Member Reviews

This was adorable, funny and quite deep and hilarious at the same time.
The author imagines the philosophical thoughts of his cat Penny, in these hilarious comics. The art is beautiful, and though there was some repetitions, and some typical stereotypes about cats and what they think of humans, I loved it and enjoyed it immensely. I highly recommend it especially if you're a car lover.

I thank Netgalley and Chronicle books for the digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the perspective of the cat throughout the book. I also had a cat named Penny so it was fun to think about what she always though. Fun and quick read!

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully illustrated, at times funny, ironic, a little morbid and delightfully fanciful, this graphic novel memoir of Penny is definitely entertaining. It's a little long, and there's definitely a few repetitive scenes, but overall I enjoyed it. Penny is definitely a character, and I loved her little fantasies and memories of her past. The conversations with her toys are a nice touch too. Penny does get a little dark, so there are some scenes that are a bit of a downer, but it's a well balanced book, I don't think those scene overpower the humor or lighthearted scenes.

Was this review helpful?

Penny by Karl Stevens is an interesting graphic novel about a very philosophical cat.

This book was a little dull for me, but the illustrations were incredible. Penny was a stray kitten on the street who was picked up, "kidnapped", and adopted by a couple. They bring Penny home and the cat begins to think about everything philosophical about a cat, existence and life itself. The cat is sassy, intelligent and has an intriguing story.

I thought this book might be funnier or a bit more engaging than it was. I found it very slow to get through but I really like cats and graphic novels and I really wanted to finish it.

Overall, this is a good book but it wasn't fast enough or funny enough for me. It was advertised as a comedy on NetGalley which is why I was excited for it.

Three out of five stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and Chronicle Books for providing me a free copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

If you have a cat, this will make you chuckle. So much existential dread. I loved it. Who knew all that was going on in a cat’s head?

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading Penny. I thought of my own rescue cat while I read it and put him in Penny's shoes a lot. The daily life of this cat as a memoir kind of reminded me of a blend of Garfield with a much more refined cat. At points in the story, I giggled. At other points, I had to set the book down and come back a few hours later. Overall, I would recommend this book to more of an older age group. I do not think that it is engaging enough for children unless it is split into more of a chapter/section book. I did enjoy it though and think that it could be a hit for a somewhat niche market.

I just reviewed Penny by Karl Stevens. #Penny #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel is perfect for cat lovers. I enjoyed following Penny through her daily cat life. She is exactly what I imagine cats to be... philosophical, intelligent, and independent. Every day she contemplatee her cat existence while hunting, playing, or sleeping. It was a little humorous, I found myself chuckling a couple of times. It was very heartwarming and cute! The one thing I would change would probably be the art style. It was beautiful but I didnt feel like it matched the tone of the book. Overall, it was a fun read and I highly recommend to any and all cat lover's.

Was this review helpful?

Penny is an enjoyable and well-composed example of graphic novel memoir. The illustrations are absolutely stunning and the story is thoughtful and engaging. Well worth reading!

Was this review helpful?

Rescued from the streets, Penny lives a rather boring pampered existence while having a full and vivid mental life full of existential ponderings. I thoroughly enjoyed dichotomy of Penny stretched out in a patch of sunlight as she deems the bright light to be a portal to another dimension. I can understand it may not be everyone's cup of tea, but as a fan of cats and sarcasm it brought me many a smile. The illustrations are of a quality I don't normally see in too many graphic novels, several are frameable.

Was this review helpful?

I had high expectations for this, as I love cats and most cat-centric graphic novels/comics, but this was a bit disappointing. The art is beautiful, but Penny's thoughts are a bit repetitive and, at times, the 'memoir' borders on pretentious (think the viral French cat Henri and his 'ennui,' but without the satire). I did appreciate the more fantastical 'dreams' Penny had, though.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the ARC NetGalley. Anyone who has owned a cat for any period of time certainly wonders what they are thinking. This sweet graphic novel about Penny the cat answers all those questions and more, Highly enjoyable. #penny #netgalley

Was this review helpful?

Sure we don't actually know what cats are thinking, but this seems super accurate. I mean, have you ever watched a cat being weird? They are clearly living big inner lives that we puny humans will never understand.

This beautifully illustrated graphic novel proves my theory that cats are happiest when thinking about the deaths of small things and their humans.

Recommended for: cat lovers

I received a digital ARC of this from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

If you expected a book about a most worldly-wise, mystically-minded moggie to be a lazily-drawn comic, think again. This shows great craft and artistry in giving a portrait of a cat that just seems to be doing cute cat things, and sleeping it off when there was little 'it' in the first place to speak of, but actually is cogitating life, the universe and everything. As great as the visuals are, this is for dipping into and not binging on, for it can get one-note, even if it is broken up with the humans' holidaying and leaving Penny at home alone, and other more plotted sections. Also, Penny's interior monologue does stretch from the opening, where you think she'd be able to understand "Tenet" at the first watch, to the fact she thinks a stuffed mouse with a broken ear is her boyfriend. An odd swing to the character, then (partly caused, you eventually work out, by a non-sequential presentation of stand-alone pages desperately out of order), but this whole effort is odd – and oddly compelling, too.

Was this review helpful?

I love cats. I've grown up with cats, I've always had cats around. I have a cat now. I'm the guy who comes to visit you, and your normally shy cat will climb all over me. What I am trying to say is I love cats, guys.

Fiction involving cats as a character can go several ways. My least favourite kind anthropomorphises cats too much, makes them speak and think like a human being.

This book seems to go down that route, although it does something different too. The book is about Penny, a cat who lived on the street and was adopted by the author and his significant other. Turns out that Penny has a rich intellectual inner life, and likes to ponder the feline condition. This boils down to her having a lot philosophical thoughts, and linking that to her personal predicament.

How she views humans (and specifically her humans) is a bit more cliched - she is a prisoner in a velvet cage, she doesn't really think much of her owners, etc. It's the usual spiel about cats not really loving their owners, or of them being cold and calculating animals. I personally think that's a bit hackneyed, as in my experience cats are quite sensitive and responsive.

All of this makes Penny a quirky character, but also kind of... well, boring. There's nowhere left to go with the character. The book is a collection of mostly one page comics, Penny grumping about her life, and several multi-page stories - one in which indoor cat Penny escapes her building is the one that sticks most in my mind (probably because this would be a personal nightmare scenario).

I do think the art is great, and has a real sweet edge to it, full of warm colours.

Was this review helpful?

This is a rather lovingly illustrated book about the life of a very dull cat, who thinks big thoughts.

And that is it. The cat questions her existence. The cat questions life. The cat pays with toy mice. The only excitement is when the cat escapes her apartment, but other than that, nothing more happens. A lot of this is typical cat things, such as eating, sleeping, and playing.

But, as I said, the pictures are lovely and very spot on to how cats look and climb and sleep and do all the things they like to do. But if you are looking for a plot of some kind, or story then you have come to the wrong place.


Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?