Holy hold on to your hat for this gothic and romantic mystery.
Jane, the main character, is pretty level-headed when it comes to life. She looks at life situations thru facts, until she starts working alongside her proposed husband, Augustine. Is he everything he says he is? Why can't she stay at his official home?
I gathered that is in late 1800s due to the setting, and the medical practices that are shared. I enjoyed that part of the story as it is very unique.
The bulk of the mystery takes place at Augustine's home outside of town.
Sterling has done a creative job involving the reader in the emotion of the story... I literally feel like I need a night light tonight.

The Death of Jane Lawrence by Caitlin Starling is an excellent novel that encompasses several genres: historical fiction, suspense, mystery, gothic fiction, horror, and it truly kept me captivated from beginning to end.

This novel takes place in the latter 1800s as my best guess, as it almost has a Victorian era feel to it. Here we readers take a mind-bending trip down the unraveling of an intricate and mystical plot to find out what is real and what is part of imagination, and what is from another realm.

Through the unveiling and untold portions of narrative (what is not said is just as important as what is said), we see the relationship and marriage of convenience of Jane and Augustine Lawrence. We see the medical oddities, surgical procedures, instruments, methods, and lives taking place within the medical community at that time. We see both individuals wanting one another, however both are haunted and holding back for reasons unique to each of their pasts. The awkwardness of this antagonistic coupling is part fiery part cold and limp.

As each layer of mystery is peeled away, we see that there is so much more under each layer in regards to not only Jane and Augustine, but also with their associates, hired help, colleagues, adopted families, their residences, and pasts.

There are so many mysteries and secrets and lies that I cannot even begin to describe this gem.

I was literally gripping the chair as I desperately turned pages to see what would happen next, what new surprise would be foretold around every dark and shadowy corner within Lindridge Hall, and within the hauntings that are held within.

I was scared, stunned, surprised, fascinated, and drawn to every twist and turn. I wanted for so many things to happen, yet afraid of the consequences that would take hold. And the end....I am still wrapping my brain around the conclusion. I love a book that leaves me thinking about its meaning for many hours thereafter. It isn’t very often that I get to experience that...and I love it.

This book is for anyone that wants a fascinating and addictive ride into the past that balances on this world and the next. An excellent book. I can’t wait to see what others think.

5/5 stars

Thank you NG and St. Martin’s Press for this awesome arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.

I am posting this review to my GR, Instagram, and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication.

I had an enjoyable time reading this and it held my attention the entire way through that I finished it within the day! I enjoyed every page and thought that the plot/story was very unique. Would recommend to anyone!

Fans of gothic horror are going to absolutely love this book! This novel was like Rebecca with a spark of magic. First, the book really takes you to the location. I loved the feel of the run down house where you can almost smell the musty damp smell. The main character is a smart, grounded woman who thinks in terms of numbers and equations. She's not the type to jump at any shadow. So the slow descent into this creepy house with secrets is just too good. There is also a romance story going on which is what reminded me so much of Rebecca. The combination of the two elements just makes such a good story. I highly recommend this book to anyone who is looking for the traditional "haunted house" story but with a refreshing new take!

My full review will be on my blog 30th September 2021.

Content Warnings: graphic surgical descriptions (1800s medical practices), body horror, gore, death, drug use, miscarriage.

I knew a lot about this book going into it, but somehow it still managed to surprise me at almost every turn. One thing that wasn’t a surprise was Caitlin Starling’s flawless prose. As always, I was blown away by the gorgeous writing itself. In all of her books, I don’t think Starling has ever wasted a word – everything builds together to create a beautiful and deep and usually horrifying world and THE DEATH OF JANE LAWRENCE is no different. If you like your horror steeped in gothic atmosphere and dangerous, gory magic, look no further.

The majority of this book is set in Lindridge Hall, the decaying family manor of Augustine Lawrence, Jane’s husband of convenience, and in true gothic fashion the manor feels like a character in its own right. It’s the perfect setting for the terrible, terrible things that Jane and Augustine go through, and i love the vivid descriptions that make it feel steeped in history and fear. It’s isolated, crumbling and atmospheric, and made me tense and anxious every time night fell and Jane was still in the Hall. I’ve read a lot of gothic horror and I am deeply impressed by the way that Starling built on the traditional characteristics of the genre to make the reader feel like they know exactly where it’s going, and then subverted all of those expectations. There’s a lot going on under the surface of this novel, and I would love to see more of this world.

Jane herself is, predictably, my absolute favourite part of this novel. A dedicated woman in a hellish situation of magic and madness? I love her. From the first chapter she stole my heart with her unusual and business-like approach to their marriage, and I adored seeing the way that she relates to the world. Jane is an accountant, focused on numbers and facts. She likes the tangible and has a strong sense of self and an almost stubborn grasp on the world around her. Which, obviously, makes her the perfect protagonist to stumble into her new husband’s messy past, full of secrets and magic. The way that she approaches magic is fascinating to me. I can’t go into it in too much detail without spoiling it, and I love the way it unravels far too much to risk that, but it’s a really interesting perspective and was a lot of fun to read as someone who habitually reads a lot of books about magic and craft.

The ending of this novel was honestly a mindfuck, in the best way possible. I stayed up far past my bedtime because I couldn’t put it down, and the first thing I did the next morning was reach for my kindle to finish it. It’s complicated and deliciously twisty and I know that the second I have a physical copy of this in my hands, I’m going to read it all over again because I have a feeling it’s going to be just as good the second time around.