're attitudes are so anachronistic. It just kept getting worse from there. The attitudes of main characters seemed to reflect modern sensibilities. The author's casual use of Edo suggests superior googling skills, but not understand of language or culture. The callous attitude displayed by the main character toward death and torture is appalling.

Then their guide is describe as simian. The interplay between Elle and Rip at the "fetish" house shows a lack of understand of anthropology that makes the claim of Elle's being an anthropologist ludicrous. The tribe they are visiting "crucifies" their criminals and foreigners. The list of subtle and overt racism just began to climb from there.

I can barely believe this book is from this decade. I could never in good conscience recommend this book to someone else. Sure there's some sexy times somewhere in that mess, and yes, I've read some horribly anachronistic "romances" before and managed to get over the ridiculousness, but this book was frankly appalling. I can't believe this book ever got past an agent and made it to a publisher, let alone was actually published. It needs a POC editor in the worst way, but I would feel incredibly sorry for that person at the same time.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley in return for my honest opinion. They might regret that.

Was this review helpful?