Member Reviews

Loved reading this book. Amazing story and the characters lend to the charm of this book. I would highly recommend this book. You would not be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/5325605640#:~:text=bookshelves%3A%20netgalley-,I%20have%20enjoyed%20this%20series%20and%20the%20quirky%20characters%20that%20visit,for%20the%20ARC%20and%20the%20opportunity%20to%20post%20an%20honest%20review.,-READING%20PROGRESS

Was this review helpful?

This book showed me so much about having patience with others and the wonders it can do in a relationship. It also showed how not having patience and being "mean" with each other can make a relationship strained. Whether it's with a friend, a parent, or some other relative or relationship. This story shows us many different relationships and how these characters worked through them. We're showed with Jayce how being unhappy where he lives but figuring out where he'd rather live also effected his relationship with his father. I really enjoyed this book and the two other books in this series. Overall, this was a great book in a great series.

"This book was provided to me by NetGalley and Zondervan. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. All opinions are my own.”

Was this review helpful?

Due to personal reasons I have altered the genres I am reviewing and I will not be finishing this book. I'm sure it is an enjoyable read however it is not for me.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautiful story with wonderful characters! I so enjoyed reading this book. The author did an outstanding job in making these characters believable. Always looking forward to another book from this author.

I voluntarily received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was the second of The Amish Inn series. Lizzie and Esther run the Inn and are the matchmakers. This time it really is an unlikely match between a young man from Hollywood and a Amish lady. I really enjoyed this book.

Was this review helpful?

Boy, is this title ever an understatement! An Unlikely Match brings together an Amish woman, Evelyn Schrock, and an English young man, Jayce Clarkson, whose father is a Hollywood movie producer. The movie crew is staying at the Peony Inn, owned by sisters Esther and Lizzie who are known all over the area for their matchmaking. The sisters see the attraction between Evelyn and Jayce, but knowing the lifestyle he has lived, they know better than to encourage a relationship. Or, at least, Esther does. Lizzie comes across as a bit of a ditz, who can't keep her teeth in her mouth let alone keep from meddling in Evelyn's love life.

Jayce is fascinated by the slow, gentle pace of Amish life. He never realized how much he has craved a change until he came to Amish country. Yes, he has faith in God - something his father has never encouraged, but then, when has his father ever encouraged him about anything? Could he find the peace he's been searching for in this place, and in this faith?

Talk about unlikely! It seems more like an impossible match, but then, God is in the business of making impossible things happen. There is, as always, a lot of humor in these stories - most from Esther and Lizzie's antics. Jayce's story is heart-rending, but his faith carries him through some pretty deep waters. I have enjoyed all three books in this series - this is book 2 - and would recommend reading them in order.

Was this review helpful?

An Unlikely Match is a good addition to Beth Wiseman's Amish Inn series. I liked it and am giving it four stars.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this story, and reading about characters from the previous book. There's grumpy 'ole Gus, Lizzie, who still misplaces her dentures, Esther. Lizzie and Esther still run the Peony Inn, and still are in the matchmaking business.
Do not pass this story by if you haven't read the first one in this series. You won't feel like part of it is missing. It's great as a stand alone, but I suspect you'll want to, also read the first one.
Evelyn, is still officially in her rumspringa, but she knows without a doubt that she loves the Amish life and faith. She hasn't found a man she's willing to commit to, so far.
LIzzie made a mistake when she rented out rooms, and then these motor homes pull in, along with fancy cars. Esther is in a panic about what to do with all these people and what to feed them, as there are so many more than expected. It seems Lizzie told them they could park their motor homes on the property. Well, those motor homes with their big, loud generators running are a problem for grumpy Gus.
These people are there to film a movie and will be there a few weeks.
Jayce is the director's son who has a bad relationship with his father, and is only there to make the money so he can move out of his dad's place after the film and not be dependent on him anymore.
Jayce and Evelyn meet and become friends. Her mother cautions her that friends is all they can ever be, and there will be pain when he inevitably has to leave for Los Angeles and his life there, if she lets the friendship go further.
Both Jayce and Evelyn have fears, which they work together to overcome.
You'll love all the characters, even grumpy 'ole Gus!
This was such a delightful story with a happy ending!
I was given an advanced ecopy by the publisher, Zondervan and Netgalley. I was under no obligation to leave a positive review.

Was this review helpful?

I always love beth 📚 books.
I absolutely loved this book can not wait for more of her books
I love the characters and the cover.

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyed the story of Lizzie, Esther and Gus. I like how their lives are intertwined with the guests at the inn and with each other. Would like to know more of Gus’s story.
I would give this book 5 stars but didn’t like how everything was wrapped up in the end, especially Jayce and Evelyn’s story.

Was this review helpful?

Beth Wiseman is a master storyteller, as once again proven in her newest book, "An Unlikely Match", Book Two in "The Amish Inn Series", taking place at The Peony Inn in Indiana. This novel is classed as Amish Fiction, however it is far from the norm for this genre! The Amish meet Hollywood.... just how different is that!! If you are looking for just the regular Amish genre of girl meets boy then this book is not for you!

Beth has used her unique talent of including the most unexpected events and subjects in a way that captures the reader’s interest and makes you at once become part of the characters’ lives! All of the characters are descibed so vividly and realistically that you easily identify with them. This author has a special talent in adding humour in her stories with the many unusual, quirky personalities . I have to say that I loved both Esther and Lizzie, who took the problems of the world in their rather inept hands.



The plot moved quickly with many twists and turns, keeping the reader totally engaged. How can an Amish girl be so attracted to a handsome, rich Englischer? Would it ever work?? Can Lizzie and Esther influence the final decision??

This book is one that I will be rereading again and again. Definitely a five star book!!



This book was supplied by NetGalley. The opinions and thoughts expressed are honest and my own.

Was this review helpful?

Captivating interest from beginning to end of this story, "An Unlikely Match".
Two senior sisters who love to play matchmaker have their hands full, not only with the couple they are trying to bring together, but also with the occupant that lives in one of the structures on their land. And adding to those full hands are a movie production team and their RVs.

The intertwining of humor and seriousness mixed with a tiny bit of mystery and light romance made this book just right. Beth wrote an impressive storyline about healing. Everything within the story speaks to the heart of the reader.

Overall I really look forward to the third book in this series by Beth Wiseman, "A Season of Change".

I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley, no monetary exchange, only agreement was that I write an honest review of my own words. This is my review in my own words.

Was this review helpful?

I thought that this was a sweet romance, but I was disappointed that there wasn't as much emphasis on the Amish way of life and more on Jayce, a troubled man who had a difficult relationship with his father. The ending seemed rushed since you learn that Jayce had decided to join the Order (the Amish faith), but you don't really learn about his decision making process. It is a huge lifestyle change and it would have been interesting to learn more about his thoughts and experiences. There was also a lot of emphasis on the Amish sisters who owned the inn. It might have been better to read the series in order.

Was this review helpful?

Although this is book two in The Amish Inn Novels, don’t let that stop if you haven’t read book one, A Picture of Love. An Unlikely Match can be read as a standalone, although you will want to read book one because it’s good.

The book was a bit surprising because you don’t often read about an Amish girl falling for the son of a movie producer. That pretty much goes against the Ordnung. But that doesn’t stop author Beth Wiseman from tackling it, and doing it well.

With likeable characters who will make you laugh, such as sisters Lizzie and Esther, and househelp Rose, you’ll want to go visit the Peony Inn. Oh, and let’s not forget grumpy old Gus who has a secret I never expected.

This story is charming, shows that we all want to be loved and accepted, and has a mystery along with a sweet romance. I loved it and hope you will to.

I received a complimentary copy of this book but was not required to leave a review.

Was this review helpful?

An Unlikely Match by Beth Wiseman is book two in The Amish Inn Novel series. This is a great story that could be read alone, but it does follow up after the first in the series so it is best to read this series in order. This story is well written with caring and sometimes funny characters. I really enjoyed reading this story. I enjoyed Jayce’s character as he follows through with a commitment to his father and he looks towards what his future will be. He is so caring and helps all those around him. His struggle with could he give up everything he has grown up with to pursue a relationship with Evelyn is so real. I also enjoyed the characters of Gus and the Inn’s new employee. The writing is so clear I could almost taste the terrible food she cooked.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and Zondervan publishing. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

An Unlikely Match by Beth Wiseman is the 2nd book in The Amish Inn Novels. Esther and Lizzie have twelve guests descending on The Peony Inn from Los Angeles. Lizzie told Esther that the guests are from a produce company with meetings in the area. It turns out that it is a production company. They will be staying a month while they shoot a movie nearby. The ladies are unprepared for the two limousines as well as two large RVs with their loud generators. It seems that some of the guests are not willing to live without modern conveniences. Jayce Clarkson meets Evelyn Schrock and is smitten with her. Evelyn knows that they cannot be, but she is attracted to Jayce. He is the first man with whom she could envision having a future. What does God have in store for these star-crossed lovers? An Unlikely Match can be read as a standalone, but you will be missing out on a cute Amish novel if you do not read A Picture of Love. I thought An Unlikely Match was well-written with great characters. I love Esther and Lizzie. In addition, there is grumpy Gus who surprises you at times. We get to meet Rose who is Esther and Lizzie’s new helper. They need to keep Rose away from sugar and caffeine. There is one scene with Rose that had me laughing so hard. An Unlikely Match is a character driven book. I enjoyed the witty banter. We get to see the differences between the Englisch and Amish worlds in this story. Jayce is curious about the Amish. He asks Evelyn many questions about the Amish and their beliefs. There are some touching moments in this tale. I like how faith was incorporated into the story. It is present and the point is made without it being preachy. Prayer and the importance of listening for God’s voice are items I gleamed from the story. An Unlikely Match is one of those stories that you do not want to end. I am eager for the next book in The Amish Inn Novels. An Unlikely Match is a delightful Amish tale with septuagenarian matchmakers, a grumpy Gus, an energetic Rose, rain galore, clamorous generators, and mouthwatering meals.

Was this review helpful?

Adorable elderly Amish innkeepers Esther and Lizzie are back in this heartwarming romance of forbidden love as a movie set rolls into their small Amish community.

Evelyn doesn't want to settle in love, and she is intrigued by Jayce Clarkson who is working hard to make his own way while putting in his time with his father's production company. I liked their easy friendship, and Jayce is a thoughtful man with dreams of his own, and I loved how he get's on well with Lizzie and Esther.

I like that this series follows the sisters Lizzie and Esther, one of my favorite parts of the story is the friendship between Esther and Gus, and I was so happy to see it continued from the previous book. Rose is a hardworking, well meaning young woman, and I couldn't help but admire her determination and industry.

Overall, a charming Amish romance, with wonderful engaging characters, a fun plot, faith and family.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked the last Beth Wiseman I read so I had high expectations for this one. They weren't quite met but this was a lovely read still.
A love story that can't be, a broken boy, a girl that's looking for more. It's a love story but it's also a story about people who love and don't, who fail and try again. The elderly matchmaking sisters and the characters with heart and failings that sound very true are what make this book and it works. Very good read and, although it can be read as a standalone, I wish I'd read the first in the series previously.

Was this review helpful?

This is an Amish Clean Romance, and this is the second book in the Amish Inn series. I have read and review the first book in this series before reading this book. I do not think you have to read the first book before picking this book up. I have to say this series is a very different for the normal Amish Clean Romance series. I love the characters in this book. Jayce is an Englisher that stays at the Inn with his Dad because they are filming a movie. Jayce fells in love with a cute Amish girl named Evelyn. I love both Jayce and Evelyn characters. I also loved seeing more of the character of Gus for the first book. We get some of Gus's backstory, and I really love Gus. I am so happy his character is more in this book. I love the character development this book gets, and this book is so character driven. I think this book does a good job showing some of the difference between the Amish and the English world. I love a book that I fell in love with all the characters. I did not want to put this book down at anytime during me reading this book. I was kindly provided an e-copy of this book by the publisher (Zondervan) or author (Beth Wiseman) via NetGalley, so I can give honest review about how I feel about this book. I want to send a big Thank you to them for that.

Was this review helpful?