Member Reviews

This was a beautiful tale. A rendition of the ugly duckling. From the start of the story we get to know Audrey's struggles with feeling left out by her family. From her sisters bullying and her father's indifference. It was nice to see her spirit shine in the midst of all this and when disaster strikes and her father tries to later marry her off, she runs away and finds herself being taken care of at the Dericott Castle.
I loved her spirit and how she didn't let her circumstances turn her into someone else. She learned to rest in God through all her struggles.
Edwin has also been through a lot and had to learn to deal with his deformity. He finds Audrey different and they gradually fall in love and even have to make hard decisions concerning Maris.
This was a wonderful story with themes of honour.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions expressed are solely mine.

Was this review helpful?

I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Castle of Refuge is the second installment in The Dericott Tales. Just like the previous book, I completely devoured this one. Which is somewhat interesting since I'm not a big fan of Christian Fiction. Yet, somehow, these books are just so easy to get lost in. I could do with less 'thank god we are alive' though but I could see why they were said so many times as well.

In it, you will meet Audrey and Edwin. Now Audrey has always been put down by her own sister. Someone who she should look up to but is constantly afraid of. I mean.. the girl was definitely something with a side of crazy. I hated how she constantly put Audrey down and tried to kill her.

Then there's Edwin who was just all kinds of sweet. He's like my little cinnamon roll and I just loved him with all my heart. Together they were just really cute and I liked their little slow burn of a romance. Even though I definitely wanted more but I'm good with what I got since it's Christian Fiction.

Other than that, I'm pretty intrigued by the third book becoming a possibility. I can't wait for it to become available - published or ARC just so I can continue with this retelling adventure.

Was this review helpful?

In this medieval tale of danger and trying times, Audrey seeks to make a difference in the world. However, her older sister, Maris, hates her and tries to harm her and ruin her bright future. Set in England, with castles and knights, the story gives an authentic picture of life in the fourteenth century. Lord Edwin Dericott, who has also suffered physical injury, comes to the rescue of an injured maiden. The novel focuses on these two and their struggles in life. It seems like each chapter plunges them into further peril. Audrey and Edwin seem quite realistic, but Maris is over the top. Another fine fairy tale retelling by a talented author. The book is part of a series, but stands alone too. I received a copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Castle of Reguge was a great book that helped me forget about my own stresses and worries for a little bit. Audrey and Edwin have many more stressors than I have ever had! It was a fun book to escape into for a little while.

Audrey's sister, Maris, suffers from mental health issues. Many called her crazy or mad, which would have been appropriate for the time period. Maris is jealous and seeks to make Audrey just as miserable as she is. In a moment Audrey's life is forever changed and her options limited.

Edwin comes from a loving home, but things change when he and his brothers are charged with treason. His life is altered as well and his options also become limited. This is a story of two people who have been broken. Their friendship helps to mend both of them. The world is open to them as they heal together. Their life isn't perfect, there are many obstacles that they must overcome and danger is always near. Maris is still out for revenge and trying to destroy Audrey's life.

This story is a loosely based retelling of the Ugly Duckling. It is a friend to more romance that is squeaky clean. The story contains Christian-based themes. It is entertaining and engaging.

Source: I received a complimentary copy via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this book, but it just fell flat for me. I didn't feel any connection with Audrey and Edwin. Even the challenges with Maris didn't capture my attention. I ended up skimming through the last half of the book.

I received a copy from Netgalley. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second book in the Dericott series by Melanie Dickerson. While you could read it as a stand alone book, the first book offers some helpful background information. I really enjoyed this story and the journey that the main characters went on. Both Edwin and Audrey have suffered physical and emotional wounds, which have scarred them in more ways than one. Both have issues of mistrust and insecurity. While Edwin's wounds occurred in book one while he was defending his family, Audrey's occurred as a result of the cruelty and neglect of hers. That aspect is especially challenging to read and may need some discussion with sensitive/younger readers. I did appreciate that both characters persevered despite their struggles. Melanie expertly provided the contrast of very difficult situations that could lead to hatred and bitterness with choosing a path of love and forgiveness. She did this while still showing that forgiving someone doesn't mean you allow them to continue to abuse you. This is a relevant lesson for young adult readers (and really all readers), even as the book is set in the Middle Ages. Above all, this story shows that trusting in God, even when circumstances seem hopeless, gives us the courage to continue on.

I would definitely recommend this series to Young Adult and older readers.



**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in order to share my personal opinion, which I did.**

Was this review helpful?

My heart went out to Audrey right from the start. She has such a gentle loving spirit who tries so hard to forgive and love her sister, even though it is so not deserved. Between facing her abusive sister or marrying a man older than her father she feels she has no other choice but to run away. She finds things can get worse when she wakes up to find she is being robbed of her money, valuables and her horse. God is watching out for Audrey and when she finally wakes up from being very sick for three days, she is at Dericott Castle. The home of a former acquaintance . I enjoyed this story and found the adventure and mystery interesting.
Thank you to Thomas Nelson through NetGalley for allowing me to read and review this book. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This was the first book I’ve read by Melanie Dickerson. Halfway through, I was pretty sure I’d found a new favorite author!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Recommendation

Highly and happily recommend! I am so excited, not only about this book, but also with the prospect of reading more from Melanie Dickerson.
Clean Reading

As a child and teenager, I read a variety of books from different genres and only occasionally came across objectionable content that would make me close a book and stop reading. Of course, the fact that I typically chose children’s fiction made for cleaner reading than the books in the YA section.

As an adult, I’ve continued the trend of enjoying children’s books. Typically, if I read an adult (or YA) book, it’s in the Christian genre. The one major difference I’ve noticed is that, even in children’s books, I find that’s it so much harder to find wholesome content.

For this reason, I’ve been wanting to find more “go-to” Christian authors (my favorites are Ted Dekker, Robin Jones Gunn, Melody Carlson, Frank Peretti and Bill Myers). With that said, I have just finished my first book by Melanie Dickerson and am so happy to report that she may be a new “go-to” author for me. Reading this book was such a blessing!

Genre

I wanted to comment on genre, because this is the first book, of its type, that I’ve read. Castle of Refuge is a Christian, YA fairy tale. It might more accurately be described as “historical fiction,” because the story is realistic— no magic, nor mythology. However, the book is also marketed as an adaptation of the Ugly Duckling story, which drew me in, and is set in the same time period as many beloved fairy tale/ adventure stories.

I’ve read my fair share of Christian adventure/allegory stories for children (which are some of my very favorite books to read), as well as some realistic Christian fiction for teens (which I also really enjoy), but am not accustomed to seeing this type of book for this particular age group. I also really like that the novel did not include magic, because, YA novels often take on a darker tone with magic. Plus, I’ve seen more and more books that are sympathetic to witchcraft, as well as a rise of witchcraft in our society, so am more reticent toward inclusion of magic, in general.

Tales of Dericott

When I first saw this book on NetGalley, I decided not to request it because I saw that it was the second in a series. I later thought I was mistaken and ended up requesting it.

This book is indeed part of a book series. However, I’m glad to say that it definitely “works” as a standalone. Based on the synopsis I read about book one, it is from the perspective of a completely different character, who plays only a small role in book two. Although I do my best to avoid jumping into series in the middle, I didn’t feel that I missed out on any important information because I started with the second book. The one disclaimer I would add is that, having read book two, I have no desire to backtrack to book one, because the events (and conclusion) of book one are clearly spelled out.

Characters

I found the protagonists, Audrey and Edwin, to be very likable, as well as inspiring. Both characters desire to do what is right and to show love and compassion to those around them. They are also determined to live out Jesus’ teachings, even when their actions defy societal expectations. Secondary characters were also well-fleshed out and believable.

Spiritual Elements

I also found this book refreshing because of the spiritual elements. Audrey’s faith informs her moment-by-moment life, as well as her dreams for the future. We often catch glimpses of her praying or remembering Scriptures. This reminded me a little bit of the Mandie books by Lois Gladys Leppard, but the writing was a lot better, in my opinion.

Even the romance is surrounded with interactions with God. I say “even the romance” in contrast with certain Christian romances that seem to include faith as an afterthought. This book is grounded!

Romance

Based on the first part of the book, the second half included a bit more romance (kissing scenes) than I had expected. However, there is a clear statement of commitment before this happens. Because of the amount of romance, I would not recommend this book to children, but think that it is appropriate for a YA audience. There was also some definite allegory along with the romance 🙂

CLICK HERE FOR A FREE EXCERPT
“It’s always noble to save your own life from someone who’s trying to harm you.”

Melanie Dickerson
This was one of my favorite quotes because, as Christians, it is easy to mistake self-hatred for self-sacrifice. Audrey learns more about her identity throughout the book 🙂

Was this review helpful?

This book is a book in front of a fire kind of book, even with the heavier subjects touched upon. Characters are well developed and seem to be positive. I like how Dickerson always makes the best of the situations she writes about. These two characters have gone through more in a life time than most people and still manage to find happiness. Beautiful story.

Thank you to NetGalley for an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review.

Was this review helpful?

Audrey has grown up in fear while living with her older sister, Maris, whose sole purpose seems to be tormenting and emotionally abusing her younger sister. Many of Audrey’s beliefs about herself and her actions are influenced by her sister’s ongoing abuse toward her, something that is well-known by others in the household and yet rarely addressed. She had once hoped to marry but feels that is now nothing but a dream after Maris purposely trips her into the fire, leaving her with burns on one side of her face. With her prospects looking grim, Audrey chooses to leave a life of material comfort and stability and runs away, never expecting she’ll run into the man she once imagined a future with.
Edwin, who will be familiar to readers who are up to date on Dickerson’s work, has also undergone some physical changes and is adjusting to the loss of his left arm. Like Audrey, he feels like has become less or isn’t seen as being as worthy as he once was. However, the two see the other as they did at their first meeting, with their own internal thoughts holding them back.
Dickerson’s books are comfort reads, even with the heavier subjects touched upon. Characters feel familiar, and though the characters confront various challenges and danger, there are always positive moments, rich friendships, and a happily ever after for the couple. The medieval setting is used to advance the plot and explain why the characters act in a certain way, though some of the details feel anachronistic. I know enough history that this jarred me out of the story a few times and took away from what otherwise was a light, enjoyable read. If these had been left out or the time period adjusted, it would have improved the story dramatically for me.
Thank you to Just Read Tours and the publisher for a complimentary copy. This did not affect my review.

Was this review helpful?

Melanie wrote the emotional trauma and struggles of both Audrey and Edwin beautifully. She gave great insight into their understanding hearts while still being true to their fears and vulnerability.

There was a time or two I wasn’t sure if I loved how Maris was portrayed. It was a tricky thing to show her as both equally damaged, and malicious. I appreciated the back story we were given and the small glimmer of hope for her future. She did present a really good foil for Audrey who had also experienced neglect and trauma and chose to stay positive.

Melanie’s stories can some time seem a little formulaic in their plot structure, but she teaches fabulous things in a way that can resonate with ya readers.

Was this review helpful?

I loved everything about Castle Of Refuge! From the gorgeous cover to the fast-moving plot to the engaging characters, Castle of Refuge is sure to delight. I must admit that I devoured it in one day! Melanie Dickerson continues to earn her title as Queen of Fairy tale retellings! I love all things medieval and this book is delightful. So brew a pot of tea and curl up in your favorite reading nook, you will soon be lost in a world long gone by.

I was given a copy of this book with no expectations. All thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Castle of Refuge by Melanie Dickerson is the second book in the Dericott Tales series. And while it is a young adult book, it would be enjoyed by readers of all ages. Audrey and Edwin’s tale is one of acceptance--both of others and self--and finding God’s purpose in your life even if it doesn’t look like what you once dreamed. I loved these themes in the book and how easily they can apply to reader’s lives today.
One of my favorite things in this book was when Audrey had the opportunity to teach the girls in the village to read. I loved that she included girls from all walks of life and how she provided much more than just reading lessons with baked goods, friendship, and encouragement. And it warmed my heart to see Edwin be so supportive of her cause when that would not have been a popular view from men of his class at the time.
Overall, I enjoyed this story. The romance was slow and sweet and based upon more than physical attraction. I think the story’s message is great for young adults especially, but any fan of medieval fiction/romance would enjoy this book.
I was given a copy of the book by the publisher with no expectations of a positive review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Melanie Dickerson has delivered another delightfully romantic medieval romance in this retelling of the Ugly Duckling story. As always, she creates a strong heroine and a swoon-worthy hero in a tale of adventure and true love that also teaches powerful spiritual lessons. Her writing style could be considered more at the young adult level, but I absolutely love her books and know that they appeal to young adult and adult readers alike. The romance in this book was especially sweet, and I particularly loved that Audrey and Edwin fell in love about halfway through the book so that we could see them handle adversity and trials as an engaged couple before their wedding, which is rare for Christian fiction! Wonderfully romantic rescue scenes are always my favorite, and with Edwin determined to defend Audrey from the very start of the story, he is the best type of protective and adoring hero. I also loved that Edwin and Audrey deal with emotional and physicals scars to gain self-confidence in Christ and deal with the hatred of others with grace. This is an important lesson for so many to learn, and I am glad Melanie Dickerson tackled this subject so well. Castle of Refuge is yet another marvelous medieval fairytale retelling from Melanie Dickerson, and I highly recommend it (like all her books) to those who love adventure, romance, and spiritual lessons weaved into a book that you simply cannot put down.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley for review purposes. My thoughts are my own— I really did love it!

Was this review helpful?

Cover:

Das Cover gefällt mir wieder richtig gut. Es ist märchenhaft und sehr ansprechend gestaltet. Wirklich ansprechend!

Inhalt:

Audrey hat seit einem traumatischen Ereignis aus ihrer Jugend Narben im Gesicht, die ihre Chancen auf eine Liebesheirat bzw. eine gute Heirat stark einschränken. Außerdem lebt sie in ständiger Angst vor ihrer Schwester, die sie dauernd bedroht. Als sie schließlich einen alten Ritter heiraten soll und ihre Schwester nach einem längeren Aufenthalt im Kloster zurück nach Hause kommt, sieht Audrey keinen anderen Weg als zu fliehen.

Edwin Dericott lebt seit einigen Ungerechtigkeiten in seiner Vergangenheit als Lord Dericott in seinem Schloss. Dort muss er sich damit zurechtfinden, dass er einen Arm verloren hat und viele Dinge neu lernen.

Als er eines Tages ein fremdes Mädchen während eines schlimmen Unwetters vor seinem Schloss findet, beginnt für beide eine aufregende Zeit voller Abenteuer, Gefahren und Liebe.

Meinung:

Mir hat das Buch wieder unfassbar gut gefallen. Vor allem Edwin war einfach super. Man kann sich nur in ihn verlieben. Er nimmt viel Rücksicht und versucht das Leben aller zu verbessern. Audrey ist eine unfassbar fröhliche, liebevolle junge Frau, die trotz ihrer Vergangenheit immer noch Hoffnung hat.

Die Spannung war konstant und man wollte ständig weiterlesen. Der Schreibstil war typisch für Melanie Dickerson. Es lässt sich locker und leicht lesen.

Am Ende war es mit teilweise etwas zu viel Drama, aber trotzdem weiterhin fesselnd. Man kann das Buch eben wirklich kaum aus der Hand legen.

Fazit:

Eins meiner liebsten Melanie Dickerson Bücher. Ich kann es wirklich jedem nur ans Herz legen, vor allem weil die Charakter so super sind.

Was this review helpful?

Melanie Dickerson is know for her retelling of classic fairy tales. In Castle of Refuge, she gives us the tale of the Ugly Duckling. This is the second of the Dericott Tales. Our heroine is a Vicounts daughter who has been cruelly abused by her older sister. She runs away and eventually ends up in Dericott Castle where she begins working as a servant.

I had looked forward to reading this book. A fairy tale in medieval England was something I should have enjoyed reading. I wanted to love it. But I didn’t. I was bored. None of the characters captured my attention. The pacing was slow, and I often found myself skimming forward to find something interesting. I was disappointed by this book.

I received a copy of Castles of Refuge from Net Galley in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars rounded up. A sweet (if a little slow) medieval retelling of the Ugly Duckling.
I liked Edwin quite a bit. His ability to see past Audrey's scars is sweet. Audrey's sister, Maris, is quite the villain. I love that both Audrey and Edwin treat those around them with compassion and kindness, when they could have used every excuse to do the opposite after the trials they have faced, both apart and together.

Was this review helpful?

"Audrey hid behind a tree and watched a knight and his squire riding down the lane." From the first line to the last, Castle of Refuge captivated me. It is Gripping. Compelling. Powerful. And faith is as natural as breathing.

"That was what Audrey wished for her life to be-a burst of light. An intense color."

Audrey is the viscount's daughter, and as such, high expectations are put upon her. But when her sister Maris acts maliciously against her, scarring her, her father gives up the ideals of a good marriage for her. Audrey makes the best of the situation and always has a positive outlook, and a healthy fear of her sister. Audrey shows great courage and resilience, including a desire to do something extraordinary.

"Love had always seemed to be the highest ideal, a noble goal, since the opposite of love was what caused so much evil in life."

Maris is also the viscount's daughter. However, due to the cruelty from a nurse when she is younger, she is vengeful and mad. She takes great pleasure in seeing others suffer. When her father sends her to a convent it incenses her more. Once she is released from the convent she sets out to ruin any chance of Audrey having happiness.

"She was only a girl, not worthy of respect."

Lord Edwin Dericott has scars of his own. Edwin is a good man who never intended to be "Lord" so young. He is one of the good guys, always tries to do the right thing, and willing to fight for what he believes in. He is intrigued by Audrey from the moment she enters his castle.

"Edwin was being defended. From a badger. By a girl."

This is my first book by Melanie Dickerson and it will not be my last. I have resisted reading anything by her because I was not sure that I would enjoy a fairy tale retelling, it's never been my thing. But, I read this book and I want so much more!!! While it is the second book in the series I do not feel that I missed anything (although I probably did!), so I feel it can be read as a stand-alone. Fans of fairy tale retellings, Melanie Dickerson, and historical fiction will enjoy this book.

Thank you to Net Galley, Thomas Nelson, and the author for the opportunity to read this book. I was not expected to give a glowing review, but am happy to do so. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't realize that Castle of Refuge was the second book in a series when I had the privilege of reading it. I didn't feel lost or that I was missing anything. #CastleofRefuge is a Christian romance novel set in 14th century England where we have knights saving ladies, women who are just as malicious as men, and budding love. It was a fun escape from real life and an enjoyable book. Thank you #NetGalley for allowing me to give my voluntary and honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for this advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review.

I did read book 1 in the Dericott Tales but didn’t necessarily need to, as the first story was mentioned several times.

This is supposed to be Edwins book, but it turned into a Audrey vs. Maris plot with a side of Dericott romance. The love story was sweet and the disability and treatment by others regarding that was talked about extensively (mostly Audrey).
The first half of the book, I couldn’t put down, but then it started to go slow and Maris kept popping up and it dragged to the end. There was a lot of talking to God and faith which seemed more as a filler to me and repetitive.

Overall the first half of the book gets 4 stars from me, but the second half only 2 stars, so in the end it’s a 3 star read.

Was this review helpful?