Member Reviews

Disclaimer: I got this book in exchange for an honest review.

This book is ideal for fans of We Were Liars X Black Mirror X Studio Ghibli. Cee wakes up on an island with no idea of how she got there except for the fact that she has an old android and one memory: she has a sister that she needs to find. Kasey is a STEM prodigy who just wants to escape from science and her home that she used to trust. She has to decide if she wants to help save humanity by using science even though it let down people who mattered a lot to her. This book was pretty good, but it had a slow start.

Was this review helpful?

i won’t lie, one of the main reasons i joined joan’s street team was the potential to get ARCs of her books, and i am SO glad i did. i have no words for how wonderful this book was—the world building was amazingly intricate, the characters jumped off the page, the story was filled with plot twist after plot twist. it’s been i-don’t-even-know-how-long since the last time i read sci-fi, and this took a while to get into, but once i was onboard? oh my goodness. i could not stop reading. please read this book when you get a chance, and big thanks to macmillan for getting this book to all of hesina’s imperial court.

Was this review helpful?

We Were Liars meets Black Mirror in this twisting tale of two sisters, one who woke up on an abandoned island with no memory except of her sister and the other a STEM prodigy living in this dystopian Earth where every inch of life is dying due to pollution and the inevitable dangers of climate change.

I've read a handful of books so far in 2021, and I'm sure most of you are aware how I dislike every fictional main character ever no matter who it is because... they always have some way to annoy me.

But surprisingly, I can say that I really enjoyed all the characters in TOWMTF!!! Even I'm surprised that I liked every single character in this book! They were all interesting, complex, and I was really invested in the relationship between Cee and her sister Kasey. Immediately after reading the synopsis, I was hooked.

You get see life from two different points of view. One from Cee on her abandoned island, and one from Kasey on her dying skydome. Cee on her journey of trying to find her way back to her sister and Kasey trying to save human existence.

To those who have read TOWMTF have been discoursing over which sister they like better, whether it be Cee or Kasey. Even though Kasey is a fellow STEM student like myself, I would have to say I prefer Cee. I think that her storyline and plot throughout the book made me more interested and invested than Kasey's did. Her determination to get off this island and find her sister tugged on my heart strings because even though Cee has no recollection of her life before, she only remembered and knew one thing. She had to find her sister. At all costs.

Kasey was more closed off and reserved. I found it hard to find her likeable because of how gray her character was. But I do admire how she set she was on trying to make the best of her skydome life. I did enjoy seeing both different points of view, one life on in island, the other life in a modern world away from a polluted earth.

I really liked the STEM side of this book as well! As a person in STEM myself, it was really interesting to see Kasey's side of things and hard she worked for to make life livable.

At first, the synopsis of this book made me think of it as Lost meets The Giver because of its scientific environment but after reading, I can definitely see where the We Were Liars and Black Mirror aspect comes from. This book definitely rubbed me in the Black Mirror part. You have these kind of expectations and predictions for what's going to happen until the technological side weaves in and changes everything.

Joan has a way of building up scenes and emotions that leaves me absolutely shook. The twists and turns are something that I don't expect at all and I am still trying to process what tf happened! You don't see these twists coming at all and that's what I loved the most about this ARC.

I loved every aspect of TOWMTF. From being on an abandoned island, mysterious allies and brooding side characters, the scientific side of trying to save life and human existence- it just had me hooked from beginning to end. I didn't know what to expect at all and Joan He really did that.

If you are planning to read this book or is currently reading it, all I can say is that you are going to be completely shook reading The Ones We're Meant to Find.

Was this review helpful?

The Ones We’re Meant to Find I has left me speechless. I loved this book, and all of the twist and turns and ultimately the look at the bonds we share as human beings.
-
This book follows Cee, a girl who woke up three years ago on an abandoned island. She wants to find her sister, Kay, so she works to find a way to swim across the ocean to her. The second perspective is Kay’s, as she tries to find a way back to Cee.
-
While this book was a wonderful sci-fi, it ultimately was about the bonds shared by sisters and how they are impossible to be broken. The problems of the environment and the people who polluted it were addressed so nicely, and this futuristic society really came alive. I don’t read that much science fiction, but this book has convinced me to try to read more of it.
-
Technology was integrated so well into this book, with everything feeling very believable. My only complaint would be that it was a little confusing in the first three chapters or so. Once it gets started though, it is very hard to put down.
-
Overall, I would recommend this to fans of sci-fi and fans of slower, more emotional reads.
-
CW- death, grief, vehicle accident
-
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

A huge THANK YOU to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

My gosh. This book was EVERYTHING I wanted. I am SO happy; this was one of my most anticipated releases this year and it completely obliterated my expectations. An enthusiastic five stars.

This was a book I read slowly because I wanted to savor it. Joan He's writing was spectacularly gorgeous, and her world-building skills are excellent. The world was so full and vibrant, and felt so real - I loved that there was little to no info dumping. We learned about the world Kasey lives in as we needed to and as Kasey moved within it. Joan He did an amazing job opening our eyes to a new, possible future-Earth without obnoxious hand-holding. That's was I like in a good sci-fi! The world itself is a great commentary on our current climate crisis without seeming preachy. It felt like a truly realistic society built from the ruins of humanity, trying to learn from our past environmental mistakes. It felt just complicated enough to be real, but not so complicated that it was hard to follow.

Learning about Kasey's past and wondering how/when/if Cee would ever get off the island and reunite with her sister kept me turning the pages. I loved Kasey and Cee, loved how their personalities were so opposite but worked so well together and complimented each other. I really appreciate that the focus of this novel was a sister relationship. I NEVER expected any of the twists in this book - the mysterious element really worked for me. I wish more sci-fi novels had the tone of this one. I absolutely fell in love with Cee and her story.

I have a feeling this will be my favorite new sci-fi release of 2021. I am so happy to have read this and will 100% recommend this book to everyone.

Was this review helpful?

I've waited a little bit after finishing The Ones We're Meant to Find hoping some coherent thoughts would find their way into my brain and it's just not happening. This book has left me speechless. It's no secret that I loved Joan' first novel, Descendant of the Crane and this book is just as good (maybe better but don't tell Hesina!) The genre is a bit different, more of dystopian sci-fi setting but there's still the classic Joan plot twists that left me screaming and some super sad scenes that brought out all of my tears.

This is primarily a book about sisters, Celia and Kasey. Cee has been stuck on an abandoned island with only an outdated robot for company. She's lost most of her memory but knows that she has a sister out in the world and is trying her best to get back to her. Kasey back home in eco-city, a floating metropolis designed to protect people from the decaying planet, has no idea what happened to her sister after a camera records her taking a boat out to sea more than three months prior. Kasey rules her life by logic and science and logic says that Celia should have died of dehydration or drowning after being missing for so long but she can't stop the hope that Celia will be found. Celia is the only one who could break through Kasey's stoicism. I loved the sisters so much, their relationship and characterization was so much more complex than the initial assumption of social butterfly and stoic loner.

Someone else said this book reminded them of a Studio Ghibli film and I could not agree more. A lot of Ghibli films focus on themes of environmentalism. In The Ones We're Meant to Find humanity has destroyed the planet, mega quakes are common occurrences, the water has become incredibly polluted, even the air is filled with toxic gas. The lucky few managed to make it to an eco-city, floating above most of the horrors that now plague the Earth. Space is tight in the eco-cities and there's simply not enough room for everyone on Earth, the governing bodies of the eco-cities have become desperate for ideas on how to save humanity. I was fascinated by all the examples of how what's currently being done to the planet can turn into these mega-disasters if nothing is done to course correct. Ghibli films also have beautiful quiet moments that let the larger story breathe. I found those same moments in this book, more so in the beginning before the twists get really crazy and start propelling the story but they were still there in a couple of scenes toward the end. This was a truly beautiful book and I cannot wait to hold the finished copy in my hands.

Was this review helpful?

My thoughts are just a mess of screeching from this book, so please forgive the short review. The twists and turns in this were so exciting, I definitely never saw the ending coming! There were such subtle hints dropped that I didn't even really notice, and then it would all just fall into place so nicely. Cee and Kasey are so completely different, and they really complimented each other nicely. Like a cold glass of milk and a warm, gooey cookie. The character growth in both of them - in all the characters, really - was amazing. I also loved the discussion of climate change. It emphasized how important taking care of the planet is without seeming preachy. This honestly has to be one of of the best sci-fi books I've read. I fell in love from the first page, and I have a feeling I'll keep thinking about this one for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really interesting book that had a really unique take on the futuristic/dystopian genre. The book is set in a future dramatically affected by climate change and follows two sisters, one of whom has been missing and presumed dead for three years. To be honest, I found Kasey's chapter's much more interesting than Celia's because I was more interested in the world building and Kasey's character. The writing was excellent in both Celia and Kasey's perspectives and both of them had very clear and distinct voices, which I don't always find in books with multiple POVs, but personally I found Kasey's more compelling because of how she processed her emotions and used her emotional regulators throughout the book to cope with her life. The science was also really intriguing even though I was confused by some of it since I am not normally a science fiction reader. Though there were a lot of things I personally thought were interesting about this book, I had a bit of a hard time imagining how I might pitch it to teens and imagining which of my YA readers I would try to hand sell it to. This one is definitely one I'd try to sell more to older YA readers and even adult patrons who are interested in science fiction, but unfortunately most of my teen patrons would likely pass on this one.

Was this review helpful?

[digital arc provided by the publisher]

‘the ones we’re meant to find’ is a thrilling, heartrending sci-fi novel following two sisters—celia, who’s been surviving on an abandoned island with one mission: to find her sister, kasey, who’s trying to decide if she’ll use science to help save humanity, that has continued to fail her and the people who mattered most.

”some secrets are best left at sea.”

wow. if it’s not apparent by the rating, i cannot stress this enough, i loved this book. it blew me away. it had me floored. i am speechless by what joan he has achieved here and i know that this review will not never serve the book any justice but i will try my best to articulate my overwhelming feelings.

this is a story about love, hope, humanity, and what we’re willing to do—or rather, sacrifice—to survive. within that, the author explored what i believe is the heart of the story: sisterhood. it is a compelling, heart-searching tale of family ties and a thought-provoking prodding of humankind trying and failing and trying again to find freedom in life.

i was immediately transported into the world with the characters. even though the sci-fi aspect hindered my reading because i was trying to absorb it all in, it was just me marveling at the sheer imagining of the setting and the author’s ability to bring life to words on a page through excellent world-building that resonated with our real world and hit close to home. it felt fully realized just enough to be able to tell the story the author was trying to tell—and it was done beautifully.

similarly, the atmosphere the book created was just stunning. it really could be a studio ghibli film. i was more in love with cee’s chapters—the descriptions and the writing there excelled, in my opinion. maybe i’m biased because i’m a sea/ocean/beach fanatic but every mention of the sea and the sand and the sun and the sky tugged at my heart.

the writing took some getting used to; i get that it was an authorial choice to write in fragments to fit the mood of the book and i felt it chunky and kind of awkward at first but i quickly got accustomed to it and better yet enjoyed it so much. joan he has got some heart-wrenching tricks under her sleeve to make you feel emotional—i was a satisfied victim of her ways and it made the book all the more compelling.

the characters stole my heart from the very first page and i found myself getting increasingly engrossed in their lives and minds and hearts as the twists kept coming. my heart rarely takes leaps and races so fast when i’m reading a book and towmtf did. celia was very easy to love, constantly challenged and constantly having her life shattered only to renew her faith in survival and finding her sister across the sea, it was so refreshing to read a hope that strong. kasey was such a strong character and very interesting to read from, i found myself always questioning her actions but also understanding her, trying to find answers and choose the “right” thing. hero and actinium are also such, such prominent characters who i care dearly for and truly made this book the journey it is. every single character was crafted with thought and care and i absolutely loved them all.

the only hiccup i initially had was the pacing in the first half of the book, but by the ending and after all the plot twists and revelations, i found myself understand the route of storytelling joan he took in this book. it simply just made sense to have the book start slow and steady; in that way it made me resonate with the characters and become engrossed in the world.

and really, with all the mind-blowing plot twists we get in the second half are just enough to keep me thinking about this book for an eternity to come. i will never be over what joan he has done to me. and i am so excited to have it done to me again with the next thing she comes up with!!


tw: terminal illness, suicide, violence (including choking), death, death of parents (off-page), death of a loved one, drowning, vomiting, large-scale natural disasters and mass casualties, gore.

Was this review helpful?

The Ones We’re Meant to Find is a brilliant science fiction novel with dystopian themes, that deals incredibly thoughtfully with topics such as identity & morality, as well as climate change & privilege. It’s thrilling at times, thought-provoking from the first page to the last, and doesn’t pull any punches; that’s one of the things I loved about it most. That, and the focus on the relationship of our two protagonists—two sisters—Kasey and Cee.

Kasey and Cee live in a world that’s, despite the advanced technology and even further deteriorating climate, not so different from ours. In this uncomfortably close future, life as we know it only exists on the edges. Nature is dying around us, one climate catastrophe chasing the next. Most people live in so-called eco-cities, cities floating in the sky, in which life is mostly lived virtually, people only able to take up that much space, to reduce the strain on our climate. Those who don’t live in e-cities exist in constant danger, one earthquake or tsunami or some sort of other disaster away from death. The world is ending, or it will be soon, if nothing is going to change.

Reading The Ones We’re Meant to Find was a journey: I never knew what to expect, but I was so utterly and entirely immersed in the story. Joan He has a talent for pulling the reader in, giving them just enough hints to keep things interesting, while simultaneously surprising them on every turn. The plot twists in this book! 25 chapters or so into the story, I felt like I couldn’t breathe if I didn’t keep reading, didn’t figure out what was going to happen next—or what had already happened, what I might still be missing.

This story was so much bigger than it first appeared, and yet, it never lost its focus: Kasey and Cee. Two sisters, who are so different from each other—one logical, one emotional—and yet share so much love between them. I loved to get to know them both, loved the insights into their past, loved how they grew and changed. It’s difficult to talk about them without giving too much of the story away, but the way they moved parallel to each other, while always thinking they were so far apart—Joan He handled both of their stories so carefully. She created two truly unforgettable characters.

The atmosphere of the world Joan He created was another thing I absolutely adored and what made for an incredibly immersive reading experience. An abandoned island surrounded by an endless sea, cities floating in the sky, and a dying world surrounding it all. The world was as unsettling as it was vivid, despite nature collapsing; a fascinating setting for an equally intriguing premise.

Despite this being science fiction, despite the existence of bots and holograms and so much more, The Ones We’re Meant to Find is, at its heart, one of the most human stories I have ever read. Who deserves to live? Is one life worth more than another? Does a person who is—however passively—to blame for another’s suffering or even death deserve to live their own life without consequence? These and other questions are raised throughout the book and will leave the reader with much to think about, even beyond the last page.

Overall, The Ones We’re Meant to Find is an excellent examination of the consequences of climate change, and our part as humans in its rapid advance. It thoughtfully centres themes of morality, of privilege, of identity and what it means to be human—as well as posing the question of the worth of a life, especially in comparison to another. At the heart of this book, though, are two sisters—and a love that spans the sea. Fans of Patrick Ness’s More Than This would enjoy The Ones We're Meant to Find quite a lot, I think!

Was this review helpful?

The world building in The Ones We're Meant to Find was amazing! In the beginning of the book, I was slightly confused about the setup of the world, but after a couple chapters, there was a clear picture painted in my mind of what the world was like. I really enjoyed reading about the contrasts of the dystopian and desolate state of Earth versus the utopian, dreamy descriptions of a Metropolis that ran on the most advanced technology. The world building was almost a little bit unsettling because of how plausible it could be. As of right now, the world is changing rapidly due to global warming, and technology is advancing everyday, so in a few hundred years our world could look a lot like the one Joan He created in this book. There is a fantastical element of the world, but it is also based in so much reality that I could easily visualize it.

In my opinion, the characters in this book were what drove the story the most. Through the main characters Kasey and Celia, Joan He explored the bonds of sisterhood, and how far a person is willing to go for a loved one without losing themselves in the process. A theme that was explored deeply throughout the book was the morality and the dangers of technology and artificial intelligence. Who determines what is right and wrong? Can anything be okay if your intentions behind it are good? Is technology unethical?

The characters in this book experience love, loss, betrayal, pain, and hope all in the span of 400 pages, and all of those emotions were explored so deeply within each character. I could tell that Joan He put immense effort into her character development. I became attached to one of the characters in particular, which made the book that much more of an engaging experience for me.

Along with the characters, the plot of this story was so captivating. When the timeline of Celia and Kasey's story finally became clear to me, my mind was BLOWN. Joan He masterfully wove their stories together, and tied them up perfectly by the end. The story is told in two different points of view, which made it feel 10x more unpredictable and high stakes. I was so nervous, yet eager to finally just see how everything ends, and I was on my edge of my seat all the way to the very end. There are a lot of plot twists and shocking moments in this book and every single one evoked strong emotion and made me want to keep on reading.

Overall, The One's We Were Meant to Find is a book that will stay with me for a long time. Joan He creates really important discourse about events that are relevant to all of our lives right now, and the events that take place in this story have inspired me to take more action right now to save our Earth before it is too late. The characters of this book will stay with me for a long time. I hope that a second book is in the making, because I NEED to know what happens after the end. If you have not picked up The Ones We're Meant to Find, I highly recommend that you preorder it as soon as you can. No matter how old you are, you will absolutely find value in this story.

Was this review helpful?

An instant favorite! I forgot how much I absolutely adore Sci-Fi until I read this book. The Ones We're Meant to Find reads like a Black Mirror episode and it was so captivating yet thrilling throughout the entire time. I couldn't get enough of the book and ended up flying through it within 24 hours. It's a story about love, climate change, but also humanity and what makes us human. I had so much fun trying to dissect every word and every mystery trying to see if I could solve the big plot twist!! The pacing was honestly perfect for me and I loved loved loved the back and forth time jump!! Five stars.

Was this review helpful?

The Ones We’re Meant to Find is a stunning and captivating read; it drags you into its currents, and you struggle to keep treading water while the story inundates you with unexpected twists and turns, dropping subtle hints and clues to the larger story like desperate gasps of oxygen into your lungs. Kasey and Celia, two sisters farther apart and more closely bonded than you can imagine in the first few chapters, wind closer and closer as the story stretches on and the stakes humanity faces raise quicker than sea levels. This novel challenges readers: the journey you’re taken on paralleling the sisters’ journey; a hunt for answers and solutions, and questions of ethics and philosophy. The Ones We’re Meant to Find is a masterpiece in prose, each drop of information and story building into a bigger wave that crashes to the shore in an epic conclusion that changes everything; readers are left to reel in its wake and face what’s been washed away and what’s left behind. A careful balance is struck between the larger plot at play, the push and pull of characters and their relationships, and a broader, yet fathomless conversation about climate change and the questions we must all begin to face about our privileges, responsibilities, and our futures.

Was this review helpful?

I’m so glad I got the chance to read Joan He's new book early. It’s. So. Good!!

THE ONES WE’RE MEANT TO FIND is a YA sci-fi/dystopia about two sisters. Cee is stranded on an abandoned island, only able to remember her sister. Kasey lives in an eco-city, one of the last places on Earth safe from pollution. There, she has to decide whether to use science to help humanity after it failed those she loves.

This book is my favorite of 2021 so far! I’m not usually big on dystopias, but I loved He’s debut, DESCENDANT OF THE CRANE, so I knew I’d want to read this one.

I was gripped from page one. The plot was so compelling and full of the best twists. It was also so easy to route for the characters. I love both sisters so much, and I really appreciated Kasey.

There are so many other amazing things: the gorgeous prose and worldbuilding! The different themes! He masterfully incorporates it all into a captivating story.

(Something I didn't add in my online review: this twists are so awesome and the plot is so compelling because the foreshadowing is so well done! He knows exactly when to hide information and when to share. The worldbuilding details are also so fleshed-out and really make the world come alive; this is apparent from chapter one. I was considering starting an official book blog, and I'd definitely would add a more in-depth review of this book if I do. THE ONES WE'RE MEANT TO FIND has cemented its place as one of my favorite books).

Was this review helpful?

As a member of Joan He’s street team since her debut, I’ve been eagerly anticipating her sophomore book. This book definitely lived up to the wait! The Ones We’re Meant to Find was a gripping read about complex sister relationships, the effects of climate change, and what it means to find ourselves.

Three years ago, Cee woke up on an abandoned island with no clothes and no memories, other than the notion that she has a sister, Kasey, and she needs to find her. Parallelly, Kasey is dealing with the grief of Celia’s disappearance as well as the impending doom of Earth as pollution causes more and more eco-disasters. She has to decide whether she’s willing to use her skills to help the world, even if it won’t save Celia.

Forgive me if this review is incoherent; I’m still processing this book! I actually think I’ll have to reread it soon to fully appreciate everything. I’m also trying very, very hard not to spoil something accidentally.

Much of this book deals with the aftereffects of climate change. Kasey, along with her family, live in an eco-city, a city built in the air. Eco-cities were constructed because of the toxicity of the Earth although people still live on the land due to the lack of space in the eco-cities. Natural disasters, like devastating earthquakes, are occurring more and more often, and chemicals are poisoning the earth and the ocean. This was certainly interesting to follow as a plot and really brings to life an issue that is pervasive in our own lives.

While this book is centered around climate change, it is also very rooted in Celia and Kasey’s complex relationship. We get both of their points-of-view, so we get to see their bond despite how different they are. Celia is lively and outgoing; Kasey is reserved and pragmatic. I loved how even the writing reflected this: Celia’s chapters are from a first person point-of-view, which shows how sure she is of herself, while Kasey’s are in third person, demonstrating almost a disconnected feeling. This also mirrors their emotions throughout the book, as Celia struggles to remember her life before and Kasey grieves.

Although their chapters follow separate plot lines, you can clearly see how much Celia and Kasey mean to each other. Celia’s singular motivation is to find Kasey; meanwhile, Kasey is dealing with her grief over the disappearance of the one person who means the most to her. However, while they are undeniably close, they still keep secrets from each other, which Kasey finds out throughout the story. Celia and Kasey’s relationship is the driving force behind both of their stories; they’re meant to find each other, even if finding each other means learning something about the other they didn’t want to know.

The writing was gorgeous, as expected. The ocean plays many roles in this book, as you may have noticed from the cover, but I loved how Joan utilized it as both a literal and figurative player. Physically, it is something that Celia has fixated on, an obsession that Kasey begrudgingly went along with. Figuratively, the sea and drowning represent loss and the vastness of emotion and so much more. There are actually more dots I could connect, but again, spoilers!

I’ve been purposely vague about their specific plot lines, as well as mentioning other characters, because I’m afraid of spoiling something, even if it’s just something small. Joan herself called this a “twist-y” book and believe me, this book is completely filled with plot twists. While the book may be confusing at first, there’s a moment when all the pieces start clicking together, and you start realizing something bad is to come, and then the plot twists just keep coming. And they don’t stop! Once I began processing one revelation, something new would be revealed. I actually couldn’t put this book down, even reading during my classes.

This is a standalone and wraps up…I don’t want to say nicely because the ending has caused me so much emotional distress, but the ending is very poignant and reflects the protagonists’ arcs very well. Although I’m still crying over exactly how the book ended, I really did like where Celia and Kasey end up.

The Ones We’re Meant to Find is a beautiful story about love and loss. I adored the characters and the writing; the plot was amazing and masterfully paced. If you want a gorgeously written book about sisters, or one that analyzes a world living with the consequences of climate change, I cannot recommend The Ones We’re Meant to Find enough.

Was this review helpful?

The Ones We're Meant to Find is everything it promises to be--full of twists you can't see coming, original and inclusive worldbuilding, and complex characters with a variety of motivations. The characters all hurt and want so badly and you can't help but root for them. The two sisters especially feel so distinct, with each their own unique perspective and yet they're held together by a rugged determination and an unyielding love for the other.

As an avid fantasy reader, I'm always a little wary of scifi (I have enough science in school >:( ) but the worldbuilding and the science surrounding it was super articulate--information is given when it is relevant, without major infodumps. And as a member of the target demographic (18 y/o) I sometimes feel YA is gearing more towards full-fledged adults with its themes and conflicts, but TOWMTF is excellent in portraying the young adult experience. It captures the uncertainty of the transition from teen to adult and the slow process of knowing how you fit in the world and what you want from it.

Also I have to mention the twists. There were so many of them and they're so well done, because they're built in a way that you can't guess them from the beginning--they're reliant on new pieces of information the characters receive and shaped by their actions upon receiving them. Rather, you go in with an initial theory that molds and changes as you learn more about the two sisters; if you manage to guess a twist as it nears, you're rewarded with the satisfaction of having solved a labyrinthine puzzle, and if you don't, you get your mind blown. Win-win imo.

Above all, there's a certain inevitability to the resolution, and it makes for an incredibly fulfilling story. There's no if onlys or why didn't she x. The characters make their decisions based on who they are and what they've become, and I'm so proud of them for it. *wipes tear* Their choices are wholly their own, not made for the sake of narrative convenience.

There are a few flaws--the midpoint conflict feels a little abrupt and foreshadowing it could have led to a bit more tension in the first part, but I reviewed an early copy, and they weren't nearly enough to hinder my overall enjoyment of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I could not stop reading The Ones We're Meant to Find. I mean it. I read 60% in one sitting. And then I finished it the next day. The Ones We're Meant to Find is thrilling and thought provoking. I'd say that the first 2/3 is pure thrill, mystery, and the best kind of confusion. Whereas the last 1/3 still has these revelations and twists, but also this thought provoking SF quality. Keep reading this book review to hear my ranting!

I finished The Ones We're Meant to Find and immediately needed to re-read it. Joan He is an autobuy author for me after her stunning debut and her second book only cements my love for her. It's rare I find the need to dive back into a world, into a story, immediately after finishing but I do. It's like watching those great movies that capture you completely. The Ones We're Meant to Find is five stars for pure thrills and thought provoking quality. And I want to go back to the beginning and unravel it all over again with a fine toothed comb.

He's world building is spectacular. It's a world of mass climate change and environmental destruction. A world where we have to live parts of it in holoworlds for the future of our world. Where we are haunted by the sins and mistakes of our past. A time where robots are common place and the technology we've seen in SF books comes alive. Not only that, but He subtly and slowly brings a thoughtful-ness to this world. We are forced to examine the destruction we have wrought. Furthermore, we must contemplate our own future.

Even more emotional, The Ones We're Meant to Find has one of the best sister relationships. I went into this book having heard the keyword of sisters, and I am just so thoroughly impressed. He exposes the differences between them, the ways we feel compared and lackluster, but also the strong love between them. In this dual POV book, their memories and emotions are exposed to us. He's second book examines the people who come into our lives like pieces of puzzles we never knew.

What begins as subtle tension and mystery, propels readers through The Ones We're Meant to Find until we're wrapped up in a tornado. By halfway through, you won't be able to stop reading. Prepare to cancel your plans and just snuggle deeper into your chair. I cannot stress enough that around this time, my notes for this book were just pure screaming.

Was this review helpful?

Carefully structured, this explores a future world decimated by climate change. Sisters narrate a story in different timelines and places, as you come to realize that both know quite different things. Suprising mystery unfolds with twists. The best of YA science fiction, I think. Despite the weird cover.

Was this review helpful?

There is so much for me to love about this book. That cover is beyond stunning. There has been artwork shared that killed me with beauty. And so I knew I would end up loving this one. Also because I adore Joan and her first book. It was such a stunning story of two sisters, living in a floating city, set far in the future.

I loved this world that Joan created. It is science and the future and the world ending. Natural disasters killing almost everyone, because of what humans did to this earth. It is the story about Cee and Kasey surviving in their floating city. Or trying their best to. There is so much going on in this book. Loved every moment.

The writing was pretty much perfect too, and I loved that. I felt connected with these characters and I adored them so. Though they also ruined me most of the time. How rude. They were two sisters. Alike, but fully different. The beginning of this book is not easy to completely understand. The book is told from both point of views. We begin with Celia. Whom we learn has been alone on an island for the past three years. Then there is her sister, Kasey. It has been three months since her sister went missing. So we get to see from both sisters, at different times. We get some memories of them together, and I loved that so much. Wish we had gotten more of them together, though. Yet reading about them apart was all kinds of stunning. As I grew to love them so.

There is so much going on in this story. I shall not spoil anything big. Simply sharing my thoughts about certain things. This is a story about two sisters. A story about an earth that is dying. And how one sister might be able to save those who are still alive, if she wants to. We get to know them both so much and I adored them so. We get to see so much of Cee and her abandoned island. It was heartbreaking at times. But so very good and I loved it the most. She had a small bot with her, but not one she could truly talk to.

And we get to see a lot about Kasey and her life while living in the floating city about the sea. Where she shares about the failing earth and how no one knows how to save it. How she misses her sister, yet how she does not feel the same as everyone around her does. She was different. And I liked her very much. I may have loved Cee and her island life the most, but I loved Kasey just as much. And I loved how they were both searching for each other. All the secrets that were revealed. They all killed me, though. Sobs.

I cannot decide what I felt about the different types of romances in this book. Cee and Hero was the most adorable thing and I loved them so very much. But Kasey and Act. Well. I shipped them. And then I didn't, except I still did. And I am so confused about that whole thing. So well written, though. I loved getting to know Hero. He showed up on Cee's island, without memory as well. And I found him to be every kind of precious. Then there was Actinium. Felt so conflicted about him, and needed to know much more of him.

There was also the sister relationship between Celia and Kasey. We see more about them being apart. Thinking about the other. And they had a complicated relationship too. Yet so much love for each other. And I very much enjoyed that. I loved learning more about their past. Who they both were. And what they meant to each other. Kasey was difficult to love. Set more apart from others. And yet I loved her so very much. Cee was very easy to love, yet had such a gentle heart too. I simply adored these two sisters so.

It is a four star for me because of a few things. Firstly, some of the science was a little too much for me to understand at times. It also took me a little time to get into the book. Wish that the timing had been made clearer. Like how Cee was at three years, and Kasey at just three months. Then that ending. It feels fully open with many things not clear yet. Summary says "Lost with a satisfying resolution." I feel a bit tricked. Thought there would be a sequel, there won't be. And there is so much I do not know. What happened?

And yet I loved this book so very much. It captured me from beginning to end, made me love these two girls. I just wish the ending had been clearer. It does not feel like an end to me. It feels very much ready for a sequel. And oh, how I wish there will be one. Though I see that Joan has said there will not be. And that is breaking my heart a little, to be fully honest. I wish to know what actually happened so badly. I wish more so so much. And so I will try being hopeful, that Joan might be writing a sequel one day. Want it so.

The Ones We're Meant to Find was such a beautiful book. And I very much loved it. It was everything I had hoped it to be. And yet so much more. Such a huge twist that I did not at all see coming. I probably should have seen it, but I did not. And I very much loved that, haha. But it so ruined me. Then everything after the twist ruined me even more. It was so good, but oh, my poor heart. Okay, the ending was not that open. But I need answers even so. It was such an incredible story and I shall never forget it. Do read this.

Was this review helpful?

Joan He did it once again.
The Ones We're Meant to Find (the title now making sense to me) is a wonderful blend of dystopia, light sci-fi and environmentalism, a relevant read for our current times.

Before I get into it, I just need to shoutout that cover. IT'S GORGEOUS. (The cover artist is by Aykut Aydoğdu. Find him on Instagram @aykutmaykut)

GENERAL THINGS (and the little things?)
I love the narrative choices He makes to tell the story of Cee and Kasey as it complements and enhances their personalities. The choices He makes in what kinds of metaphors or similes the two MCs uses further emphasize the MCs' personalities.
The book kept me going as questions like "How are the sisters going to get back together?", "Who is he?" and a few more spoilery ones kept popping up as more details were revealed. I'm not sure if He is going to keep how the chapter numbers looked like in the ARC in the final version (or if it's her choice) but MAN I love it. It's the tiny things that give this book a bit more pizzaz.

The CHARACTERS.
I...can't say much except I can see why one of them was a struggle to write because... Hesina, as intelligent as she is, doesn't rank within the same league as one of the MCs (sorry, Sina!) But trust me (if you dare), you'll love them for their cheeky humor and sharp mentalities.

Now to He's favourite part: THE TWISTS.
It was the subtlety. The little details that stuck out made my puzzle-piecing of the story's mysteries not fit. And then when they clicked, OOH. The jaw-drop. Just... yes. Yes yes yes yes yes.
But, then there's that One. The one where the whole story stops for. I kid you not, I gasped because of the sheer shock. I did not see it coming, even though there were details that didn't line up, and then did afterwards, and boy I felt as betrayed as *spoiler*.

Now onto my favourite part: THE INTERNAL TORTURE.
It's as if He took me by the shoulders and shook me because the constant "will they won't they" game she's playing made me die a little on the inside (in a good way.) She built up these characters, made us bond with them like the MCs are, and then rip them away like a riptide. WHY? (It's rhetorical.) And THEN she had the audacity to give them back and take them away AGAIN. This part is already 5/5 in my book.

THE THOUGHTS
Reading about all the environmentalism here and the harsh realities that exist in TOWMTF made me think about our world. The best way I can summarize my thoughts is: to advance ourselves, we cost the world. But what's the point if we can't live in it? We need to take care of it, but our inability to commit to something that isn't directly tied to our individual self-preservation costs us precious time that could be crucial in the fight to reverse our damage. This book tugs on these hard truths, and will leave you cynical.

Was this review helpful?