Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley and the publisher for the chance to read this graphic novel!

Rating: 4.5 stars

I absolutely adored “Super Late Bloomer” by this author, so when I saw “My Life in Transition” to read on NetGalley I instantly hit download and read it in one sitting.

I loved the overall format, where each page is a day in the author's life over the course of 6 months.

Overall, I highly recommend this to anyone looking for more queer and/or non-fiction comics. I can’t wait to read more by Julia Kaye!

Was this review helpful?

This book is written in comic strips. It was very interesting to see the progression throughout a long period of time of someone who is transitioning. I especially liked how the relationships and way of thinking changed. The author is very brave for putting their thoughts out.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great slice-of-life cartoon compilation, and I certainly appreciated how much range Julia Kaye captured in this volume, from joy to misery to more ambiguous emotions. The premise (drawing a cartoon a day for 6 months) is immediately engaging, and this is a great complement to her first volume.

Was this review helpful?

There was a lot for me, as a cismale, to consider and think about in this book. It was funny and heartfelt. What I liked most about it is that the comics made clear that trans people are people. They have thoughts and emotions that are, in some ways, not so different than anyone else. They are not some scary "other." All this made without bashing the readers over the head. I enjoyed this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is a wonderful and honest comic strip depicting 6 months in the life of the author/artist, a trans woman. It will be relatable for those who have transitioned or are thinking of it, but it's also relatable just as a human dealing with insecurities, breakups, grief, toxic family members, friendships, etc. It is not a funny comic strip but it's an ultimately hopeful, poignant, interesting and impactful one. Highly recommended.

I read a temporary digital ARC of this book via Net Galley for review.

Was this review helpful?

A cute and genuinely fun life comic, still dealing with heavier themes of family and relationships, all in the midst of transitioning. The found family moments alleviated the heavier parts; the stress inducing aspects of dating and recent heartbreak, and the anxiety of less than accepting family. A very vulnerable comic.

Was this review helpful?

I received a digital ARC through NetGalley from Andrews McMeel Publishing. This 2nd volume in Julia Kaye’s journey really hit its stride. This volume focuses on a specific 6 month period of dated graphic strips of her life during transition. There are ups, downs, anxiety, romance and so much more. She does a nice foreword, epilogue and afterword, which makes joining her journey deeply personal and not just about the day to day of this time period. I thank her for putting her life so fully on the page.

Was this review helpful?

My Life in Transition
Author/Cartoonist: Julia Kaye
Genre: Collection of webtoons
Pages: 167
Publication Date: 2/16/2021

This collection is written and drawn by Julia Kaye and describes Julia’s experiences after she transitioned. It focuses on her life after the early days of her transition and covers topics such as break-ups, mental health, dating, and friendship. The collection covers a six-month period from December 2018 to June 2019.

What I liked:
*I love that this collection focuses on life after the transition. When trans people are depicted in media, the focus is often on their transition and the early days. This collection allows us to see some of Julia’s authentic experiences of what her “new normal” is going to be.
*The art style reminds me of the Sunday funnies. It is easy to read and very cute.
*I really enjoyed the chronological nature of this collection showing us small victories and setbacks for Julia.
*I liked that this comic depicted the complexity of gender after the transition. The societal influences do not disappear after someone transitions but continue to impact how they see themselves, how others see them and who they attracted to.
*The afterword was *powerful* talking about regret. As someone who came to her queerness later in life, I have grabbled with this. I really hope the author explores this theme in future comics as it is powerful!

What I didn’t like:
*The cover was very hard to read due to the lack of contrast. I had to enlarge the cover to be able to read the title and see the art. The cover also did not draw me in as I scrolled by it several times before reading the description.
*At times, I felt like the narrative did not fit the three-panel cartoon. Subsequently, some of the third panels were filler or platitudes that did not feel authentic.
*The story arc about Julia’s relationship with Liv felt abrupt. In several comics, we are shown how happy they are and then they break-up with little explanation. As the reader, I was unclear why they broke-up. Julia talks about how they just were not a good fit, but it would have been better to see that lack of a fit depicted in comics before their break-up or in flashbacks.

I would highly recommend this collection of webtoons. The artwork is cute and will remind you of the warm feelings you had reading the Sunday funnies as a kid while the narrative is powerful depiction of life after transition. It is a quick and thoughtful read.

Was this review helpful?

More than anything, I appreciate Julia Kaye for taking the time to document these parts of her life. Many people often only see the beginning stages of transition or the focus ON transition and Kaye takes the opportunity to allow people to explore life beyond just that singular detail while acknowledging that being trans is often a major part of identity and self.

The comics are short and fun to read and I feel that, even if someone is not trans, they would find themselves able to relate to many of Kaye's experiences with dating, breakups, family struggles, and more. As a queer person, the added layer of familiarity compared to my own life was a touch of homecoming, recognizing that there are others who experience similar things as I do too.

Was this review helpful?

My Life in Transition: A Super Late Bloomer Collection
eARC Netgalley Review

I loved this collection of comics by Julia Kaye. As a whole, it was endearing and powerful in its simplicity. Julia's story is very different from my own yet I still found myself relating to her.

Spanning over the course of six months, Julia drew a comic a day. It's a collection of moments, big and small, three years after she began her transition. Some days were devastating and others had me laughing out loud.

For anyone who enjoys reading stories told in comic form -- this is a must read. I would love to own a physical copy once published. I’m also about to go buy her first collection now too!

Was this review helpful?

Have you ever been so lucky to find yourself a new favorite author? I feel like 2020 is just filled with amazing gems that I’m utterly grateful.

This is the second graphic novel I read by the author and I totally love the way she draws her daily life, since I think we all can relate to funny, wholehearted moments with friends, as well as the loss and grief of someone loved, perhaps you don’t know what are you doing with your life, but that’s OK. The beauty of life is that nobody really knows what the future would hold and pretending to have it all figured it all is more painful than not. We have both good and bad moments, and we should cherish them all. Life should not be taken for granted and we all should make the effort to live the way we really want to.

Anyway, Julia takes us into her private life and she show us her doubts and struggles with dating, or the exciting feeling of meeting new people. She lets us know she has the best friends as well as the important moments of solitude: those we need to heal from past relationships and maybe, even learn how to take care and forgive oneself.

I seriously loved every single page and it made me chuckle the same way it made me realize that perhaps we don’t see big changes from day to day life, but after six months, a year or more, we surely change –hopefully into someone better, kinder.

Was this review helpful?

First, I want to thank NetGalley and Andrews McMeel Publishing for giving me early access to this book in exchange for an honest review.

In many ways, this was a quick read because each page is a 3 panel comic, but this is a book that feels like it's one the reader can return to again and again. While there are some everyday parts of her life that she depicts, there is also a huge range of deep emotions that readers are taken on as well: joy, pain, recovery, uncertainty, healing.

While there are parts of her story that I cannot fully relate to because I'm cis gendered, there were also many emotions that I could relate to in my own way. And that reminder that even though our experiences are different, we are all still so human and all feel many similar emotions throughout our lives is beautiful and powerful.

I would highly recommend this book for anyone would enjoys stories about real people going through life, but especially for anyone who is transgender to be reaffirmed that you aren't alone on your path to expressing who you are more authentically to the world.

Was this review helpful?

I haven’t read any of this author‘s previous works, but knowing any other of Julia‘s comics wasn’t necessary to understand this book.
First things first. The art style: I didn’t love it, but that’s just my personal subjective opinion.
Secondly the plot. Since the comic tells the author‘s personal experiences it’s difficult to review it. It was incredibly interesting to get insights into the experiences of someone who is transgender. Some of the incidents mentioned were almost painful to read because I really felt for Julia.
Sometimes the change of scenes felt rather abrupt though. For example we‘d get to see a scene where the author has a really hurtful experience, and the next scene would be about having fun watching tv with some friends. I would’ve preferred a little more depth in these moments.
Parts of the book we’re also a little repetitive.
Overall this was an interesting read, but flawed based on the autobiographical nature of the comic.

Was this review helpful?

I'm sad to say that I cant download this one. Which is sad because I was really looking forward to reading it. Hopefully, the download will be fixed soon and I'll be able to leave a real review.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a fan of Julia online. I didn't know this was a sequel, but I didn't have any problems understanding the plot without reading the first book. I found the format a little annoying on mobile, but I'm sure that's fixed in the formal file.

Was this review helpful?

Julia Kaye is such a gift.

For those who wondered where she went after Super Late Bloomer, Kaye has returned to show us! There is something so refreshing and so joyful about a trans woman documenting the real ups-and-downs of her life when she has already begun to pass. Kaye writes about strangers generally recognizing her as a woman, and her LGBT friends, and tons of romance; and also about the aspects of her transition she still hopes to complete, her struggles with transphobic family, and days that seem impossible to get through.

For many trans people, it's hard to imagine what it will be like to live happily as yourself. I have a vision of who I want to be, but they often seem completely out of reach. Kaye happily proves that, while you may change during your transition, the other side isn't so mysterious after all. You're still you, and you still have your good and bad days. A lot of your trans-related problems dissolve just slightly with transitioning. It could not possibly be overstated how important an accessible, good-hearted, honest autobiographical comic from a trans woman can be, and this one delivers on every front.

In terms of the comic medium, this book pleases me every time I look at it-- cute style, skilled flexibility, cohesive tone, easy to read, so so so difficult to put down. I happily took an hour out of my day just to sit down and enjoy Kaye's work. There wasn't a strip I disliked seeing, and there wasn't a moment I wanted to step away, which is not just surprising but incredibly impressive for daily comics. I hadn't even considered a second collection after SLB, but here it is, and it's just as good as the first.

In general, I really can't overstate how happy I am with this book. And the chance to read it and review it early! Fantastic. Highly recommend if any of the above-- autobiographical comics, trans memoirs, etc-- appeal to you. I'm confident both cis and trans people will enjoy it (though perhaps trans people will laugh a little harder at some very relatable moments.) Already excited to see Kaye's next collection, and going to bed smiling thinking about this one.

Was this review helpful?

A warm and heart-searching recounting of the author/artist's early years of transition. Relationships, friendships, clothing, lingering dysphoria and more are blended in storylines that shine with realism, sincerity, and the warmth of Kaye's wonderful friendships as well as her own heart.

Was this review helpful?

As I always say in cases like this I am not own voices so please seek out own voices reviews first!
Okay so I did not read the first graphic novel by Kaye but that is only because I had no idea that it existed. I really liked this as a little look into what it is like after coming out and after transitioning. This book was not all happy or all sad it was very much what a slice of life should be like.
This is one of those books I would suggest all book stores and libraries should carry. This is a book that would and will help so many young or just early trans people. This is simply one of those books every should at least know about.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Andrews McMeel Publishingm for the digital galley of this book.

My Life in Transition is the follow up to Kaye’s earlier collection, Super Late Bloomer, and though the art-style and tone is the same, Kaye is further along in her journey, and it’s really cool to see her grow and change. She mentions in the afterword that though she felt super out of sorts and like she didn’t know what she was doing, by drawing a comic each day, her life follows a pretty clear arc, and that is great for self-discovery, but also it makes for compelling storytelling.

This book isn’t about the transition so much as the existence of being trans in society once the hormones have done their thing. I really enjoyed being along for the ride of Kaye’s journey. It was like catching up with an old friend I hadn’t seen in a year or so, and in these wild times, that is even more comforting.

This collection is out in February, and if you enjoy good things with a bit of humor and a lot of heart, check it out!
Thanks to NetGalley and Andrews McMeel Publishingm for the digital galley of this book.

My Life in Transition is the follow up to Kaye’s earlier collection, Super Late Bloomer, and though the art-style and tone is the same, Kaye is further along in her journey, and it’s really cool to see her grow and change. She mentions in the afterword that though she felt super out of sorts and like she didn’t know what she was doing, by drawing a comic each day, her life follows a pretty clear arc, and that is great for self-discovery, but also it makes for compelling storytelling.

This book isn’t about the transition so much as the existence of being trans in society once the hormones have done their thing. I really enjoyed being along for the ride of Kaye’s journey. It was like catching up with an old friend I hadn’t seen in a year or so, and in these wild times, that is even more comforting.

This collection is out in February, and if you enjoy good things with a bit of humor and a lot of heart, check it out!

Was this review helpful?

A very nice follow-up to Super Late Bloomer as Julia grows more into herself as a trans woman and tries out the world of dating, which is horrible no matter what your preference is. Dating SUUUUCKS! It sucks suck sucks!

Was this review helpful?